Settings

Theme

United Airlines experiencing a widespread system outage, airline says

cnn.com

235 points by bearsyankees · 123 comments · 1 min read

Reader

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50524260

23 threads
zytoon

Experienced teams gone with layoffs. AI based attacks smarter. Going forward its going to be part of life and cost of doing business. When these disruptions hit analog things (water, power, transportation) its going to be even crazier

  • henny_no

    Lots of speculation and hysteria, but very little actual information. It's been difficult to navigate these stories.

  • Beijinger

    This is possible. But still, I don't like it.

    Military rule of thumb:

    It happens once, it happens by chance. It happens twice, it is bad luck. It happens three times; it is sabotage.

    • whatshisface

      The USB-C to 3.5mm adapter I use has broken way past three times - I think it's a precursor to an alien invasion.

      • ssl-3

        Your USB-C to 3.5mm adapter has an entire goddamn USB sound card and headphone amplifier built into the connector, and this fact alone should serve as adequate proof of an alien invasion.

    • bix6

      Is that a serious military rule of thumb? By strike 3 everyone is dead…

      • jayrot

        No it’s not a serious military rule. It’s from a James Bond novel.

        “Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action" -Ian Fleming, Goldfinger

        Still a pithy quote though!

    • eastbound

      Especially since "NATO fans on social networks" (not saying it's massive, AI-driven propaganda, but it's curious) constantly tout our capacity to destroy Russian factories, distribution centers and refineries.

      • mikrotikker

        Yes but the difference is NATO doesn't use deniable third parties with names like fancy bear or silkworm, so any action would be an act of war, not to mention that NATO is a defense pact, not offence.

        • rapidaneurism

          If the Iraq liberation can be claimed to be a defensive act, then there are very few actions that would not be defensive.

          • apelapan

            The invasion of Iraq was not a NATO operation. Neither was the attack on Afghanistan.

            NATO:s article 5 response to 9/11 was mostly symbolic and took place in North America and the Mediterranean.

            Wikipedia has all the details, in case you are actually interested.

  • skeeter2020

    >> Experienced teams gone with layoffs.

    I'm seeing the opposite; juniors & intermediates gone under the guise of "talent densification". IMO this is no better than losing more experienced people; it's all being done as cost cutting and they will pay the price.

    • bigfatkitten

      I see both.

      Layoffs target the juniors and intermediates. In response to that, the experienced people with the best prospects elsewhere will jump.

      Better to leave on your own terms for a new opportunity that you actually want than to be forced into the job market when you get laid off also.

      • paimapi

        This is what I'm seeing too. Nobody wants to get left behind with a skeleton crew expected to keep the same pace.

        The 'right-sizing' tactic is just a lot of acquisitions that didn't play well and those consequences socialized to ICs instead of the execs or the boards that pushed for those moves in the first place.

        Those COVID-era interest rates might be great but if there's negative returns then corps will absolutely pull the lever for the trolley to run over the largest number of people possible if it means they get to avoid it.

    • ijidak

      > and they will pay the price

      Correction, we all will pay the price.

      Their degradation is our degradation. Their outage is our outage. Their collapse is our collapse.

      I'm not sure alternative providers can stand up fast enough to offset their rapid slide.

      Otherwise, I'm completely with you.

  • ulfw

    Too simple an explanation. We are seeing attacks on major western companies right now from Microsoft over Chase to United, Bank of America, Wells Fargo

    This is "hey is the plane flying into World Trade Center an accident, oh shit there is another one, this isn't an accident" level bad now

    • solid_fuel

      None of these recent incidents have been cyber attacks.

      • mikrotikker

        That's just what they told us. It's not entirely unheard of for enemy actions, especially successful ones to be denied. Especially if they want to draw the enemies into claiming their actions

    • CyberDildonics

      This is based on what evidence?

  • mminer237

    They're saying it's not a cyber attack, AI-based or not. It's just a good old fashioned production bug, like the last several.

    • tedd4u

      It's easy to believe this is just a software or software hosting problem. United has had several outages related specifically to their weight-and-balance tools:

         • Today       : ~90 min departure hold; 400+ delayed flights
         • Aug  6, 2025: Multi-airport ground stops; 1,000+ delays, 200+ cancellations 
         • Apr  1, 2019: ~150 United Express regional flights delayed or held
         • Oct 13, 2016: Overnight departure holds and cascading system-wide delays
      
      And if you broaden to include all flight-affecting IT issues, that adds in these dispatch, operations, and electronic comms outages:

         • Jul 19, 2024: Global ground stop; widespread delays and cancellations
         • Sep  5, 2023: ~1 hr nationwide FAA ground stop; 260 delays (~9% of schedule)
         • Jan 22, 2017: ~2.5 hr nationwide domestic ground stop
         • Jul  8, 2015: ~2 hr nationwide ground stop; 1,100+ delays, 60+ cancellations
         • Jun  2, 2015: ~1 hr domestic departure pause; widespread delays
         • Jun 20, 2007: ~2 hr nationwide departure halt; hundreds of delays, 24 cancellations
      
      They do seem to be increasing in frequency though.
    • vlovich123

      Are they legally required to be honest? In the past companies have hidden attacks because they fear it makes them a repeat target and it shakers the confidence of their clients.

      • gruez

        Yes, because of the threat of securities fraud lawsuits.

        • vlovich123

          I don’t believe that’s the case. That only applies if the breach might be materially relevant and that’s the same wording used in the SEC 4-day reporting rule. There’s even been pushback against the SEC trying to pierce the corporate veil (successful with Joe Sullivan, not with SolarWinds). I’m not so sure it’s as clear cut as you claim.

        • fivetenpen

          They can certainly lie if they are directed to by the government. And some governments are opposed to AI regulation as a matter of national security.

        • joquarky

          Historically, what kind of penalties are applied as the result of those lawsuits?

    • gibsonf1

      Such as someone using genAI for mission-critical production code.

      • schaefer

        If you have evidence to back up your claim, please share it. Or is this baseless speculation?

        • paganel

          The evidence should now point to the contrary, i.e. that the code was not AI-generated. There are many people on forums like this one saying that at their (big, although not-named) big companies they haven't touched actual code when programming for the last 6 months or so, and judging by what I encounter on my search for a job right now this is what the general "spirit" of the industry is.

        • solid_fuel

          Haven't you heard that the age of manual coding is over? You can check almost any comment section here and see people loudly proclaiming that no one writes code by hand anymore - the entire industry has gone to genAI coding.

          I don't buy that narrative for the whole industry, but I have seen management at a lot of tech companies aggressively pushing LLMs for coding, and in the process they often expect increased delivery speed. That means generated code that has not been properly reviewed or designed is often being shipped and more frequent outages would not be a surprising result.

    • carabiner

      This is basically skynet.

    • IAmGraydon

      Who needs cyber attacks when we’re very good at sabotaging our own critical infrastructure with vibe coded nonsense?

  • interestica

    So, tomorrow?

tyingq

It's whatever their integration is with a vendor that does weight and balance before the flight. Likely not the vendor, as that vendor serves many airlines.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/united-airlines-system-outage-d...

throwawaypty

Complex systems won't survive the competency crisis.

aschla

This would have probably gone unnoticed by most, including news organizations, if last week's debacle wasn't so recent.

  • ragequittah

    Agreed. Now we get to hear about every minor system outage for a few weeks and people will blame cyber attacks (super competent AI) or vibe coding (incompetent AI) for all of it with 0 evidence. If you ever worked for a big company you know regular outages were a thing way before anyone was using AI.

codeduck

It's Monday evening and this week already feels like Bedlam.

colesantiago

This appears that it is going to get a bit worse before it gets much better.

sooraj_sj

is it outlook issue?

jmyeet

The problem is nobody in leadership ever gets punished for any of this. So you have quarter after quarter of cost-cutting for share buybacks and then eventually it's too much and the entire thing blows up. And then you just blame it on someone or something else.

And then things need to be fixed, often manually, and that's impossible because all the customer service staff were fired, offshored to India and/or replaced with AI chatbots. Nobody knows what they're doing because there's no training, high turnover and 3 hour wait times anyway.

And then some big firm comes in and replaces the system at the cost of hundreds of millions if not billions and it barely works at all. But it's convenient because the leadership can blame McKinsey (or whoever) while everybody is making money all the way down and that CEO, if they ever get ousted, will get another job anyway.

The desperate desire to displace, deskill and offshore every ounce of labor involved in all of this is going to be a huge problem for society at some point too.

This is mostly why I don't believe any of these outages were cyberattacks. Why cyberattack something that'll simply fall apart all on its own soon enough?

And while these all are separate incidents with different reasons, I don't think the public is going to make that distinction. I don't know what the long term consequences of this but I get the feeling that public sentiment is going to significantly change in the coming years as these issues will (IMHO) become more common.

  • xnx

    > The problem is nobody in leadership ever gets punished for any of this.

    It only matters to leadership if it affects the stock price. If it affects the stock price, there's definitely punishment.

  • _doctor_love

    The reckoning is not here quiet yet but it is for sure coming soon. AI is the accelerant that will tip most people over the line and into things falling apart.

    I think on the long-term we will have another quality revolution but it will take time. Likely it will have to get pretty ugly first unfortunately.

dolphinscorpion

Iran? North Korea?

jrflo

Microsoft, FAA, the banking system, now this- I'm usually not one to believe in conspiracy theories, but this is starting to look really odd. I know no one has said any of these were cyberattacks, but could it be a really covert attack that is unlike something we've seen before? Some unreleased internal model going haywire?

Please, someone give the boring explanation...

  • kylecazar

    I don't know the cause, but if you step back -- 13% of a single airline's departures are delayed. This isn't all that rare.

    I suspect it's a good example of media bandwagoning and availability cascade.

    • jrflo

      This the stance I'd usually take if it was just 2 or 3 incidents, but with 4 major systems being completely disrupted within 4 days is really odd.

      • motionlessveloc

        The United issue affected 13% of flights and was resolved in under 45 minutes.

        This would not even be news if people weren't jumpy after last week's chaos.

        • swsieber

          This. At $PREVIOUS_JOB people would call in the day of a release (a saas product) and insist something broke in a new way for them only for us to dig in and see it was an existing bug that people only noticed because they knew there was a release.

        • mym1990

          The spokespeople say 45 minutes, but our flight was brought back to the gate, deplaned, we were given little to no information for 2 hours and then reboarded. All in all, 4 hours delayed.

        • fma

          Every article I have read says it took 1.5 hours.

      • IAmGraydon

        You’re missing his point.

      • vkou

        It's not odd in the brave new world where any idiot with an LLM can pwn your company, and where any internal idiot with an LLM can push out a fix for that exploit that will break your company.

  • United857

    Part of it is recency bias. For instance after a plane crash, the media tends to report on every single aviation incident following it that otherwise wouldn’t have made the news. We’re seeing the same thing play out here in the IT space.

    • Merrill

      Without better data, it's impossible to say whether there is an event cluster or simply editorial selection.

  • smellf

    My pet theory: LLMs make software development go a lot faster. Their code also has fewer defects per unit shipped than human-written code does, on average and when LLMs are used properly. But since the volume is up, the absolute defect count is up too, even though the defect rate per unit of code shipped is lower.

    • shonenknifefan1

      This is my boring theory as well. I suspect that the defects at probably developing at the boundary between services. Everyone is accelerating using AI at the time, but maybe we are neglecting the human coordination between systems, or we haven't come to equilibrium in a new world yet where everyone is developing at a much faster pace than before.

      • smellf

        The system boundaries thing is a really good point. The only reason we all still have jobs is because the LLM context is finite - it can't yet reliably do really broad context like people can, so we have to focus them in on one subsystem, and they don't know what they don't know, leading to these integration gaps.

        Unfortunately I think the AI researchers will figure it out, next year or five years from now. There's too much money riding on the "let's fire all the SWEs" bet, and there's prior art - we exist, so that machine can (probably) exist.

    • __MatrixMan__

      Any thoughts on why the changes, now being made more quickly, aren't taking the systems to a more robust state? Is it just the same old "we're not paying off tech debt" complaint, now at hyperspeed, or is something about the speed creating new kinds of debt?

      • smellf

        Most software systems aren't being made more robust because robustness in most orgs is still prioritized the same as it has always been, they're just shipping product faster. You could ship product with fewer defects at a slower pace, but that's not Moving Fast and Breaking Things™. Market forces dictate the speed at which product needs to ship, and you have to balance that with the defect rate to be competitive.

      • dannyw

        It’s almost code freeze time for many organisations, so people are pushing things out to close the year with something for performance review.

        Also, if you flip a fair coin enough times, you’ll eventually get a streak that feels rigged or strange.

    • glad_duck

      > Their code also has fewer defects per unit shipped than human-written code does

      Nope, and here's why:

      > when LLMs are used properly

      Yeah, and when they (humans) keep failing to use something "properly" there is always "No True Scotsman" argument. Nothing new in this world, we had it before. FP, strong type systems, memory safety etc. Bugs keep coming though.

      • AnimalMuppet

        Don't just blame the programmers, either. Management mandates like "all developers must use X number of token per week" absolutely guarantee that LLMs are not used properly by most developers.

  • ac29

    Airlines have major outages frequently, its a pretty fragile system

    • trollbridge

      Oddly enough they didn’t used to and used to have rock solid computer systems with paper backup procedures. So did banks

  • porkshoe

    The cost and special abilities required to hack almost any system have plummeted because of AI.

    As such, cyberattacks are no longer limited to people and organizations with unusual capabilities.

  • eggdaft

    It seems patently obvious there are a series of cyber attacks going on. In the UK we have been told to prep food and water, which is obviously for a cyber attack, so the govt clearly knows more than they’re letting on.

    They don’t want people to panic, they want to decide how and when to retaliate without it being all over the press.

    It’s going to get weirder and it’s going to take a while to get through this.

    • michaelt

      > In the UK we have been told to prep food and water, which is obviously for a cyber attack,

      Agreed - and we've seen cyberattacks against e.g. supermarket fridges so it's clear supply chain infrastructure is at risk.

      > so the govt clearly knows more than they’re letting on.

      Do they? It's no great secret that many internet-of-things/SCADA/PLC systems have very poor security, and that a lot of it gets connected to the internet anyway. It's also well known that any organisation of thousands of employees will have someone fooled by a phishing e-mail from time to time.

      We also live in an age with a lot of sabre-rattling, and a lot of war - Ukraine/Russia, Israel/Palestine, America/Iran.

  • spankibalt

    Don't worry, it's gonna get worse.

  • vikramkr

    Im genuinely 50/50 on what the boring Occam's razor explanation is. Because obviously it should be "software be buggy sometimes" like duh. However, hypothetically: - let there country A and country C - A and C are caught in technological arms race involving technology that enables cyberattcks - A has a much more powerful version of the technology than C so C probably does not want a direct escalatory cyberwar - A large event occurs in which Cs apparent access to an important enabling technology for this arms race is revealed and the consequences likely involve A cutting them off - The leaders of A and C are also scheduled to meet at a summit within days of the large event.

    So we are in a period between the large event and a summit. A period where C may feel compelled to make a point/insinuate consequences before a pivotal meeting. But also if they do anything that's obviously a cyber attack and traceable it could escalate and they might not win.

    If suddenly there are a series of high profile embarrassing disruptive cyber occurrences with no clear shared cause during that interval impacting As government and key industry players in their tech banking and defense sectors, well, look. Occam's razor is still probably "software be buggy." But also like they're on their way to a summit literally this week which sounds like a really obvious time to amp up the pressure a bit no?

  • joshAg

    The boring explanation is no one actually gives any fucks at all about reliability. They sometimes think they do and they sometimes say they do, but when the KPIs meet the roadmap, reliability reliably gets prioritized behind shipping more features faster. Fail fast. Agile. Ship the MVP and iterate. Etc. If you've read fight club or watched the movie and remember the bit about whether Ford will do a vehicle recall, they're essentially doing that but for making the system reliable. There's a very strong argument that they're actually right, because as painful and expensive as these outages are, they pale in comparison to the money that gets raked in from being the first-mover and establishing a moat.

    That's not a fun thing to arrive at for people who want to build reliable and secure systems, but if that's what you actually want, get a job coding something that is actually EAL (or something similar) certified even to just level 1, because everything else is just lying to themselves and everyone else when it says it cares about reliability. No, an SLA isn't equivalent.

  • dpkirchner

    It could also be folks emergency patching yet-to-be-exploited zero days, for all we know.

  • solarpunk_enthu

    Anthropic later today: apologiez everyone, that was our model. Just hyping our IPO in this grim post-Huang environment. Please forgive us and don't forget to invest.

  • carimura

    While we're on the subject, there was also the Jensen leak and immediate follow up of other victims.... all seemed quite odd on timing with everything else.

  • alfalfasprout

    gutting teams with experienced people in favor of cheaper talent with AI will produce these results. It's nothing new. We saw this in the past with heavy outsourcing pushes too, the velocity of the change is just unlike we've ever seen before.

    Combine that with offensive cybersecurity research now leveraging AI and you have a recipe for disaster.

ernubufiei

I wonder if all these outages are caused by very bad security bugs (AI) being found, rushing out a fix, and there being issues in the fix or the updates surrounding it.

A lot of these systems I suspect are not built to be updated at the velocity current security patches require.

  • al_borland

    This is the tension I'm seeing at work. One side of the business saying, "update everything NOW!!!!", while the other side is saying, "don't you dare skip the 15 levels of approval and testing required to roll that patch out everywhere. You need to coordinate 300 teams to test if you want to roll this out."

    Action and inaction both result in job risk, and it's also a race against the clock hoping nothing is exploited while sorting out the politics.

    • robomc

      Yeah it's total victory for the CI devops always-be-deploying people tbh, because everything on the internet needs to be more or less instantly updatable from here on out. Traditional change control is going to seem comically quaint in a few years.

      • al_borland

        I've even seen issues there where the security team wants action today, but the CI process requires waiting for packages to be properly released.

        • jamesfinlayson

          Yeah where I work, any change needs to be approved with a two day lead team. Security of course expect it be fixed by the end of the day.

The_Blade

this following the Microsoft, Claude, FAA / NWS, and Banking Big B outages

with Anthropic's IPO and GTA VI hitting the same day this week, what could possibly go wrong?

SoftTalker

If you don't want to suffer CNN's main website:

https://lite.cnn.com/2026/11/16/us/united-airlines-outage

jjoe

A lot of security researchers/tinkerers, who would occasionally stumble upon vulnerabilities in websites and report them responsibly, threw the towel long ago. They'd rather not get sucked into lawsuits for being samaritans. It left a gap wide open for ruthless LLMs/agents. I guess you can't subpoena an LLM / agent yet

rootsudo

so the ramp up to the holiday change freeze issues are hitting hard this year.

I wouldn't want to be travelling much this year. Southwest had their issue because, what floppies? They were quick to pivot to make a solution for their crew manifests be cloud based and well...

One airline crew issue will cascade to the others quickly.

jaybrendansmith

Hmm. Sure. All of these outages are not because of AI hacks. Do they think we're stupid??

api

Anyone have any explanation that is not just a wild guess rooted in trend du jour?

dead_hn_theory

Looks like China sending a message for Huang's departure.

The best is yet to come.

aristofun

Wait till ai slop reaches actual planes designs and firmware - i hope only cargo planes will fall from the sky.

methodical

I'm starting to think that the AI companies might've been lying about what the singularity looks like and it'll actually be a world where 90% uptime is the new norm. Thanks, I hate it.

  • lsllc

    I don't know about that but I'm very happy with Microsoft Office 328.5!

  • api

    Yes near term instability in systems that undergo large changes never improves. Cars are still as dangerous as they were in the 1950s and power plants never got scrubbers. OSes today crash as often as MS-DOS did in the 1980s.

    • fedpost

      Not sure if sarcasm?

      Cars are killing more people than in the 1950s, particularly as of late in America thanks to the vehicle size arms race.

      Power plants are being deregulated

      Windows has completely gone to shit, MacOS following suit. Not as crash happy as DOS was but not great

      • KerrAvon

        Cars are killing fewer people than in the 1950s in America; this is not actually debatable. Even if you single out only pedestrians killed by cars, it's down from the 1950's peak.

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...

        Are they killing too many people still? Yup! Should Americans buy smaller cars? Yup! Etc.

        Power plants are not being deregulated as a whole. The current US regime is hostile to any sort of regulation but that regime is on the way out starting in January.

        Windows and macOS are fine. macOS remains exceptionally stable. I moved to Linux on my PC so I can't vouch for Windows as of right now, but I used 11 up until the AI screenshot cruft went in.

        • fedpost

          It's pretty debatable if the link you post shows a big red graph with the 50s averaging at something like 38k deaths and the most recent data point at 48k deaths...

          Also we're literally building hundreds of unregulated gas turbine generators across the country which have no emissions controls.

          • icedchai

            How about measuring deaths per capita? The US population has more than doubled since the 50's. On top of that, vehicle ownership also more than doubled.

          • NeutralCrane

            It’s only debatable if you ignore the concepts of a rates and exposure

            • JumpCrisscross

              > It’s only debatable if you ignore the concepts of a rates and exposure

              To be fair, "cars are killing fewer people than in the 1950s in America" is a statement about magnitude. "Cars are safer" or "cars are killing people less frequently" would be more correct.

            • fedpost

              Are we looking at the same big red graph?

              It sounds like you're trying to argue something in terms of per mile rates or whatever instead of # of dead people > other # dead people?

empath75

All these places put out statements really quickly that it's not a cyberattack to the point that it makes me suspicious that these _are_ cyberattacks.

  • password54321

    Saying it is a cyberattack could lead to a greater loss of people trusting your platform, so probably.

  • happytoexplain

    It is a cyberattack in a sense. The cyberattack of low-regulation capitalism on complex systems.

solarpunk_enthu

Anthropic later today: apologiez everyone, that was our model. Just hyping our IPO in this grim post-Huang environment. Please forgive us and don't forget to invest.

jsLavaGoat

All the people in the other thread saying it's all just a coincidence.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection