Obituaries
stratechery.com> For both of these groups, Huang was public enemy number one, because of his determination to do what was best for Nvidia’s business, which was to sell chips to China. This made sense for Nvidia for multiple reasons:
I think hearing Huang make his argument himself is pretty helpful:
https://youtu.be/Hrbq66XqtCo?si=6AEP1xdQWypoMw5C&t=3460
In my opinion, he came off as defensive, and many of his positions were contradictory and logically inconsistent. At the very best, it appears he wanted to milk the Chinese market for all he could in the short term, all other considerations be damned.
The whole article, which completely skips over crypto currencies [0] and pretends we went straight from graphics to AI, seems to pretending all of this was something that happened to Jensen instead of 100% his own making. I was not a fan of Ben's coverage of Anthropic earlier this year and it seems that I will continue to think little of his opinions given this article.
[0] Which I think are a scourge used for scams and speculation first and foremost. Also a thing Nvidia went all-in on from my perspective.
The article does say this "Huang may have fundamentally disagreed with the chip ban, but at the end of the day, it was his duty to accept that it was the law of the land. To the extent he did not do so is ultimately his responsibility."
Do you think the article was too soft on Huang? Kind of seems like the article agrees with your point "100% of his own making."
> What is clear now, however, is that the doomers and the hawks have won
I think this goes too far. Obviously losing its leading voice is pretty painful for any faction. But Jensen was not the only person making the "AI as normal technology" argument, and he was a very imperfect messenger for it because of his inherent conflict of interest. For instance, the author of the piece himself, has been a more compelling messenger for this argument for me than Jensen ever was!
"There are whispers that Megaspeed’s ultimate customer was not, or not just, Alibaba, but also the Chinese military. These are whispers, to be clear; it was the affairs that were enough, at least publicly, to lead to Huang’s resignation."
PLA getting their hands on restricted chips? Even whispers will be enough to invite some very pointed questions (and presented evidence, weak or otherwise) at the Congressional hearings.
There are no good answers or easy way to spin this situation.
Would the US military want to get technology supply from China? Or it is already doing it? That would be a national security risk if it does.