Settings

Theme

Ask HN: What do luxurious things that should have in prison/Detention Center?

1 points by triilman 17 days ago · 4 comments · 1 min read

Reader

In my country, corruptors are given luxurious facilities that they do not deserve. But I believe the only thing that should be considered a luxury in detention centers or prisons is a library.

onion2k 17 days ago

It depends on what purpose you think prisons serve:

- If you believe that they're a punishment, then probably nothing.

- If you believe that prisons are there to rehabilitate people into being good members of society, then things like libraries, televisions, and other educational things should definitely be there.

- If you believe prisons are there mostly to protect the public from people who have committed crimes, then they should really be quite similar to life outside of prison just with the freedom to move around in public removed.

It's probably some combination of the second two. Prisons as a punishment only serves to create worse criminals who are suffering some deep trauma when they leave, which causes them to commit more crime. But also, people who have committed crimes that don't demonstrate a risk to others probably ought to receive non-custodial sentences and then prisons can be much smaller.

gregjor 17 days ago

Why do you care? Who decides what someone else "deserves?" Does prison or detention have to include deprivation and cruelty? This doesn't seem like something to get upset about unless you plan to spend time in prison.

ctenb 17 days ago

This doesn't seem like a topic to ask about on hacker news. Also, your grammar is confusing to the point I don't exactly know what the question is.

delaminator 17 days ago

This sounds like a homework question.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection