Settings

Theme

Ask HN: Why Don't GPUs Scale?

1 points by miraculixx a year ago · 3 comments · 1 min read


The deeper question is will GPUs get CPU-like features for task-parallelism like virtual cores, pipelines, order rewriting etc?

PaulHoule a year ago

My understanding is they are plenty pipelined, though the GPU is working on a more predictable workload so the order is more likely to be rewritten by the compiler than by the silicon -- that is, the CPU tries as hard as it can to maximize single threaded performance for branchy workload and "wastes" transistors and power on that, the GPU expects branches and memory access to be more predictable and spends the transistors and power it saves to add more cores.

6SixTy a year ago

GPUs do scale because they are parallel processors. Software tools like CUDA and ROCm are very specifically designed for parallel compute on GPU.

  • miraculixxOP a year ago

    Yes GPUs process a (one) computational task on a vast array of data in parallel. But it cannot process two independent tasks concurrently (except, perhaps, by reducing compute power for each task).

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection