Settings

Theme

Show HN: Shout It – A platform to shout out your feelings

apprester.com

29 points by _aenb 6 years ago · 39 comments

Reader

ketralnis 6 years ago

See also Aaaaah, a social network for yelling existentially into the void https://twitter.com/chromakode/status/1186348053575262208?s=...

_aenbOP 6 years ago

You can share your feelings, stress, and anxiety! More features are coming on. I would like to get some feedback on it.

The site isn't mobile-friendly at the moment. Please use a desktop browser for time-being, we are planning to improve frontend over the weekend

z_open 6 years ago

I assumed this would be more personal. People expressing anger, depression, etc. This seems to be rants about things they find mildly annoying. Not sure if the site wants or will encourage/enforce one or the others.

  • _aenbOP 6 years ago

    I am thinking of grouping people with similar problems so they can discuss the issue, but as of now, it has been spam I guess.

    It did help me validate the idea, so I am thankful for that!

krilly 6 years ago

https://i.postimg.cc/zBhVFjDg/Screenshot-20191225-175902.png

Yikes. I get not supporting mobile for now, but what about people who like to use little browser windows like me? Doesn't seem to be responsive at all.

  • _aenbOP 6 years ago

    I understand your problem. Apparently, our front-end dev isn't available on weekdays, so we are discussing it and trying to optimize the frontend. Thank you for your feedback.

  • bryanrasmussen 6 years ago

    I have always assumed that people like to use at least most of their screen's real estate if not all - what is your reason for liking narrow windows (especially considering that I think even nowadays on most of the web the experience would be degraded)

    • nvrspyx 6 years ago

      Multitasking. Watching videos, writing something up, having another website open, messaging, Skype, or anything else you can think of while browsing. Having two windows open side by side isn't abnormal and is one of the main reasons why window managers even exist instead of desktops using a mobile-like UI paradigm where you can only have one program on the screen at a time.

      Counter question: why would you want something as one-dimensional as a website (especially the OP) taking up all of your screen real estate?

      • bryanrasmussen 6 years ago

        I guess I don't actually believe in multitasking.

        • soneca 6 years ago

          I can divide my screen among several windows to perform one task.

          The most obvious example for me is coding. Terminal, code editor, browser running the code locally.

          Even when I want to have a break and check HN I prefer to open another tab on the non-fullscreen browser for an easy transition to and from the break.

          • bryanrasmussen 6 years ago

            most people I see do this do it on multiple screens not multiple windows on one screen (or multiple tablet sized windows on one large screen, and most do it without making any screen as extremely narrow as the parent did.

            However I suppose also that most is not all, and there must be some outliers who do it on a single laptop screen either from necessity or preference. I might find myself doing extremely narrow windows out of necessity but never preference, and then the extremely narrow windows would almost always be on something I was working on - as it is indeed in your case - and not to interact with someone else's site.

        • cortesoft 6 years ago

          You never have to refer to something else while working on something? Like having docs or help on what part of the screen while programming?

          • bryanrasmussen 6 years ago

            As a general rule then I would move between tabs or windows if I were reading documentation or help on a subject.

            I tend not to read at the same time as programming, I might read, stop reading, and then program based on what I read, but not have two tools open and have my eyes continually hopping between them.

    • _aenbOP 6 years ago

      We wanted to make something where people can come and "shout" immediately. We will improve this design over time. Thank you for your concerns.

pollux01 6 years ago

chuck signup all together, u'll get more engagement. Signup is a hassle.

  • cmd_spectre 6 years ago

    This will lead to a lower risk for people shouting their actual feelings on the platform. Also I feel like something like this is direly needed with big tech starting to become "regulated" and breeding an atmosphere of censorship and "like farming". On the other hand, this could also allow for people to easily spread hate and zeal for or about things that will cause more negativity and suffering.

  • _aenbOP 6 years ago

    Thank you! I understand the issue. Currently, we aren't using any email.

rsync 6 years ago

I found signup and initial use to be quick and easy - no email or confirmation, etc.

The output does not respect carriage returns / newlines ... so while this HN post has multiple paragraphs, a similar input at "Shout It" would have this all run together with no newlines...

  • _aenbOP 6 years ago

    Thank you for the feedback! We will work on that over the weekend. I understand that it is an issue not being able to format the text.

    • new_guy 6 years ago

      Why would you not even bother getting basic functionality working before showing it to everyone?

      • dajohnson89 6 years ago

        Show HN can be used to show a work-in-progress. There's no expectation for the projects to be bug-free.

      • _aenbOP 6 years ago

        Thank you for your feedback! We will update this by the weekend.

        Our main reason to show was to validate if people would like to pen down their feelings, so we wanted to confirm this! We have also thought a lot of ideas and are keeping them on hold. We basically wanted to know if the core functionality is useful or not!

brian-armstrong 6 years ago

For some reason this site has gone out of its way to make reading more difficult by removing scroll momentum. As a result it takes quite a lot of effort just to read a few of these.

quickthrower2 6 years ago

Agh! Same thing happens to every anonymous chat app on show HN. It degraded into “your mum lolz” and “<a href...>” etc.

joegahona 6 years ago

Aside from the large signup box, the “shouts” tend to just be gibberish for me. Is the site currently being hacked?

pickdenis 6 years ago

Slight UI nitpick: On narrow screens (<800px), the signup part of the screen is cut off. There is a scroll bar but it doesn't work as intended.

https://i.imgur.com/pRtOd73.png

_aenbOP 6 years ago

We have taken your suggestion and changed some features of the platform, we are continually developing it. We would like to know your feedback. --The dev team

SlowRobotAhead 6 years ago

As of typing it has a few hundred spam posts from user “a”. Needs work

jpm_sd 6 years ago

It's too bad "I'll Scream Your Tweets" never took off

https://youtu.be/Td1MYuLu5Nc

hanniabu 6 years ago

So basically Twitter?

  • _aenbOP 6 years ago

    We have some features on the hold. We want to make it a place where people help each other.

aliswe 6 years ago

Nice! but block tags.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection