Settings

Theme

Can Universities Survive? AI vs. Higher Education [audio]

ppfideas.com

31 points by frereubu · 44 comments

Reader

9 threads
thepryz

The problem as I see it, is the universities lost sight of what they were created to do and what their role in society should be. The focus seems to have been to meet graduation targets and generate revenue that could be redirected to research programs and maintain an academic ivory tower.

Higher education needs to rethink how they teach and how they structure their programs so that going to college isn't a terminal event but a lifelong engagement. They currently fail to do that in a sustainable and scaleable way.

  • TFNA

    This is a very Anglo-American-centric perspective. In much of the world, the most prestigious universities are public (private universities are for people who don’t have grades good enough to get into a public one), and “revenue generation” isn’t the kind of priority it is in, for example, the USA.

    AI is going to impact higher education everywhere, so better not to blame it too much on the foibles of one particular country or approach.

    • wolfinterval

      In the USA, colleges are basically crowd sourced hedge funds with a management fee of 100%.

      Imagine this, some kids in America are starting to realize this is a poor value proposition.

  • watwut

    Lifelong engagement is not what universities were created for. Teaching that ends at some point and science you complain about were.

  • thatguy0900

    I mean jobs were also to blame. When a huge portion of us jobs decided that they didn't want apprentices and trainees and instead they wanted colleges to do the training part for them then colleges become less a thing you go to as a destination to learn and instead just a stepping stone to the career you want

    • linguae

      That’s part of a broader trend of US companies switching from employment being a long-term relationship that sometimes span decades to a short-term relationship that typically spans just a few years, with layoffs being rather commonplace these days, even when the company isn’t struggling. Companies want employees who are able to contribute immediately, and some would rather let go of employees who don’t fit into changing business needs rather than invest in retraining them.

      I don’t know the situation in Europe, but in Japan there are still many large employers who hire employees directly out of college with the expectation that they’ll be part of the company for the long term. Japanese companies still invest in training junior employees. Now, colleges in Japan still serve as a stepping stone to a stable career, but unlike in America, job training hasn’t been outsourced to Japanese universities. I know people with bachelor’s degrees in math and physics who became computer science researchers at Japanese companies through years of internal training.

    • bluefirebrand

      Employers wanting to do the minimum they can for their employees is absolutely a big problem for society in general right now.

      • cattenwallen

        I really am fascinated by the adjustment of a corporation as being an entity responsible to society at large to an entity being responsible solely to shareholders. I'm young, I don't remember 9/11, but from the ways my older coworkers talk about it seems they remember a time (not their time but their parents' time maybe) that a corporation was expected to at least have a veneer of caring for their people and be for the betterment of society as a whole.

  • robotresearcher

    Your complaint is that they:

    - meet graduation targets

    - [support] research

    Having undergrads succeed in graduating, and having labs do research seems… ok. No?

mtrx

Since I run a writing-process-based AI detection platform (www.turingo.net), I’m in regular contact with many professors. Here’s what I’m seeing:

Some have started banning AI and reverting to oral exams, and they say they’re happier for it!

Others are trying to avoid AI by restructuring lessons around group work, in-class discussions, debates, and other activities. This takes a lot of work, and it’s unclear how it affects the quality of the education they provide. After all, you won’t learn how to write a business proposal through debates alone...

Many feel like they’re fighting a losing battle against students’ overuse of AI. I’m happy to report that some of them are now my clients and use the writing process to TALK to students about their work. That seems to help more than making accusations without proof.

There are also those who advocate for universities to embrace AI. The idea sounds appealing, but I’ve yet to see it implemented properly. IMO, they ignore that students need to develop foundational skills the hard way before they can tackle more complex problems or judge AI’s work. They can’t develop those skills by outsourcing the work to AI. It’s like claiming you understand a codebase just because you’ve done few code reviews... And with every new model release, it becomes harder to define what a complex, “AI-resistant” problem even looks like!

Interestingly, I see the same assumption among students who want to be AI-ready for the workplace: that knowing how to prompt is enough...

I wish I knew what the answer was. Maybe banning AI for the first couple of years... or entirely, as some professors already do? After all, isn't this how most of us learned?

I’m certainly glad I’m not a university student right now.. :)

chriskanan

I wrote an article about this a year ago: https://syntheticminds.substack.com/p/universities-must-embr...

But as a professor, enrollments are way down. In general, this was expected but not prepared for just due to the "demographic cliff" due to people having fewer children in the USA. I think university leadership had an aspirational hope that foreign enrollment would fill that gap, but instead foreign applicants have gone way down (and this was starting to happen even before the Trump administration accelerated it).

Universities are very slow moving and most professors, even in computer science, haven't really been using agents. Even as an AI professor, it is _so_ hard to keep up with the pace of change. I'd say my opinions are more dire now, than I express in that article I wrote a year ago.

  • somethingsome

    Yes and the most problematic aspect is that universities are very slow moving.

    I wouldn't actually mind to have fewer students, but only students that are really there for learning.

  • scitec

    The university in the sense of the Lyceum survived the Roman Empire, the Middle Ages and even critical theory and will surely survive genAI.

    The university as remade in America from the Morrill Act of 1862 through the 1944 G.I. Bill has had large and largely positive influences on agricultural education and the research efforts and training of the American workforce that capitalized on the postwar era and produced the laurels they now rest on..

    Generative AI threatens the parts of these training and research endeavors that are most lucrative in terms of tuition and grants and arguably least aligned with the original Lyceum's ideal.

    It would be beneficial, from the overall perspective of the history of the university in western society, if this precipitated a restructuring that did away with dubious gegrees and research projects, but as there is no one ready to advocate for the return to the intellectual ideals of the Lyceum, my personal observations at the SEC institutions that I deal is that the overall strategic shifts are currently more focused on moving towards profitability enhancement in collegiate sports teams [1,2] and degrees that appeal to social media influenced high school students [3,4] and similar..

    University-corporate partnerships which, while too varied to characterize generally, seem the best hope for American style universities to realign their vocational and research missions, given the uniformly unresponsive nature of their own management structures. The twin threats of demographics and rapidly proliferating generative AI capabilities in the mid and lower levels of most professional and research workforces mean that, absent a coordinated and fluent response from university administrators, the best thing American style universities can do in the professional spheres that their students have traditionally aspired to is to serve as facilitators for on the job training, essentially vetting and supporting students and workplaces (from whom they should draw revenues proportionately).

    More importantly, in the era of 1.5C+ climate change, it seems likely that their original role after the American Civil War as agricultural education and research institutions will once again become their most important future role..

    1. https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Articles/2025/12/01/in... 2. https://fortune.com/2026/08/21/business-of-college-sports/ 3. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/tech-innovation/teaching... 4. https://thehill.com/homenews/education/5030730-social-media-...

    • talon8635

      Did it survive critical theory? Seems to be self imploding under that ideology over past decade.

  • wolfinterval

    As if the completely ridiculous cost of college is not causing this at the margin for enrollment to be down.

    IMO the biggest problem is the faculty/admin/decision makers at these colleges.

    You all have totally failed society.

barbariangrunge

If you have teenage kids, what do you tell them to do to prepare for the near future? Do you send them to uni? To study what? Or do you advise something else? Curious how the hn crowd is approaching this with their own teenagers

  • yummypaint

    A general education is more useful than ever. Being a strong and clear communicator (writing and speaking) with a command of logic (math, cs, science) and a cultural participant (history politics and the arts) will always be important. Being able to learn new things quickly will always be important. Avoid "training" programs that turn students into one trick ponies.

  • frereubuOP

    I have a 12-year-old and having been thinking about this a lot. This podcast is part of a series that PPF Ideas are doing (you can go to Episodes and filter by "Can Universities Survive" at the top) and it's been really helpful to give me a bit of the lay of the land. Everything is changing so fast I haven't reached any conclusions, and we still have a way to go with our child, but I found them useful, particularly the later ones in the series after the historical stuff.

figers

Ronny Chieng Commencement speech clip

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DfdEs7VhvaX/

yepyoukno

Let us focus on the transformation of individuals into competent capable and responsible persons.

Universities have an opportunity to reinvent.

The mind that there must be a currency conversion for every virtue is a product of successful western consumertopia.

When we learn to live for ourselves rather than the measure of our projected whole we will learn in entirely new and more gratifying ways.

  • frereubuOP

    I think you would enjoy the linked podcast. They cover a lot of this. There's also this episode in the same series that advocates for the role of universities in developing rounded people as a whole not just degree factories: https://www.ppfideas.com/episodes/can-universities-survive-f... Some enjoyable advocacy for English literature degrees given that the current UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham studied English at Cambridge.

  • bsoles

    > Universities have an opportunity to reinvent.

    It must be stated that traditional universities are extremely bureaucratic and slow-moving organizations, with a top-down management structure when it comes to policy decisions. They might have an opportunity to reinvent, but they have absolutely no structural ability to do so. I reckon a lot of them will go the way Kodak did.

  • epolanski

    > Universities have an opportunity to reinvent.

    Universities have always been about the growth of the individual and intellectual community.

    It's only in the last 3 decades that the attention shifted on creating cogs that match the economic system.

    Even on this very board you see endless comments about their curriculum not fitting whatever was the state of some industry at the time.

    • scottLobster

      Please, the highest paid university faculty are coaches, and many prestigious private institutions (i.e. Harvard) have endowments so large they're essentially tax-advantaged hedge funds that double as finishing schools for the well-connected.

      A university truly devoted to the growth of the individual and intellectual community is a pet project of the wealthy or bankrupt.

      • fph

        > the highest paid university faculty are coaches

        That's an America problem, not a world problem.

      • HWR_14

        > the highest paid university faculty are coaches, and many prestigious private institutions (i.e. Harvard)

        The highest paid Harvard employee in a non-administrative role is a CS professor, making somewhere between 5x and 8x what the head coach makes.

        • scottLobster

          Meanwhile the head coach of Duke University Men's Basketball makes more than the University President.

          And if you went to Harvard and misread my statement so badly, it's further indication that education isn't the top priority.

          • HWR_14

            You put forth a universal rule about coaches salaries. It only applies to the SEC/Big10/a few others for football and in a small number of competitive teams in basketball.

            Duke makes it to the final four frequently.

            A small percentage of schools.

          • hoppyhoppy2

            The highest-paid state employee of the entire State of North Carolina is the head men's basketball coach at UNC-Chapel Hill. Or the head coach of the same school's football program, depending on how you calculate it. Third is the football coach at NC State University.

      • epolanski

        Not sure what does your comment has to do with mine.

        • scottLobster

          You were stating a very rose-tinted ideal that wasn't true 30 years ago any more than it is today.

          • epolanski

            My university (Sapienza in Rome, Italy) is 500 years older than your country, the US.

            I don't think that whatever happens in your utilitarian and commercial education system represents the global norm.

      • 11101010010001

        I tell my students they better learn enough before they graduate so they can drop out and not become cogs in the machine!

  • gosub100

    And get the prestigious-journal rat race cancelled too (publish or perish). Strictly focus on advancing their field of study.

    I get the complaints about academic decline in students. But they're doing it to avoid poverty. I think that's a more noble cause than the research tier that chases grant money. They already have a huge cash flow from tuition. If the administration steals it for a new dorm tower and athletic center every 5 years, that's a separate problem.

bemtevi

I hope some of the existing ones don't, especially the top-tier research institutions. They're elitist, out-of-touch factories for producing cogs in the failing machine of AI-powered capitalism.

Maybe something new and more human-oriented will come about that actually is kinder and more beneficial for the individual.

  • talon8635

    I hope so but I’ve yet to hear an argument for investing in human knowledge when replicable and infinitely available and tireless magical machines will be order of magnitude smarter on every topic and more capable on every task

    If school was 100% free and you have nothing better to do than because there’s no employment to be had, or money to earn, and the only other option is scrolling endless addictively entertaining AI produced content… then sure, universities can maintain a presence

    I don’t want to be a doomer, but I am just not hearing and coherent argument for how this all plays out

    • bemtevi

      > magical machines will be order of magnitude smarter on every topic and more capable on every task

      Perhaps we shouldn't put "most efficient completion of tasks // innovation" as a priority. I certainly don't.

yepyoukno

I thought about this.

Universities should be like monasteries (over time) where serious minded persons, either in the ascent as young minds, or re-investigating mature minds, go to test, and press the precipice of “modern” human understanding.

A fresh look, or devotional niche will continue to churn human significance, whatever our technology does.

Everyone else should just go make money, live well, and adapt (learn) on the fly.

metalman

ZERO computer or wireless conectivity universitys. learn to learn,establish solid personal work habbits and organizational skills, and show usefull knowledge and skills in there chosen fields, then get clicky with it. we do not need hordes of 'google graduates' 'ai pro's', bro

  • thunderpaper

    I'd even be open to a place like this but with a LAN without connection to the broader internet. Without a search engine or especially LLMs, it could be amazing.

    That said, the appeal of zero computers is strong too, and I can see how it'd have better mass appeal (easier to explain, etc.).

  • marstall

    that would be great. a refuge from screens into a space for learning and connecting.

    maybe it could spread out into spaces eventually that could be accessed by adults

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection