Settings

Theme

Pell Puzzles Review

dles.gg

19 points by trizoza · 20 comments

Reader

5 threads
thih9

The game is here: https://pell.achromath.com

I'd update the HN submission url to the actual source, i.e. either the above game url, or its "how to play" section at https://pell.achromath.com/how-to-play .

Currently the submission points to a third party review of the game - IMO it seems more appropriate as a comment.

  • andersmurphy

    Wait. So if I write a review/article about a product the HN link should be changed to point to the product not my review? That makes no sense.

    • thih9

      If the review is about a casual web game and if instead of reading quotes, your impression and your ads I can experience the game myself then yes we should point to the product.

      • trizozaOP

        What ads are you talking about? There are 0 ads on my site!

        • thih9

          House ads do count.

          • trizozaOP

            You mean, links to other pages on my site?

            • thih9

              When they are off topic, yes.

              Note that the whole review seems off topic too. It’s neither more interesting nor more accessible than the topic itself.

              • trizozaOP

                Dude, the links in that article go to: 1. The review framework used to review the game 2. The game page itself where user can post their own reviews 3. The original game url

                I can't see how are these off topic?

playhimade

Fun game. For the first few games I think a way to peek at the rules while playing would be great, and maybe call out the non-obvious ones. I initially missed that one X never connects to an O since it’s the length-1 path

bsammon

So... how long before this gets added to Simon Tatham's puzzle collection? (https://www.chiark.greenend.org.uk/~sgtatham/puzzles/)

  • achromath

    Huge fan of this collection. Would love to collab if anyone knows more C than me (which means any C).

fph

Why do incomplete paths light up the corresponding number? I don't understand this UI choice.

  • bsammon

    I submitted this gripe (before I saw your comment) to the "report an issue" widget on the puzzle site. I wonder if this puzzle will get ongoing development.

    I have a few ideas for feature requests, but I'm not going to bother submitting them if it appears there's no interest.

    • achromath

      I'm the creator, got your request and made myself an issue to remember. Thanks for playing, and I'd love to hear what else you have in mind.

  • achromath

    Very fair point I will fix shortly.

trizozaOP

Author here, can someone explain what happened here? I submitted this article 2 days ago and 1 upvote and it got some how resubmitted today?

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection