Settings

Theme

Code from MIT's 1986 SICP video lectures

github.com

160 points by felipap · 26 comments

Reader

8 threads
725686

If you are into SICP, you would probably like a nicely formatted html version of the book:

https://sarabander.github.io/sicp/html/index.xhtml#SEC_Conte...

And also this:

https://eli.thegreenplace.net/tag/sicp

aesbetic

In the first lecture, Abelson says Computer Science is neither a science nor is it really about computers. Considering the current ML paradigm, maybe CS has finally earned its name as a science.

  • bmitc

    What about the current ML paradigm makes it a science?

    • computerfriend

      Observing and testing phenomena we don't understand.

      • mcmoor

        I guess it's been progressing from being math, to natural science, to social science

    • aesbetic

      We have “laws” and routinely conduct “experiments” which are kind of unheard of in CS.

      • bmitc

        Do you have any references I could learn about these types of laws and experiments?

  • postexitus

    It is one of the most memorable first lectures in the history of Computer Science.

  • gjvc

    quite the opposite

matheusmoreira

There's also this interesting study about the difficulty and time requirement of SICP's exercises:

https://lockywolf.wordpress.com/2021/02/08/solving-sicp/

The math stuff is brutal.

  • Jtsummers

    Take that writeup with a massive grain of salt. The author claims they spent 459 minutes on exercise 1.1, that exercise is this:

    > Exercise 1.1: Below is a sequence of expressions. What is the result printed by the interpreter in response to each expression? Assume that the sequence is to be evaluated in the order in which it is presented.

    There are then 12 simple expressions to evaluate. That is, it took them nearly 40 minutes for each expression.

    Exercise 2.46 took them 535 minutes to implement. It wasn't even complex math, they needed to create a 2d-vector data type (their choice on implementation details) with a constructor, accessors, addition, subtraction, and scaling. That should not have taken 9 hours to complete (not by that point in the book at least).

tmtvl

The SICP video lectures with Gerald Sussman and Harold Abelson got me into Scheme and from there on Lisp. Although now I'm wondering if this would be better as a 'Show HN' submission.

vismit2000

Most of the code from the book is also available here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13918465

hnarayanan

This is such a fun class!

xdavidliu

i watched the lecture series during the pandemic and commented on many of the youtube videos. in at least one instance, a library function is used on the board that is not compatible with the current function signature in mit scheme.

carverauto

would be better if you could just use AI to re-do those particular scenes in the video series..

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection