Settings

Theme

Study investigates how mass distribution of baseball bat affects performance

news.wsu.edu

24 points by Magi604 3 months ago · 18 comments · 1 min read

Reader

https://baseball.physics.illinois.edu/ISEA2026-Torpedo-v7.pd...

Mathnerd314 3 months ago

Yeah, it's like just ignoring the actual conclusions. I mean, it's easier to hit and then it hits less hard, which is actually good because professional baseball players generally hit it out of the park when they get a good hit. So the conclusion is actually completely opposite what the title of the article is - it's not the same. It is a substantial improvement.

  • bombcar 3 months ago

    The moment I saw “slight difference in location of sweet spot” I knew the bat would have tremendous real-world impact even if the robots couldn’t hit any better.

  • sam1r 3 months ago

    Modern 2026 click bait:

    1. Provide “distinct” proof 2. Title it as the antithesis

  • devindotcom 3 months ago

    i'm sorry but where are you seeing this completely opposite and substantial improvement?

    >The team found nearly identical performance for the torpedo and standard bats except that the sweet spot for the torpedo bat was a half inch farther from the bat tip than the standard bat.

    >“It was actually pretty phenomenal how close they were,” said Smith.

    >For some players who like to hit the ball closer in, the torpedo bat might be a better option for them

    some players with some batting characteristics may find this better? is that what you are referring to? What part of the article disputes this at all, let alone concludes the opposite? Is it the researcher's own quote? I really don't understand your objection here. It seems to be based on your own intuition about how players "generally" hit balls. But the researchers themselves have presented their own data and conclusions pretty clearly here.

excalibur 3 months ago

> For some players who like to hit the ball closer in, the torpedo bat might be a better option for them, though, he added. And because the barrel is wider in a place where those batters do hit, they will be more likely to hit the ball more often — giving players a higher batting average.

If the only constraints are material and weight, it should be possible to create a design that performs even better for this purpose. But at some point it stops looking like a baseball bat.

wnevets 3 months ago

I forgot all about the torpedo bat "craze", It was largely a dead story by the all star break.

jeffbee 3 months ago

Imagine writing a whole article like this and only including one really unclear photo with a distracting background and not indicating which bat is which in the photo.

restlessforge 3 months ago

So... The Torpedo Bat is basically the Placebo Bat?

  • bryanlarsen 3 months ago

    The end of the article notes several very real changes in behavior, including being more likely to get a hit, which is significant.

    And it compares equal weight bats. If the torpedo bat allows you to use a lighter bat, that will increase your swing speed.

orthecreedence 3 months ago

> “Wood is wood,” said Smith

Ahh, finally. A definitive answer!

nsxwolf 3 months ago

Very ugly bat. Poor aesthetics for baseball.

talkfold 3 months ago

Scientists spent money confirming that wood is wood.

kaonwarb 3 months ago

Disappointing article. As another commenter mentioned, the very last sentence of the article reveals a potentially positive impact on batting average, which is extremely relevant to how well a bat works! But this seems to be ignored by the conclusion of both the researchers and the article, which focuses on hitting power.

  • sam1r 3 months ago

    This is just the most oxymoronic article. It’s like it knew we would all be like… wait.

  • devindotcom 3 months ago

    the last sentence is part of a paragraph specifying it "might" be better for "some players who like to hit the ball closer in"

    not really ignored when it's in the article. the researchers themselves are quoted saying the results are incredibly close.

lawrenceduk 3 months ago

Clicked on the story expecting underwater bat-like weapon system. Was incredibly disappointed.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection