Settings

Theme

Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display

trmnl.com

529 points by geerlingguy · 440 comments

Reader

56 threads
Calvin02

I was a huge fan of Trmnl when they first launched. I even convinced my friends to buy a few.

Then the QA started to go down or the devices wouldn’t ship on time. On top of that, Ryan’s politics were a big turnoff.

I would not buy another device from this company.

  • psadauskas

    Since he deleted his blog, and scrubbed it all from wayback, here's an archive of some of the problematic things Ryan has written: https://thewritingsofryankculp.pages.dev/

    • JoshTriplett
      • hyperbovine

        Wow! Putting wallet back in pocket.

        • ffsm8

          While he seems incredibly immature to put this out on the internet, y'all in serious help of mental health care as well.

          • kashunstva

            > While he seems incredibly immature…

            Immaturity is the least of the issues. He appears to hold views that are deeply offensive to many.

            > y'all in serious help of mental health care as well.

            For what mental disorder is one’s refusal to financially support an offensive person a diagnostic criterion?

          • angoragoats

            As a person who has had mental health issues in the past, and who is now happily medicated/therapized (?) and doing very well, I am also putting my wallet away and will never take it out again for this guy.

            It's really slimy to accuse others of needing mental health care, especially over the internet. Please stop it.

          • hyperbovine

            Well, the other reason I wasn't sold is because I'm reading this product info and thinking, Wait! They're just rebranding eInk hardware that you can easily source from other vendors (e.g. WaveShare, Seeed Studio, AliBaba) for much less. Their software ecosystem is not really a value add for me, especially now that Claude has entered the chat.

            But the fact that the founder appears to be some sort of MAGA groyper nutcase doesn't really help, no.

      • alwaysmrno

        Holy crap this is a goldmine! "men die in wars so women can gossip with friends about colleagues they don't like"

        This guy is hillarious

        • dennis_jeeves2

          I wish it were only hilarious (which it is). There is a lot of truth in what he says

          • ozozozd

            You haven’t heard of mandatory military service in Israel where women also serve?

            Or Soviet women who flew warplanes?

            Do you not have the Internet?

        • limagnolia

          I haven't read the context, but that sounds like a sarcastic take on the Freedom of speech and the idea of soldiers "fighting for liberty". I'm sure there is more to what was said than that, but just going off that one quote out of context, it sounds like parody.

      • sixothree

        That's outright unhinged.

      • KuhlMensch

        :|

      • darkwater

        Oh god, another DHH and Elon.

    • hattmall

      His opinions seem shockingly reasonable, albeit poorly phrased in some cases.

      The bottom line is it's a cool and unique product but generally too expensive for what it is right now.

    • schainks

      YIKES.

      • 0x6c6f6c

        This is a better summary of what I wanted to say without getting reported here. I am truly appalled

        • schainks

          I mean, you never know who is building what tech that does the job, but trying to scrub what are obviously terrible things to say publicly is... a look.

          If you're blaming others publicly, that's not really owning your own problems, eh.

    • nunez

      Wow. I thought TRMNL was cool; no way I'm buying any now.

    • tarokun-io

      Thanks for sharing. I had no idea...

      Just reading the first few gave me a knot in my stomach.

    • Modified3019

      Ah, good to know.

    • Zambyte

      What's the deal with e-paper and people being bad at have opinions? I personally got the Daylight Computer day one of pre-orders being open. Now they've gone anti-vax. I was about to order this device as well, but then I saw this. I still may order it, but this sucks. Funding this behavior feels ugly.

      Edit since this is being downvoted: https://casewrites.leaflet.pub/3mt5ap4xpxs2a?utm_source=blue...

      This is not my blog post, but I am writing this comment on my DC-1.

      • _heimdall

        I'm actually surprised "anti-vax" would be enough to make you reconsider the purchase. Assuming the link above are indeed quotes from the TRMNL guy, there's some pretty unhinged stuff in there. Anti-vax seems pretty tame in comparison.

        • Zambyte

          Yes, tame in comparison. In isolation it sucks.

          • _heimdall

            Maybe? I don't have such a strong reaction to it. I haven't seen data convincing me that autism is in part caused by childhood vaccines, but I also haven't seen data convincing me of any other root cause.

            I'd rather people research unconventional or unpopular hypothesis then have everyone focused on one idea, or only focused on symptom management.

            • BobaFloutist

              Your perspective, while superficially reasonable, amounts to a public health hazard. Children die because their parents just aren't quite sure about one or two specific vaccines. Even if there were a (necessarily microscopic) link between autism and childhood vaccines, you would be buying reduced rates of autism with dead children, at a less than 1:1 ratio.

              • _heimdall

                I think you're adding more to my view than what I said, or would agree with.

                Vaccines have strong evidence and a long history of relative safety (nothing is 100% safe, I'm not taking a slight at them being unsafe).

                If parents are reading to much into hypothesis related to autism causes, or ignoring evidence for vaccines used today, that's on them and up to them to decide.

                Is your argument that we should silence research into alternative ideas of what may be causing autism? Or are we on the same page in different words, i.e. people should follow what is best understood today and make their own decisions?

                • BobaFloutist

                  I don't think people should make their own decisions, I think they should trust their health-care providers and public health officials.

                  I think this for the same reason I think people shouldn't make their own decisions regarding fire and electrical codes or driving safety.

                  • _heimdall

                    We just very much have opposing views there then, which is totally fine and I'd rather have conversations with those that see things differently than be an echo chamber.

                    So to that end, thanks for plating along here.

                    My personal opinion is that people should look to experts but make their own decisions. The caveat there is when their decisions directly impact others in a meaningful way.

                    With vaccines that's a gray area in my opinion, a vast majority of the population is eligible to get vaccinated and if they work then it shouldn't matter what their neighbor does. With building codes, I live in a rural area and if I poorly wire my barns its largely just my problem, someone living in a more densely populated area is in a different situation.

            • JoshTriplett

              Much of the incorrect information claiming a link between the two comes from one fraudulent research paper by an author who made up his results for financial reasons: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wakefield_MMR-autism_fraud

              The author had a competing vaccine, and made money selling diagnostic kits for the syndrome that he'd made up.

              The same person peddled his anti-vax message elsewhere, including a 60 Minutes interview in the US, which largely kicked that off in the US.

              This is where quite a lot of it comes from: one fraudster doing it for fear and money.

              • _heimdall

                No argument there at all, and as I said I've never seen research that is convincing with regards to a link between vaccines and autism.

                My point was simply that more diverse avenues of research is useful if we want to find answers. In the meantime, people also shouldn't be making claims or policy that can't be backed up with solid research results.

                • JoshTriplett

                  > No argument there at all, and as I said I've never seen research that is convincing with regards to a link between vaccines and autism.

                  There has been specific research showing that there isn't a link. See the network of wikipedia articles starting from the one I linked.

                  • _heimdall

                    That's a hard argument to draw. While I do agree plenty of that research exists, its the only view given research dollars in any meaningful scale.

                    Again, for clarity as many here seem to be assuming I'm arguing against vaccines or for some autism link - I'm not. I'm reading the data today and don't see any good explanation for why autism rates have increased and support a wide range of research. I would propose, though, that research dollars haven't chased a similarly broad range of hypothesis so its difficult to read into the funded studies that focus on one main view.

                    • JoshTriplett

                      > While I do agree plenty of that research exists, its the only view given research dollars in any meaningful scale.

                      It's been given research dollars precisely to debunk the claims of fraudsters and anti-vaxxers. There's enough research there to be convincing in the negative. Right now, the research supports a conclusion of "I don't know, but it's not vaccines". (There may be also other negative results in the literature that are less well known.)

                      > why autism rates have increased

                      My hypothesis: largely for the same reason that left-handedness has "increased", namely increased diagnosis and increased acceptance.

                      • _heimdall

                        Allocating research dollars to debunk others claims is precisely the bias I'm talking about. My opinion would align with the idea that vaccines don't cause autism, but science needs to be blind to such opinions and by your own description said research was funded only to debunk hypothesise that have yet been proven or unproven.

                        Edit to add: your hypothesis seems reasonable though I don't considered being a lefty a diagnosis. I have wondered if autism is higher only by change to diagnostic procedure and focus, for example turning a single diagnosis into a spectrum must increase the rate of positive diagnoses.

                        • JoshTriplett

                          At this point I really have no idea what point you're trying to make. It seems like you're spending way too much energy attempting to apply misplaced cynicism to elevate a thoroughly debunked fraud that various people perpetuated, when the actual probability you assign to that fraud should round to zero.

            • felixgallo

              there's decades of research, and discreditation of research, showing that childhood vaccines are not caused by autism. If you instead reach for 'gosh I don't know, let's all just do our own research', you are absolutely on the side of the antivaxers.

              • _heimdall

                I think you likely meant childhood vaccines are causing autism rather than caused by.

                Your characterisation of my comment as "gosh I don't know, let's all just do our own research" isnt a fair representation of what I said.

                If you disagree in my claim that we don't know what causes are leading to higher autism rates, I'd be interested to see what you know of that I may have missed.

                I didn't say we should all do our own research, though are you opposed to people researching what is known today? Do you also take issue with informed consent, whick often requires doing your own research and asking the right questions?

                I take issue with the idea of "antivaxers" as a concept entirely, I'm not on either side. Expecting that people are either all for every vaccine offered or opposed to every vaccine is absurd, and anyone holding those views is just in a political debate that has no useful value.

                • GTP

                  I'm not an expert of this matter, I just would like to point out a logic mistake: saying we don't know the root cause for higher autism rates is different than saying vaccines aren't the cause. These statements can be true at the same time without any contradiction. Then maybe someone can add more information on what we know about the root cause. Without doing any research, I would suspect increased pollution might play a role.

                  • _heimdall

                    I agree, though its worth noting that if you go down the path of reading studies related to that purported link the breadth of research is highly biased. There are plenty of studies funded to disprove the link and extremely few, if any, funded to prove the link.

                    This is a hot topic so I feel the need to caveat each post here. I'm in no way saying vaccines, or any particular vaccine, is a cause of autism. I'm specifically pointing out that said link has never been found in any studies worth their salt. Down this chain of reasoning I'm simply adding that there is selection bias with regards to what hypothesise have been given funding at all, and its difficult to read an unbiased result from a pool of biased studies.

                    • felixgallo

                      on what possible basis do you accuse the pro-vax studies as being 'biased'?

                      • _heimdall

                        I don't actually know what would make a pro-vax study.

                        I'm arguing that the broad body of research disproving the link both may be valid and is biased. Biased because they start with the intent to disprove the link, and subject to selection bias as funding is almost exclusively given to any studies trying to disprove the link rather than prove it.

                        • felixgallo

                          I don't think you understand how science works.

                          • _heimdall

                            Enlighten me. My expectation is that science is blind to politics and popular opinion. Research should be focused on questions like "is there a correlational or causal link between X and Y" rather than "we need to debunk X"

                            If you're questioning scientific process, its also worth noting that almost all research into causes of autism are epistemological studies. Those can prove likely correlation not likely causation, they similarly can't disprove causation but may help disprove correlation. We'd need controlled studies to know more, and rightfully so no one is willing to approve such a thing for a condition like autism.

        • CGMthrowaway

          All * families are alike; each ** family is ** in its own way

        • alkonaut

          Being quietly anti-vax just means you're an idiot and perhaps endangering your kids or neighbors.

          If you're anti-vax and you have a megaphone to scream from, then you're not just dumb, you're dangerous. If you have actual power AND a megaphone, chances are you are going to be responsible for thousands of deaths.

          So there are certainly levels of anti-vax but it's mostly down to what kind of platform you have more than the opinions themselves (when it's true anti-vax sentiments, not just the milder "I think vaccines are great but I don't want to be first testing this" that we saw during Covid). Basically: the people who think Polio and Measles shouldn't be vaccinated against.

          • _heimdall

            I'm not sure of you're trying to claim that I'm quietly antivax so I'll assume positive intent, and for clarity I'm not. I was vaccinated and don't have children of my own yet, it's a topic I've never had to commit to.

            Your claim of an anti-vax person endangering their kids and neighbors is a tough one though. Assuming vaccines are effective, and that's heavily supported by research, the neighbors are safe if they chose to vaccinate. Legally we allow parents to be medical decision makers for their underage children, for better or whose thats the way it is and I don't know what alternatives would be beyond making every child a ward of the state. With the big caveat as well that some people have medical conditions preventing them from being able to take vaccines themselves, that's a difficult challenge similar to parents deciding in ways that much of the public disagrees with.

            • alkonaut

              No, vaccines are used to eradicate diseases from populations as well as protect individuals. Those who can’t take the vaccine for some reason will only be protected by the disease not circulating. We got rid of measles and polio.

              • _heimdall

                Worth noting that I did indeed include a big caveat at the end for those who have medical conditions preventing them from being eligible for vaccines.

                We didn't get rid of measles or polio though. Measles is showing back up today meaning it was never eradicated, just removed from at least symptomatic infection in the population. That's a big deal for sure and a huge win we shouldn't reverse, but claims of eradication are little more than political stunts.

                • alkonaut

                  We basically need 90+% of people to be vaccinated and these diseases aren’t a problem. And this wasn’t an issue. It shouldn’t be an issue. It’s just stupidity if we even allow this to take any place at all in the political discourse. Which luckily it doesn’t in any way shape or form - except in the US.

      • officeplant

        >What's the deal with e-paper and people being bad at have opinions?

        Unfortunately all of these feed good computing projects attract chiropractor natural healing type folks, because it's trying to offer a "Healthier" device that fits that vibe an aesthetic.

        Which sucks because I just want more e-paper displays and eco-conscious computing without the bullshit.

      • cryzinger

        As another disappointed DC-1 owner (all the more disappointed because despite everything, I still love and use mine, too), I'm not entirely shocked that they went down the crunchy-granola-to-anti-vax rabbit hole. Looking back, their whole branding angle was always a little woowoo. I didn't think much of it, though, until after I'd already bought one and they sent out a user survey asking about my experience with the DC-1. One of the questions was whether the reduced exposure to blue light had enabled me to quit taking antidepressants(?!?).

        They certainly won't get more money from me, but if/when my DC-1 ever dies (or when the apps that I need finally stop working on its ridiculously outdated version of Android) I'm not sure what I'll do to replace it. The most promising thing I've seen so far is the TCL NXTPAPER, which has an e-ink-ish mode, and it's a hell of a lot cheaper than anything comparable from Boox/reMarkable/etc.

      • api

        “Wellness” stuff, which is unfortunately a mix of some good advice (not eating crap, exercise, avoiding doom scrolling and other mental junk food) and a lot of bullshit (antivax, quackery, paranoia about EM fields, and in some cases stuff I can only call “volkisch fascist” ideas).

        I remember a few years ago there was this huge outcry about “why the hell does my yoga teacher now love Trump and believe in Qanon?”

        Didn’t surprise me at all, knowing the roots of the new age and related stuff.

    • victorbjorklund

      Damn. I’m glad I haven’t yet purchased anything from them.

    • plagiarist

      I'm glad I did not buy one of these devices.

      • raddan

        Annoyingly I literally just bought one. I haven’t even taken it out of the packaging yet. I wish I had seen these posts 1 week ago.

        • jaffa2

          what difference does it make?

          • onthrowaway457

            Part of buying these is to support the independent creators doing something interesting. It’s unpleasant to use mine or promote it because I now associate that with supporting a person who would degrade and insult me and people I care about. Seeing the device reminds me of those statements and ideas, it’s like a bad smell.

            I don’t begrudge him the right to hold these opinions in the first place, but it sure takes the fun out of using this product.

        • sixothree

          You can return it.

    • simondotau

      Why should we expect people to reconsider their views, let alone reform, when the response is so often extreme public condemnation and ostracism? I'm broadly on what most here would consider the correct side of these social divides, but I find it remarkable how often people on that side respond to misguided perspectives with modern-day witch burnings rather than positive encouragement towards kindness and understanding.

      If the goal truly is social progress, perhaps we should spend a little less energy hunting heretics and a little more effort showing empathy. It doesn't matter that the empathy isn't reciprocated. There's value in being the more likeable side to anyone watching from the sidelines.

      It's not lost on me that our side often responds to hateful language with our own forms of hatred. Both sides are complicit in allowing these differences to calcify into the worst kind of political tribalism, but I think our side fails every time it turns a teachable moment into a "hateable moment".

      Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.

      • AlecSchueler

        > If the goal truly is social progress, perhaps we should spend a little less energy hunting heretics and a little more effort showing empathy.

        I'm fine with showing empathy and going into discussion but the topic at hand is whether or not to support this man financially. Deciding to boycott a company because of their values seems totally reasonable.

        > It's not lost on me that our side often responds to hateful language with our own forms of hatred. Both sides are complicit

        I have no idea what side I'm on but I would suggest that it's better for everyone to stop with this us and them thinking. There's nuance in the world, embrace it.

        • myrmidon

          Boycotting companies for their founders views/politics is very likely to end in utter hypocrisy.

          The reason is that to be consistent with this, you'd have to know the political/ideological alignment of companies you interact with. But board members and CEOs can just be misanthropic assholes in private.

          I'd honestly rather have open public discourse on opinions/views held by powerful people. If you boycott people at the first sign of wrongthink, all you achieve is punishing the people that are open and honest about their bigotry (and I'd personally much prefer those over the other bigots).

          • AlecSchueler

            > Boycotting companies for their founders views/politics is very likely to end in utter hypocrisy.

            > The reason is that to be consistent with this....

            I don't have to be perfect. It's not hypocritical to work within the confines of my knowledge. Asking for more—with the suggestion that one shouldn't bother at all if nothing less than perfection is reached—is asking for something more than human.

            > But board members and CEOs can just be misanthropic assholes in private.

            They can and they are. What can I do about that? I can't read their minds, and I would think those who are vocal about it will be happier to use their riches to sway public perceptions.

            > I'd honestly rather have open public discourse on opinions/views held by powerful people. If you boycott people at the first sign of wrongthink

            So would I but A) calling it "wrongthink" is needlessly charged when it comes to such dehumanising language and B) it's not "the first sign" when it's multiple posts on multiple topics with a consistency covering multiple years, is it?

            > all you achieve is punishing the people that are open and honest about their bigotry

            Sounds good to me

            • myrmidon

              > I don't have to be perfect. It's not hypocritical to work within the confines of my knowledge.

              I'm not asking for perfection, nor for you to be doing or stopping any specific boycott.

              All I'm saying is that instant-boycott in cases like this makes it very difficult not to be a hypocrite; you tacitly acknowledge this yourself by admitting that there are lots of silent bigots that go unpunished.

              An analogy: If you reward randomly selected people (that you know nothing about, no name, age appearance, etc.) for their upper body strength, then that is clearly sexist-- because the correlation with gender is very strong. There is no excuse that "it couldn't be sexism because I clearly couldn't have known the gender".

              > I can't read their minds, and I would think those who are vocal about it will be happier to use their riches to sway public perceptions.

              Maybe. But instant condemnation/boycott suffocates any public discussion, because it very clearly incentivizes people to just not talk about such topics publicly, and things that you can't honestly talk about in public you can't really change either.

              > "wrongthink" / "first sign"

              I don't know how big the volume of posts is where this was cherry-picked from, nor how much "fuel" he got from similar-minded peers (resulting in posts much edgier than his actual views). But even if you barely polish those statements, I'd estimate that at least 10% of Americans would broadly agree (possibly more).

              My personal, unfiltered opinion on this:

              Boycott in such cases is "feelgood" activism that achieves less than nothing:

              It's most certainly not going to change his view, it is quite unlikely to change the view of anyone that agrees with him, and it is not helping any victim (slandered immigrant or woman) either. On the other hand, it suffocates honest public debate and it looks bad to anyone on the fence because it's basically a witch hunt, which is why I personally refrain from sanctioning people like this even if I strongly disagree with them.

              • AlecSchueler

                > ...very difficult not to be a hypocrite; you tacitly acknowledge this yourself by admitting...

                Did I tacitly acknowledge it? Sorry, I thought I was doing so explicitly: I have no qualms with hypocrisy born out of an ignorance which I have no power to correct. That would be like arguing against gravity, some things just are what they are.

                > An analogy: If you reward randomly selected people ....

                You'll have to run this analogy past me again because I'm struggling to relate any part of it to the topic at hand

                > It's most certainly not going to change his view, it is quite unlikely to change the view of anyone that agrees with him, and it is not helping any victim

                I don't care to change his view but I wouldn't like to support his ability to influence politics or anything else that he might gain through being a financially successful CEO.

                It certainly helps victims to publicly show that I don't tolerate their dehumanisation.

                > it suffocates honest public debate and it looks bad to anyone on the fence

                In what way? These issues are debated and discussed confidently. People dedicate their lives to research on these topics, there's a whole field of gender studies, there are conferences and panels aplenty. Migration and trans rights are some of the most visible topics in the media and are being discussed in parliaments and other legislatures that represent populations around the world.

                In what way is my choosing not to financially support someone who comes away from those discussions with the view that women are "retards" stifle those discussions?

                Is it because other bigots and people who are "on the fence" about hate speech might feel shamed into hiding their views? Good! Bring back shame.

                > it's basically a witch hunt

                "Basically" meaning not really? Witch hunts are horrible because they targeted innocent people, because the victims weren't actually witches and there was no way to prove someone was/wasn't a witch. In comparison with this case where we know with certainty that this man is a bigot who is publicly espousing hatred against people who already struggle against very systemic blockers.

                • myrmidon

                  > I have no qualms with hypocrisy born out of an ignorance which I have no power to correct.

                  Alright, that's what I wanted to get at. My position is that this double standard/conditionality is worse than anything such a boycott is likely to achieve.

                  > witch hunt

                  It's a witch hunt in my eyes because it is extra-judicial (there is obviously no interest to legalize/formalize the process), relies on group dynamics, has very little interest in precisely establishing guilt and applies obviously hypocritical standards: I'm fairly positive that no one crying boycott in this entire thread would find it desirable to be on the receiving end and face career consequences/job loss or similar because people from the other side of the political spectrum deem some of their old comments immoral or sinful.

                  One last point I'd like to make is that everyone thinks their own values/standards to be self-evident and correct; but a good majority would have spoken and acted with similar conviction against people like Turing in the past (for "abominable sodomy") barely a century ago, and would look really stupid today. So I'd caution against overconfidence in the timelessness of your own judgement, and much rather leave this to the courts when in doubt.

                  Thanks for the discussion; I feel that I at least understand your position better than before despite not being entirely convinced by it.

        • p-e-w

          > Deciding to boycott a company because of their values seems totally reasonable.

          It’s also hypocritical if you do it only for an indie company and not for the corporations that made your phone using slave labor.

          Ah, let me guess… making a product using literal slaves isn’t as bad as writing blog posts that offend the prevailing Silicon Valley culture de jour. Did I get it right?

          • darkwater

            > It’s also hypocritical if you do it only for an indie company and not for the corporations that made your phone using slave labor.

            And one has all the rights in the world to be hypocritical, because we and the world are not perfect. And that totally leaves the door open for personal judgement, opinions and "voting with your wallet".

            In this specific scenario, if you are an indie developer/builder, where your own personal brand and presence are part of the product, and you have strong opinions on $TOPIC, well, it's part of the game. Don't have strong opinions or don't put yourself in the limelight if you don't want those things to hurt your project.

          • supern0va

            > It’s also hypocritical if you do it only for an indie company and not for the corporations that made your phone using slave labor.

            Is there any major phone manufacturer that is intentionally using slaves in their supply chain? If yes, please do share the details and evidence.

            If the issue is that some parts are supplied from companies that are using slaves without disclosure and one or more companies weren't aware of it, and nearly every company has been burned by this...then what are you supposed to do? It seems like the alternative is not to buy anything in that product category.

            Regardless, you seem to be implying that these companies are "pro-slave", but some quick searching shows that there is at least an attempt to regularly audit suppliers by most manufacturers.

            As far as an "indie company": I would argue that it's a bit easier to justify not buying from a solopreneur/bootstrapper: 100% of their company is taking whatever bad position, because it's just one person. With a large corporation, it's full of employees and financial stakeholders with differing views. Dumping a company with 10k employees because the CEO or a board member sucks is trickier, because many hands are in that pot.

            Plus, your sale has more impact on that smaller company, so you're doing more to financially support an individual you might feel uncomfortable supporting, as opposed to feeding money into a capitalist behemoth.

          • chownie

            It's not hypocritical of you to have made this assumption without the 5 minute Google to inform yourself that these e-ink displays are almost certainly also produced using slave labour, but it is lame.

          • AlecSchueler

            > making a product using literal slaves isn’t as bad as writing blog posts that offend the prevailing Silicon Valley culture de jour. Did I get it right?

            No you didn't, but you win the strawman of the day award for sure.

      • culi

        I don't understand what you're upset about. People don't wanna buy stuff from some guy who says, and likely does, really vile things. We have the right to spend our money where our values are

        • simondotau

          Absolutely vote your conscience when deciding how to spend your money, that's not something I would ever disagree with.

      • abc42

        Yeah. For many people, the ostracism is probably the number one reason their views got radicalized. So instead of causing reform, messaging like that is causing the exact opposite.

        I don't know what the cure is. Love may legitimize the "wrong opinion" which would not be great either. Social media is just generally bad for this sort of thing. Perhaps the cure would be a norm where talking politics online is considered extremely rude.

        • simondotau

          I think the gay rights / marriage equality movements represent social progress at its finest. Some of the most effective advocacy was making something that had seemed threatening or alien feel fundamentally human. It gave people an opportunity to reconsider their views without first having to contend with mind-closing accusations of being a terrible human being.

          We can challenge ideas without condemning the people who hold them. We can ask for respect without demanding ideological conformity. And we can demonstrate kindness without endorsing prejudice. Unfortunately, it seems we've forgotten these lessons, too often prioritising the fleeting satisfaction of moral superiority over the harder work of actually changing minds.

          • abc42

            > I think the gay rights / marriage equality movements represent social progress at its finest. Some of the most effective advocacy was making something that had seemed threatening or alien feel fundamentally human.

            Most of the important work around gay rights probably happened not online, right? Perhaps that's why it worked so well -- even though it did take quite a long time.

      • aprilthird2021

        Because he's old enough that he got there himself and not because he's never been exposed to kindness. I used to think like you do but two terms of Trump absolutely willfully destroying the country I love has left me with no remorse for his acolytes anymore. They can figure their own way back to a functional society. I'll be fine without them

        • simondotau

          I think you've missed the point of my post.

          I believe we're all products of our environments, including the assumptions through which we interpret new information and decide whether to change our views. None of us chose those starting conditions. That doesn't absolve us of personal responsibility, but it should encourage a little humility in how we judge others.

          More importantly, the empathy I'm advocating isn't primarily about changing his mind. It's about the neutral third party watching the exchange. How we treat people whose views we find objectionable says something about us, and influences how others perceive the values we claim to represent.

          I'm not suggesting you buy his products. And you're well within your rights to give up on him as a person. All I'm saying is that demonstrating kindness towards someone who doesn't reciprocate it isn't weakness or capitulation. It's an opportunity to show others what a better alternative looks like.

          • aprilthird2021

            > More importantly, the empathy I'm advocating isn't primarily about changing his mind. It's about the neutral third party watching the exchange. How we treat people whose views we find objectionable says something about us, and influences how others perceive the values we claim to represent.

            Yeah and I'm telling the third party these people have ruined this country and I hope they suffer the consequences they thought they would be able to inflict on others.

            There's a difference between being kind to people who might not deserve it and being kind to people in this destructive and powerful movement. They are actively enabling things that will have serious consequences in our country for years afterwards right now.

            • simondotau

              No, you’re telling the neutral third party that straying from our orthodoxy threatens their livelihood.

          • AlecSchueler

            > How we treat people whose views we find objectionable says something about us, and influences how others perceive the values we claim to represent.

            The man is essentially dehumanising many of the people I care for and respect, he's espousing ideas that would treat women as second class citizens, he's diminishing the societal contributions of everyone who isn't like himself and he's feeding a political rhetoric that has very dangerous real world consequences when given power. I think a visceral reaction of disgust is human and understandable.

            > It's an opportunity to show others what a better alternative looks like.

            I'm curious what this alternative might look like and would encourage you to embody it by responding that way instead of focusing your critique on the people who are rightfully disturbed by the idea that this man is in a position of power, not least over his employees who no doubt include people he considers to be "retarded."

            • simondotau

              I don't disagree that his views deserve to be challenged, or that anger is justified. But there's a difference between condemning someone's views and condemning the person. If changing minds is the goal, we need to leave people room to change. Remember, hatred isn't a goal in itself, and as a means to an end, it's spectacularly ineffective.

              Justified anger and effective persuasion aren't necessarily the same thing. And the audience for that persuasion extends well beyond the person we're arguing with. I'd argue that the bystanders matter far more than the target of our criticism. Making people afraid to question the prevailing orthodoxy can be spectacularly counter-productive.

              As for what the alternative looks like: it looks more like debate. Leave people a way to change their minds without losing face. And remember that how we conduct ourselves matters just as much to those watching as what we're actually arguing.

              • felixgallo

                a problem with your argument is that permitting this sort of vile nihilism into the universe of acceptable public discourse invariably moves the acceptability window, and one side does not care at all about actually discussing the issues like sensible people and instead just wishes to be nihilist. See the entire history of 'right wingers are being silenced on twitter, we must be free speech absolutists' and how that turned out.

              • AlecSchueler

                > As for what the alternative looks like: it looks more like debate.

                And I'm saying go for it! Have you emailed this guy or started a debate about these views? It seems like your attention is squarely on those who have been upset by his assertions

                > Leave people a way to change their minds without losing face.

                He's welcome to change his mind and make a statement to that effect.

                > And remember that how we conduct ourselves matters just as much to those watching as what we're actually arguing.

                Great, I hope anyone "on the fence" about things like misogyny learns that such views will lead to people rightfully not wanting to associate with them.

      • hdndjsbbs

        Who is on the sidelines trying to decide between hard-line anti-immigrant, deliberately inflammatory people throwing slurs around versus "the woke" who are guilty of... saying being racist is bad?

        I'm not interested in appeasing Nazis to try and convince some both-sides fence sitter who can't tell if racism is bad.

        • hattmall

          It depends on what all you are enveloping in "the woke" but a lot of the feel good empathy first doctrine ignores reality and has very real consequences.

          In particular using a wide brush to paint racism or bigotry on a broad swath of informed opinions cause legitimate issues to continually remain unresolved.

    • fblp

      Thanks for the headsup!

    • nilsherzig

      Damn I don't know what I expected but that's actually bad. Like no nuance needed, just straight up insanely cringe behavior. Seems like he's 12 and trying to be an edge lord on 4chan or something. Now I regret spending money with this company.

      • nilsherzig

        Also (even tho I'm in non of the group he seems to hate / fear) now I feel icky about having my Google calendar and Todoist linked to company run by someone who doesn't seem to be in control of himself :/

    • jmuguy

      I literally just pre-ordered one of these things and now I have to cancel, what a loser.

    • CorpoZoomie

      Hah you know it's bad when there's a site dedicated to the archival of it..

    • jkahrs595

      i love the tags on the quotes in case you weren't sure what made them offensive

    • hliyan

      My God. The full trifecta in a single post. There's a lot of unprocessed anger toward the world here:

      > "illegals need to get the hell out of our country, or that kids chopping off their d*cks is evil and their parents should be put in prison" · "Muslim refugees are ruining the continent and i made sure to say it loud enough for those around us to hear it" · "isn't it wild how often a Leftist turns out to be a pedophile" · "for women, be prettier and further along in life (married, kids, house)"

    • alkonaut

      I just went "How bad can it be, I'm sure it ca.... JESUS CHRIST"

    • guax

      Oof. Another milkshake duck I was not expecting. Taking out of my wishlist here. :(

    • mschuster91

      > according to Milo there are 3 <transphobic BS>

      Damn it's been some time since I last saw someone positively refer to Milo Yiannopoulos...

      The rest is vile enough I won't repost it in here. Blergh. Almost makes Musk look tame.

    • wyager

      How flattering to have some weird internet paparazzo make an archive of your blog

    • Executor

      "problematic" == he doesn't agree with my politics.

      • psadauskas

        You're right, "problematic" is too weak, when he thinks some of my friends shouldn't be allowed to exist. I was being polite.

        • lostmsu

          How do you know what he thinks? None of the quotes on that page suggest killing anyone.

      • ok_dad

        He openly disrespects people calling then letter people, trannies, etc. that’s not politics. It’s a jerk.

        • neuroticnews25

          I've been disrespected many times on the internet, it's not that serious.

          • ok_dad

            What if I told you that I didn’t think you had a right to exist, maybe I wanted to kill you and your family and friends because they knew you. That’s what those folks have to deal with. It’s a lot more than disrespect, I worded that poorly. This guy spouts the same garbage takes as those who would kill people they don’t like. You are probably also one of those jerks if you pass this off as not a big deal so I’ll stop replying but obviously I don’t think much of someone who would comment like you did anyways.

      • peterpost2

        Have you read what he wrote? The man is a transphobe.

      • myko

        Evil would be a better description of his views than any particular political affiliation

      • chneu

        Lol that isn't political. That's being a hateful person. Big difference.

  • wateralien

    Once they're back in stock it's better to save some money and DIY the project - and at the same time avoid Ryan's hateful, divisive politics.

    https://shopkits.eink.com/en/product/detail/31.5''Spectra6eP...

  • dkobia

    What a shame. I've been a fan of Ryan Kulp and bought the first trmnl device ($139). I thought when I clicked on those links it might be the regular run of mill conservative vs liberal stuff I don't care about. It is not, and I wish I could get my money back.

  • pimterry

    Anybody know a good alternative? Or any suggestions on sourcing good ePaper displays to build this yourself?

    • lp92

      If you're the DIY kind, buy the display yourself ie https://www.good-display.com/product/560.html

      And make a case for it along with getting the QSPI driver bboard.given the lack of 31.5" eink i think Terminal is using this as the base display.

    • TreeInBuxton

      For a smaller size, I'm happy with my reTerminal E1004 - I wrote my own firmware in the Arduino IDE to get everything exactly as I wanted it, but you can flash esphome to it (or use their OpenDisplay firmware)

  • brisket_bronson

    What a horrible person

  • drayfield

    Ah that sucks, I was this close to a purchase yesterday.

    • subsistence234

      the quality is incredible, and mine shipped within two weeks.

      most of the folks badmouthing the device just have a problem with his edgy jokes and "politics."

      • human305893

        Can you explain the jokes to me? I'd like to understand the humour.

      • guax

        It’s not edgy jokes. It’s clear and loud bigotry. The kind of things he spew were not only politics it was character and morals I do not want to endorse, regardless of how nice the product is. I’ll look for alternatives.

      • drayfield

        Not sure I can agree with you on that one chief. He seems like a pretty bad egg to me.

  • dawnerd

    I was about to pull the trigger, thank goodness I saw this and looked into it.

  • pseudosaid

    I was too until I took a brand new one out, and while I was standing up on a table, it tipped over and fell flat on its frame. And when I lifted it up, the screen was broken. The amount of force necessary to destroy the screen was surprisingly low, and the company wanted nothing to do with me and refused to replace it.

    • criddell

      I wouldn't expect a company to replace something you damaged but your credit card might. Check your benefits for purchase protection.

      I bought a phone and a week later I dropped it and broke the screen. Called Amex and they refunded the charge. It was an easy and fast process.

  • npteljes

    You were not wrong about their "politics" being a turnoff. Jesus.

origini

Yada yada 1.2k :(

Man how long and often do I need to get my hopes up?

You can't tell me that the company having the patent is so bad in making it cheaper and better so that the mass market would kick in?

Or is there 0 mass market for things like that?

Or is it really that expensive to make them bigger?

Lets see who wins in a few years: The price going down or my wallet

  • ThePhysicist

    They're probably using a GoodDisplay 31.5 panel which costs around 800 USD retail, I guess when they order a few thousands they should get that significantly cheaper, maybe 400-600 USD? Then the driver board and the wood framing and assembly, and their margin. Seems not ridiculously priced, maybe they make around 300-400 USD margin on those accounting for assembly? You can get your own display and the driver board and make a wood frame but that will take you a long time I guess. This is just not a mass market product, 31 inches is still quite small so you cannot really use this as a centerpiece for a wall, and I can get dozens of real high quality framed prints or a few really big ones for that price. I get the appeal but in the end it's just a crappy 6 color display, if you like art just hang a real painting.

  • nemomarx

    There's really not much mass market outside of e-readers already. e ink monitor sized panels are a niche of a niche.

    • xnx

      No mass market at $400/sqft, but there might be all kinds up applications at $25/sqft like tvs.

      • eli

        Bit of a chicken and egg. TV panels got so cheap because of the massive volume used.

      • galleywest200

        Can this eInk display drive at 30-60fps continually for months without damage?

        • Legend2440

          30fps? No.

          Continually for months is fine though. In fact it can passively display the same image forever without power or burn-in.

          • KennyBlanken

            eInk is in fact susceptible to aging, burn-in, and wear.

            It's literally a mechanical device (well, I suppose, an electrostatic/fluidic device, but still, it is not solid state...fairly large particles have to physically move/rotate in a liquid layer), one that utilizes a voltage difference of up to 40v, too.

            A color iEink screen even more sensitive because now you're not just dealing with flipping particles or making them move closer or further from the surface, you're doing it with four different particles. Similar to how SLC is more durable than TLC, which is more durable than QLC, etc.

            • throooooo

              This is the first time I've heard of e-ink experiencing burn-in. I've never had that happen after 10+ years of Kindle usage. Google seems to agree that doesn't happen with e-ink displays. They do experience ghosting, which is cleared upon the next full screen refresh.

              • officeplant

                > I've never had that happen after 10+ years of Kindle usage

                Because Kindle's are following strict refresh cycles on the panel and not pushing it beyond limits between full screen wipes.

                The problems crop up when you try to avoid full screen wipes as often to prevent a "flashing" effect on the E-ink panel.

            • efskap

              True but iirc the particles can only get stuck if you try to squeeze more speed out of the display than you should. Then the particles can slam into the wall and get stuck. Drive safely!

          • NooneAtAll5

            tbf there were news that 30fps has been achieved just fine

            dunno about longevity

        • xnx

          Seems unlikely. Commercial grade digital signage displays are better suited to that.

        • jansan

          That is not the idea of an eInk display. It is not primarily meant for animations.

          • fc417fc802

            Exactly. I'd like a few of these for my computer to display documentation. Or at least I always did in the past but with AI I'm not sure it's as necessary anymore.

        • somat

          Why would you want to?

          We have this display technology that is ideal for low/no power mostly static super high contrast(monochrome) displays, first thing some people ask "can I have it as a high power, quickly updating, low contrast(colored) display?"

          Why? we have good displays for that use case. Why do you want to compromise on the features this type of display is good at to fit a use case it is bad at?

    • nostromo

      Not true. Every price tag on a shelf should be an e-ink display by now. But it's still rare since they are price prohibitive for most retailers.

      There are lots of these use cases where e-ink displays would be perfect, but cannot be adopted.

      • eddieroger

        I think most people don't realize that the cost for e-ink on a shelf versus paper is still way in the favor of paper, as you said. And that says nothing of the technical challenge that comes with adding that many devices to either an RF or IP network and ensuring that it works with existing, sometimes decades-old pricing systems. Then there's the legal challenges for displaying one price on the shelf but ringing another at the register - with paper, a human can indicate that the price label is updated, but with e-ink, there needs to be some other confirmation of change.

        • solarkraft

          In some places, the calculation is clearly going in favor of E-Ink tags. I assume the lower management effort you mentioned will be a part of that.

          • geerlingguyOP

            Most Walmarts I've been to in the past year seem to have switched to all eInk displays. I'd love to see a writeup on that rollout.

            • diggernet

              https://groundworkcollaborative.org/work/the-walmart-watchto...

              Apparently to support surveillance based pricing.

            • dspillett

              Several supermarkets here (UK) have mostly switched over, including those traditionally thought of as bargain basement establishments.

            • criddell

              I wonder if they would ever change the prices dynamically since they know roughly who is shopping in the store and when.

            • reaperducer

              Most Walmarts I've been to in the past year seem to have switched to all eInk displays. I'd love to see a writeup on that rollout.

              They're more than just e-ink displays. They also have a very bright green light that flashes when a Wal-Mart picker is nearby so they can find the next item on their list faster.

              • geerlingguyOP

                Ah THAT'S what that's for. TIL.

                I've seen a few flashing and was wondering why; that seems like a lot of battery power to waste, but that makes a lot more sense than some kind of status update nobody would ever see.

              • bombcar

                That makes sense why they’d bother as the prices don’t change THAT rapidly

                • vel0city

                  As someone who used to have a retail job where one duty was updating tags (not at Walmart) they'll jump around a good bit depending on the merchandise.

            • sleepybrett

              They buy at such scale that it may make some sense. I worked an UHF-RFID project for an american retailer with many many stores maybe 10-12 years back, but even we couldn't find a way to overcome the cost of the tags, which at the time was just under a nickle a tag. Granted they are disposed of after a sale.

        • KennyBlanken

          The cost is not in favor of paper and hasn't been for a decade or so. These devices have been in widespread use in Asia for a long time. Best Buy went to them a few years ago, Walmart is moving to them.

          The devices are often optical, with overhead IR transmitters. The fact that you don't know that shows how little you know about the market and thus should not be talking about it.

          RF is also used, yes - various protocols ranging from proprietary to bluetooth LE.

          Even if only one price per second can be transmitted, that's 3600 items per hour, which means that in 24 hours, 86,400 items can be re-priced. You'd need several employees working non-stop to even hope to hit that rate.

          As for the legal challenges they're able to point to logs as well as information on the digital display showing when it was last updated. Also, updates are not necessarily live - they can push out updated pricing info and then activate it at a specific time or via secondary command.

      • fh973

        In German supermarkets, they basically are everywhere. Two colored (black and red), of various sizes. The do look like paper so hardly anyone notices.

      • arnejenssen

        These price tags are everywhere in Scandinavian shops https://www.pricer.com/

      • madeofpalk

        > Every price tag on a shelf should be an e-ink display by now.

        This is the case in multiple chains in the UK.

      • magixx

        I'm kind of glad in a way that paper prices are still in effect, I think dynamic pricing will be a much more common thing once this goes away and the barrier to do it is much lower.

      • lp92

        Absolutely not. This is the kind of tech that enables dynamic and survailancr based "personalized" pricing at the grocery store. Screw that.

      • mikepurvis

        E-ink price tags are everywhere in Canada, even at discount-type grocery stores that don't yet have other "innovations" like self check out.

      • hypercube33

        Digital calendars, wall photos that change with the month or seasons or like Antitrust - change after reading the mood in the room with a local AI model on an ESP32 or some other mcu. E-Readers, digital signage (depending on what it is)...

      • HWR_14

        Prices should be stable enough that the costs of updating paper labels isn't prohibitive.

        • sgerenser

          Depends entirely on the business model of the store. Classic “high/low” pricing models, used by most grocery stores, department stores, and many discount chains require at a minimum weekly repricing of thousands of SKUs (for start of sale and end of sale).

      • fodkodrasz

        In Hungary, you know, the poorer corner of the EU, most major supermarkets, discount franchises carry eink price tags.

      • UltraSane

        Wal-Mart is switching every price tag to e-ink by the end of 2026.

      • LtWorf

        They are e-ink where I live (sweden).

      • nemomarx

        very small ones seems like the best use case, sure

    • jo-m

      What about Samsung Smart Signage EM32DX (eg LH32EMDIBGBXEN)?

    • guenthert

      Advertising?

      • nemomarx

        People like bright colors for advertising and tv panels are pretty cheap now. I can't see a huge demand for eink specifically there

    • sleepybrett

      also their colors are incredibly washed out. I love eink for the reader use-case but little else (i've seen them in stores as shelf tags as well.. seems like a printer in the back is just as easy and about 90% cheaper in the end.

    • nakedrobot2

      I absolutely do not agree with that.

  • HWR_14

    Why is all epaper in weird sizes? Why isn't there an 8.5x11 or 8.5x14 sized display? Or even a notecard sized 3.5x5?

    • samplatt

      Just a guess, but probably because 8.5x11 / 8.5x14 are American standards, which use different standards for paper sizes than the rest of the world, and there's more of an appetite for e-paper outside of America.

      • HWR_14

        Epaper also doesn't come in A4 size, which is pretty close in size.

  • alwaysmrno

    Yeah It's the price that's stopping me. It is a really cool idea but not 1.2k cool.

  • jpmitchell

    I'm looking forward to the day e-ink is so cheap I can paper my walls with it.

    Until then I'll just have to be satisfied buying every Kobo I find at my local thrift shop (3 so far).

  • kevin_thibedeau

    For perspective, a 24" CRT was much more than that 20 years ago, even before adjusting for inflation.

  • port11

    They’re making a few hundred. I don’t see mass market appeal in this, especially against the 10x cheaper home assistant thingies out there (Privacy Not Included).

  • hadlock

    It's a 30 inch eink screen from a very small company based in the US. This isn't a million unit run from samsung, run by some EVP who buys out the entire factory's output six years in a row.

  • stevage

    Everyone talking about the price was LCD are ignoring the fact it has a handwade wooden frame and is being marketed as a boutique, locally assembled art piece.

  • julianlam

    Just niche markets. There's a kickstarter for a two-panel eInk display that was shown displaying music.

    I'd like that, though not at the price point they wanted to launch at ($1200, I think)

    • foobarchu

      Displaying like a visualizer? Isn't that kind of a waste of the technology? I always understood e-ink to excel at applications that can survive with very low refresh rates

      • JRandomHacker42

        Sheet music - most of the time I see a dual-panel eink device, it's being used to read sheet music off of during a performance, probably with a page-change pedal input too

  • TheRealPomax

    So make your own with an old monitor panel for a few hundred bucks?

    And yeah: there is zero commercial demand for a product like this, it's about as niche as it gets while still existing. No normal person needs an e-ink display this big (because something this size is pretty much useless for anything but a digital poster, which regular TV/monitors can already do better, for cheaper), and the sizes folks do need (e.g. e-readers and passive displays) already have plenty on offer.

    But, there are always individuals who want something like this. Not enough to make it a runaway commercial success, but enough to make it a boutique successful-enough-to-stick-around-for-a-while at least.

  • deno

    Get a similar sized IPS for $250 and you can use the rest to cover electricity use for the next 20 years at US avg price. That's assuming 24/7 but you can make it turn off if no one's looking or at night. Not sure what's the use case.

    • joshstrange

      I'm sure you know this and were just offering other options, but the primary reason I like e-ink is for how it looks. How it isn't bright/shiny/lit/in-your-face. It's subdued.

      My book-quotes e-ink screens around the house blend in and don't look like screens really and that's exactly how I want them. I wouldn't matter if they were giving away IPS screens, I wouldn't want that all over my house.

    • geerlingguyOP

      One primary use case would be in areas with poor lighting conditions; IPS and other similar displays wind up glare-y or with poor off-axis viewing. These displays at least look like they'd hold up better in a hallway or room with a big window and mixed lighting.

      It's a lot to ask for it, and it's too much for my liking... but it's certainly a feature I'd pay a little extra for.

      The other would be battery operation — being able to run a device like this for 6 months or a year on battery means I don't have to route a cable up through the wall or in a cable channel, and that's kinda neat too. But again, for the price... oof!

      • ranguna

        Now the questions is: do I want to spend 5x more to get your product, or just put the IPS in the shade. Or get an LED matrix.

        Hopefully you'll find you niche market, because this might be too expensive for the general public.

    • origini

      I do want to render a dashboard and/or images and would like to have the eink style of display for it.

      Sure i could use a LCD, run ith with less herz than usual and only turn on/off the backlight with a motion sensor but do you know how long i'm waiting for this type of eink display by now? years.

      • deno

        Idk I've done it with used tablets and once a laptop display (3:2 hidpi) and it works great.

        Just set the backlight to dynamic level based on ambient light from webcam data and turn off on timer or ambient light below min level and it's like 99% good enough.

        Also I like the option to show IPTV camera feed on it so eInk wouldn't work anyway.

  • IshKebab

    It's a fairly reasonable price compared to the competition. E.g. this looks like it uses the same display but is much more expensive: https://inkposter.com/products/inkposter-affresco-31-5

    It's a niche product and e-ink has a monopoly on the technology. They can basically price it how they like.

    I agree it would be really nice if it was like half the price though. Hard to justify at £1k.

    • saturn8601

      Seems like the other guys have partnered with companies like pocketbook and in the case of the really high end device: Pininfarina.

    • ruined

      the other display a few hundred dollars more, but shipping is 2-10 days instead of "estimated early 2027"

  • moffkalast

    Sold out immediately anyway, I don't think there's much customer pressure driving down prices for these when they make like 400 and sell them to the richest people they can find.

    For about same price you can get a Steam Fram- oh wait you can't, Valve also only made 400 of them lmao.

RGS1811

I’ve been wanting something like this for a while. $1200 is more than I’m ready to pay for it but it’s cool that this exists!

  • tkslucas

    I really wish they were more affordable, they are so cool, can't wait to put a bunch of eink displays everywhere

  • comboy

    Well it's sold out so I guess they didn't set price high enough.

    • bl4kers

      False? "Only 351 of 475 left in this first batch"

      • comboy

        At the time of writing my original comment and now this url [1] says sold out, where are you seeing your info?

        1. https://shop.trmnl.com/products/frame

        • ThrowawayR2

          There's an annotation below the stock counter that says "Outside the USA, Canada, Australia, or Mexico? We're not sold out. Order here."

        • bl4kers

          That's the URL I'm looking at. It now says "Only 283 of 475 left in this first batch" and it allows me to add it to my cart and check out. I'm in the U.S.

car

For a smaller, more affordable version I've been very happy with the Soldered Inkplate 6-color 13SPECTRA display [0]. Sold by Crowdsupply [1].

The technology common to all these displays is Spectra™ 6 by E-Ink [2,3].

Hacked a newspaper front-page rotation with Claude, and it looks great. With 10 minute refresh, the battery lasts for 2-3 weeks.

[0] https://soldered.com/collections/inkplate-e-paper-displays/p...

[1] https://www.crowdsupply.com/soldered/inkplate-13spectra

[2] https://www.eink.com/product/detail/EL133UF1

[3] https://www.eink.com/product/detail/EL253EW1

schlap

This is a new J curve for product pricing that ive never seen before

5x the price of the next cheapest product is incredibly steep and with how the X released, I dont have a ton of confidence for the product even though i really want to.

If this was closer to $500 it would make sense

Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.

Make it easily frameable for all types of frames instead of requiring a handmade wooden one that likely increases production costs

  • flanz_10

    I think the wood is delightful. It's very tasteful and I generally prefer natural materials whenever possible.

    • bijowo1676

      the wood frame is made in America, but the display itself is made in China and can be sourced from there, I believe.

      waiting for some noname brands with this exact same product show up on Amazon soon

    • egeozcan

      I think the point is, you can do it yourself or hire a carpenter if you really care about that.

      • munificent

        I mean, that's true of like most things. People buy things so that they don't have to make them themselves. This is the fundamental premise of markets.

      • sleepybrett

        or walk down to the dozens of frame stores that exist everywhere.

      • flanz_10

        i could also order a 31.5 inch E Ink Spectra 6 panel

        and, if i'm being really dedicated, i could head on down to the beach with a shovel, some carbon, a heat source, a quartz crucible, a uv source, a laser printer, some hobby knives, a liter of sulfuric acid, and a flagrant disrespect for the EPA

        then i could grab a couple of notebooks, and bootstrap my own isa, runtime, renderer, and a couple of banks of dip switches.

        you know... if you really care about that

  • JamesSwift

    > Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.

    I mean.. the product seems to be pretty focused on being an aesthetic, customizable screen and not a utilitarian tech dashboard. In which case, it absolutely needs the wood frame to "fit in" to decor.

vunderba

I have a second-hand Samsung Frame connected to an old laptop that periodically wakes up, generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame TV via the Samsung Frame’s WebSocket API. It automatically changes the picture every 30 minutes.

The "Art Mode" setting along with its matte finish makes it non-reflective, so it just acts like a nice little gallery on my wall. It’s using older models, mainly SDXL, so a lot of the pictures can be a little goofy and its been humming along for several years at this point.

I’d love to pick up one of these TRMNL devices and do something similar but the price at $1200 (soon to be $1300) gives me pause.

https://imgpb.com/EZmRX

  • mathieudombrock

    > generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame

    I don't mean this in a rude way, but you display AI images in your home as art? Do you just like the AI images better than art?

    I'm trying to understand what this actually means.

    • haiemi

      Looks like that’s the case, the blog linked in the original post describes their image generation setup.

    • stavros

      Not the GP, but I did a similar thing where an eink picture frame displays AI-generated landscapes with the weather being the same as the current weather/time of day as outside.

      I just like the variation and didn't need to go source a bunch of actual images of the specific weather patterns.

    • MisterMunchkin

      Generating a family gives you much better looking family members

  • IAmNotACellist

    Are Samsung Frames (or similar) worth it? It's hard to justify when some spyware TV can go on a wall and be $400

    • eblume

      I purchased a Frame (43”) a few years back. For the specific purpose of being a TV with an Art Mode that plausibly blends in to my living room, it succeeds. Although I do ding it for charging a yearly $75 subscription for access to the updated curated catalogue of art. A few points back again for that sub actually being, in a way, almost worth it. The art is good, is what I’m saying.

      Which is a hell of a thing because the smart tv software is so aggressively hostile and awful that it makes me want to give up on using it. The worst experience from moment one on. You can plug it in to an Apple TV and get mostly there but then you need to fight with the remote to get it to reliably switch to art mode.

      I do not recommend it, but it’s possible that with some hacking it could be good.

    • teamonkey

      The screen quality is lovely and very good at displaying artwork. It doesn’t look like a TV screen; not exactly like a picture either, but it’s really quite impressive.

      The software is appalling in so many ways. Aggressively user-hostile except when it’s upselling at you.

    • vunderba

      Honestly, I would have the same reservations. Mine's an older model, but Samsung has only become more user-hostile as time has gone on.

      That being said, I was able to pretty easily connect my Samsung Frame to the LAN and then block it at the router level from making outbound requests to the internet.

  • loveiswork

    Thanks for this, I too have an older Frame TV in my living room. Want to explore exporting my calendar and photos to it from a home server via that API!

    TRMNL is a cool product, I have the original. This new model looks exactly like what I wanted but certainly not in the budget. Now I have another option!

  • ryanckulp

    looks awesome, thanks for sharing.

  • npodbielski

    But is oled right? So it constantly sips power right?

    • vunderba

      Mine is an old 2022 model so its not OLED - I measured it a while ago (43") and in art mode it was drawing down around ~35-40W on average about 5-6 bucks a month when left on continuously.

TechPlasma

I have a use case for this. I want it. I can use it in my daily life. It's what I've been hoping for for years... But this price is crazy. I can't justify owning this at 1.2k. Maybe at 400,id even go for 500, which is a crazy amount of money for a wall display/calendar. But I'd justify the utility at that price.

porphyra

I feel like e-ink displays are the ideal way to chat with an AI coding agent. Less eye strain, more suited to reading prose. Theoretically, if you chat with it by voice, it doesn't even need high refresh rate. Too bad the technology remains expensive.

layer8

This is basically only usable as a picture frame for paintings and drawings and/or some text; photos don’t look too well.

Full frame updates take 20-30 seconds.

Content needs to be dithered to the six fixed colors (no gradations) at the already fairly low 93 PPI.

Contrast is something like 25:1.

  • jameshart

    It’s spectra-6, presumably. They’re the same refresh speed, resolution and contrast ratio at any size.

    It’s a good display tech. Don’t expect any end product to be particularly differentiated in terms of image quality though.

  • mrandish

    Thank you for posting the relevant facts the company chose to not mention in their long blog post nor its tl;dr header.

    To the company: We all understand that ePaper displays are a set of trade-offs, but hiding those specs doesn't make them go away, it just wastes the time of those who want to know what they are.

rhim

It makes me sad that ePaper displays are still at low availability and very high prices. There are so many opportunities to craft cool projects with such a display, but 1.2k bucks for a such a display is a lot of money for hobby projects.

  • lp92

    The larger eink displays are expensive, but a 6" monochrome or dual color are pretty cheap and good enough for most status display type uses.

jdprgm

This looks dope but at that price is just a neat accessory for the wealthy. Is there a feasible route to it being about a tenth the price, like $150? Is it just a scale thing? You can get new dell monitors around that size for $200 or less.

It seems expensive because it is niche, and niche because it is expensive. At a dramatically lower price I think loads of people would love two or three of these around the house.

  • eschaton

    A 31.5in color e-ink display suitable for presenting art is “just a neat accessory for the wealthy” is a pretty crazy take when it’s cheaper than a professional-quality LCD like the lowest-end Studio Display.

  • solarkraft

    E-Ink yields are supposedly low at these sizes. But they also have patents, so y’know. There are reflective/transflective LCDs, but they’re not quite the same.

asenna

Slightly relevant but I was just researching a smaller eink-display to place in a hotel room for a client and I discovered the `ReTerminal E1001` - pretty cool if anyone is looking for smaller (7.5") hackable solution with mics and beep for $69.

I hope the prices of the larger displays come down a bit at some point and become more popular.

  • kimos

    I’ve been using a couple of the ReTerminal displays and they’re great. I use the e1004 13” for a family calendar/schedule board. It comes framed and the battery lasts a month or two. It’s the best option I have found that’s not over a thousand dollars.

  • s1n_

    Looks like they have a color version too for ≈$100 (reTerminal E1002) and a larger 13.3" color display for $280 (reTerminal E1004)

    • joshstrange

      I have the color and the monochrome one and just know that updates on the color screen take almost 30 seconds of flashing the screen. You don't want one of those in your eyeline. The monochrome are done in <3s.

      I have mine set up around the house to display book quotes (rotate once a day) and I quite enjoy them. Though I've been dabbling in BTLE boards instead of ESP32 (what in inside a reTerminal) for more updates and longer battery life.

      • s1n_

        Ah, that is a pretty huge downside. Thanks for the heads up!

  • mzs

    Can the monochrome ones do partial screen updates, like 8x12 in half a second?

  • georgemcbay

    I recently started playing with a reTerminal E1003, the 10.3 inch monochrome version and I've been very happy with it.

    $150 not bad at all for a reasonably high resolution (1404x1872) 10 inch e-ink panel with a touch screen.

    Really easy setup for writing custom firmware (I've been using PlatformIO, C and LVGL) and just really solid hardware so far.

    The only downside was that it took close to 2 months to get off backorder.

    While looking into the available e-ink options I took a look at TRMNL's stuff as well but it turns out the TRMNL founder is a hardcore MAGA racist misogynist and I refuse to give money to such people.

thangalin

Self-charging options?

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inkanva/inkanva

Such as:

https://www.ntu.edu.sg/news/detail/near-invisible-ultrathin-...

majidmir

Could this be the cheaper version directly sold by the Chinese supplier? https://www.epaperia.org/Mall/13.html Current price: $880

schainks

Oh man I was really hoping it was using this tech under the hood: https://www.crowdsupply.com/modos-tech/modos-flow

denysvitali

If you want something smaller, with fewer colors: https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1002-p-6533.html

(Just a happy customer, this thing has both a battery, an ESP32-S3 and some buttons - it's fantastic and doesn't cost 1k)

coppertuft

Looks great! Love the wood frame. Would prefer it to be in a different aspect ratio tho, this ratio just says 'screen'.. but perhaps a e.g. 5:7 panel wouldn't be that easy to find?

windex

Ive learned one thing about e-ink. Prices never fall. This is one tech that refuses to figure out how to scale orders. If there is any alt tech or low power display, should check that.

fennecfoxy

I just got the 7.3" Pimoroni one to use for a small project. I would like one this size for my entranceway but all are prohibitively expensive. Makes me wonder how cheap they'd be if a proper display manufacturer like Samsung etc got onto them.

  • sleepybrett

    The market for these displays is just incredibly small. led, lcd, oled all of those have gigantic markets tvs, monitors, phone displays, tablets, video walls, video signs (basically just tvs)... eink's only real niche at this point are e-readers and shelf tags (and shelf tags are tenuous). You need to hit a certain level of scale before you can really really scale it.

  • puzzlingcaptcha

    I also used a 7.3" Inky Impression recently, though the 127 PPI is a bit disappointing (and the 13.3" is almost three times as expensive!).

flaburgan

I am not interested about art nor colour screen but if I could have my grafana monitoring refreshing every 10 sec that would be quite cool. They seem to have other products that are targeting this but I am confused about how the image should go from my browser to the device. You even have to pay extra for the "developer" feature that allows you to access the API (?!).

neom

Not quite the same but FWIW I just got a 13.3" SwitchBot Art Frame original and I really like it, I think I'd prob find more use/enjoyment from x2 13" vs a single 31" (SwitchBot have a 31" for around $1,100).

  • taude

    I think they're pretty similar. Same Spectre 6 Panel.

    I like my little switchbot, though, and like you I hvae the smaller 13" version. I wish it was more vibrant, though. Not sure if the OP's custom profile thing Lazarus fixes anything with that.

proee

I'd personally prefer a larger frame with mat. Most nice looking art is framed this way.

mclanett

Love the e-paper display concept. Also the wood frame is nice. On top of that all I need is an API.

Aunche

I've been eyeing the TRMNL X for a while, but I heard the launch was very unreliable. Has anyone here had any experience with it?

joshstrange

> $1,299.00

Whoa, no thanks. I _love_ e-ink and as I was reading I was bracing myself for $300-400, 3-4x that doesn't work for me. I get it's large, I know that large e-ink (even b/w) are not cheap but $1.3K is too rich for my blood.

I was going to buy it as just a nice all-in-one I could flash my own firmware on but not at that price. I guess I'll keep playing with my 7" e-ink screens run by ESP32's or BTLE boards.

david_van_loon

This looks like something I would love to have, but certainly not at that price.

albertgoeswoof

I made a 13 inch version myself for about $300, battery powered, esp32

So those complaining about price, it’s not bad tbh

amelius

Any ideas about where he sources his panels from?

geerlingguyOP

It's a bit expensive, at $1,299.

wavey-throw

This would be a heck of a lot more interesting if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller instead of just putting up with eink's glacial pace of, well, everything (development, improvement, actual image refresh on the panel). There's so much possible with the multipigment screens that's yet to be unlocked with better driver hardware and software.

See https://github.com/Modos-Labs/Glider/blob/main/README.md#fas... for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7), or https://www.eniacelec.com/pages/tickey for an actual recent product that's pushing 48 native colors on a spectra 6 panel.

For a product that's designed for static images where repaint speed isn't a major consideration, there's no excuse for putting up with eink's cruddy driverware at the cost of quality. Missed opportunity for differentiation.

  • papua_is_being_

    > if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller

    What do you specifically mean? Are you Modos?

    > for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7)

    "Though to be honest I hacked the right one a bit to display 512 colors opposed to the stock 7 colors".

    There's only 4 pigments, CMYK in the panel. Dithering is "512 colors"?

    > eink's cruddy driverware

    What do you specifically mean?

rendleflag

I really dislike the muted colors, soft spoken, quiet music, product videos that seem to be everywhere, talking about how "different" they are. Showing someone hand-carving into a piece of wood, talking about "made in the USA", like some third-generation craftsman with a beard and a cap. It all feels like artisanal firewood. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI

bdcravens

I'm sure it's a high quality product, but given that "hacking" a random screen is just a Claude prompt these days, I think it's a hard sale. I think most consumers don't really care about the advantages of eInk versus a cheap display.

https://wesbos.com/hacking-smart-photo-frames

lampiaio

Why does the "transparent supply chain" list "Overseas" instead of the actual place of origin? The US-sourced parts go as far as saying the city for some entries. It just looks like a ridiculous avoidance of saying China.

malshe

I see a few comments mentioning the price is 1.2k. But I saw $1,299 which is basically 1.3k, even more expensive!

mboehm

Haven‘t tried it out yet, but isn‘t the Samsung em32dx an alternative?

purpleidea

$2,000 ! zomg, I wish. I am not this rich haha.

stronglikedan

Yikes, now I know why it's customary to capitalize the first letter of a sentence, even if it's grammatically correct either way! I literally cannot follow that style for more than two sentences at a time.

vivzkestrel

- stupid question

- why does everyone want one more screen in their house?

- what is the research, intuition behind this?

- smart mirrors, this, wall screens, why are people obsessed with more screens?

crystaln

I’m disappointed it’s missing adware and spyware.

What’s the point of an art frame if it doesn’t scan and profile your network to sell ads?

dmitrygr

Looked interesting, until I saw that you had to pay an extra $20 for unlocking developer mode. At the $1300 price point, nickel-and-diming me for $20 was such a completely unneeded snap in the face, that i closed the purchase tab. Good luck I guess, but i will not be a customer, out of principle.

  • ryanckulp

    appreciate the feedback. our perspective is we bend over backwards for the dev community. priority support, 1:1 team chats in our dev-only Discord, manual plugin reviews by hand prior to publication, etc. but if you choose to self host, unnecessary.

    • amarcheschi

      Cheap ereaders such as xteink were made popular partly due to the unlocked firmware and custom roms for them. I guess this is a completely different target, but I would think double about it, you just need some guy with too much time and an llm agent to make something that goes popular on YouTube/reddit (...), but for 20$ he might not even want to try it

      • ryanckulp

        100s of Xteink readers are hooked up to TRMNL. next step there is being able to sideload the ereader + dashboard binaries.

    • altairprime

      I think the $20 is a reasonable filter for access to the dev team's energy and time, especially given the alternative of a vastly more expensive moderation and review burden if the floodgates were left open to everyone. HN won't much like it, but that's a normal bias in our community, so don't let us sway you by emotions alone.

    • dmitrygr

      So why not a $0 "unlock anything you wish but no support, RTFM || GTFO" option?

      • nout

        Better option is to just provide the dev support for all devs that need something for this device and have it included in the large price. The price splitting makes sense when you have $100 device, but not for $1000+ device.

      • qtk8

        > Local hosting is also available and firmware is open source.

        • dmitrygr

          Yes i saw this and found this to be 100% in conflict with "pay to unlock". But when in doubt, I assume the interpretation that leaves me more screwed.

worthyrae

What’s fps on this?

fhn

"we spend our time looking at screens" invents another screen

sleepybrett

colors are crazy washed out, epaper just isn't there for this stuff yet.

fwip

LLM slop in user-facing UI. "Stays on screen until another screen's time comes." :/

  • Zambyte

    The promo video is also an AI slop script. It's always jarring hearing a person speak Claudish.

jiveturkey

94 dpi

lazzlazzlazz

Seems it doesn't support wifi or any internet connectivity (zero mention of any of these on any of the sites), which makes it essentially useless. Tough for the price.

micromacrofoot

Everyone's making the same mistake here... eInk and ePaper are not necessarily the same thing. eInk is a type of ePaper. eInk is a brand.

IAmGraydon

FWIW, you can get a much cheaper/smaller version here that uses the exact same display technology (Spectra 6):

https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1004-p-6692.html

Also, apparently Samsung's version uses the same Spectra 6 panel as well:

https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1963755-REG/samsung_e...

IAmGraydon

I would buy one at $1200 if the colors look good/rich in person and if you can change for a different frame. I have a feeling I'm going to be disappointed though - most of the pictures make it look like it has a bit of a washed out appearance.

close04

At 31.5” and 1440p resolution this display has a PPI of 94. So it’s probably best viewed from a distance. I’m waiting for my 13” version (~150 PPI) to see if it makes sense to go bigger.

  • SoftTalker

    For something hanging on a wall, I'd think a viewing distance of several feet would be entirely normal.

jllyhill

It so strange to see a slop-coded refresh Web app in an advert of an artisinal screen.

eink-lover

To all those decrying that this device is USD 1200 - you should look at the Samsung EM32DX and Samsung EM32DX-A displays. They are likely the same panel in a (flimsy) digital signage frame, and the EM32DX has gone for EUR 500 recently. Both devices started at EUR 1200 as well, so I guess that is just the cost for the eInk panels.

https://geizhals.de/?in=&fs=samsung%20em32dx

Likely, they will also show up on eBay soon.

bijowo1676

only wooden frame is made in the US

the display itself is made in China using Chinese technologies

fwipsy

The tl;dr should include the price. That is the one thing I click on the page looking for.

drcongo

I hate this childish, deliberate, lower-case style even more than reading something an LLM has written. Unbelievable that this is on a corporate blog.

  • lukeify

    Completely agreed. There's a place for that style in discord messages and texts, but for proper communication it comes off as childish and insincere.

  • mhb

    In the same vein is using the word "corporate" imagining that it conveys some meaning other than the user not understanding that one person corporations are a thing.

    • Brian_K_White

      It conveys that the presentation of a business is different than a person, if the person is at all professional and adult. The number of employees is irrelevant.

      A single person still wears different clothes and speaks with different language when acting as or on behalf of a business, than when at home in their pajamas passing a bong with their friends.

      A business, like anyone, can certainly decide that it wants to portray this exact crafted image intentionally (rather than as the result of being dipshits) but equally potential cutomers or vendors can percieve that image however they want and make whatever judgements and conclusions about the business operators they want from it.

      Anyway the single-personhood has no bearing. You're accusing someone of something only you did.

      • mhb

        You've argued against the straw man you've created that "corporate" and "business" are synonyms - the same as the original commenter. Just say "business" if that's what is meant instead of tarting it up in some imagined way by writing "corporate". Unless you actually wouldn't object to the presentation style if the business was, instead, a partnership.

shen

16:9 no thanks.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection