Settings

Theme

Ask HN: Why is there no collapse comment thread feature on HN?

12 points by koala_advert 12 years ago · 7 comments · 1 min read


Is there some benefit to making users scroll through every single comment? Reddit has this feature by default. I use a GreaseMonkey script that adds the functionality to HN, and when I browse from another device, I'm reminded how tedious it is to scroll through a long comment thread just to get to the next root comment.

ScottWhigham 12 years ago

I use the greasemonkey script Hacker News Threadify and it works great for FF:

http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/110317

neduma 12 years ago

Try HackerNew Chrome plugin to collapse and related features.

wikwocket 12 years ago

Try http://hn.premii.com/.

Clicking a comment lets you collapse it or the entire thread it's in.

Works great on mobile too, feels like a native app.

thelogos 12 years ago

I'm set to release an app in about a week that will let you collapse comments.

Will be posting it on here once it passes through review.

thoughtpalette 12 years ago

HN is pretty much intended to be featureless.

BlackDeath3 12 years ago

And what the hell is with expired links?

  • EpicEng 12 years ago

    And the fact that leaving a comment takes you back to the top of the thread... I love HN for its content, but it's certainly not a marvel of usability. The expired link issue is ridiculous.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection