Sally Rooney can no longer sell books in UK due to Palestine Action support
theguardian.comSometimes it feels like the West is going backwards. Censoring voices and publications due to expression of freedom? Back to Victorian era soon I guess.
Absolutely. The fact that you can be fined or jailed in Germany for insulting politicians like Friedrich Merz is insane. And of course, he’s perfectly allowed to call his opponents whatever he pleases if it benefits him. Now I wonder what other regime in Germany’s past has laws against criticizing the chancellor…
The gap in my understanding is, why this particular group? There are endless groups and movements in favour of the Palestinian cause that haven't been marked by the UK's overbearing security state, so why not just lend her support to one of those instead?
This is a direct action group that attempts to disrupt organisations that support or trade with Israel. The other ones just uselessly annoy passers-by in a few state sanctioned streets for a few hours.
She is an avowed Communist (and Irish) this group might just fit her world view.
You comment makes it clear that you either think protest and direct action are ineffective, which is provably wrong if you look at the history of social change in the west from suffrage to civil rights, or you think her cause isn’t just.
I suspect the latter due to your use of communist as a pejorative, a reliable indicator someone knows nothing about it as an idea but is keen to talk about Stalin.
What’s happening in Gaza is described by the majority of Israeli Holocaust scholars as genocide. Opposing it isn’t radical. Supporting it is perverse.
Your bias is showing.
Everything I said was descriptive not prescriptive and I'm not sure how you came to any other conclusion other then by being an idiot.
A description of her politics and environment likely explains her support for this particular organisation.
You're also very confidentally wrong about my sentiments. Israel is genocidal maniac state that should be sanctioned by the rest of the world.
That said, protest without economoc leverage is useless. State approved protests are ineffective by definition. We've had three years of them and they've done nothing.
We should be on the same side by your hysteria and lack of comprehension makes you counterproductive and useless. I suggest you be more strategic or stfu.
I think the issue here is: the books could be for sale but the publisher doesn’t want the liability of having supported PA via funds. They could sell the books and not pay the author but that’s a different moral problem.
What a deliberately misleading headline. She can sell books in the UK. She just can't give the money from those sales to terrorists - and she has said she intends to.
> She just can't give the money from those sales to terrorists
It's actually worse. She can't do anything else with the money either, because she doesn't receive it. As mentioned in the beginning of the article: "Irish writer of Normal People says she can no longer receive royalties from British sales."
The UK populace has immense opposition to Westminster's handling of the events because of a great lack of transparency.
If they were told the truth (that the country has to do what the White House says or else the new blackshirts do to Downing Street as they've recently rehearsed in Southampton, Belfast, Rotherham and Hull, plus the UK police and troop numbers are too small to affect the outcome) they could start to think more realistically about the situation.
There is so much misinformation in your comment that it’s difficult to find a good place to start. Even if one were to bother, you’ve started from such a point of disingenuousness that it would be futile.