Settings

Theme

Ask HN: Are upvotes considered a factor in search ranking?

spraveen.posterous.com

2 points by spraveen80 15 years ago · 3 comments

Reader

benologist 15 years ago

I doubt they are:

1) the volume of popular stories on digg/reddit/stumbleupon/hn etc cover a miniscule portion of the internet and aren't necessarily more important or better than the overwhelming majority of the internet.

2) Google can't trust votes/users, and in lots of cases can't even see who made the vote let alone decide whether user x on site y is legitimate. They also can't trust the sites to handle that themselves - they get gamed all day every day with fake accounts/paid submitters (even on HN!), manufactured content, summary spam etc.

3) every site implements/displays it differently which would mean scraping most of the time, and tapping into APIs only some of the time.

There are SEO benefits though like people linking to your site because of the popular submission, your site spending a day or two on a high-PR website's front page etc.

  • spraveen80OP 15 years ago

    I agree point 2 and 3 could be too challenging to overcome. But on point 1, a story could be important for a search query considering who has upvoted it.

theDoug 15 years ago

Short answer: No, but many search engines are increasingly aware of the microformat data you may wish to supply. (http://www.google.com/help/features.html of some examples)

This info shows up when you search for things like movies and Google shows "3 1/2 stars" or "starts 7:30pm." I forget the format's exact name but there's a lot you can provide.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection