Settings

Theme

Rant: Gemini 4 does not make any sense

6 points by sambejk · 8 comments · 2 min read


On November 18th, Google released another model, this one called Neon. Making it the fourth model in just 2 months.

OpenAI makes sense: Luna-Terra-Sol-Astra. Moon is smaller than earth, earth is smaller than sun and I can forgive them for not knowing that sun is also a star.

Anthropic is even better: Haiku-Sonnet-Opus-Mythos/Fable. Haiku is an extremely short poem, Sonnet is a bit longer, Opus is very long and Mythos is extremely long. Ok, Fable does not exactly really fit in there, but they came up with it after they only had the three models, so we had time to adjust. Also, Claude told me: Fable is basically Mythos with extra safety, and a fable is a story with a moral.

Now, I want you to think back to those high school chemistry classes. Which is bigger neon or carbon or hydrogen or argon? Impossible right? The correct answer, hydrogen, carbon, neon, argon, doesn't even match with model capabilities. To make things worse, there is no consistency, they are combining noble gases with other non-metals. You can't even say they went for easy names, helium, is not in there as an example. They really should have gone with just noble gasses: helium, neon, argon and xenon (skipping krypton to not confuse with kryptonite)

I'm glad that Google is sort of back in the race, but they should really invest in someone who is not AI-pilled to come up with these names.

PS don't get me started on Meta, wtf is a glimmer?

4 threads
dofm

> wtf is a glimmer?

Really?

Muse, Glimmer, Spark, Wonder — all words regarding inspiration/discovery/creativity.

Glimmer being a word for a hint of light or hope, or an inkling of an idea or potential discovery.

As good a set of names as any.

endean-eng

When they dropped Argon with an emphasis on low hallucination and named it after a Noble gas, I was really hoping that was going to be a theme.

Then Carbon made sense since it was the most versatile and could build (bond to) almost anything. Fine, works I guess.

And then Hydrogen dropped. Hydrogen is light and versatile, so that makes sense...kind of.

Along came the Helix leak. Never heard of that element before.

And now we have Neon. Which has a hallucination rate between Hydrogen and Carbon...but is named after a noble gas.

Yep. Agreed. Not sure what's going on anymore.

  • sambejkOP

    they apparently are going to release Krypton which is at Fable level. I hope they just retire the hydrogen and carbon models and then have a reasonable line-up... but that would be too much to expect from them.

muzani

I get the impression these models were made by different, competing teams in Google.

  • sambejkOP

    At 5000 people, Deepmind is by far the biggest AI lab. Would make sense if they just let them compete. But I think it is giving them too much credit.

  • kbrannigan

    You are onto something. Probably has the most training data and brain to create a superior product, too big to unite to actually deliver.

    My bet is microsoft,

setnone

i hope cache invalidation is getting easier at least

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection