Settings

Theme

OpenRadioss is not open anymore

siemens.com

21 points by hdrz · 22 comments

Reader

7 threads
nejch

As a Siemens employee this is so sad to watch. Some of us have been pushing hard for more open source culture at the company and it's disheartening hitting setbacks like this.

Anyways.. here's a supported open source fork already. Didn't take long: https://opencourant.org/ https://github.com/OpenCourant/OpenCourant/

  • hdrzOP

    I am very happy to see this, a continuation under the stewardship of rocky linux. I really hope it takes off and continues with force and velocity… I intend to help if I can.

kragen

It looks like there are some AGPL copies on Software Heritage, such as https://archive.softwareheritage.org/browse/origin/directory..., which mysteriously has gone missing from GitHub itself.

There are a few different open-source finite element solvers available, but I don't know enough about them to know what their strengths and weaknesses are. Coincidentally, over the last day, I've been vibecoding a multiphysics engine for sand battery design... on a grid rather than using FEM, although I'm starting to wonder if FEM would start to pay off at this point, because a thin fiberglass blanket around the outside of the sand battery seems to make a big difference, but reducing the grid grain to the thickness of the blanket would suck pretty bad.

jacquesm

I hope someone still has a copy and can put it up on github. Siemens just gained themselves a place on my shitlist for this action and I sincerely hope the industry will call them out for it.

hdrzOP

Until recently it was under AGPL. It was open sourced in 2022, and now siemens bought altair (the company who developed it for many years) and closed it again. Some of us cared and contributed, and now it’s gone… Maybe this can continue under another name using the last source release?

hackerfoo

I found this: https://github.com/QiangF/OpenRadioss_nolfs Here's an older one that fails because it needs LFS: https://github.com/Lucyants/OpenRadioss.git

jacquesm

Some of these are still alive:

http://web.archive.org/web/20251202100620/https://github.com...

spartaguy

https://github.com/gabrielrussell/OpenRadioss

Someone made a fresh repository with the version updated last week.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection