Settings

Theme

Nvidia's China Problem [pdf]

culperresearch.com

44 points by Erikun · 21 comments

Reader

9 threads
zug_zug

According to these allegations (May):

1. 20% of Nvidia's FY2026 compute revenue was ultimately driven by Chinese demand through intermediaries and alleged illegal diversion.

2. This was driven by Alice Huang (the spy)

3. Crucially this report has allegations that Jensen KNEW that these chips were being sold illegally, and that he even went on-site to these sites ALONGSIDE ALIBABA representatives.

Nvidia is down 5.7% this morning (probably on this news), but is trading at a P/E of 23x still -- my mental math if it's expecting to lose 20% of its revenue AND a CEO that it has more to fall.

  • Joker_vD

    OMFG, it's an open secret that lots of Malaysia-, Indonesia-, and Singapore-registered businesses resell GPUs to China instead of building AI datacenters themselves. And they don't need to sleep with NVIDIA's CEO to do that, you know.

    • rramadass

      Right. There are tons of companies (shell or otherwise) all over South-East Asia which feed China with what they need, sanctions or no sanctions.

      Hence there is no way the US did not know of this.

      My conspiracy theory is that the US used this to pump "poisoned" Nvidia chips (with hardware trojans via fab masks) into Chinese datacenters. Maybe the Chinese found out (they stopped buying) and hence this was framed publicly with/without the consent of the parties involved (who may not know they were just pawns) as "CEO honeytrapped by beautiful spy" which is a nice salacious piece of popular news.

      PS: Michael Barr wrote a sci-fi novel "Metacompiler" which has something about hardware trojans - https://metacompiler.me/

      • gregw2

        If you are interested in earlier conspiratorial sci-fi books featuring hardware trojans, you might try to get a copy of another sci-fi novel called "Acts of the Apostles" by John Sundman.

        John Sundman wrote and published the book in 1999 after working for many years at Sun Microsystems so it is a fiction born out of the Silicon Valley geek/tech culture of that era.

        Pertinent only to this thread's context, and not indicative of anything in particular, John would have been at Sun for many years at the same time as Nvidia cofounders Chris Malachowsky and Curtis Priem, late 80s through early 90s.

        • rramadass

          Browsed the book. It seems Michael Barr was "heavily inspired" by Sundman's book. For example, in Sundman's book the chip is called "Kali" while in Barr's book the heroine is named "Kali" and both deal with software backdoors and hardware trojans. Should be an interesting read, thanks for the pointer. There are too few sci-fi novels with actual science/technology in it.

          W.r.t. Chris and Curtis being at Sun with John, that seems true. It is also interesting to note that Curtis has almost 200 patents(!) so he obviously is an electrical engineer and chip designer par excellence (was also CTO of Nvidia for a decade). Hence he might have been the source for all the hardware shenanigans described in the novels. Interestingly he went off-the-grid after resigning from Nvidia (did he know what was coming?).

          Most people just look at the surface level of what is presented to them and don't really think about anything (unless forced by circumstances). In spite of the fact that we know everything is Propaganda and Deception (of one sort or another) managed by vested interests (not always to one's detriment though) people want to believe they are "free to act as they please". Given what we know today about the world, human psychology and the power of technology, this belief is so naive that i find it hard to understand how one can maintain it. People are consciously maneuvered into a "mental box" and they seem to be unaware of it.

          Some resources:

          1) Propaganda: The Formation of Men's Attitudes by Jacques Ellul - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda:_The_Formation_of_M...

          “The individual who burns with desire for action but does not know what to do is a common type in our society. He wants to act for the sake of justice, peace, progress, but does not know how. If propaganda can show him this ‘how’ then it has won the game; action will surely follow.”

          2) The Technological Society by Jacques Ellul - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Technological_Society This has come true now as "The Age of AI".

          3) Deception: The Invisible War Between the KGB and the CIA by Edward Jay Epstein - A very interesting book

          • boznz

            Since we are kind of doing sci-fi recommendations I will shamelessly plug my 2022 novel The Summer of Reasoning [https://rodyne.com/?p=1252] It is Creative commons so free to download/share and a long read, but has plenty of hardware/software/AI/spy shenanigans and, as both an electronic hardware and software engineer, the technologies and capabilities I describe in the book are all pretty accurate (well at least up until the sci-fi kicks in)

            • rramadass

              Thanks for the link to your novel, will give it a read. Your other novel also seems interesting.

              PS: Your "About" page is interesting (GCHQ? ;-)

              • boznz

                Yes, the 80's and 90's were, well let's say, interesting times.

      • boznz

        So the options are either to spend billions on trying to create undetectable trojan chips, or train a few hundred hot women spies? I can see why the latter is more popular in Russia and China. BTW Thanks for the book recommendation, I might give it a read.

    • zug_zug

      Well now that it's documented in writing, that business will have to be shut down (-20% revenue), somebody will have to be blamed for it (fired, arrested?), and who knows how big the fines will be.

gizzlon

"Analysts treat China as potential upside. We believe it’s the exact opposite. Nvidia’s China business – which the Company told investors went to zero a year ago – is now actually going to zero as Beijing’s late 2025 and early 2026 policies have, for example, blocked Nvidia imports in favor of its own domestic alternatives. Beijing’s stance appears hardline. Our review of trade records suggests substantial declines in CY Q1 2026 shipments, while mainland operators tell us that there are now “very few orders” in China, presenting “a huge blow to Nvidia financially.” Nvidia now faces a massive air gap in this year’s estimates. We think this also explains Jensen’s recent behavior on the Dwarkesh Patel podcast, particularly when presented with questions surrounding China"

chinathrow

> Finally, per one current Megaspeed employee, Jensen visits Megaspeed-linked data centers “every few months” and “every single time” he visits, he is accompanied by representatives from Alibaba.

tancop

I hope it's all true and China has been getting top tier GPUs all this time. Even better if they reverse engineered them to make their own. If we in Europe can't beat America they can do it for us.

freakynit

When your company's sales are in 100's of billions of dollars a year, sanctions that would evaporate 20% of those does not work.

Folks at intelligence agencies are smart enough to understand this. Yet they allowed it to happen.

This feels it has much more than just a CEO who got honey-trapped by a Chinese spy.

iantpe

In Taiwan, this was news from a year ago. But why Jensen would come forward to admit it now is what people find strange.

likeclockwork

What happened to all that free trade talk?

DarkNova6

I doubt anybody would defend him on the merit of his good character...

DivingForGold

Will time tell,is Huang actually a traitor ?

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection