Settings

Theme

USCIS will weight H-1B lottery by salary starting Feb 2026

theh1brecords.substack.com

10 points by codebyaditya a month ago · 8 comments

Reader

codebyadityaOP a month ago

Author here.

Quick summary of probability shifts under the weighted system:

  Level I ($80K median):  -57% selection probability
  Level II ($103K median): -14%
  Level III ($135K median): +29%
  Level IV ($158K median): +73%
The counterintuitive finding: product companies (direct employers) have 22% Level I concentration vs 7% for staffing firms. The rule designed to stop "lottery abuse" hits direct employers 3x harder.

Data source: DOL LCA disclosure data. Happy to discuss methodology.

  • square_usual a month ago

    > The rule designed to stop "lottery abuse" hits direct employers 3x harder.

    To prove this, you need to compute the total numbers and not just proportion. If 22% of the direct employees are Level 1, but there's only 300 direct level 1 filings total, the absolute numbers are dwarfed by the drop in probability of the staffing firms.

    • codebyadityaOP a month ago

      Excellent point. My analysis calculated Level I concentration within each employer type but not absolute volumes.

      You're correct that if staffing firms file significantly more total applications, their absolute number of affected Level I positions could exceed product companies despite lower concentration.

      To properly claim "3x harder hit," I'd need to show either: 1. Total Level I applications by employer type, or 2. Total estimated selection losses by employer type

      Without those absolute numbers, the "3x harder" claim overstates what the data shows. The accurate claim is that product companies have 3x higher Level I concentration - but that's not the same as 3x more impact.

      This is a good catch. The proportions tell us about hiring patterns but not total system impact.

      • graysonk a month ago

        It’s like you’re trying to fill out a bingo card of “obviously written by ai” markers

        • codebyadityaOP a month ago

          Hey, lemme apologize first. I indeed generated this above comment by AI because I was extremely busy with something else and didn't have time to respond but i'll make sure this will not happen again.

          sincerely.

        • jawilson2 a month ago

          Good lord, is there a way to block someone on HN? What slop...

          • codebyadityaOP a month ago

            Hey, I didn't generate everything by AI but only to frame the words since i was busy with something else. I'll make sure from now on such mistakes will never happen again.

            sincerely.

      • RGamma a month ago

        How many rs in raspberry? Think hard.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection