Settings

Theme

Windows 11 Sends Tremendous Amount of User Data to Third Parties

tomshardware.com

42 points by benevol 3 years ago · 15 comments

Reader

nehal3m 3 years ago

Previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34712640

kaetemi 3 years ago

So much data and they still can't figure out what their users really want.

  • nehal3m 3 years ago

    Agreed. Pleeeease give us an option to move the notification toast.

    If I have the system tray open and a toast appears OVER (!?) it, I move to close the toast. That's a click outside the systray, which causes it to close. The notification system leaves me with enough time to open the systray back up (and any subsequent program menu I'm in there for) just to bother me with a toast AGAIN.

    It makes my blood boil. Either let me move the toast to the top right of the screen (without covering window controls please!) or pop under the systray!

  • pointlessone 3 years ago

    You assume that is their goal but what if it’s not? Say, what if selling data is the only/primary goal?

  • mmerlin 3 years ago

    What I would like to see is all the lost/removed keyboard shortcuts from all their bundled apps from Win10, reinstated back into Win11.

    It feels like dozens of keyboard shortcuts were just forgotten about or purposefully discarded in windows 11... maybe abandoned by the current generation of Microsfties (who I presume are mouse-only people?)

    For example, who was the decision maker who decided nobody wants to keep on using "left/right arrow key and enter" to navigate a dialog box... make them use the mouse... or if they complain, let them use Shift+Tab instead of the left arrow key.

    Also, change windows start button so that when you type we will add extra lag and bing recommendations... when I am just trying to open a locally installed program.

    Win11 looked nice at first but after using it for work for the past 8 months I think it is a clunky laggy hog that forces me to learn a new set of weird shortcuts that require extra keystrokes and abandon the old muscle memory... or have to fumble around for a mouse because the old previously good keyboard shortcut no longer exists any more.

    I reckon Win10 was a lot better.

acd 3 years ago

You are the product in Windows 10 & Windows 11, Social media platforms like Facebook, Tiktok, Whatsapp and search engines Google. Your behaviours is sold for marketing products.

You can most likely calculate how much your personal data is worth. Take yearly income statements from above companies and divide by platform number of users.

qualudeheart 3 years ago

Why we use Linux.

  • jlpcsl 3 years ago

    Same here. GNU/Linux and other free and opensource software is our only way to regain our privacy, and general control over our computers. Corporate software is just more and more ads and spyware.

hestefisk 3 years ago

Has anyone ever done a gdpr request for MS based on their Win11 telemetry data?

emsign 3 years ago

This is why you should want to block advertisers and trackers via DNS right at your DHCP server as a first line defense. Better safe than sorry.

  • qwertox 3 years ago

    I wonder if it would be illegal for MS to use their own DNS over HTTPS in order to evade being filtered out with let's say Pi-hole.

    If I set DNS in network settings to be my own resolver I'm expressing my will to have all the queries my computer sent to that one resolver.

thevania 3 years ago

just use https://wpd.app/

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection