Settings

Theme

Electromagnetic harvester gathers free electricity from thin air

extremetech.com

2 points by bchar 13 years ago · 1 comment

Reader

lutusp 13 years ago

This article is a well-meaning summary of a project the author doesn't understand, and that cannot live up to its hype. Consider the following:

1. There are any number of electromagnetic fields present in the atmosphere, caused by power lines, radio transmitters, lightning, and many other sources.

2. Notwithstanding the above, in a typical location, "harvesting" the sum of all the fields cannot produce any useful power.

3. There's an exception -- being located close to a commercial radio broadcasting station or beneath power lines.

4. In such locations, one might be able to harvest a small amount of power, but one doesn't want to live in such a place because of the possibility of long-term adverse effects of strong electromagnetic fields.

5. The above risk is well-established enough that many governments require warning signs near radio transmitters:

http://www.satcoms.org.uk/satellite/forum/uploads/1/RadHazDo...

6. The originator of this idea either does understand these issues, in which case he's misleading people, or he doesn't, in which case he's misleading himself.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection