Settings

Theme

Show HN: A working reference implementation of context engineering

github.com

46 points by linsys 2 months ago · 20 comments · 1 min read

Reader

I've been presenting at local meetups about Context Engineering, RAG, Skills, etc.. I even have a vbrownbag coming up on LinkedIn about this topic so I figured I would make a basic example that uses bedrock so I can use it in my talks or vbrownbags. Hopefully it's useful.

rao-v 2 months ago

I don’t really think this reflects the current era of challenges?

The “enforcement layer” is the hardest and most important part, and is barely addressed.

- is the answer structurally / syntactically valid?

- is it appropriately grounded and evidenced?

- is it accurate? In what ways does it fall short?

Each of these should be triggering an agent to rework and resubmit etc. or failing that a disclosure to the user about how the answer falls short and should be reviewed / remediated.

This feels like it’s from the era of trying to oneshot a good enough answer.

zihotki 2 months ago

No numbers/measurements/benchmarks and you dare call it "a working" one? Any real proofs that this 'works'?

segmondy 2 months ago

I like it, it's a good start.

slashdave 2 months ago

> the information an AI system needs to produce accurate ... outputs

I would have stuck a qualifier in there

r4ge 2 months ago

I feel like AI is going to be doing all the fun stuff and I will just left organizing the data and docs it needs to generate code.

tmpz22 2 months ago

Putting engineering after a term doesnt make it engineering.

  • jryio 2 months ago

    Software engineering is certainly not engineering. Even at the highest levels. Real engineering have infinitely more complex interactions in the physical world than symbolic institutions for machines.

    • whattheheckheck 2 months ago

      Thats right, no need to understand anything other than symbols on a machine. No people involved. No reality to model. No economics to think about. Nothing like real engineering. Thats for the big boys and girls

  • slashdave 2 months ago

    Probably just using the convention started by the term "prompt engineering", which is forgivable.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection