Settings

Theme

Slop is the new name for unwanted AI-generated content

simonwillison.net

92 points by beardicus 2 years ago · 43 comments

Reader

voakbasda 2 years ago

I imagine the use of this term comes from the name for the leftover foodstuff that gets fed to pigs, usually from a bucket.

As a small scale pig farmer, I approve of the use of this term; I care enough about the welfare of my pigs that I would never risk feeding them anything that would be considered slop. Plus, pigs fed with slop usually end up tasting bad, because they are what they eat.

A wonderfully apt metaphor that reflects both the voracious appetites of modern AI systems and the resulting quality of the results.

Tiberium 2 years ago

It's been used in this meaning on 4chan for at least half a year, maybe more.

Jerrrry 2 years ago

I was actually pondering the new delineation yesterday; the line between spam, propaganda, trolling, and censorship was never too fine as it is now.

I like the term slop. I needed the word yesterday.

kelipso 2 years ago

LLM slop or AI slop totally works but slop just by itself is so generic, I doubt slop by itself will catch on but who knows.

barbazoo 2 years ago

Stop trying to make slop happen, it's not gonna happen.

slowhadoken 2 years ago

Slop is an old term for allowed overlap between objects.

  • valbaca 2 years ago

    as a contrast to "slip" right?

    • slowhadoken 2 years ago

      Contrast? Not that I know of. Slip is a type of collision resolution that allows obstacles to slide off each other instead of just stopping. Similar to a circle rolling with slipping down an incline.

ivanjermakov 2 years ago

Slop is a word for waste water and messy animal food. Don't quite understand the debates here in the comments.

I like how it sounds similar to spam.

bredren 2 years ago

A good coin, this one. It needed a simple name, and it falls perfectly into a list of "four letter words."

rolph 2 years ago

slop is also unwanted food waste watered down and fed to swine.

  • ubertaco 2 years ago

    Sounds like AI-generated content to me, especially since it's often fed into spam emails/comments/blog-posts.

zug_zug 2 years ago

Eh, the internet is full of garbage SEO-spam already. We have a word for that, which is enshittification, which imo correctly identifies the root perpetrators of the problem: platform owners utilizing monopolies.

I don't see why we need a word for AI-generated garbage specifically, not yet at least.

Like if I go onto google maps and search "Best restaurants in my area" it's going to 100% recommend fast-food chains that have purchased product placement. I don't feel AI plays a significant role in bad recommendations at this point, and to blaming/stopping AI wouldn't really help.

  • simonw 2 years ago

    Enshittification means something entirely different: it's the inevitable decline of online services as they face the pressure to continually monetize.

    Plenty of examples of enshittification have nothing to do with generative AI.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification mentions Cory's alternative definition of "platform decline".

    • polshaw 2 years ago

      Platform *decay seems inadequate though because it fails to make the distinction that the platform is declining specifically in quality and likely NOT in use.

    • rimunroe 2 years ago

      Also I wouldn't call a particular blog post's content "enshittification" anyway. "Enshittification" is a process, not a particular type of content. We have plenty of terms for the latter, like "SEO spam" or "rage bait". I don't see anything wrong with someone trying to come up with a shorthand term for "unwanted AI-generated content"

    • zug_zug 2 years ago

      They're only different if an individual is manually posting slop.

      If a company is automatically posting slop, then the root of the problem is enshittification, and AI is just means.

      • Lalabadie 2 years ago

        If we forewent all words that are symptoms but not root problems, we would have very few words.

  • rightbyte 2 years ago

    "Enshittification" is some sort of rug pull scam. Not AI spam...

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection