Settings

Theme

Tell HN: OpenAI seems to be A/B testing ads in answers

7 points by FrenchDevRemote 2 years ago · 12 comments · 1 min read

Reader

I just asked it a question about programming and got back an answer recommending me a weight loss supplement that is completely unrelated to my question.

I repeated the same prompt in another chat and got an actual answer.

Either it's an ad or it's the worst hallucination I've seen in 5 years of using various LLMs, supposedly on the most advanced model out there, which I find hard to believe.

carlosjobim 2 years ago

I run a very traditional online business. We have very sparse "marketing speak" in our copy, instead trying to be on point and information dense. Every AI engine we have tried will recommend our website and products for the user when asking for the kind of things that we offer, but every AI engine will also insert a whole bunch of meaningless marketing speak for us, that is nowhere to be found in our own copy. Kind of funny.

  • qup 2 years ago

    Why would an LLM built by openai mimic the writing style of your business?

    • carlosjobim 2 years ago

      If the LLM is talking about my products and linking to the pages were we sell them, I'd expect it to source its material from those pages. Where do the marketing phrases enter the model?

artninja1988 2 years ago

Can you share a screenshot or the conversation link?

moomoo11 2 years ago

Well. It was inevitable lol. Always knew it was going to come to this, and companies will pay to have their products or services mentioned first by AI.

uptownfunk 2 years ago

I’m surprised they didn’t do it sooner. They will consume Google. They should literally roll out email and a browser and a device and it’s game over

LogHouse 2 years ago

You sure it’s not something like this? https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1d29fu2/it_looks_l...

markus_zhang 2 years ago

If they do it I'll cancel my subscription. I don't use it very often and my company pays for internal usages.

smarri 2 years ago

I hope this doesn't end up in the paid or API versions.

cranberryturkey 2 years ago

Are you on the free version?

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection