Settings

Theme

Trial by jury is a right that needs protecting

ft.com

31 points by xyzzy3000 2 months ago · 9 comments

Reader

ChrisArchitect 2 months ago

Related:

UK: Jury trials scrapped for crimes with sentences of less than three years

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46121736

bogantech 2 months ago

And the UK marches further into authoritarianism

Now they'll fast-track you to jail for social media posts

general1465 2 months ago

Trial by jury is a kangaroo court where random people will tell you if they like you or not. Are you ugly, but other party is beautiful and charismatic? Yep you lost the case.

  • voxic11 2 months ago

    Has this been your experience serving on juries? Mine hasn't been like this at all (northeastern US).

    • general1465 2 months ago

      I am from a part of the world, where people's courts are not a thing. As it should be in civilized society.

rayiner 2 months ago

Jury trials are an ancient Germanic tradition without cultural precedent in most countries. Lee Kuan Yew eliminated jury trials in Singapore because he didn’t believe they were viable in a multi-cultural country: https://www.postcolonialweb.org/Singapore/government/leekuan...

  • devilbunny 2 months ago

    Singapore is also a pretty authoritarian state. Not to put down the amazing work that Lee did in making it a functional, successful state that's substantially wealthier than its neighbors, but it's a product of the time and place of its formation that made a lot of hard choices to prevent it from spinning out into nothingness or being absorbed by its much larger neighbors. I wouldn't call it a model for the UK.

voxic11 2 months ago

Keep in mind the right to a jury trial doesn't mean you are forced to always receive a jury trial. If you think a trial by judge would be better for you then you can always waive your right to be tried by a jury. The right to waive your rights is itself a right.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection