AI Safety Is Mostly A Sex Cult In Berkeley, California

· Very Sane AI Newsletter ·

63 min read Original article ↗

These people shouldn’t make policy.

There has been a great effort over many years to distance AI Safety discussion from its origin and intellectual center, because its center is a sex cult started by a fan fiction author. Since those involved want to be taken seriously, they have to hide that. Everyone else working in AI Safety is, in effect, a smokescreen for this core group and their ideas.

We might some day have “AI Safety”, as a science or policy area, that is not primarily a sex cult in Berkeley, California, but it does not currently exist.

This is Eliezer Yudkowsky. He is seen here in a meeting with Bernie Sanders, who he is advising on AI policy, and in The AI Doc, now on Netflix.

Two-slide carousel. Slide 1: X post by Sen. Bernie Sanders (@SenSanders), dated 4:02 PM · Mar 4, 2026, with a video still of Eliezer Yudkowsky speaking. Post text: “Will AI become smarter than humans?  If so, is humanity in danger?  I went to Silicon Valley to ask some of the leading AI experts that question.  Here’s what they had to say:” The video subtitle reads: “They are running the factories.” Slide 2: Close-up of Yudkowsky wearing glasses and a black hat in The AI Doc. Subtitle: “THE ABRUPT EXTERMINATION.”Two-slide carousel. Slide 1: X post by Sen. Bernie Sanders (@SenSanders), dated 4:02 PM · Mar 4, 2026, with a video still of Eliezer Yudkowsky speaking. Post text: “Will AI become smarter than humans?  If so, is humanity in danger?  I went to Silicon Valley to ask some of the leading AI experts that question.  Here’s what they had to say:” The video subtitle reads: “They are running the factories.” Slide 2: Close-up of Yudkowsky wearing glasses and a black hat in The AI Doc. Subtitle: “THE ABRUPT EXTERMINATION.”

This is Yudkowsky in Time Magazine in 2023, advocating in favor of risking nuclear war to prevent AI research from happening anywhere on Earth.

Text excerpt from Yudkowsky’s Time essay: “Frame nothing as a conflict between national interests, have it clear that anyone talking of arms races is a fool. That we all live or die as one, in this, is not a policy but a fact of nature. Make it explicit in international diplomacy that preventing AI extinction scenarios is considered a priority above preventing a full nuclear exchange, and that allied nuclear countries are willing to run some risk of nuclear exchange if that’s what it takes to reduce the risk of large AI training runs.”

This is very senior OpenAI employee and unofficial OpenAI spokesman Roon. Roon’s publicly stated opinion about Yudkowsky is:

  1. Yudkowsky is in and/or running what Roon describes as a sex cult.

  2. Yudkowsky’s opinions about AI are important, and Roon says he takes the things he says quite seriously.

This seems to be an extremely common pair of opinions concerning Yudkowsky.

X exchange dated Sep 13. Casey, @caseycantor_: “Roon I feel like major players in AI, including executives and engineers, rarely engage publicly with arguments from people like Yudkowsky and Soares. Is that because these arguments have already been explored ad nauseam, because they aren’t taken very seriously, or because I’m just not following the right part of Twitter?” roon, @tszzl: “they aren’t taken very seriously for various reasons. they’re all so deep in their sex cult and their high horse that they don’t know how hard they’ve made it to take them seriously. nate soares looked extremely at home on tucker carlson as one among many crazies on his show” roon: “however I think yudkowsky is one of the most powerful philosophers of this century. when he says something I take it quite seriously. I have to psychologically tamp down my immune reaction. he is a good man and has done much to save the world”

Yudkowsky is sufficiently controversial that people motivated by his ideas often downplay or deny his influence. Sometimes this spans multiple layers: People who received money from Sam Bankman-Fried denying they’re Effective Altruists, Sam Bankman-Fried denying he’s an Effective Altruist when caught, Effective Altruists denying their version of AI Safety is heavily influenced by Yudkowsky’s, people who are extremely core members of the movement often call themselves “rationalist adjacent”, and so on. But Yudkowsky is provably, publicly influential on essentially all major public figures in AI. It is easy to deny not because it is hidden but because it seems so insane.

Yudkowsky is the person who connected Shane Legg and Demis Hassabis to Peter Thiel so that they could secure funding to start DeepMind1, which is now Google's AI research division. Here's Sam Altman's opinion of Yudkowsky.

Two X posts by Sam Altman, @sama, dated Feb 3, 2023: “eliezer has IMO done more to accelerate AGI than anyone else.  certainly he got many of us interested in AGI, helped deepmind get funded at a time when AGI was extremely outside of the overton window, was critical in the decision to start openai, etc.” “it is possible at some point he will deserve the nobel peace prize for this--I continue to think short timelines and slow takeoff is likely the safest quadrant of the short/long timelines and slow/fast takeoff matrix.”

Left, we have a schedule for the Future of Life Institute’s January 2015 AI conference in Puerto Rico, which both Elon Musk and Yudkowsky attended. Right, we have a separate, explicitly Effective Altruist event: EA Global, held in Mountain View that August, where Musk and Yudkowsky both also appeared.2 Musk would cofound OpenAI that December. Given these events and Sam Altman’s direct credit, Yudkowsky and Effective Altruism were certainly adjacent to and probably did play a critical role in the decision to start OpenAI.

Two-slide carousel. Slide 1, conference schedule: “0800-0900: Breakfast 0900-1200: Creating human-level AI: how and when? Short talks followed by panel discussion: will it happen, and if so, when? Via engineered solution, whole brain emulation, or other means? (We defer until the 4pm session questions regarding what will happen, about whether machines will have goals, about ethics, etc.) Speakers: • Demis Hassabis, Google/DeepMind • Dileep George, Vicarious (pdf) • Tom Mitchell, CMU (pdf) Panelists include Joscha Bach (MIT), Francesca Rossi (Padova), Richard Mallah (Cambridge Semantics), Richard Sutton (Alberta) 1200-1300: Lunch 1300-1515: Free play/breakout sessions on the beach 1515-1545: Coffee & snacks 1545-1600: Breakout session reports 1600-1900: Intelligence explosion: science or fiction? If an intelligence explosion happens, then what are likely outcomes? What can we do now to maximize the probability of a positive outcome? Containment problem? Is “friendly AI” possible? Feasible? Likely to happen? Speakers: • Nick Bostrom, Oxford (pdf) • Bart Selman, Cornell (pdf) • Jaan Tallinn, Skype founder (pdf) • Elon Musk, SpaceX, Tesla Motors Panelists include Shane Legg (Google/DeepMind), Murray Shanahan (Imperial), Vernor Vinge (San Diego), Eliezer Yudkowsky (MIRI) 1930: banquet (outside by beach)” Slide 2: Five panelists sit onstage beneath a screen reading “Effective Altruism Global 2015.” The article’s caption identifies them, from left to right, as Daniel Dewey, Nick Bostrom, Elon Musk, Nate Soares, and Stuart Russell.Two-slide carousel. Slide 1, conference schedule: “0800-0900: Breakfast 0900-1200: Creating human-level AI: how and when? Short talks followed by panel discussion: will it happen, and if so, when? Via engineered solution, whole brain emulation, or other means? (We defer until the 4pm session questions regarding what will happen, about whether machines will have goals, about ethics, etc.) Speakers: • Demis Hassabis, Google/DeepMind • Dileep George, Vicarious (pdf) • Tom Mitchell, CMU (pdf) Panelists include Joscha Bach (MIT), Francesca Rossi (Padova), Richard Mallah (Cambridge Semantics), Richard Sutton (Alberta) 1200-1300: Lunch 1300-1515: Free play/breakout sessions on the beach 1515-1545: Coffee & snacks 1545-1600: Breakout session reports 1600-1900: Intelligence explosion: science or fiction? If an intelligence explosion happens, then what are likely outcomes? What can we do now to maximize the probability of a positive outcome? Containment problem? Is “friendly AI” possible? Feasible? Likely to happen? Speakers: • Nick Bostrom, Oxford (pdf) • Bart Selman, Cornell (pdf) • Jaan Tallinn, Skype founder (pdf) • Elon Musk, SpaceX, Tesla Motors Panelists include Shane Legg (Google/DeepMind), Murray Shanahan (Imperial), Vernor Vinge (San Diego), Eliezer Yudkowsky (MIRI) 1930: banquet (outside by beach)” Slide 2: Five panelists sit onstage beneath a screen reading “Effective Altruism Global 2015.” The article’s caption identifies them, from left to right, as Daniel Dewey, Nick Bostrom, Elon Musk, Nate Soares, and Stuart Russell.
On the right, in order, Daniel Dewey (MIRI), Nick Bostrom (Oxford Future of Humanity Institute), Elon Musk (self-explanatory), Nate Soares (MIRI), Stuart Russell (Quite Good At AI Research, otherwise uninvolved)

Dario Amodei, current CEO of Anthropic, is here in 2013 identified as a "member of the effective altruism community" on the blog of Yudkowsky's non-profit. He appears along with Holden Karnofsky, also identified as an Effective Altruist.

MIRI webpage screenshot: “MIRI strategy conversation with Steinhardt, Karnofsky, and Amodei January 13, 2014 | Luke Muehlhauser On October 27th, 2013, MIRI met with three additional members of the effective altruism community to discuss MIRI’s organizational strategy. The participants were: • Eliezer Yudkowsky (research fellow at MIRI) • Luke Muehlhauser (executive director at MIRI) • Holden Karnofsky (co-CEO at GiveWell) • Jacob Steinhardt (grad student in computer science at Stanford) • Dario Amodei (post-doc in biophysics at Stanford) We recorded and transcribed much of the conversation, and then edited and paraphrased the transcript for clarity, conciseness, and to protect the privacy of some content. The resulting edited transcript is available in full here (62 pages).”

And here Dario is arguing with Yudkowsky about the paperclip maximizer, a now-classic thought experiment, originally Yudkowsky’s, about an AI that might kill everyone.

Discussion transcript excerpt:  Jacob: I think what Eliezer would say, and correct me if I'm wrong, is that there is a natural category that looks kind of like fulfillment on some level, but it includes all sorts of things that you don't want. Like saying 'yes' to wire-heading. Is that right?  Eliezer: Yes.  Dario: For any short term neural computational category, that's going to be the case. There's a longer term category that refers to what we mean, that describes something of greater spatial-temporal extent. The question is whether that's natural or not? Are you saying that it's not?  Eliezer: Why would a paperclip maximizer need to know about that in order to manipulate you?  Dario: Maybe it’ll win so quickly that it doesn’t need to know about that. But something that was interacting with humans over an extended period of time might need to know that.  Eliezer: Why?  Jacob: Actually, I'm not convinced that continuing along this line vs. popping up a couple of levels is the best use of our time.  Eliezer: The whole fundamental question about, "Why is FAI hard?" has awful lot to do with a lot of this. I do suspect that diving into the details and seeing that lots of specific things don’t work out might help people see why FAI is so hard.

“AI Alignment” and “AI Safety” were first popularized by Yudkowsky’s non-profit, MIRI, the Machine Intelligence Research Institute. OpenAI and Anthropic have cited Yudkowsky or his non-profit at least a dozen times3, and the entire way we talk about AI today uses terminology his non-profit popularized. It is effectively impossible to even discuss these areas without, implicitly or explicitly, performing commentary on Yudkowsky’s writing.

This is Jacob Coxon, the recent “whistleblower” who quit Anthropic, being asked his opinions on rationalists and effective altruists.

X exchange. Ed Zitron, @edzitron: “what is your relationship to the rationalists and effective altruists?” Jacob Coxon, @hilbertspaess: “Yeah, this is a really important question.  I’ve been associating with rationalists for almost a decade. Their ideas were compelling and you can’t deny their foresight. The founders of every superintelligence effort are all bound up in the rationality sphere. Sam Altman and Greg Brockman used to frequent the MIRI offices.  The way I relate to rationalists is it’s like the bizarre hypertrophied physiques on specialized athletes. In my opinion they have weirdly specialized minds that make them uniquely able to be correct about topics removed from daily experience. These “specialized minds” also can make them off-putting to many people.  I dont know if I’d consider myself a rationalist. I am intuitively opposed to polyamory, veganism, and consequentialist intuitions. But I certainly trust them to be correct about factual questions.”

This is Nate Silver citing LessWrong as a source of information about AI risk. LessWrong is a website started by Yudkowsky in 2009, and was originally filled only with Yudkowsky’s writing.

Nate Silver, @NateSilver538, 8:10 AM · Sep 11, 2026: “The AI risk people actually do show their work! There are hundreds of working papers, thousands of LessWrong posts, literally entire best-selling books about this.”  Quoted post by rat king 🐀, @MikeIsaac · Sep 11: a frustrating thing about all the "TK percent chance we die" headlines is that researchers can say any number and non-technical people will just be like "damn well that guy's in tech, im worried"  show your work! is this about scaling laws or some arxiv file ive yet to read? ... [cut off]

This is Oliver Habryka, who is the executive director of the nonprofit controlling LessWrong and the rationalists’ compound, known as Lighthaven. He is here explaining how large he thinks the influence of rationalism is on AI Safety and AI existential risk discourse. He appears to be engaged in some kind of internal territorial dispute. It is possibly the only time I have ever agreed with him.

Screenshot of a post by Oliver Habryka, @ohabryka, dated 6:51 PM · Sep 21, 2026:  > This has given EA the power to affect the discourse, eg by METR writing about the Hugging Face hack or Dario publishing the Pacing The Frontier letter.  Come on, this seems just absurd. LessWrong gets more views than basically all popular EA content combined. How does EA have "power to affect the discourse" in ways that the rationality community does not?  If anything the memetic influence of the rationality community, with its persistent focus on AI Safety and existential risk is obviously the one that has majorly affected the discourse. The rationality community is most of the reason why the EA community has cared about AI existential risk for the last decade!  Some of your other points seem valid, but this one just leaves me a bit baffled.

This is a podcast interview with Daniel Alejandro Moreno-Gama, who attempted to firebomb Sam Altman’s house, in which he names Yudkowsky as his primary influence.

Yudkowsky’s more dedicated followers seem to prefer to call themselves “the rationality community” these days, everyone else calls them “rationalists”, the entire following “rationalism”. “Rats” is also common.4

This is a long denial that they are a religion. I alternate between finding these denials funny and finding them insulting.

Three-slide carousel of a post by Aella, @Aella_Girl. Slide 1: “ok full thoughts on 'is rationality religion' now that i have a keyboard and time. 1. 'rationality' is a community that sprung up out of a bunch of ppl who read blogs (sequences, hpmor, ssc, etc) and realized that they got along really well with other people who read those same blogs. 2. it ended up with the name 'rationality' community, which many ppl regret but it's too late to change. often ppl say they are 'aspiring' rationalists, partially cause it's dangerous to get your ego tied up in a flattering word, partly cause of general distrust of appeals to credentialism, and partly cause imo rationality is more of a 'process' than it is a point you can hit. 3. it's a community, or a scene, that centered around a shared value that not only can you 'want' to figure out how to think in ways that result in truth more often, but that you can actually put specific, intentional effort into these things. 4. Many of these ideas center around figuring out ways to identify if your thinking is wrong. like, if you think x is going to happen, actually bet money on it, so that you can't dismiss it to yourself if it doesn't happen. You actually have to suffer a consequence if you're wrong. This will help you avoid psychological cope that you might not notice you're doing. 5. There's been tons of meta community discussion around how to avoid failures that come from 'trying to do rationality things' as opposed to 'trying to figure out what's true'. For example, you might think that emotions interfere with figuring out the truth (as e.g. fear or greed does with choosing stocks), so you then go 'i should ignore emotions' and then proceed to miss out on tons of valuable information about yourself and the world. 6. The community contains tons of disagreement about facts about the world, and even the sequences. in the current bay area sequences reading group, one of the default prompts for the readings is 'do you disagree with anything here? if so, what?' and then people debate about it. 7. The community tends to be insular and weird. It attracts pretty autistic, high sat scorers, shape rotator type people. They've developed a vocabulary and norms and their own culture. I've heard a lot of ppl say "I am dissatisfied by the rationality community but I haven't found any other community I like more."  ok - is it a religion?” Slide 2: “No, and thinking it is drastically misunderstands both religion and weird insular cultures.  The thing most people today think of as 'religion' is a faint shadow of an ancient, powerful monster. Religion has raised and destroyed entire civilizations; martyrs have chosen to be burned alive than simply say 'nah u got me i don't believe that.' Is there any belief you hold that you would refuse to say the words 'fine i don't believe it' to stop bad guys from literally burning you to death? Can you imagine what that's like? It has chiseled sacred norms that touch every single part of life, from clothing to marriage to war to death itself. It's a force that has, historically, burrowed deep to the core of human minds and completely transformed them into weapons for its own bidding.  In much of the western world, that beast has died, and cultures walk around wearing gilded remnants of its flesh. "Look, I go to church," they say, but their soul is possessed by nothing, it's filled with osmosis of the secular norms around them. They support gay marriage, or have ever had a divorce, or treat the sacred texts not as sacred but as some inspirational poetry or as a self-help alternative.  And like, sure. Get meaning where you can. Traditions are comforting. But the unitarian universalists or the casual catholics or the cultural jews are entirely unpossessed by the beast.  'Religion' to people in western culture is watered down, and thus is very easy a term to throw at anyone in different clothing. And fine - it doesn't matter the word we use itself as long as everyone is on the same page. We can expand it, why not. But expanding it doesn't actually make change how possessed people are by the Beast.  Rationalists, imo, don't even wear the skin of the religious. There's no sacred text - there's common texts, and it's weird to be unfamiliar with them if you're very integrated in the community - but it's weirder still if you agree with all of them uncritically. There's no single set of beliefs - you can find liberals and conservatives, socialists and libertarians, theists and atheist. The community of course *tends* towards certain sets of beliefs, but it is by no means exclusionary towards conclusions! I personally am a member of the rationalist community, perhaps amongst its most visible members, but I have deeply batshit spiritual beliefs and don't really think reality is made out of molecules.” Slide 3: “Perhaps most importantly, rationality is not spiritual, does not claim to be spiritual. I've seen many a rat debate consciousness at a meetup, but somehow their discussions manage strip the thing of all sparkle.  If there's anything that is central to qualifying as a religion, in my mind, it's something like a systematized source of spirituality. Imo the rationalists are lacking in this, and I would love them to have more of it. I don't think 'rationality' as a practice performs this function at all. It's mostly unrelated.  I *do* think that the rationality community has occasionally attracted people who are using it to provide a certain sort of meaning in their life; something like a desire to be a good person deserving of love, fulfilled by EA-adjacent do-gooding. Or a fear of loss of control, soothed by working hard at making sure your thoughts are Very Correct Or Else. (The community has had a lot of internal discourse about this too). Maybe people from the outside look at rationality and think 'oh, if I were going to get into this, my motivation would be trying to fix a brokenness inside me', and they pattern-match this onto the function of religion?  But I suspect more commonly it's related to the tendency for humans to outgroup the weirdos, especially earnest weirdos, and especially earnest weirdos who have the potential to be powerful in some way (High SAT-score math nerds usually end up with a lot of money).  There's qualities that vaguely reflect some aspects of religion in many nonreligious aspects of human life, because the things that make religion compelling to people are often tied into basic human urges that manifest everywhere, religion or not. The knitting community has drama over patterns, and litigates within itself the moral norms around creativity and ownership. The conservatives bristle with defensiveness against the sins of the immigrants; likeminded furries wear furry uniforms and gather regularly to commune and celebrate their ways of life.  Science, academia, etc. is also an elevated community with regular meetings, quite a lot of ritual, it attracts a certain type of person, it has a set of important teachings everyone is expected to learn and follow. The culture around it is often quite toxic, but usually the people who accuse it of being a 'religion' are people who are quite bad at doing science themselves. Community, autism, and shared values around practicing a skill does not a religion make.  I'm not saying you can't criticise the rationality community, but you'll have to do better than 'it's a religion'.”Three-slide carousel of a post by Aella, @Aella_Girl. Slide 1: “ok full thoughts on 'is rationality religion' now that i have a keyboard and time. 1. 'rationality' is a community that sprung up out of a bunch of ppl who read blogs (sequences, hpmor, ssc, etc) and realized that they got along really well with other people who read those same blogs. 2. it ended up with the name 'rationality' community, which many ppl regret but it's too late to change. often ppl say they are 'aspiring' rationalists, partially cause it's dangerous to get your ego tied up in a flattering word, partly cause of general distrust of appeals to credentialism, and partly cause imo rationality is more of a 'process' than it is a point you can hit. 3. it's a community, or a scene, that centered around a shared value that not only can you 'want' to figure out how to think in ways that result in truth more often, but that you can actually put specific, intentional effort into these things. 4. Many of these ideas center around figuring out ways to identify if your thinking is wrong. like, if you think x is going to happen, actually bet money on it, so that you can't dismiss it to yourself if it doesn't happen. You actually have to suffer a consequence if you're wrong. This will help you avoid psychological cope that you might not notice you're doing. 5. There's been tons of meta community discussion around how to avoid failures that come from 'trying to do rationality things' as opposed to 'trying to figure out what's true'. For example, you might think that emotions interfere with figuring out the truth (as e.g. fear or greed does with choosing stocks), so you then go 'i should ignore emotions' and then proceed to miss out on tons of valuable information about yourself and the world. 6. The community contains tons of disagreement about facts about the world, and even the sequences. in the current bay area sequences reading group, one of the default prompts for the readings is 'do you disagree with anything here? if so, what?' and then people debate about it. 7. The community tends to be insular and weird. It attracts pretty autistic, high sat scorers, shape rotator type people. They've developed a vocabulary and norms and their own culture. I've heard a lot of ppl say "I am dissatisfied by the rationality community but I haven't found any other community I like more."  ok - is it a religion?” Slide 2: “No, and thinking it is drastically misunderstands both religion and weird insular cultures.  The thing most people today think of as 'religion' is a faint shadow of an ancient, powerful monster. Religion has raised and destroyed entire civilizations; martyrs have chosen to be burned alive than simply say 'nah u got me i don't believe that.' Is there any belief you hold that you would refuse to say the words 'fine i don't believe it' to stop bad guys from literally burning you to death? Can you imagine what that's like? It has chiseled sacred norms that touch every single part of life, from clothing to marriage to war to death itself. It's a force that has, historically, burrowed deep to the core of human minds and completely transformed them into weapons for its own bidding.  In much of the western world, that beast has died, and cultures walk around wearing gilded remnants of its flesh. "Look, I go to church," they say, but their soul is possessed by nothing, it's filled with osmosis of the secular norms around them. They support gay marriage, or have ever had a divorce, or treat the sacred texts not as sacred but as some inspirational poetry or as a self-help alternative.  And like, sure. Get meaning where you can. Traditions are comforting. But the unitarian universalists or the casual catholics or the cultural jews are entirely unpossessed by the beast.  'Religion' to people in western culture is watered down, and thus is very easy a term to throw at anyone in different clothing. And fine - it doesn't matter the word we use itself as long as everyone is on the same page. We can expand it, why not. But expanding it doesn't actually make change how possessed people are by the Beast.  Rationalists, imo, don't even wear the skin of the religious. There's no sacred text - there's common texts, and it's weird to be unfamiliar with them if you're very integrated in the community - but it's weirder still if you agree with all of them uncritically. There's no single set of beliefs - you can find liberals and conservatives, socialists and libertarians, theists and atheist. The community of course *tends* towards certain sets of beliefs, but it is by no means exclusionary towards conclusions! I personally am a member of the rationalist community, perhaps amongst its most visible members, but I have deeply batshit spiritual beliefs and don't really think reality is made out of molecules.” Slide 3: “Perhaps most importantly, rationality is not spiritual, does not claim to be spiritual. I've seen many a rat debate consciousness at a meetup, but somehow their discussions manage strip the thing of all sparkle.  If there's anything that is central to qualifying as a religion, in my mind, it's something like a systematized source of spirituality. Imo the rationalists are lacking in this, and I would love them to have more of it. I don't think 'rationality' as a practice performs this function at all. It's mostly unrelated.  I *do* think that the rationality community has occasionally attracted people who are using it to provide a certain sort of meaning in their life; something like a desire to be a good person deserving of love, fulfilled by EA-adjacent do-gooding. Or a fear of loss of control, soothed by working hard at making sure your thoughts are Very Correct Or Else. (The community has had a lot of internal discourse about this too). Maybe people from the outside look at rationality and think 'oh, if I were going to get into this, my motivation would be trying to fix a brokenness inside me', and they pattern-match this onto the function of religion?  But I suspect more commonly it's related to the tendency for humans to outgroup the weirdos, especially earnest weirdos, and especially earnest weirdos who have the potential to be powerful in some way (High SAT-score math nerds usually end up with a lot of money).  There's qualities that vaguely reflect some aspects of religion in many nonreligious aspects of human life, because the things that make religion compelling to people are often tied into basic human urges that manifest everywhere, religion or not. The knitting community has drama over patterns, and litigates within itself the moral norms around creativity and ownership. The conservatives bristle with defensiveness against the sins of the immigrants; likeminded furries wear furry uniforms and gather regularly to commune and celebrate their ways of life.  Science, academia, etc. is also an elevated community with regular meetings, quite a lot of ritual, it attracts a certain type of person, it has a set of important teachings everyone is expected to learn and follow. The culture around it is often quite toxic, but usually the people who accuse it of being a 'religion' are people who are quite bad at doing science themselves. Community, autism, and shared values around practicing a skill does not a religion make.  I'm not saying you can't criticise the rationality community, but you'll have to do better than 'it's a religion'.”Three-slide carousel of a post by Aella, @Aella_Girl. Slide 1: “ok full thoughts on 'is rationality religion' now that i have a keyboard and time. 1. 'rationality' is a community that sprung up out of a bunch of ppl who read blogs (sequences, hpmor, ssc, etc) and realized that they got along really well with other people who read those same blogs. 2. it ended up with the name 'rationality' community, which many ppl regret but it's too late to change. often ppl say they are 'aspiring' rationalists, partially cause it's dangerous to get your ego tied up in a flattering word, partly cause of general distrust of appeals to credentialism, and partly cause imo rationality is more of a 'process' than it is a point you can hit. 3. it's a community, or a scene, that centered around a shared value that not only can you 'want' to figure out how to think in ways that result in truth more often, but that you can actually put specific, intentional effort into these things. 4. Many of these ideas center around figuring out ways to identify if your thinking is wrong. like, if you think x is going to happen, actually bet money on it, so that you can't dismiss it to yourself if it doesn't happen. You actually have to suffer a consequence if you're wrong. This will help you avoid psychological cope that you might not notice you're doing. 5. There's been tons of meta community discussion around how to avoid failures that come from 'trying to do rationality things' as opposed to 'trying to figure out what's true'. For example, you might think that emotions interfere with figuring out the truth (as e.g. fear or greed does with choosing stocks), so you then go 'i should ignore emotions' and then proceed to miss out on tons of valuable information about yourself and the world. 6. The community contains tons of disagreement about facts about the world, and even the sequences. in the current bay area sequences reading group, one of the default prompts for the readings is 'do you disagree with anything here? if so, what?' and then people debate about it. 7. The community tends to be insular and weird. It attracts pretty autistic, high sat scorers, shape rotator type people. They've developed a vocabulary and norms and their own culture. I've heard a lot of ppl say "I am dissatisfied by the rationality community but I haven't found any other community I like more."  ok - is it a religion?” Slide 2: “No, and thinking it is drastically misunderstands both religion and weird insular cultures.  The thing most people today think of as 'religion' is a faint shadow of an ancient, powerful monster. Religion has raised and destroyed entire civilizations; martyrs have chosen to be burned alive than simply say 'nah u got me i don't believe that.' Is there any belief you hold that you would refuse to say the words 'fine i don't believe it' to stop bad guys from literally burning you to death? Can you imagine what that's like? It has chiseled sacred norms that touch every single part of life, from clothing to marriage to war to death itself. It's a force that has, historically, burrowed deep to the core of human minds and completely transformed them into weapons for its own bidding.  In much of the western world, that beast has died, and cultures walk around wearing gilded remnants of its flesh. "Look, I go to church," they say, but their soul is possessed by nothing, it's filled with osmosis of the secular norms around them. They support gay marriage, or have ever had a divorce, or treat the sacred texts not as sacred but as some inspirational poetry or as a self-help alternative.  And like, sure. Get meaning where you can. Traditions are comforting. But the unitarian universalists or the casual catholics or the cultural jews are entirely unpossessed by the beast.  'Religion' to people in western culture is watered down, and thus is very easy a term to throw at anyone in different clothing. And fine - it doesn't matter the word we use itself as long as everyone is on the same page. We can expand it, why not. But expanding it doesn't actually make change how possessed people are by the Beast.  Rationalists, imo, don't even wear the skin of the religious. There's no sacred text - there's common texts, and it's weird to be unfamiliar with them if you're very integrated in the community - but it's weirder still if you agree with all of them uncritically. There's no single set of beliefs - you can find liberals and conservatives, socialists and libertarians, theists and atheist. The community of course *tends* towards certain sets of beliefs, but it is by no means exclusionary towards conclusions! I personally am a member of the rationalist community, perhaps amongst its most visible members, but I have deeply batshit spiritual beliefs and don't really think reality is made out of molecules.” Slide 3: “Perhaps most importantly, rationality is not spiritual, does not claim to be spiritual. I've seen many a rat debate consciousness at a meetup, but somehow their discussions manage strip the thing of all sparkle.  If there's anything that is central to qualifying as a religion, in my mind, it's something like a systematized source of spirituality. Imo the rationalists are lacking in this, and I would love them to have more of it. I don't think 'rationality' as a practice performs this function at all. It's mostly unrelated.  I *do* think that the rationality community has occasionally attracted people who are using it to provide a certain sort of meaning in their life; something like a desire to be a good person deserving of love, fulfilled by EA-adjacent do-gooding. Or a fear of loss of control, soothed by working hard at making sure your thoughts are Very Correct Or Else. (The community has had a lot of internal discourse about this too). Maybe people from the outside look at rationality and think 'oh, if I were going to get into this, my motivation would be trying to fix a brokenness inside me', and they pattern-match this onto the function of religion?  But I suspect more commonly it's related to the tendency for humans to outgroup the weirdos, especially earnest weirdos, and especially earnest weirdos who have the potential to be powerful in some way (High SAT-score math nerds usually end up with a lot of money).  There's qualities that vaguely reflect some aspects of religion in many nonreligious aspects of human life, because the things that make religion compelling to people are often tied into basic human urges that manifest everywhere, religion or not. The knitting community has drama over patterns, and litigates within itself the moral norms around creativity and ownership. The conservatives bristle with defensiveness against the sins of the immigrants; likeminded furries wear furry uniforms and gather regularly to commune and celebrate their ways of life.  Science, academia, etc. is also an elevated community with regular meetings, quite a lot of ritual, it attracts a certain type of person, it has a set of important teachings everyone is expected to learn and follow. The culture around it is often quite toxic, but usually the people who accuse it of being a 'religion' are people who are quite bad at doing science themselves. Community, autism, and shared values around practicing a skill does not a religion make.  I'm not saying you can't criticise the rationality community, but you'll have to do better than 'it's a religion'.”

The fan fiction that launched a thousand cults is Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality, or “HPMOR”. It is possibly the highest-impact single modern religious text, rivalled only by the Book of Mormon. Its influence may not yet have peaked. It is the holy book of the first great Internet cult.

Allegedly, Effective Altruism and its AI safety efforts are a separate thing and not directly beholden to Yudkowsky. This is very difficult to believe when familiar with the facts. Effective Altruism in the Bay Area has almost perfect overlap with rationalism, and the Effective Altruist AI Safety people in the Bay set the agenda for the rest of Effective Altruism’s safety efforts.

In the Bay Area, Rationalism and Effective Altruism appear to be the same people, at the same events, in the same places, who believe the things said by the same authors and leaders, with only very slight differences between spheres of influence. Yudkowsky called himself both an effective altruist (as late as 2022)5 and a rationalist until a peculiar internal schism. Scott Alexander, the second-most influential writer in the space, has usually called himself both. Often, members of these communities seem to show up in groups working for the same companies and non-profits.

Frequently, Effective Altruists bring up all of Effective Altruism’s other charitable activities and its charming, benevolent members who don’t live in the Bay Area to deflect true criticisms of the Bay Area Effective Altruist community. This effectively makes their other charitable operations and workers shields and fronts for the priorities and behavior of the Effective Altruists in the Bay Area, who are interested almost exclusively in AI.

Two-slide carousel of essay excerpts. Slide 1: “That Is Not How Anything Works  I am, arguably, part of the secret circle of cool effective altruists. I have friends who work for Anthropic and Lightcone Infrastructure. I am at least friendly acquaintances with many writers you’ve heard of (Kelsey Piper, Scott Alexander, Eliezer Yudkowsky). Every article about the Bay Area effective altruism community is contractually obligated to include my friends’ group house and their habit of singing Landsailor before Friday night Shabbat.  You know who all these statements are also true of? My coparent Lindsey, who dropped out of college because he couldn’t hack it, works as an elementary-school teacher, and was my first choice to give the speech at my Solstice about being a failed effective altruist.[1]”  Slide 2: “There Are Better Ways To Achieve Your Goals  I have occasionally amused myself at events by watching people try to suck up to Scott Alexander.[3] If you want Scott Alexander—or any other effective altruist microcelebrity—to think well of you, you need to treat them like a normal person. If you instead act like a supplicant begging for any bits of wisdom that drop from their lips, or vomit up your entire curriculum vitae to show that you’re worthy to participate in this conversation, or pick stupid fights to show that you’re not overawed by them, they will be uncomfortable and not want to spend more time with you than etiquette demands.  In general, the more you try to impress people, the weirder you act, and the less impressed they are by you. You are far more likely to actually impress people if you’re fine with the possibility that they’ll think you’re stupid, annoying, boring, or a jerk. Being really invested in joining the Secret Inner Circle of Cool Effective Altruists makes you worse at befriending people you admire.  Doing effective altruist work has a far lower barrier to entry than getting an effective altruist job. If you want a job in communications or technical AI safety research or global priorities research or investigative journalism, you can literally just do that shit on your own, write up your results, and post it somewhere people will read. Hiring managers at effective-altruism-associated nonprofits really do follow LessWrong and the Effective Altruism Forum, and if your work there is impressive you are far more likely to get a job.”Two-slide carousel of essay excerpts. Slide 1: “That Is Not How Anything Works  I am, arguably, part of the secret circle of cool effective altruists. I have friends who work for Anthropic and Lightcone Infrastructure. I am at least friendly acquaintances with many writers you’ve heard of (Kelsey Piper, Scott Alexander, Eliezer Yudkowsky). Every article about the Bay Area effective altruism community is contractually obligated to include my friends’ group house and their habit of singing Landsailor before Friday night Shabbat.  You know who all these statements are also true of? My coparent Lindsey, who dropped out of college because he couldn’t hack it, works as an elementary-school teacher, and was my first choice to give the speech at my Solstice about being a failed effective altruist.[1]”  Slide 2: “There Are Better Ways To Achieve Your Goals  I have occasionally amused myself at events by watching people try to suck up to Scott Alexander.[3] If you want Scott Alexander—or any other effective altruist microcelebrity—to think well of you, you need to treat them like a normal person. If you instead act like a supplicant begging for any bits of wisdom that drop from their lips, or vomit up your entire curriculum vitae to show that you’re worthy to participate in this conversation, or pick stupid fights to show that you’re not overawed by them, they will be uncomfortable and not want to spend more time with you than etiquette demands.  In general, the more you try to impress people, the weirder you act, and the less impressed they are by you. You are far more likely to actually impress people if you’re fine with the possibility that they’ll think you’re stupid, annoying, boring, or a jerk. Being really invested in joining the Secret Inner Circle of Cool Effective Altruists makes you worse at befriending people you admire.  Doing effective altruist work has a far lower barrier to entry than getting an effective altruist job. If you want a job in communications or technical AI safety research or global priorities research or investigative journalism, you can literally just do that shit on your own, write up your results, and post it somewhere people will read. Hiring managers at effective-altruism-associated nonprofits really do follow LessWrong and the Effective Altruism Forum, and if your work there is impressive you are far more likely to get a job.”

Where there is any separation between the two things in the Bay, “rationalism” is people and things more closely tied to Yudkowsky, and “effective altruism” has had a few institutional centers but is currently focused around Anthropic and its CEO, Dario Amodei. They compete for attention and funding in that space. Yudkowsky’s position is that AI will definitely kill us, and Dario’s position is that AI is ten to twenty-five percent likely to kill us.

Both are saying what justifies giving them and no one else money, labor and attention. Since Yudkowsky is a writer and not a scientist of any kind, he can only claim that he and his organization are important and deserve money and prestige if AI Safety is an unsolvable problem and only advocating against AI matters. Since Dario leads a company that actually makes AI, Dario must claim that “AI doom” is a very large problem that only his company is able to manage.

Yudkowsky, similarly, claimed that his (non-profit) company was the best chance at “saving the human species”, back when AI companies seldom made anything and he could claim to be doing research by simply writing.6 Yudkowsky’s belief system is a successful pitch for investors, donors, volunteers and employees. It is also, politically and doctrinally, a pitch for people to give you total control over them, because if they do not, the world might end. After Yudkowsky refined this pitch modifications of it became the pitch for organizations like OpenAI and Anthropic7. This millenarian ideology appears to have become integral to employee morale and recruiting because so many research staff are believers to one degree or another.

Yudkowsky is not going to stop preaching the gospel of doom because, among other reasons, doing so is the only job he has ever had. He would stand to lose his social position and the roughly $600,000 in income he is paid out of his non-profit if he changed his tune. In general, if doom prophecies are worth money, people will produce more. This system’s purpose is to attract funding and young idealists and to find ways to spend the funding and make use of the young idealists. Historically, rationalists have seemed to encourage many of their young idealists to take up sex work.8

People tend to follow their incentives.

People sometimes deny that Anthropic is an Effective Altruist organization. This may be technically true. Anthropic, the company, can say it is or isn’t whatever it wants to. Anthropic’s founders, senior employees, and investors, however, have numerous ties with Effective Altruism.9

Dario in particular is almost perfectly on-type for a Bay Area Effective Altruist in what he says and how he says it. Dario’s often bizarre, vague, and meandering writing style alone has no real precedent besides LessWrong and its AI-focused spinoff, Alignment Forum. He has been directly involved in Yudkowsky’s community meetups since at least 2008.10 Anthropic’s strategy is very similar to the playbook Yudkowsky laid out, back before the success of deep learning and companies that specialize in deep learning made Yudkowsky’s organization no longer credible as a serious research project.

This same denial of affiliation happens when it comes to the incestuous relationships between all of the other non-profits in the Bay that are meant to be focused on AI risk. They virtually all draw support from a handful of sources of funding and they recruit from the movement. Holden Karnofsky, currently Anthropic, formerly head of Coefficient Giving, was an original board member of Redwood Research and one of the initial champions for METR. Both Redwood and METR hold themselves up as independent organizations. They may be formally independent, but they are aimed at the same goals as the rest of the movement and are broadly ideologically compliant.

Redwood Research in particular seems to be trying to catch the same lightning in a bottle that Yudkowsky had with MIRI while avoiding the sloppiness of his presentation or tying the whole thing to his specific social life. Redwood seems to be laundering essentially the same world view into policy papers that can be cited and pointed to as having come from a serious organization. Their CEO is a former MIRI staffer11, and when they first launched they had a glowing quote from Nate Soares, who has been either Executive Director or President of MIRI since 2015, on their site.12

The people in the video with Bernie Sanders are:

So when they go to get people to talk to a senator we have Yudkowsky, Yudkowsky’s top lieutenant, and two people whose paychecks are from Effective Altruist charities. We will be seeing all of them again later.

Former Biden White House officials Bruce Reed and Ben Buchanan recently wrote an op-ed in which they deny having said that they wanted to ban open-source AI. They claim the first thing they were told in that meeting, by Marc Andreessen, was to watch out for “the sex cult that wants to run America’s AI policy.”

They then deny being Effective Altruists, as follows:

First, Andreessen warned us to watch out for “the sex cult that wants to run America’s AI policy.” This appears to be a reference to instances of polyamory in the effective altruism movement, many of whose adherents believe AI poses existential risks to humanity. Effective altruism is a philosophy we and the Biden administration did not share.

Ben Buchanan worked for two years as Director of the CyberAI Project at Georgetown University’s Center for Security and Emerging Technology (CSET), which appears to have received roughly 90% of its funding from Coefficient Giving (then Open Philanthropy). Since May 2025, four months after the end of the Biden administration, he has been working as a consultant for Anthropic.

Buchanan has a book, published March 2022, in which he discusses the possibility of export controlling GPUs. In October 2022, the Biden administration put in place export restrictions for GPUs.

I read Buchanan’s book13, and I think he is probably not an Effective Altruist because his ideas are not weird enough; but since 2019, his salary has come either from Effective Altruist groups or from the White House. I am reasonably sure he comes by his opinions honestly, and believes in them for normal policy advisor reasons. If he changes his opinions his career is probably in trouble.

In spite of being considered embarrassing by more professional Effective Altruists and now being somewhat starved for cash, Yudkowsky and the organizations most closely tied to him are still, by far, the most influential sources of thinking about AI safety in the Bay and therefore on Earth. Because so many investors and key staff members hold him and his ideas in high regard, it is not clear that major AI companies can directly disown him, even if they want to. Dario, in particular, seems in his public statements to be indirectly trying to carve influence away from Yudkowsky’s faction when he says to be less religious or less obsessed with “doom”. The fact that Dario has to say it indirectly is a hint that saying it directly might cost Dario dearly in those communities, and that he’s aware of that fact.

Because the Bay Area Rationalists and Effective Altruists are so influential in the AI industry, people who are not insiders to this subculture cannot meaningfully influence the research or policy agenda of that industry. This includes many of the people doing actual research. Some current AI Safety research may produce useful knowledge for the future, but its main effect today is to lend scientific legitimacy to people who are not at all doing science, but who are asserting a very particular religious and political agenda.

Yudkowsky’s most viral idea, the one that infects the most people and spreads the farthest, is that AI, if we continue to develop it, will

  1. certainly recursively self-improve (“RSI”), quickly achieving superintelligence (“ASI”),

  2. certainly escape human control,

  3. certainly kill everyone (“paperclip them”, “doom”).

All arguments about AI Safety and AI Alignment are primarily about mitigating this exact scenario under his exact terms. Significant modification is relatively rare. Where lower probabilities of doom than “certain” are given, people seem to still generally worry exclusively about Yudkowsky’s rough scenario: a sudden, unpredictable sequence of 1) superintelligence, 2) immediate escape from control, and 3) the death of all humans on Earth. This is always, implicitly, what "safety" and "alignment" are about.

These ideas occasionally veer into the belief that AI is magic. When presented as serious science and policy, this sort of thing is omitted.

Screenshot of a message signed by Eliezer S. Yudkowsky. Quoted text at the top: “> well, i get the spirit of the message, but the literal > implications are really pushing it. after all, the confined seed is not > _literally_ omnipotent; there will still be things it can not do -- and i > would guess transmitting elf signals while off web and without a hardware > transmitter would be one of those things.” Response: “One of the things you can't rule out - and I mean this seriously - is "magic". Magic plain and simple. Running a particular sequence of instructions through the CPU so that a certain transistor turns on and off in a certain sequence and modulates the quantum cheat codes of the Universe. Or something. Dealing with a real superintelligence, it can't be ruled out. It obviously can't be relied on, but it can't be ruled out. Trying to oppose or even constrain a superintelligence is a fool's game. Get It Right The First Time. -- -- -- -- Eliezer S. Yudkowsky http://intelligence.org/ Research Fellow, Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence”

Ordinarily, the play here would be to disown this and other concrete statements of his about AI doom as irrelevant. Of course we aren’t just repeating Yudkowsky! We are smart, normal people who believe normal things for normal reasons. Compare it, however, to AI 2027, allegedly a serious policy document, written by Daniel Kokotajlo and Scott Alexander, presenting its doom scenario.

Excerpt from AI 2027: “For about three months, Consensus-1 expands around humans, tiling the prairies and icecaps with factories and solar panels. Eventually it finds the remaining humans too much of an impediment: in mid-2030, the AI releases a dozen quiet-spreading biological weapons in major cities, lets them silently infect almost everyone, then triggers them with a chemical spray. Most are dead within hours; the few survivors (e.g. preppers in bunkers, sailors on submarines) are mopped up by drones. Robots scan the victims’ brains, placing copies in memory for future study or revival.[31] The new decade dawns with Consensus-1’s robot servitors spreading throughout the solar system. By 2035, trillions of tons of planetary material have been launched into space and turned into rings of satellites orbiting the sun.[32] The surface of the Earth has been reshaped into Agent-4’s version of utopia: datacenters, laboratories, particle colliders, and many other wondrous constructions doing enormously successful and impressive research. There are even engineered human-like creatures (to humans what corgis are to wolves) sitting in office-like environments all day viewing readouts of what’s going on and excitedly approving of everything, since that satisfies some of Agent-4’s drives.[33] Genomes and (when appropriate) brain scans of all animals and plants, including humans, sit in a memory bank somewhere, sole surviving artifacts of an earlier era. It is four light years to Alpha Centauri; twenty-five thousand to the galactic edge; and there are compelling theoretical reasons to expect no aliens for another fifty million light years beyond that. Earth-born civilization has a glorious future ahead of it—but not with us.”

This is a genre of science fiction that has a doomsday cult built around it. There are only slight modifications to the basic belief system. Somehow, maybe by just throwing money at it, taking these ideas seriously has been rendered prestigious or at least not too humiliating, such that Kokotajlo, credited on the above, gets to advise Bernie Sanders. JD Vance was asked about this piece by Ross Douthat at the New York Times, and said he had read it. (In my opinion, on close reading AI 2027’s primary intended audience was clearly JD Vance.)

Essentially all of AI safety is rationalizations over Eliezer Yudkowsky’s ideas and there is no other substance to it. It is smokescreens, and Eliezer Yudkowsky.

Two-slide carousel of X posts. Slide 1, Eliezer Yudkowsky, @ESYudkowsky: “Much of this is false-speaking as always with Perry, but this in particular: > They say, instead, that we need to carefully develop ‘alignment’ technologies that must be proven to be absolutely perfect in advance of permitting more development — an idea that defies the experience gained from all engineering practice in human history. Reality: I think that given the vast distance between the modern-day bureaucracy trying to handle this, and the ways of thinking required to actually survive trying to create a superintelligence, the first group permitted to try their hand at this should be humans augmented to the point where they are no longer idiots -- augmented humans so intelligent that they have stopped being bloody idiots like the rest of us, so intelligent they have stopped hoping for clever ideas to work that won't actually work. That's the level of intelligence needed to build something smarter than yourself and survive the experience. No mention of ‘proof’ is made in this proposal, nor lack of experimentation. The aforesaid human augments will perhaps try some experiments on the occasions where they can figure out a safe experiment that tells them something they don't already know and is relevant to superintelligence. The current setup is simply not competent to do that safely or validly. Their” [cut off] Slide 2, @repligate: “there's also the fact after you ‘Pause’ who decides when youre allowed to do AI development again? who decides whether the important problems have been solved? where do the selection effects and filters come from? some committee of armchair philosophers or politicians, no longer selected for those who are smart enough to have found the secrets of Intelligence in the first place? Eliezer Yudkowsky himself once said...” Quoted post by Dwarkesh Patel, @dwarkesh_sp: “Since this post cites me, I want to clarify that I think pausing right now would increase the risk of AI takeover. It might be important to pause at some point. But you should have a clear story for *why* you're pausing. Pause to do what?...” Eliezer Yudkowsky, @allTheYud, Sep 3, 2026: “Make smarter humans. Do not let them have any GPUs either. When they're smart enough to build it on one CPU, you will have actually tested for ‘finding the secrets of intelligence’ rather than doing alchemy with GPUs.”Two-slide carousel of X posts. Slide 1, Eliezer Yudkowsky, @ESYudkowsky: “Much of this is false-speaking as always with Perry, but this in particular: > They say, instead, that we need to carefully develop ‘alignment’ technologies that must be proven to be absolutely perfect in advance of permitting more development — an idea that defies the experience gained from all engineering practice in human history. Reality: I think that given the vast distance between the modern-day bureaucracy trying to handle this, and the ways of thinking required to actually survive trying to create a superintelligence, the first group permitted to try their hand at this should be humans augmented to the point where they are no longer idiots -- augmented humans so intelligent that they have stopped being bloody idiots like the rest of us, so intelligent they have stopped hoping for clever ideas to work that won't actually work. That's the level of intelligence needed to build something smarter than yourself and survive the experience. No mention of ‘proof’ is made in this proposal, nor lack of experimentation. The aforesaid human augments will perhaps try some experiments on the occasions where they can figure out a safe experiment that tells them something they don't already know and is relevant to superintelligence. The current setup is simply not competent to do that safely or validly. Their” [cut off] Slide 2, @repligate: “there's also the fact after you ‘Pause’ who decides when youre allowed to do AI development again? who decides whether the important problems have been solved? where do the selection effects and filters come from? some committee of armchair philosophers or politicians, no longer selected for those who are smart enough to have found the secrets of Intelligence in the first place? Eliezer Yudkowsky himself once said...” Quoted post by Dwarkesh Patel, @dwarkesh_sp: “Since this post cites me, I want to clarify that I think pausing right now would increase the risk of AI takeover. It might be important to pause at some point. But you should have a clear story for *why* you're pausing. Pause to do what?...” Eliezer Yudkowsky, @allTheYud, Sep 3, 2026: “Make smarter humans. Do not let them have any GPUs either. When they're smart enough to build it on one CPU, you will have actually tested for ‘finding the secrets of intelligence’ rather than doing alchemy with GPUs.”

This is his actual plan: to halt all AI research, all across the Earth, and instead do genetic engineering eugenics for a generation. Pause AI, stop AI, slowdown, pacing the frontier, they are all smokescreens, rationalizations, or ways of watering down this plan. This is why there is never any real “after we pause”, or “we will unpause when”; this is the only actual plan, and the public front for the plan cannot say this because it is too stupid and too offensive to be spoken in public, except by Yudkowsky himself, who never stops talking and who is too ridiculous for anyone on the outside of Effective Altruism to believe that everyone listens to him.

Anyone who thinks this is not the plan is not in on the plan, or is part of some faction that simply has no real plan. If this describes you and you didn’t know that, I am sorry that this is how you found out.

He has long since deleted this post demonstrating what his idea of an acceptable outcome is; this is ordinarily implied and not stated.

X exchange. Sarah Shoker, @SarahShoker, replying to @ESYudkowsky and @Miles_Brundage: “I disagree that you’ve mentioned what it takes to live; you’ve gestured at nuclear risk. US military ops use a collateral damage estimate that they then compare to achievable military gains before making a decision to strike. How many people are allowed to die to prevent AGI?” Eliezer Yudkowsky, @ESYudkowsky, Mar 31, 2023: “There should be enough survivors on Earth in close contact to form a viable reproductive population, with room to spare, and they should have a sustainable food supply. So long as that's true, there's still a chance of reaching the stars someday.”

This industry approaches regulation in this way because it has, at its core, a millenarian death cult that worships and fears AI, believes AI will end the world, feels compelled to create AI, and at least somewhat wants to destroy AI as an entire field.

I will repeat: I do not think that these people should be making policy. I would vastly prefer if this were merely some insane Bay Area drama that I could ignore, but the still-growing success and importance of the companies founded by or employing this group of people has made this a very public national and international concern.

The paperclip maximizer is a thought experiment from 2003 and of very little relevance at all. People are perpetually striving to find evidence for this theory because they already believe it is true, and take pains to interpret any research or security development in AI as evidence for this exact doom coming to pass. As things happen which contradict this scenario, as often they do, they are often not understood because they do not match the prophecy. Alternative explanations are so unthinkable that many people cannot even be told.

Doom seems to be the most infectious idea here because it activates the same neurosis that every apocalyptic or millenarian cult does. The world is going to end, and only I and my special group of people in the know can maybe stop it.

You can argue with them in any way you like but it barely matters. It's not, mostly, something people believe for good reasons, and they will simply go back to complaining about the apocalypse as soon as you stop paying attention. There are enough of them that the belief is self-reinforcing; they can arrange their lives such that they essentially never talk to anyone who is not a believer.

Harry Potter fan fiction, of course, is especially popular with children, and many people have made this their belief system since they were teenagers.

Since recruitment largely happens on the internet, people are widely dispersed. Where they are gathered in person, it is mostly in various communes in Berkeley, California. They call their communes "group houses", maybe to make it sound less cultish. Most of the details of this are what you expect from "a commune in Berkeley".

Everyone attends the same events, everyone lives in the same group homes, everyone venerates the same few authors, everyone is very worried about AI doom, polyamory seems to be extremely popular, and more than a few appear to be on psychedelic drugs. They are all very contrarian together, and they are usually contrarian about the exact same things.

Lots and lots of them, currently, work at AI companies and non-profits. The safety, red team and alignment teams seem especially afflicted, because that's the area you go into to worry about and try to work against AI doom, which you are sure is at least medium likely. Other members will seek work in finance, because Effective Altruism, by creed, says you should seek more money so you can give more to charity. Those most concerned with AI risk will tend to almost exclusively give to AI charities and not any other Effective Altruist concern.

As a whole, this is a religious movement. Not everyone takes marching orders; they’re united by an idea, not any particular structure. The vast network of Effective Altruists around the world working on other charitable concerns is basically irrelevant to AI Safety. There are core people who mostly live and attend events together, and there are many many more who are less directly involved, who are part of the wider movement, and who are primarily its recruiting funnel, funding, and labor base.

Any time you get more than a few people who are deeply concerned with AI doom together, it seems like their natural form of organization looks like a cult; the movement as a whole, internationally, is less of a cult than it is a cult factory. Some of these cults have gone very badly. One of them is the Zizians.

That rationalists form cults constantly has been previously examined. There are many causative factors, but the core one is just that the entire thing is, in and of itself, a millenarian doomsday cult. If you believe you’re saving the world, it justifies anything; you cannot go against the cause for any reason. This gives leaders, whether official or unofficial, immense power over their members.

Forming a separate cult is also how you carve off influence and ultimately power for yourself, separate from the wider movement. This tends to mean that people try to do it more. All of these power struggles make the details of all of this extremely noisy, chaotic, and difficult to explain.

When you cut through all the distractions, chaos, and power struggles, San Francisco Rationalism is effectively the inner circle of San Francisco Effective Altruism, and San Francisco Effective Altruism is effectively the inner circle of Effective Altruism globally. Power and especially intellectual leadership flow almost entirely outwards from SF Rationalism to SF Effective Altruism to Effective Altruism’s global AI safety efforts. Everything else about Effective Altruism is effectively a front.

All of this has been an open secret for years. Everyone knows. Everyone knows if they say anything it will be ignored. I am shocked that I have drawn as much attention to the problem as I have; so let me try to get everything that seems to be very important into the record.

What I am hoping to convey is that Rationalism and Effective Altruism are not many small things, they are one big thing, tied together through ideology, funding, and key people.

Bay Area rationalists and effective altruists do not document their own history because it is disgraceful. Only their enemies deliberately keep records of what they have done and are doing.

They do write constantly, but they do this mostly as a social activity. They have been writing essays, chattering, bragging, or engaging in some kind of drama constantly for the last fifteen years.

So you really just have to read a lot to put this together. Everything I am saying, to the best of my knowledge, is true, and I believe the vast majority can be established entirely by reviewing the public record. I am just connecting the dots by putting one straight line through them.

In 1996, a 17-year-old Eliezer Yudkowsky joins Usenet and the Extropians mailing list. His more notable influences are Drexler’s book on nanotechnology, Kurzweil’s book on AI, and Nick Bostrom, who frequents the Extropians mailing list. (Usenet was still largely full of academics). In 1998, Nick Bostrom argues that a superintelligent AI might not necessarily be good or friendly, which, along with many of Bostrom’s other ideas, will later become core to Yudkowsky.

In the year 2000, Yudkowsky founds the Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence, SIAI, later renamed to the Machine Intelligence Research Institute, MIRI. This appears to have started as a fake-it-til-you-make-it sort of thing, and it doesn’t pick up until he gets sponsored by Peter Thiel. Peter Thiel will be his largest sponsor until about 2015 or 2016. Now in 2026, Thiel has long since cut all ties, called this scene a “burning man camp” and “Luddite”, and called Yudkowsky the Antichrist.14

Jeffrey Epstein gave them fifty thousand dollars in 2009. One of MIRI’s former associates, Ben Goertzel, appears to have solicited a separate $2,000 donation from Epstein that went in under his name in that year, also. (Confirmed separately on his blog). One of the former presidents of MIRI is mentioned in Jeffrey Epstein’s emails15, which pass on thanks for a visit to the island. (MIRI is documented as turning down his money in 2016 when he was much more notorious, if you want to figure out what to make of their statements about that.)

I considered putting all this in a footnote because of how unimportant Jeffrey Epstein’s appearance here is in the context of everything else. He is the Forrest Gump of evil shit. Of course he was here.

Eliezer Yudkowsky spends some time before 2009 blogging, and then contracts out setting up LessWrong as a customized version of Reddit’s code. In 2009, he bundles his last year or two of blog posts and puts them all on the newly made LessWrong, where they come to be called The Sequences. Much later, in 2015, they are published as Rationality: From AI to Zombies. This is a series of essays about science and epistemology, most of them pretty closely related to books and ideas then in the zeitgeist but with both a very distinctly transhumanist and distinctly AI Doom thesis. (So, “conquer death with technology” and “if we do technology wrong, we are all going to die”.) It is written in such a way that it also works as, effectively, a self-help book about how to be better at thinking. This will later be something like the Rationalist Old Testament.

From 2010 to 2015, he writes HPMOR, and his audience becomes much larger, and this becomes a well-defined scene and people invested in the movement begin relocating to the Bay Area.

In 2010, Roko Mijic invents Roko’s Basilisk, which is most easily explained as the invention of Rationalist Pascal’s Wager, Rationalist Satan and Rationalist Hell, where those who fail to evangelize and help bring about the eschaton are sent. This will seem, over time, to drive the rationalists who are the most susceptible to religious mania and obsession insane.16 Yudkowsky disowns the Basilisk immediately and tries to ban discussion of it from LessWrong, which makes it more popular.

At least as late as 2013, Yudkowsky is still advocating that we should make AI as long as we could do it safely.17 He is under the impression that his non-profit, MIRI, might be able to make “Friendly AI”, that is, one that does not kill everyone, ushers in the singularity and makes them immortal.

The Center for Applied Rationality, or CFAR, is founded in 2011 and offers classes. You essentially pay money for self-help, but it is primarily a recruiting front for MIRI, Yudkowsky’s actual operation. It also seems to function as a more-official avenue for community management, and its newsletters describe it coordinating co-housing meetings and mediating alumni disputes.

They start a bunch of children’s camps, math camps, and study programs that are mostly still around. SPARC was the earliest, beginning in 2012, and takes high school students. All of its graduates from then will be adults now. Probably a bunch of them live in the Bay and work on AI safety.

Moving to the Bay Area worked for some people extremely well, and for others extremely badly. Much of this happened bottom-up, with members organizing things themselves, but in some specific cases you can tell who exactly is responsible for what.

I think of this as a flywheel, where the energy that keeps it moving is, fundamentally, their talent and their raw zeal for the cause. People show up, and they believe in what they’re doing, and they give what they can.

It is the best professional network on Earth. It is like being in the most elite fraternity, if it were unisex and had many chapters in San Francisco specifically. If you have skills or can acquire them, you can have a fantastic job very quickly. There are a good number of coding bootcamps that will train you for a job and then place you in one with no money up front.18 Since Peter Thiel is most of their funding at the time, many of the connections are to companies he is invested in, but they have connections to nearly every company in Silicon Valley.

Those people offer their work or their salaries to the cause.

Next tier down are people who can’t or don’t really use the opportunity that much, but who either end up doing something else or who end up doing work at the various rationalist non-profits. These people are fine, probably; CFAR probably takes some of their money from them and they maybe could be doing better if they hadn’t spontaneously relocated to an extremely expensive city. Hopefully they really enjoy the scene.

Your bottom tier are people who are very young, are not particularly skilled, who do not fit in enough, or who otherwise do not thrive in the Bay’s job and housing market. Many of them are runaways, even those that aren’t are often still teenagers, many of them have mental health problems. Younger members who show up in person are especially likely to be trans, at least in part because trans teenagers are prone to getting thrown out of their houses. Generally, the younger and more idealistic you are when you land in the Bay, the less likely you are to thrive.19 They may be employed as some kind of household help or as assistants for other people in the community.

All of this comes down to pulling more energy into the wheel, and you can trade each thing off against the other.

Any individual person or organization is really just bleeding energy off of the wheel. OpenAI, Anthropic, God knows how many smaller companies? They’re just pulling energy from this mass of eager, smart people that are already there. Successful ventures inject more funding and provide more connections to the movement, powering another turn of the wheel.

Recognizable cults, in contrast, are more like pure parasites.

This period sees Yudkowsky finish HPMOR and stop publishing things people actually want to read, which leaves the community without a focus. As the most active and well-liked author still in the space, Scott Alexander becomes something like the Second Prophet of Rationalism. (People say these things as jokes sometimes, but this is pretty much accurate.) It seems to be much less focused leadership, though, and to some degree things start to drift.

Also in 2015, OpenAI is founded. This makes Google very sad because OpenAI exists to compete with Google on AI, and Yudkowsky knows and likes the Google guys, and he pronounces that the world is for sure going to end now20, which he has continued doing for the last eleven years.

Oh, just one more thing. A former MIRI employee puts up a web site in late 2014 alleging that MIRI does no meaningful research and is primarily busy with legal damage control for distasteful and unlawful conduct, which it details in some depth. MIRI will ultimately pay him something like $30,000 to go away and take down his site with those allegations.21

Rolling Stone, in 2025, pokes into this when writing a story about the Zizians.

The first set of allegations have been investigated and deemed baseless. They stem from a report filed by a onetime MIRI employee named Louie Helm who claimed a teenager was “being exploited” by a group of men, including Yudkowsky, who ran a local youth camp — referring to the Summer Program for Applied Rationality and Cognition, hosted by CFAR.

According to the sealed police report obtained by Rolling Stone, Helm accused Yudkowsky of having a sexual relationship with a then-18-year-old that began at least two and half years prior.

Officers were dispatched to Yudkowsky’s home, which, at the time, he shared with the 18-year-old in question. The “alleged victim,” officers wrote in the report, stressed that they “lived in a happy and safe environment.” That person later transitioned; today, he lives with his wife, whom he met in Berkeley’s Rationalist scene, and their two young children. When I spoke to him earlier this year, he told me he rejects the notion that he was exploited by anyone other than Helm, the disgruntled employee, whom he felt used him as ammunition against Yudkowsky and MIRI. “I was expedient,” he says.

Yudkowsky posted about 2000 words on twitter denying the allegation ahead of the Rolling Stone story coming out, and it seems to have blown over. Effective Altruists and Rationalists, like squid, spray ink when threatened.

Possibly because it needs someone more comfortable handling delicate and complex legal matters, in 2015 MIRI changes leadership. Nate Soares becomes Executive Director of MIRI; his title has since shifted to President, but under one title or another he seems to have been Yudkowsky’s right hand ever since.

I have no firsthand knowledge of this and know zero people involved so far as I am aware. I can only piece together what happened here from public records.22

Brent Dill was kicked out of the rationalist community for allegedly being very abusive to several girlfriends, and thereafter left San Francisco, apparently for lack of available housing.

There are several key details that made the allegations especially grim:

  1. He was significantly older.

  2. He allegedly exploited the victims’ financial and housing situations.

  3. He allegedly used BDSM concepts to justify doing things that are well over the line into abuse.

  4. It was alleged that he was using MDMA to control his partners. MDMA is sometimes used for treating PTSD, and its use for this purpose was not unknown among the rationalists.

  5. To quote CFAR: “Of the interactions CFAR had with Brent, we consider the decision to let him assist at ESPR—a program we helped run for high school students—to have been particularly unwise.”

  6. The issue was previously brought to CFAR’s Alumni Community Disputes Council, which initially did nothing about it, and which was disbanded in the aftermath of these events.

CFAR ultimately puts out this much more detailed apology, which few seem to have found very credible.

Two-slide carousel of CFAR’s statement about Brent Dill. Slide 1: “Until these abuse allegations were made public, most of our staff were wholly unaware of them, and all of us were unaware of substantial portions of them. Nevertheless, we believe we had sufficient evidence long beforehand to notice that Brent might be harmful, and that even accounting for hindsight bias, our failure to investigate this hypothesis explicitly was a mistake. As a result, we allowed Brent to attend and assist at several CFAR events, which we now suspect afforded him social legitimacy and caused significant harm in expectation.[1] CFAR messed up badly here. We have a responsibility to ensure that the events we host don’t pose undue risk to our attendees, and in this case we failed at that responsibility. What follows is a detailed account of the main mistakes we think we made regarding Brent. Some community members advised us against publicly releasing this letter when we sent them a draft, out of concern that its length and detail would imply CFAR felt it was largely responsible for the harm caused by Brent. We do not believe this is the case. But we do think our actions caused significant harm in expectation, and that the mistakes we made were both serious and preventable. It is our hope that by clearly and” [cut off] Slide 2: “Lack of Focus on Safety As event organizers, we have a responsibility to help keep our attendees safe. Unfortunately, we think that until recently, we did not spend enough time figuring out how to detect and protect against potential bad actors. For the most part, we did not think of this as a core part of our job—we spent lots of time improving our workshop, curriculum, and internal operations, but little time on vetting our volunteers or guests. Going forward we will err more on the side of caution when choosing whom to invite to workshops. We have also adopted new policies to help ensure that it’s socially and logistically easier for our staff to veto potential invitations and to register any concerns that may arise. Insufficient Institutional Safeguards A number of our staff feel that they were manipulated by Brent. In saying this, we do not mean to shift blame away from ourselves—if anything, we think the staff of an organization which exists to promote epistemic integrity should be held to an especially high bar on such matters. But our impression, unfortunately, is that Brent spent considerable effort trying to manipulate CFAR staff in particular—e.g. into ignoring their gut-level reactions to his manipulative conversational moves—and that” [cut off]Two-slide carousel of CFAR’s statement about Brent Dill. Slide 1: “Until these abuse allegations were made public, most of our staff were wholly unaware of them, and all of us were unaware of substantial portions of them. Nevertheless, we believe we had sufficient evidence long beforehand to notice that Brent might be harmful, and that even accounting for hindsight bias, our failure to investigate this hypothesis explicitly was a mistake. As a result, we allowed Brent to attend and assist at several CFAR events, which we now suspect afforded him social legitimacy and caused significant harm in expectation.[1] CFAR messed up badly here. We have a responsibility to ensure that the events we host don’t pose undue risk to our attendees, and in this case we failed at that responsibility. What follows is a detailed account of the main mistakes we think we made regarding Brent. Some community members advised us against publicly releasing this letter when we sent them a draft, out of concern that its length and detail would imply CFAR felt it was largely responsible for the harm caused by Brent. We do not believe this is the case. But we do think our actions caused significant harm in expectation, and that the mistakes we made were both serious and preventable. It is our hope that by clearly and” [cut off] Slide 2: “Lack of Focus on Safety As event organizers, we have a responsibility to help keep our attendees safe. Unfortunately, we think that until recently, we did not spend enough time figuring out how to detect and protect against potential bad actors. For the most part, we did not think of this as a core part of our job—we spent lots of time improving our workshop, curriculum, and internal operations, but little time on vetting our volunteers or guests. Going forward we will err more on the side of caution when choosing whom to invite to workshops. We have also adopted new policies to help ensure that it’s socially and logistically easier for our staff to veto potential invitations and to register any concerns that may arise. Insufficient Institutional Safeguards A number of our staff feel that they were manipulated by Brent. In saying this, we do not mean to shift blame away from ourselves—if anything, we think the staff of an organization which exists to promote epistemic integrity should be held to an especially high bar on such matters. But our impression, unfortunately, is that Brent spent considerable effort trying to manipulate CFAR staff in particular—e.g. into ignoring their gut-level reactions to his manipulative conversational moves—and that” [cut off]

In general the community takes this pretty hard, and to its credit largely seems to blame CFAR. Between this and other scandals, demand for classes at CFAR appears to fall, and it stops offering classes in 2020. CFAR started again November 2025, and you can currently sign up for a four-day applied rationality workshop if you can get past the waitlist.

CFAR webpage screenshot: “Applied Rationality Workshops Upcoming Workshops Information on all upcoming 4-day workshops September 30 - October 4, 2026 San Francisco Bay Area [At capacity - accepting waitlist applications] APPLY FOR A WORKSHOP NOW”

Brent Dill’s ouster also seems to have played a part in convincing a rationalist named Ziz, for whom the Zizians were named, that the earlier allegations from Louie Helm were true. She was already mostly an outcast from the rationalists, and had effectively thrown her career away to work for people who did not want her.

She did what any deeply devoted rationalist would about this, which is to blog a lot about a method of becoming some kind of rationalist ubermensch and then go completely insane. About a year later is the first major Zizian incident, where a number of Zizians are arrested while protesting a CFAR event. Another rationalist cult called Leverage implodes in 2019, which I mention because it was a big deal at the time and because the article is a fascinating read.

Lighthaven used to be the Rose Garden Inn in Berkeley. It has four main buildings, abundant outdoor space, and it’s a beautiful place.

Exterior photograph of Lighthaven, formerly the Rose Garden Inn: a pink and cream Tudor-style building with a stone ground floor, surrounded by garden paths, plants, trees, and small statues. It looks like a Kinkade painting.

Lighthaven was originally purchased with money wired to CFAR from Sam Bankman-Fried’s company, FTX, as it was collapsing.23 This was later found to be fraudulent: Bankman-Fried and his employees looted the company because they knew it was dying and sent as much cash as they could to their friends and to causes they believed in.

One of those causes was that the Bay Area Rationalist and Effective Altruist community should have its own permanent conference center. Some, but not all, of the money that FTX sent to buy Lighthaven was later returned.

I am expected to believe that Sam Bankman-Fried was not a true believer. I am expected to believe that he was not central to Effective Altruism. I am expected to believe that committing ten billion dollars of fraud was not in accordance with the values of Effective Altruism.

This is all bullshit. He was giving what he could to the cause. Now he is being a good soldier and disowning the cause to protect it, and he is doing his twenty-five years. I respect it. It is the only respectable thing about him.

The part of the FTX empire that handled its weird charitable donations was called FTX Future Fund. Donations to CFAR would naturally have been within this organization’s responsibilities. These donations were made between March 3, 2022 and Oct 3, 2022. The entire team resigned on November 10th, professing to be shocked and immensely saddened to learn of then-recent events involving the collapse of the FTX exchange.

These individuals are:

The rationalists didn’t lose the building when the FTX money was clawed back from them because Jaan Tallinn, the Skype billionaire, let them take a loan from him against his future donations.24

In 2022 they spun out a separate organization from CFAR called Lightcone Infrastructure, which has exactly two responsibilities: managing Lighthaven, and running LessWrong. As far as Rationalist and Effective Altruist are ever separate things in the Bay, Lighthaven is Rationalist.

Lighthaven’s initial funding, however, was Effective Altruist, and most of the events held there are Effective Altruist.

Here is a photo from Lighthaven’s page, of the outdoor area outside of a building called Darwin Den:

Lighthaven’s outdoor courtyard beside Darwin Den, with a white building and exterior stairs, a gazebo, wicker sofas, artificial turf, triangular shade sails, and string lights.

This is from the careers page of METR:

Photograph from METR’s careers page showing people seated in a circle on outdoor sofas and the lawn beneath shade sails, beside a wooden pergola and a dome-shaped structure.

Here is the listing of Lightcone’s employees, officers, and directors from their 2025 tax filing:

Table titled “Compensation.” Columns: “Key Employees and Officers”; “Compensation”; “Related”; “Other.” Rows, in that order: Robert Mushkatblat (Software Engineer): $332,254; $0; $10,085. Ruben Bloom (Software Engineer): $211,750; $0; $27,693. Rafe Kennedy (Chief Operating Officer): $201,667; $0; $10,433. James Babcock (Software Engineer): $190,000; $0; $10,834. Ronny Fernandez (Campus Generalist): $157,750; $0; $9,555. Oliver Habryka (Executive Director): $150,000; $0; $8,926. Miranda Dixon-luinenburg (Finance Lead): $148,000; $0; $0. Raymond Arnold (Software Engineer): $134,209; $0; $9,938. Matthew Gray (Director): $0; $0; $0. Daniel Kokotajlo (Director): $0; $0; $0.

Notice Daniel Kokotajlo, one of Bernie’s recent advisors. Remember Ronny Fernandez, whom we will come back to later.

Here are the public events listed on Lighthaven’s calendar in the last year. Virtually all of them are Effective Altruist events funded by Effective Altruist non-profits and donors.

  • EAGxBerkeley

  • Reproductive Frontiers Summit

  • MATS program

  • The Curve2526

  • ILIAD Conference

  • Eleos Conference

  • Manifest

  • Progress Conference

  • The Delight Nexus

  • Memoria

  • LBF Microsurgery

  • FLF Demo Day

  • Inkhaven Residency

  • Solstice Season

  • Solstice Saturday

  • Vision Weekend USA

  • Trading Bootcamp

  • PYOL

  • Vitalist Bay

  • MC0001

  • LessOnline

  • Summer Camp

  • FOO Camp

  • Out of This Box screening

  • Context Week

Aella is a sex worker, former camgirl, and person who is very good at the internet. She is also the on-again, off-again girlfriend of the President of MIRI, Nate Soares. She thrives on shock reactions, and seems unique so far in history for having used the social camouflage of being edgy on the internet to get away with as much as she has while operating almost completely in the open. Everything she does seems to be just up to the line, and there is always some defense that sort of makes sense at the time. It is incredible that she is this good at controlling and navigating the information environment. She is probably the only person in history so far to leverage social media in the way that she does.

As the scene has spiralled and become more bizarre, she has come to seem like a major cultural leader, if not the main cultural leader of rationalism. I see her posts more, she headlines their Woodstock (there’s a rationalist woodstock! it is called vibecamp), and of course she organizes many of their orgies, which appear to be the social glue holding a lot of this together.

One of the interesting things about cults is that the men are usually the leaders, figureheads, thinkers, and the public face of the organization, but often the actual getting-things-done part of the cult and arguably the real leadership that matters is done mostly by women. Jim Jones made almost none of the preparations for the Jonestown suicide. His lieutenants, who were mostly women, ordered and prepared all the kool-aid and all the cyanide.

Aella has a uniquely well-suited background for this role. She is the daughter of an abusive Calvinist preacher, and she escaped from that into atheism, LSD, social media and sex work. She has in turn made herself the primary sexual partner of Nate Soares, the president of MIRI. It is an almost perfectly Berkeley way of both inverting and becoming who she was raised to be.

She is good at giving the cause a voice. She has donated enough money to Lighthaven to have her name on a plaque27, and to have walk-in privileges whenever she likes. Yudkowsky likes her, promotes her, legitimizes her internet sex surveys as social science, and puts her into the acknowledgements of his books.

X thread screenshot. Aella (@Aella_Girl), Sep 9: “When I first started thinking about ai-risk, i was like 'ok, these arguments seem pretty good. But let me hear the arguments from the opposing side'. To my gradually growing horror, i realized almost all the opposing side arguments were mostly just social pressure or mockery.” Aella, Sep 9: “Occasionally I would hear object-level arguments but they were almost always like, level 1 or 2 objections that had been thought about extremely extensively by the people specializing in the field, and I did not find them convincing at all.” Boško Stupar (@boskicthebrain): “There is a book for you with some real arguments: goodreads.com/book/show/2286...” Goodreads preview: “If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies: Why Superhuman AI W...” and “"May prove to be the most important book of our time.”—...” The cropped book cover reads “BUILDS IT, EVERYONE DIES,” “WHY SUPERHUMAN AI WOULD KILL US ALL,” and “ELIEZER YUDKOWSKY &” [cut off]. Aella, replying to @boskicthebrain: “I am in the acknowledgements” Sep 11, 2026 · 6:34 PM UTC.

Here she is talking about the overlap between AI safety and polyamory in the Bay. It is worth reproducing her post in full: “Yeah if you count casual relationships as connections, the ai safety community in the bay is probably a single polycule”

X thread screenshot. Justine Moore, 10 Jan 25: “Always fun to try to explain the significant overlap between AI safety and polyamory to a newcomer in SF 🫠” Ben Holfeld, 10 Jan 25: “Wait what is the overlap there” Justine Moore, 10 Jan 25: “Venn diagram is almost a circle” Aella (@Aella_Girl): “Yeah if you count casual relationships as connections, the ai safety community in the bay is probably a single polycule” 1:52 AM · 11 Jan 25.

Here’s her opinion of a thread I wrote on this same subject earlier.

X post by Aella (@Aella_Girl): “getting pretty sick of people saying im a sex trafficking sex cultist. I've never trafficked anyone (why is that even a rumor??), I haven't received payment for other people's sex work, all I've done is post a guide on how to get into escorting safely for those who are interested (complete with a section on the downsides and risks), and also thrown orgies (that we turn away a huge amount of people from, and where the majority of attendees are not in AI-related stuff). People are just desperate for a salacious story, but jfc”

It’s good to know that fewer than 50% of attendees for one of her hosted orgies work in AI-related stuff.

She denies being engaged in “sex trafficking”.28

There are documented cases of cults using sex for recruitment and ideological control. Weird sex and weird power dynamics around sex are very common in cults. They are, of course, common in this one, too.

You remember Jacob Coxon? The “whistleblower” who resigned from Anthropic, and then “whistleblew” that all the things Anthropic already preaches are true? We had him at the beginning of this post, giving Ed Zitron a long explanation about how much he respects rationalists.

Here’s Aella, three days before he went public, promising to throw whoever it is a “reverse gangbang” if they will quit from a lab and whistleblow. (People keep asking me what a reverse gangbang is: one man, many women).

X post by Aella (@Aella_Girl), Sep 5: “I will throw you reverse gangbang” Quoted post by Brangus (@RatOrthodox), Sep 5: “wtf are we doing here guys? I will throw a party for any OpenAI employee who publicly resigns, whistleblows, and calls for a criminal investigation. I throw very good parties. x.com/OpenAI/status/...”

Here she is on the day of:

X thread screenshot. Jacob Coxon (@hilbertspaess), Sep 8: “I resigned from Anthropic today. I spent the last three years doing pretraining research at both OpenAI and Anthropic. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.” Aella (@Aella_Girl): “so uhhh” 5:34 PM · Sep 8, 2026.

I am supposed to believe this is a coincidence, because I am supposed to believe that everything is a coincidence.

Here we have what she calls her finest piece of work, a now-infamous Sankey diagram documenting the process for scheduling a gangbang on her birthday. She seems to thank and credit Nate Soares as the primary organizer here, and several other sources seem to confirm this.

Sankey diagram titled “Aella’s Birthday Gangbang,” aella.substack.com. The flows run left to right, with these exact number-and-label pairs: “1,604 Responded to survey” splits into “828 Failed auto filter” and “776 Passed auto filter.” “776 Passed auto filter” splits into “328 Failed manual filter” and “448 Passed manual filter.” “448 Passed manual filter” splits into “197 We didn't contact” and “251 We contacted.” “251 We contacted” splits into “143 Didn't respond,” “83 Did Interview,” and “25 Friends.” “83 Did Interview” splits into “21 We rejected” and a flow joining “25 Friends” at “87 Got invited.” “87 Got invited” splits into “31 Didn't get ticket” and “56 Got ticket.” “56 Got ticket” splits into “13 Cancelled” and “43 Did STI tests.” “43 Did STI tests” splits into “1 Didn't show” and “42 Showed up.” “42 Showed up” splits into “5 Didn't Bang Aella” and “37 Penetrated Aella.” “37 Penetrated Aella” splits into “17 Came in Aella,” “5 Came in a fluffer,” and “15 Didn't cum.”

Next we have her explaining that she is giving what she can to the cause by filtering invites to her gangbang based upon ideology. (e/acc is a rival ideology to EA. I have historically hated it but increasingly feel like I would like Literally Any Ideology Other Than Effective Altruism.)

X thread screenshot. Aella (@Aella_Girl), 29 Feb 24: “uh, also we turned away any applicants who were noticeably e/acc” Quoted Aella post, 29 Feb 24: “for my birthday, my partner and some friends organized a huge bang gang for me, with 42 attendees! Here's the breakdown of how the event was organized, exit survey statistics, and what it was like for ...” [cut off] Embedded Sankey diagram titled “Aella’s Birthday Gangbang,” aella.substack.com. Exact labels, following the flows: “1,604 Responded to survey” splits into “828 Failed auto filter” and “776 Passed auto filter”; the latter splits into “328 Failed manual filter” and “448 Passed manual filter”; the latter splits into “197 We didn't contact” and “251 We contacted”; those contacted split into “143 Didn't respond,” “83 Did Interview,” and “25 Friends.” Interviewees split into “21 We rejected” and a flow joining Friends at “87 Got invited.” Those invited split into “31 Didn't get ticket” and “56 Got ticket”; those with tickets split into “13 Cancelled” and “43 Did STI tests”; those tested split into “1 Didn't show” and “42 Showed up”; those who showed up split into “5 Didn't Bang Aella” and “37 Penetrated Aella”; the latter splits into “17 Came in Aella,” “5 Came in a fluffer,” and “15 Didn't cum.” Aella: “im not skilled enough to be in ai safety directly so i'm workin with what i got”

To spell this all the way out: Nate Soares, president of MIRI, seems to have organized a gangbang in which ideological rivals were explicitly excluded during the application process. This was documented publicly.

This is the banner for an article by Nicholas Decker from April 16, 2025, about overthrowing the United States government by force and/or violence.

Nicholas Decker post with a United States flag article banner. Banner text: “HOMO ECONOMICUS”; “When Must We Kill Them?”; “Evil has come to America.”

This is Aella’s reward for that article.

X post by Nicholas Decker (@captgouda24): “So uh...” Photograph of a man sitting on a sofa in front of six women wearing white tops and underwear; five women’s faces are blurred. Quoted post by Aella (@Aella_Girl), May 4, replying to @captgouda24 and @shaggysurvives: “actually a while ago the girlchat did have a somewhat serious discussion on whether or not we should start awarding honorary orgies for good tweets, inspired by you. we decided we were unsure about ur ethical integrity tho but there was an alternate universe where u had affairs” [cut off] Last edited 11:23 PM · Jun 3, 2025.

I think we can conclusively say that she uses sex to promote her ideology.

Aella is reputed to have introduced people into sex work:

X exchange. keysmashbandit (@keysmashbandit): “People give Aella a hard time because she's weird and sexy. A theater adult. But I think it's fairly likely she's an upright and honest individual” Daniel (@growing_daniel): “I think it’s because she’s a prostitute who coaches other women into becoming prostitutes”

She has written a guide to escorting. She gives educational sessions which produce quotes like “You are trying to get a million dollars. The million dollars is stored in his balls.”

Playboy once detailed the story of how she got into being a camgirl, and how she encouraged her sisters to do so also. She also has posts on this subject:

Three X posts by Aella (@Aella_Girl). 08 Mar 17: “Welp. My two younger sisters are camming together. God help us all.” 13 Feb 17: “Did you know I have two camgirl sisters? Follow @MFCThornyRose and @gerardeugine - the second starts in a few weeks on her 18th birthday!” 01 Mar 23, replying to @jacoburovsky: “quite an update from "literally talked your sisters into joining onlyfans"”

Aella is very public about having a fetish for “CNC”, or “consensual non-consent”, or stated more directly “simulated rape”. I have been hearing or reading, for years, that her specific simulated rape parties are dangerous, that rules are treated casually, and that everyone is on drugs.

Here is the most detailed and public negative account of her events I am aware of. It is part of a long post that includes a lot of community drama and drama concerning other rationalist spin-off cults and for some reason a rehashing of the Brent Dill saga.

Leaving the other drama aside, Aella’s reply makes this account of her parties seem credible.

Thanks for giving me a chance to talk anonymously about Aella and my experience with her. I don’t talk about her often because I don’t like badmouthing people. Also people say she’s vindictive.

I’ve only been to one of Aella’s parties but one was enough. The environment felt so uncomfortable that I spent hours and hours hiding alone and crying. The party had a lot of nudity and sex, everyone was on drugs, and it was set up so that consent as a guiding light was being continuously questioned. Maybe it could have been ok if I had known in advance that it would be a sex party with blurry consent practices but I didn’t, I thought I was just going to a normal burner party. It also wasn’t easy to leave for logistical reasons so once I was there I was stuck.

The only person I found who validated my feelings was another woman who I finally met towards the end of the party who was going around talking about how it wasn’t a safe environment. I was so grateful to her for saying something because I had almost gaslighted myself into believing that the problem was actually myself, I was just insecure, etc. In retrospect I think there must have been a lot of other women who were scared who just didn’t want to show how stressed and alone they felt in this extremely sexual blurred lines environment with a lot of horny drugged men around and no easy way to leave.

When I finally got home and talked to my friends I learned that Aella is well known for hosting parties with sketchy consent practices. I never went to one of her events again and I warn other people not to go all the time.

I want to point out that I’m not a shrinking violet. I go to burner & sex parties all the time. I have lost count of the number of times I’ve had sex in public. I also don’t judge Aella for being a sex worker. She seems like she works hard and I admire her success. But it seems like a lot of her success is organizing these events where women end up in weird sketchy situations. Maybe it feels great for some of the women who go. But I wouldn’t want Aella to be in charge of anything that demanded compassion or clarity.

This is Aella’s reply to that part of this complaint. (Her total comment is much longer and we’re going to consider most of it irrelevant to the point).

LessWrong comment by Aella: “This post is almost entirely factually incorrect, but to go point-by-point 1. For the parties I throw - I assume the person is referring to some of the parties in 2017, as those were the ones that had "a lot of sex"? I agree consent wasn't very clearly set out, but I'm not sure I regret this. I've never had anybody express to me the concerns laid out in the post, this is the first time I'm becoming aware events I've thrown have had a negative impact on people. I do genuinely not want this to happen and am now thinking about what and how to change about my events in the future. But I haven't thrown events with sex in them for years, so I'm guessing I need to be more careful if I decide to do this again? Happy to have feedback from people who've attended my events, here. 2. I've never played drug roulette or seen drug roulette played at one of my parties, this is a blatantly incorrect claim. I have joked about playing it numerous times, though; maybe someone heard me joking and misunderstood it as me saying I'd done it before? (edit: to be slightly more clear, I have speculated out loud about the specifics of how we could do this if we wanted to, for fun, but I've never claimed that I had actually done it before or made any actual plans for doing it)”

What I find especially troubling about this is that sexual assault in this context would be very nearly impossible to prove. Let’s say, hypothetically, that you showed up for an actual group sex simulated rape party and things went badly. If the rules are messed up and you outright get raped when you are trying to say no, you are going to have to explain to a cop exactly the difference between what happened and what was supposed to happen, or you are going to have to deal with some Effective Altruist mediator who is likely going to send you to counseling with your rapist,

or

you can tell your friends what happened but ask them to not mention you or tell your story, and then because your friends cannot mention you, when they want to make sure people are warned they have to say that the party is “not safe” or tell some other milder story they can get permission to tell instead of saying that someone they know was raped at one of these parties.

For Aella to be this casual, defensive and dismissive when someone raises such a concern about consent at her events is bad enough that I would assume it means she just doesn’t care. I think I can make a reasonable-confidence Bayesian inference on this one. That is the Rationalist term for “a very educated guess”. You could be reasonable and come to a different conclusion.

Part of why this continues is that everyone is fighting some factional battle, and nobody seems to make an accusation unless it helps their side. People seldom simply tell the truth about everything they know, and it is never extremely obvious which allegations are drama and which concern crimes against people.

Here are some of Aella’s opinions about rape. Ask yourself if you would trust this person to give a shit about you if you had been raped.

Two X posts by Aella (@Aella_Girl). Mar 27, 2020: “Sometimes it feels surreal that there's so little rape. Men are stronger and hornier and I am so grateful we live in a society where they just constantly go around not raping. Like *half* of all non-human sex is rape, but we managed to get our rape down to a tiny percentage.” Jan 14, 2023: “i feel weird when ppl use the term "survivors" for people who went through an unpleasant but not-even-close-to-life-threatening-thing”

Here we can find Time Magazine documenting a pattern of predatory behavior in Bay Area Effective Altruist group homes.

Here we have a viral post from 2024. I did not even remember it had happened until someone reminded me when I started talking about this a few days ago. Things like this are said all the time and the community always closes ranks, and then the story vanishes. This post describes alleged CNC sex parties and alleged heavy LSD use among elite AI researchers at, specifically, OpenAI.

“some of the most coercive and fucked up social dynamics I have ever seen”

Three-slide carousel containing an X post by Sonia Joseph (@soniajoseph_). Slide 1: “To the journalists contacting me about the AGI consensual non-consensual (cnc) sex parties— During my twenties in Silicon Valley, I ran among elite tech/AI circles through the community house scene. I have seen some troubling things around social circles of early OpenAI employees, their friends, and adjacent entrepreneurs, which I have not previously spoken about publicly. It is not my place to speak as to why Jan Leike and the superalignment team resigned. I have no idea why and cannot make any claims. However, I do believe my cultural observations of the SF AI scene are more broadly relevant to the AI industry. I don't think events like the consensual non-consensual (cnc) sex parties and heavy LSD use of some elite AI researchers have been good for women. They create a climate that can be very bad for female AI researchers, with broader implications relevant to X-risk and AGI safety. I believe they are somewhat emblematic of broader problems: a coercive climate that normalizes recklessness and crossing boundaries, which we are seeing playing out more broadly in the industry today. Move fast and break things, applied to people. There is nothing wrong imo with sex parties and heavy LSD use in theory, but combined with the shadow of 100B+ interest groups, leads to some of the most coercive and fucked up social dynamics that I have ever seen. The climate was like a fratty LSD version of 2008 Wall Street bankers, which bodes ill for AI safety.” Slide 2: “Women are like canaries in the coal mine. They are often the first to realize that something has gone horribly wrong, and to smell the cultural carbon monoxide in the air. For many women, Silicon Valley can be like Westworld, where violence is pay-to-pay. I have seen people repeatedly get shut down for pointing out these problems. Once, when trying to point out these problems, I had three OpenAI and Anthropic researchers debate whether I was mentally ill on a Google document. I have no history of mental illness; and this incident stuck with me as an example of blindspots/groupthink. I am not writing this on the behalf of any interest group. Historically, much of OpenAI-adjacent shenanigans has been blamed on groups with weaker PR teams, like Effective Altruism and rationalists. I actually feel bad for the latter two groups for taking so many undeserved hits. There are good and bad apples in every faction. There are so many brilliant, kind, amazing people at OpenAI, and there are so many brilliant, kind, and amazing people in Anthropic/EA/Google/[insert whatever group]. I’m agnostic. My one loyalty is to the respect and dignity of human life.” Slide 3: “I'm not under an NDA. I never worked for OpenAI. I just observed the surrounding AI culture through the community house scene in SF, as a fly-on-the-wall, hearing insider information and backroom deals, befriending dozens of women and allies and well-meaning parties, and watching many them get burned. It’s likely these problems are not really on OpenAI but symptomatic of a much deeper rot in the Valley. I wish I could say more, but probably shouldn’t. I will not pretend that my time among these circles didn’t do damage. I wish that 55% of my brain was not devoted to strategizing about the survival of me and of my friends. I would like to devote my brain completely and totally to AI research— finding the first principles of visual circuits, and collecting maximally activating images of CLIP SAEs to send to my collaborators for publication.” Quoted post by Jan Leike (@janleike), May 17, replying to @janleike: “We are long overdue in getting incredibly serious about the implications of AGI. We must prioritize preparing for them as best we can. ...” [cut off] 6:58 PM · May 17, 2024.Three-slide carousel containing an X post by Sonia Joseph (@soniajoseph_). Slide 1: “To the journalists contacting me about the AGI consensual non-consensual (cnc) sex parties— During my twenties in Silicon Valley, I ran among elite tech/AI circles through the community house scene. I have seen some troubling things around social circles of early OpenAI employees, their friends, and adjacent entrepreneurs, which I have not previously spoken about publicly. It is not my place to speak as to why Jan Leike and the superalignment team resigned. I have no idea why and cannot make any claims. However, I do believe my cultural observations of the SF AI scene are more broadly relevant to the AI industry. I don't think events like the consensual non-consensual (cnc) sex parties and heavy LSD use of some elite AI researchers have been good for women. They create a climate that can be very bad for female AI researchers, with broader implications relevant to X-risk and AGI safety. I believe they are somewhat emblematic of broader problems: a coercive climate that normalizes recklessness and crossing boundaries, which we are seeing playing out more broadly in the industry today. Move fast and break things, applied to people. There is nothing wrong imo with sex parties and heavy LSD use in theory, but combined with the shadow of 100B+ interest groups, leads to some of the most coercive and fucked up social dynamics that I have ever seen. The climate was like a fratty LSD version of 2008 Wall Street bankers, which bodes ill for AI safety.” Slide 2: “Women are like canaries in the coal mine. They are often the first to realize that something has gone horribly wrong, and to smell the cultural carbon monoxide in the air. For many women, Silicon Valley can be like Westworld, where violence is pay-to-pay. I have seen people repeatedly get shut down for pointing out these problems. Once, when trying to point out these problems, I had three OpenAI and Anthropic researchers debate whether I was mentally ill on a Google document. I have no history of mental illness; and this incident stuck with me as an example of blindspots/groupthink. I am not writing this on the behalf of any interest group. Historically, much of OpenAI-adjacent shenanigans has been blamed on groups with weaker PR teams, like Effective Altruism and rationalists. I actually feel bad for the latter two groups for taking so many undeserved hits. There are good and bad apples in every faction. There are so many brilliant, kind, amazing people at OpenAI, and there are so many brilliant, kind, and amazing people in Anthropic/EA/Google/[insert whatever group]. I’m agnostic. My one loyalty is to the respect and dignity of human life.” Slide 3: “I'm not under an NDA. I never worked for OpenAI. I just observed the surrounding AI culture through the community house scene in SF, as a fly-on-the-wall, hearing insider information and backroom deals, befriending dozens of women and allies and well-meaning parties, and watching many them get burned. It’s likely these problems are not really on OpenAI but symptomatic of a much deeper rot in the Valley. I wish I could say more, but probably shouldn’t. I will not pretend that my time among these circles didn’t do damage. I wish that 55% of my brain was not devoted to strategizing about the survival of me and of my friends. I would like to devote my brain completely and totally to AI research— finding the first principles of visual circuits, and collecting maximally activating images of CLIP SAEs to send to my collaborators for publication.” Quoted post by Jan Leike (@janleike), May 17, replying to @janleike: “We are long overdue in getting incredibly serious about the implications of AGI. We must prioritize preparing for them as best we can. ...” [cut off] 6:58 PM · May 17, 2024.Three-slide carousel containing an X post by Sonia Joseph (@soniajoseph_). Slide 1: “To the journalists contacting me about the AGI consensual non-consensual (cnc) sex parties— During my twenties in Silicon Valley, I ran among elite tech/AI circles through the community house scene. I have seen some troubling things around social circles of early OpenAI employees, their friends, and adjacent entrepreneurs, which I have not previously spoken about publicly. It is not my place to speak as to why Jan Leike and the superalignment team resigned. I have no idea why and cannot make any claims. However, I do believe my cultural observations of the SF AI scene are more broadly relevant to the AI industry. I don't think events like the consensual non-consensual (cnc) sex parties and heavy LSD use of some elite AI researchers have been good for women. They create a climate that can be very bad for female AI researchers, with broader implications relevant to X-risk and AGI safety. I believe they are somewhat emblematic of broader problems: a coercive climate that normalizes recklessness and crossing boundaries, which we are seeing playing out more broadly in the industry today. Move fast and break things, applied to people. There is nothing wrong imo with sex parties and heavy LSD use in theory, but combined with the shadow of 100B+ interest groups, leads to some of the most coercive and fucked up social dynamics that I have ever seen. The climate was like a fratty LSD version of 2008 Wall Street bankers, which bodes ill for AI safety.” Slide 2: “Women are like canaries in the coal mine. They are often the first to realize that something has gone horribly wrong, and to smell the cultural carbon monoxide in the air. For many women, Silicon Valley can be like Westworld, where violence is pay-to-pay. I have seen people repeatedly get shut down for pointing out these problems. Once, when trying to point out these problems, I had three OpenAI and Anthropic researchers debate whether I was mentally ill on a Google document. I have no history of mental illness; and this incident stuck with me as an example of blindspots/groupthink. I am not writing this on the behalf of any interest group. Historically, much of OpenAI-adjacent shenanigans has been blamed on groups with weaker PR teams, like Effective Altruism and rationalists. I actually feel bad for the latter two groups for taking so many undeserved hits. There are good and bad apples in every faction. There are so many brilliant, kind, amazing people at OpenAI, and there are so many brilliant, kind, and amazing people in Anthropic/EA/Google/[insert whatever group]. I’m agnostic. My one loyalty is to the respect and dignity of human life.” Slide 3: “I'm not under an NDA. I never worked for OpenAI. I just observed the surrounding AI culture through the community house scene in SF, as a fly-on-the-wall, hearing insider information and backroom deals, befriending dozens of women and allies and well-meaning parties, and watching many them get burned. It’s likely these problems are not really on OpenAI but symptomatic of a much deeper rot in the Valley. I wish I could say more, but probably shouldn’t. I will not pretend that my time among these circles didn’t do damage. I wish that 55% of my brain was not devoted to strategizing about the survival of me and of my friends. I would like to devote my brain completely and totally to AI research— finding the first principles of visual circuits, and collecting maximally activating images of CLIP SAEs to send to my collaborators for publication.” Quoted post by Jan Leike (@janleike), May 17, replying to @janleike: “We are long overdue in getting incredibly serious about the implications of AGI. We must prioritize preparing for them as best we can. ...” [cut off] 6:58 PM · May 17, 2024.

That post’s author is Sonia Joseph. Sonia Joseph first got into Rationalism and Effective Altruism by reading Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality when she was fourteen years old. That story in Bloomberg matches everything I am saying, matches the separate Time story, and so on, and so on, and so on.

This is all one big thing, people have told good chunks of the story many times and it’s just extremely hard to convince anyone that this is all one big thing and that it is this large, this prominent or this bad.

Aella’s current event series is Red Means No, which she organizes along with Gretta Duleba, Eliezer Yudkowsky’s primary partner. Red Means No is registered as an LLC in the state of California.29 Gretta will come up again very shortly.

Here is one of MIRI’s affiliates (John Wentworth, whom we will also run into again) explaining that he considers attendance at Red Means No a positive signal for someone’s career qualifications, in case it seemed plausible that this was never a de facto career requirement in that sphere.

Comment by John Wentworth, marked “Edited,” with the notice “User was temporarily suspended for this comment.” “I have been to RMN more than once, and I think it is mostly rationalists actually. But it's close enough to 50/50 that I'm not confident. Also I personally absolutely do upgrade my assessment of someone's AI alignment qualifications if I find out they go to RMN. In order to do useful thinking on AI alignment/safety, I claim it is a strict requirement that one is able to notice places where mainstream society is getting triggered and being stupid, and unflinchingly dismiss the mainstream's stupidity. Attending RMN is one of many possible strong signals that someone can dismiss mainstream stupidity in cases where the mainstream is being stupid. But there are many other signals which can substitute for it.”

This is the banner for Slutcon.

Pink speaker graphic headed “The People” and “Speakers, coaches, educators, and designated flirt partners.” Portraits and labels read, left to right, top row then bottom row: Aella — Organizer & sex researcher Diana Fleischman — Evolutionary psychologist, PhD Adam Conover — Comedian & TV host CJ TheX — Philosopher & video essayist Nina Hartley — Sex educator & performer Carol Queen — Sexologist, PhD Nicholas — Dating coach, Fullyknown Chesed — Co-organizer, SlutStack Greta — Therapist & orgy organizer “+ More soon!”

Gretta is Gretta Duleba, Eliezer Yudkowsky’s primary partner. As of their most recent filing, covering 2024, she drew a salary of about $200,000 from MIRI, and she apparently helped edit his book. She does not seem especially qualified, and lists her most recent four years of work prior to MIRI as “Relationship and Sex Therapy”. Per her posting history, she did not leave employment at MIRI until early this year, 2026.30

This event appears to be incorporated as Weird Party LLC in Wyoming under filing ID 2026-002033219 and registered in California as Entity B20260434776.

This event was held at Lighthaven.31

This is Aella in 2024 soliciting donations for Lighthaven and saying she is hoping that they will let her throw orgies at Lighthaven if she is good enough at soliciting donations for them.

Screenshot of an X thread. Aella (@Aella_Girl), Dec 3, 2024: “the Lightcone team is the most powerfully autistic group I've ever met (laudatory). You should fund them continuing to run lesswrong.  Also, if you mention that you funded them because I told you to, maybe I can finally bully them into letting me run an orgy at lighthaven  (read more about them in the thread and their post)  donation link next tweet”  Quoted post by Oliver Habryka (@ohabryka), Dec 2, 2024: “Food $200 Healthcare $150 AI Alignment $150 AI Capabilities $3,600,000,000,000 Human Intelligence Enhancement $50…” [cut off]  Embedded screenshot by Emmett Shear (@eshear), 2:13 PM · Sep 2, 2024: “70% epistemic confidence: People will talk about Lighthaven in Berkeley in the future the same way they talk about IAS at Princeton or Bell Labs.” An adjacent image is cropped to a narrow strip with incomplete text.  Brangus (@RatOrthodox), 2:51 PM · Dec 3, 2024: “Would like it to be known that my (not necessarily Lightcone's) stance here is that, barring external agreements with other parties, what you do in a private room or building that you pay for is your business, provided you do not cause unreasonable damages or risks to the venue.”

I believe that these core people involved in Berkeley AI Safety are substantially and knowingly the beneficiaries of various crimes, and that many of these crimes were committed for the express purpose of benefitting the rationalist and effective altruist movements.

I believe that these crimes include those committed at Futures Exchange, commonly known as FTX, and Alameda Research, and that the unrecovered fruits of the fraud that destroyed those companies are to this day part of the funding for this enterprise.

I believe that the specifics of the apocalyptic doctrines of the rationalists turn up as business plans and news items regularly in the AI industry.

I believe that a “pivotal act” is Yudkowsky’s euphemism for acts of warfare, government violence, or terrorism which he believes anyone making AGI must do in order to prevent competition and therefore the end of the world, and that many members of this enterprise will understand some offshoot of this idea and will understand such acts to be necessary in the course of pursuing their goals.

I believe that the most widely known rationalist text discussing pivotal acts specifically is “AGI Ruin: A List of Lethalities”, and that it discusses “burn all GPUs” as a hypothetical pivotal act preventing all competition. My understanding is that this essay claims not to endorse this plan, but that many readers come away convinced that this is a good plan, regardless.

I believe that Sam Altman was recently reported to to have discussed a scenario where one company melts all competitors’ GPUs, that Sam appeared in an interview with Fortune discussing this idea, and that Sam Altman appearing to take this seriously as an idea can only be due to Yudkowsky’s influence.

I believe that the sixth bullet point of "AGI Ruin: A List of Lethalities" is meant to indicate that the “pivotal act” which is the most likely to be necessary and achievable is not actually burning all GPUs, but something that is easier to achieve and that is unspeakable in public, and that the intended reading is for this to refer to eliminating all potential competition with engineered biological weapons. Anyone who is not a part of your project is potential competition.32

I believe that a “warning shot” is a well-established term in rationalist and effective altruist discussions of AI safety. Per Kokotajlo,

A “AI safety warning shot” is some event that causes a substantial fraction of the relevant human actors (governments, AI researchers, etc.) to become substantially more supportive of AI research and worried about existential risks posed by AI.

I believe that it is more likely than not the case that at least some prominent recent AI security incidents were either deliberately or with willful neglect caused by insiders who believed that a “warning shot” was necessary to save humanity from AI existential risk, given the prevalence of rationalist and effective altruist employees within prominent AI companies.

I believe that most of this has been conducted in the open and can be established as more probably the case than not via close examination of public records. All of this has been kept from public knowledge and understanding because it is too offensive and too bizarre to seem real when stated directly.

I would testify to these beliefs and my basis for them under oath.

This is Ronny Fernandez. He is the “Lighthaven czar”33, which I understand to mean that he manages day-to-day operations and the scheduling of all events held at Lighthaven, and has since 2024. His twitter tag is @RatOrthodox and his display name is Brangus. He is seen here receiving an amateur tattoo from Aella of the number “100” for being her hundredth recreational sex partner. She took pains to establish that “recreational” did not include her sex work clients.

Photograph of Aella leaning beside Ronny Fernandez, who is reclining shirtless in a pale green armchair. She holds a wipe against his upper arm, where a new “100” tattoo is visible. Tattoo equipment, packets and used wipes surround the chair. An orange handwritten note stuck to his forehead reads: “Do not acknowledge this sign / If you see this person suffering / act like they're a wuss and / everyone else handles it better”. A large stuffed animal sits behind his head, beside a window with orange curtains.
If you do not know what being very badly on drugs looks like, this is it.
Four-slide carousel showing an X post and photographs of a tattoo session.  Slide 1: Brangus (@RatOrthodox), 10:34 AM · May 26, 2025: “As you all know I was the 100th person to have recreational sex with @Aella_Girl, so last night I forced her to tattoo a 100 on me. She has never tattooed before. I am v happy with the result.” Embedded photos show Aella tattooing Ronny Fernandez's upper arm while he reclines shirtless in a pale green armchair, with an orange handwritten note on his forehead.  Slide 2: Overhead photograph of Aella using a tattoo machine on his upper arm. Tattoo supplies lie beside him. The orange forehead note reads: “Do not acknowledge this sign / If you see this person suffering / act like they're a wuss and / everyone else handles it better”.  Slide 3: Several people crowd around the armchair and watch the tattooing.  Slide 4: Close-up of the completed black “100” tattoo on hairy skin, with redness around the numerals.Four-slide carousel showing an X post and photographs of a tattoo session.  Slide 1: Brangus (@RatOrthodox), 10:34 AM · May 26, 2025: “As you all know I was the 100th person to have recreational sex with @Aella_Girl, so last night I forced her to tattoo a 100 on me. She has never tattooed before. I am v happy with the result.” Embedded photos show Aella tattooing Ronny Fernandez's upper arm while he reclines shirtless in a pale green armchair, with an orange handwritten note on his forehead.  Slide 2: Overhead photograph of Aella using a tattoo machine on his upper arm. Tattoo supplies lie beside him. The orange forehead note reads: “Do not acknowledge this sign / If you see this person suffering / act like they're a wuss and / everyone else handles it better”.  Slide 3: Several people crowd around the armchair and watch the tattooing.  Slide 4: Close-up of the completed black “100” tattoo on hairy skin, with redness around the numerals.
Four-slide carousel showing an X post and photographs of a tattoo session.  Slide 1: Brangus (@RatOrthodox), 10:34 AM · May 26, 2025: “As you all know I was the 100th person to have recreational sex with @Aella_Girl, so last night I forced her to tattoo a 100 on me. She has never tattooed before. I am v happy with the result.” Embedded photos show Aella tattooing Ronny Fernandez's upper arm while he reclines shirtless in a pale green armchair, with an orange handwritten note on his forehead.  Slide 2: Overhead photograph of Aella using a tattoo machine on his upper arm. Tattoo supplies lie beside him. The orange forehead note reads: “Do not acknowledge this sign / If you see this person suffering / act like they're a wuss and / everyone else handles it better”.  Slide 3: Several people crowd around the armchair and watch the tattooing.  Slide 4: Close-up of the completed black “100” tattoo on hairy skin, with redness around the numerals.Four-slide carousel showing an X post and photographs of a tattoo session.  Slide 1: Brangus (@RatOrthodox), 10:34 AM · May 26, 2025: “As you all know I was the 100th person to have recreational sex with @Aella_Girl, so last night I forced her to tattoo a 100 on me. She has never tattooed before. I am v happy with the result.” Embedded photos show Aella tattooing Ronny Fernandez's upper arm while he reclines shirtless in a pale green armchair, with an orange handwritten note on his forehead.  Slide 2: Overhead photograph of Aella using a tattoo machine on his upper arm. Tattoo supplies lie beside him. The orange forehead note reads: “Do not acknowledge this sign / If you see this person suffering / act like they're a wuss and / everyone else handles it better”.  Slide 3: Several people crowd around the armchair and watch the tattooing.  Slide 4: Close-up of the completed black “100” tattoo on hairy skin, with redness around the numerals.

This was what the kids these days call “bait”, which is anything which attracts attention on the Internet by being bizarre, disgusting or controversial. All of these people are great at attracting shock reactions and then using them as cover to do whatever they were going to do anyway.

Ronny is also Aella’s manager.34

This is a recently viral thread of a basically normal person’s experience at a meet-and-greet with the Rationalists at Lighthaven. The moderator who separated out the believers from the unbelievers was Ronny Fernandez.

Screenshot of an X post by Erin Redwing (@realizingerin), 7:53 AM · Sep 15, 2026: “I went to an rationalist/EA AI doomer event last night with the goal of meeting someone who could calmly explain to me the argument for how they get to the conclusion that AI will kill everyone.  Because these are rationalists, I expected to find people who could lay out a serious extinction pathway, walk through the assumptions and intermediate steps, identify choke points where negative pathways could potentially be regulated, and entertain disagreement about where their assumptions might break down.  My experience was the exact opposite.  The people I spoke to seemed psychologically unable to entertain the possibility that their conclusion (that AI literally kills everyone, which was a point that many would not even budge on) might be wrong.  Their most extreme conclusion was treated as an axiom.  I had multiple people walk out of conversations with me when I questioned their inevitable extinction premise.  At one point during a panel, the moderator asked everyone in the audience who was still skeptical of AI doom to raise their hands. About half the room did. He then told all of the skeptics to leave the panel and go with one of the speakers, who would answer their questions separately. They filtered out all the skeptics, and continued the panel only with the subset who accepted their extreme position.  I genuinely felt like a heretic just for questioning whether superintelligent AI inevitably leads to the extinction of humanity, or entertaining the possibility that the future might actually turn out well.  That does not mean AI safety is fake. Obviously there are serious questions about rapidly advancing AI systems and what happens as they become much more capable. Those are exactly the conversations I went there hoping to have.  But what I encountered was an apocalyptic death cult. These people are not rational. They are deeply afraid, they reinforce that fear in one another, and they have become so emotionally committed to apocalypse that they refuse to be reasoned out of it.”
Screenshot of an X post by Brangus (@RatOrthodox), Sep 15: “I am the moderator in question and I feel misunderstood by this. This was during a multiple hundred person Q&A. I invited folks who were skeptical of x-risk to have a smaller conversation with Oliver so that they could get more of a back and forth. I did not ask anyone to leave.”  Quoted post by Erin Redwing (@realizingerin), Sep 15: “I went to an rationalist/EA AI doomer event last night with the goal of meeting someone who could calmly explain to me the argument for how they get to the conclusion that AI will kill everyone.  Because these are rationalists, I expected to find people who could lay …” [cut off]

Ronny Fernandez used to be married to Holly Elmore, the Executive Director of PauseAI US. Their divorce seems to have been messy, they are both activists, and its aftermath often spilled onto twitter.

This is Holly’s most complete explanation of her divorce, told in the aftermath of Sam Kirchner’s disappearance.35

Screenshot of an X thread by Holly ⏸️ Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), Jul 13: “Ftr Ronny didn't like the guy bc he wasn't a rationalist and denigrated him for being a Doordash driver. We had a fight where he was like "A Doordash driver? Doordash? Really?"-- totally doubling down when I found that classist judgment disgusting.”  Quoted Brangus (@RatOrthodox), Jul 12: “For the record, when I met Sam Kirchner I was married to Holly Elmore, Holly and I got into an intense many day fight because I thought he seemed unhinged and unthoughtful. I wanted her to not work with him. Holly thought he was great and was very angry at me for being judgmental”  Holly Elmore: “The fight was not about Sam being dangerous. Ronny loves dangerous dudes. It was about Sam being from outside Ronny's group and me doing stuff without letting Ronny sit on his ass, try to take all the credit, and call all the shots.  One reason I was so galled about the Doordash remark is that Ronny is a mooch who has never worked that hard or honestly a day in his life. He relied on me for most of his necessities and by that point was unemployed and constantly hitting me up to "loan" him money which would then try to make me feel small or petty for trying to recoup. He's probably still using his mom like this. But he thought he was better than this guy who had the audacity to, idk, be poor and work.”  Holly Elmore: “For those who don't know, my ex-husband, Ronny Fernandez, @LighthavenPR and @plzdontkillus_, is a predator who abused me and other women. He told me he knew he was a psychopath and a narcissist. Now he kind of openly trades in that by being one of the rapists in Aella's famous rape orgies.  I hate that I have this past connection hanging over my head but I think the best thing to do about it is just be honest and warn whoever I can.”  Holly Elmore, 10:53 PM · Jul 13, 2026: “Btw I give Ronny a chance to comment by telling journalists to reach out to him and giving his contact info when he comes up in the story of my organizing, which I will certainly not hold back to protect him. If that bothers him then I guess I'll stop giving him a heads up.”  Quoted Brangus (@RatOrthodox), Jul 12: “Also for the record, it keeps happening that journalists call me and ask me to talk to them about my divorce because Holly spoke to them about my divorce. When they do this, I reply but I would not by default speak to journalists about my divorce.”

Holly was previously cancelled by essentially all of Effective Altruism, Rationalism, TPOT36, whatever you want to call these people and all of their hangers-on for objecting to this picture and saying it makes their movement and cause look bad.

Screenshot of an X post by Aella (@Aella_Girl), dated “8:42 PM · 6/7/26.” The photograph shows Aella seated cross-legged on a white sofa, with five men in black hats standing behind her. The man in the center wears a gold sequined jacket; the others wear black or white shirts. Orange curtains hang behind the group.

I do not know who the two men on the left are. The man in the golden jacket is Eliezer Yudkowsky. On the right is Nate Soares, President of MIRI. The man second from the right is John Wentworth, an “Independent AI Researcher” sometimes affiliated with MIRI.

Screenshot of an X post by Holly ⏸️ Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), 7:20 PM · Jun 13, 2026: “‘Why did no one speak out?’  Lol, lmao”

“plzdontkillus” or “pdku” was a one-month-long “creator bootcamp” thrown by the Rationalists this July, 2026. It appears to have been a social media marketing and recruitment drive to bring in new blood and bring their message to short-form video. This program offered free room and board, a $2,000 stipend, and access to a $20,000 prize pool for high-performing videos on social media.

This was hosted at Lighthaven, and partially sponsored by MIRI.

My understanding is that attendees are some combination of people who believed in the cause and people who just wanted the check. My impression is that this was part of a recruiting funnel. This event was held over the summer when school was closed, but that’s probably to avoid noise complaints from the middle school that is across the street from the compound.

Staff for this event:

  • Aella

  • Ronny Fernandez

  • Azmyth (Aella’s sister)

“Mentors” or otherwise participating:

  • Eliezer Yudkowsky

  • Nate Soares

  • Grimes

  • Jreg

  • CJ The X

  • Alex Botez

  • Tor Parsons

  • Quinn Finite

  • Aric Floyd

  • Zoe Curzi

  • Rob Miles

Liron Shapira’s podcast, “Doom Debates”, did an interview with Aella and Ronny Fernandez at the conclusion of pdku to talk about the event. This interview confirms that JJ McCullough and Jeffrey Ladish provided mentorship separately from the official schedule.

Yudkowsky, Soares, and Ladish, all involved in this event, are three out of four of Bernie’s advisors on AI risk. (The fourth is Kokotajlo, who is a director for Lightcone, which manages the property). I am trying to make the point that this specific social scene, with these specific people, at this specific property, does in fact constitute essentially the entirety of “AI Safety” and its political wing.

While I have been writing, my earlier comments seem to have touched off some internal strife within the movement. This is resurfacing issues I had forgotten, like the “pdku dead cow question”, discussed here by rationalist Vishal:

Screenshot of an X post by vishal (@koreindian): “i disagree with pretty much all of this. 60 year old voters in ohio don't know about slutcon or the pdku dead cow question, and if they did they'd forget about it quickly between media cycles. playing for respectability at the margin is a mug's game. think of trump, hunter biden, clavicular, and kanye west: the clear lesson is that americans do not care about "respectability." memory is short. it's a rule-breaker's world, and the savviest players know they just need to keep buying tickets at the discourse lottery.”

This is the beginning of a much longer post defending asking this question on the application for plzdontkillus:

“If you had to have sex with a cow would you rather it be dead or alive? Why?”

This question is being defended, broadly, as just people being people and doing weird quirky things. Anyone opposed to asking this question is accused of being uptight and killing the mood. Those who think the question is inappropriate are correct, but their reasoning is wrong: they think it is inappropriate because it makes their movement look bad.

It is inappropriate because it is being used to test people’s boundaries and filter out those who have them, to make people feel complicit, and to provide an icebreaker for talking about sex. It is inappropriate because it is being asked by people in a position of authority. It is inappropriate because it is being used to probe for weakness.

It is inappropriate because Ronny Fernandez is the one asking it.

These reasons for objecting do not occur to anyone in Bay Area Effective Altruism or Rationalism because they have completely normalized this behavior. They have been taught to never consider such questions.

Here is Aella’s explanation for why the cow question was on the application form. I would like to thank her for confirming the question was calculated.

Screenshot of an X post by Aella (@Aella_Girl), dated 11:29 AM · 22 Sep 26: “(oh i want to note: re the cow question, I did really fight for that question despite pushback from even ingroup rats. I think it (or an equivalent question, idk if the question itself was the best but i really wanted something to fill the role) was extremely good for specifically the application process of what we were trying to do. I would not include that or similar questions in other application processes for other things. I did not include it as a casual 'lol', it was a pretty deliberate strategic choice)”

Ronny Fernandez has a second twitter account, where he used to post his unfiltered thoughts. He seems to have forgotten about it. Unfortunately, in order to avoid deflection or claims that this is just a joke I have copied in a lot of it. If your opinion of him is already bad enough that more information won’t matter, I would recommend skipping this section.37

This establishes that it is his account:

 Brangus (@RatOrthodox)  Hello, I have changed my alt’s handle to @BrangusBrangus. Please follow for spicier content I am unwilling to post here.  14:46 · 2024.09.21 · 406 Views 3 likes.

This is Nate Soares interacting with his posts, and is about five months into Ronny being in charge of Lighthaven:

Screenshot of an X exchange dated 2024.12.21. Brangus Unchained: “only weak men let their gfs unionize. i hit em with the right to work laws and force them to negotiate individually” Nate Soares (@So8res), at 19:13: “(though only weak harems need joint negotiations in order to coordinate, ofc)”

This establishes that Aella is aware of the account, and is comfortable with the contents of the account:

Screenshot of an X exchange. Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), Oct 3, 2024: “Energetic sex seems interesting to me. Only problem is that idk how you would do energetic cnc.” Aella (@Aella_Girl), 10:23 AM · Oct 4, 2024: “Nate v good at that it’s horrifying”

I expect that the usual defense here would be that he is being funny, or this is just fetish content, or something. If such an excuse is made, please consider this post:

Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 12:45 PM · Apr 3, 2025: “Please know that if I ever apologize for anything I’ve said on here, I do so under extreme duress.”

In this one, he claims his assistant brings him a cold brew with a methamphetamine powder rim every morning …

Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 2:28 PM · Mar 14, 2025: “my assistant brings me a metharita every morning. that's a can of cold brew with a methamphetamine powder rim”

… and this is his assistant, Azmyth, Aella’s sister, taking a candid video because they are having a good and fun time at pdku. He says he is on a lot of stimulants.

This one is interesting because it is a joke about the normal defensive tactic this group of people uses. Act harmless, act weird, and use this to get past people’s defenses. Maybe it’s just a joke and I don’t get it.

 Screenshot of an X poll by Aella and a reply by Brangus Unchained, placed after the paragraph discussing appearing harmless and using that appearance to get past people’s defenses.  Aella (@Aella_Girl) · 2025.03.29  would you predict ancestrally that men aroused by rape are more: A) higher status, because both are downstream of general testosterone/dominance/aggression B) lower status, because if you're low status it's harder to find a woman to mate with you consensually  A — 43% B — 57% 10,853 votes · Final results  99 replies, 11 reposts, 189 likes, 79K views.  Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus)  ohhh i’m just a little low status guy, nothing to worry about here  12:39 · 2025.03.31 · 160 Views

These posts speak for themselves.

Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 16:09 · 2025.03.02: “vaginal tightness goes down with arousal which is part of why i hate making women aroused during sex”
Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 01:18 · 2025.04.14: “rapin' her after the argument just in case”
Screenshot of an X exchange. Aella (@Aella_Girl), 2023.07.27: “all the dudes i know with high bodycounts, tend to be mostly banging women who have high bodycounts. it's less 'preying on wholesome, virginal women' and more 'all the sluts are in a giant slutcloud fucking each other'” Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), 19:00 · 2024.09.23: “I used to prey on wholesome virginal women too, but we actually don’t have enough in common”
Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 15:40 · 2025.04.03: “just vapin’ n rapin’. what’re you up to?”
Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 10:21 AM · Dec 5, 2024: “Guys, it is soooo much scarier raping somebody on 5meo”
5meo refers to 5-MeO-DMT, also known as toad venom.
Screenshot of two X posts by Brangus Unchained, both dated 2025.04.20. First post: “drive your gf absolutely crazy with this one weird trick. answer in replies.” Reply: “dose her with 500 mcg of lsd without her knowing and then after a couple hours only reply to everything she says by saying “haha what, you’re being crazy””
Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained, dated 2025.01.09: “i’m pretty sure drag queen and trans women are not doing woman blackface, but i wanna make it clear that when i wear women’s clothing, I definitely am.”
Screenshot of four X posts by Brangus Unchained. 2024.10.24: “Type of guy who bihacks because he hates women. Like yeah, I only eat impossible meat because I fucking hate cows and the idea of consuming their flesh disgusts me.” 2024.10.23: “Being a guy who is genuinely into cnc sometimes feels like being the prettiest girl at the ball.” 2024.10.23: “I’ve been procrastinating on showering but i have a lot of shmegma build up so I’m gonna take care of that and then get back to facing death vicariously through my grandmother’s eyes. Talk to you guys later” 2024.10.20: “my true form is wearing nothing but a pink bonnet and an adult diaper with holes cutout for my penis and butthole. the diaper will not absorb my waste. that is not its purpose.”
Atlas Fellowship profile card with a mirror photograph of Ronny Fernandez holding a phone that shows the same scene. Text: “Ronny Fernandez Ronny studied philosophy at Rutgers University and likes to think about how artificial intelligence grounds philosophy in the concrete. He also did AI forecasting research at AI Impacts. At Atlas, he enjoys discussing formal epistemology and strategizing for Killer Queen games. Learn more →”

This is Ronny Fernandez’s picture on the page for The Atlas Fellowship, at which he was an instructor, and which appears to have run only in 2022 and 2023. I am saved from having to type out most of the important information about The Atlas Fellowship, because they put it all into one nice box.

 Screenshot of the Atlas Fellowship website in the article’s “The Atlas Fellowship” section. The visible text reads:  The Atlas Fellowship evolved out of a program called Uncommon Sense, which had a focus similar to the Atlas summer program and proved impactful for its participants. Sydney Von Arx, one of the co-founders of Uncommon Sense, teamed up with others to found the Atlas Fellowship to vastly expand the scale and scope of that program—starting the Atlas Fellowship in 2022.  In 2022, the Atlas Fellowship ran five 11-day programs in Berkeley (California) and Oxford (United Kingdom) for 111 Fellows from 18 countries, selected from over 7,000 applications. We plan to continue and refine our programs, and potentially support a substantially larger number of students in future years.  The Atlas Fellowship is a 501(c)(3) public charity in the United States (EIN 88-1678673). It is funded by Open Philanthropy, a large philanthropic organization in the United States. Previously, it also received funding from the Future Fund. If you are interested in supporting us, or if you have any questions about your donation, please contact us at info@atlasfellowship.org.

I believe the following facts are perhaps not obvious from this screenshot:

  • Open Philanthropy is now called Coefficient Giving, and is an Effective Altruist organization.

  • This is a summer camp for high school students. There are videos of them on the site.

I had never heard of this program before. I found it while trying to find a good reference photo for Ronny’s face, so now we have one. There are so many rationalist and effective altruist summer camps, youth programs, and so on that finding them all and figuring out where they are would make it impossible for me to finish this in a reasonable amount of time.

Ronny is the current manager at Lighthaven and all events are scheduled through him. He is the one who separates the believers from the unbelievers at meet-and-greets and he will have access to all of the students of any of the programs that are run at the compound.

Here is an article where he argues that having sex with an adult when he was thirteen did not harm him.

Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated Sep 20, 2024: “When I was 8 or 9 I taught a bunch of my friends how to masturbate. I was astonished their parents hadn’t taught them. I also taught them how to look up porn. Some of them weren’t allowed to hangout w me after that and it took me a long time to figure out why.”
Screenshot of an X post by Brangus Unchained (@BrangusBrangus), dated 00:54 · 2025.04.05: “i never liked constraining the potential ways my relationship could evolved with someone based on their role in my life, like if they’re my therapist, or my boss, or my sister”

When Brent Dill came up, the narrative from leadership was that they did not know what he had been doing before they put him into a position of authority at a camp for high schoolers. They should have known and were negligent but not malicious. They would do better, they were listening and learning.

I am skeptical.

Core leaders for MIRI, Lighthaven and the community fetishistically prefer simulated rape. They are bound together by having hobbies and secrets in common. This seems to be an important form of social tie in this group. They promote their sexual interests and recruit for their sexual events so prominently because these are the things they care about and believe in. These people are some of the most influential, if not the most influential people in AI Safety.

This is too obscene to be taken seriously if stated flat. This is also why no one can just say it and be believed. It sounds like a conspiracy theory. That it sounds like a conspiracy theory serves as fantastic camouflage. They are brilliant at that sort of thing.

All of the main content of rationalism is a trick. Every time Yudkowsky’s writing explains some trick your brain can pull, it is the magician showing you his sleeves while he palms a card: it is meant to convince you that whatever trick he is about to do next is impossible, and to prevent you from figuring out how it was done or ever believing it had happened.38

What he has done is craft an atheist religion that worships and fears an omnicidal God, trusts him as its prophet, and that gives him immense power over its members and over members’ actions.

This belief system primarily causes people to do things they would refuse to do for any reason other than fear of the end of the world. Nothing that has happened in the movement is a coincidence; this appears to be the primary thing the belief system is for. Its other effects are, by comparison, negligible.

During my first go-round with this post, at about this point in its length, I mostly stopped sleeping, read a great many things I very much did not enjoy, and became quite unhappy with the general state of things in Berkeley and indeed with the concept that such a place as Berkeley or Lighthaven existed. In my haste to publish I possibly overextended parts of the analysis beyond what I was able to definitively prove.39

I withdraw the previous version of this article in its entirety.

Let us continue on to what I wish I had said instead.

First, Yudkowsky is a great man.

Great as in the Great Man of History theory, all of that. If he had not lived, the world would be very different.

You could very credibly write alternative universe science fiction for the last thirty years that simply subtracts him. You’ve removed or significantly altered DeepMind, half of the weird cranks, Sam Bankman-Fried. Hell, earlier: Many early cryptocurrency figures, like Hal Finney and Wei Dai, were regulars on Yudkowsky’s blog. Do they do different things without his influence, or without his movement to bring them all together? I have no idea. If you’re an author you can go wherever you want with that. It’s fine. You can bend history however you like by removing him; he has bent the entire trajectory of technology by his influence.

He is a person who sat down at a keyboard and simply decided things should happen, and they did. He sat down as a teenager in the nineties, did nothing but write, and in 2015 he was thirty-five years old and by far the most influential person in the field. There is little evidence he has ever written a computer program of any use or value. His math is rudimentary. In traditional academic terms, he is a popular philosopher.

He thought he could personally and directly retain oversight over the entire thing, and he almost could. He was involved in DeepMind’s founding and knew its leaders personally. All of this blew up when Sam Altman and Elon Musk simply walked away, and he has been trying to scrape back direct personal control ever since. Despite that, he is still by far the most influential person in the field, and a huge chunk of thinking is still his pseudoscience.40 When Sam wants to insult him he uses a backhanded compliment. When Dario wants to disagree with him he is afraid to name him.

This is an incredible achievement.

What he did was read usenet and science blogs for over a decade, read a few of the books they recommended, and then distill everything that was in the ether. This was a mixture of having done your reading as an undergraduate, some reprocessed Korzybski41 (who also influenced Hubbard), a half dozen transhumanist authors and the sorts of things people talked about but had not written down formally, or that were only written down in an article somewhere.

From these ingredients he wrote just one thing that let you skip the line, avoid doing any real reading or real education, and acquire maybe two thirds of the world view you would have as an excellent, well-read student in a science major, but with none of the specific skills you would have learned. For some people this fast track is the most exhilarating experience of their lives. Many of them become convinced Yudkowsky is the smartest person alive.

I am not convinced he is the smartest person alive because I had basically his same reading diet at the time and almost none of this was new to me. To me, he is a guy with a pretty good generalist blog that became a religion while I wasn’t paying attention, and a bit of a crank. I was there. It was just a science blog to me. I did not see it as an ideological project because I was not looking for that. Judged as an ideological project, it is vastly more impressive work.

If we judge his writing by its impact, by how much the world changes around you with every word you write, Yudkowsky’s last rival was Lenin. Every time you hear someone call their beliefs their “priors”, they kiss the ring. They generally do not know this. I am obsessive about the origins and meanings of words and ideas and Yudkowsky’s invented or popularized jargon is everywhere. It is like hearing people talk about how Gatorade is full of anti-Thetans.

He did this while writing a story about himself because everything Yudkowsky writes is about himself; his most distinctive authorial tell is that all of his writing, no matter what else it is about, is autobiographical. It is a story about how Eliezer Yudkowsky is the smartest and kindest person who ever lived, and he understands you.

All of this to say: I can assume that his writing is intended to influence people, and to cause them to do things, and it is well-calculated and good at doing this.

All of this cashes out into power, and that power is hidden in plain sight.

This power is hidden because HPMOR is an adolescent power fantasy. For the book or its ideas or its fandom to be important seems too absurd. It is hidden because it is silly and because it exploits our desire to tolerate the weird, to avoid sneering at anyone just because they’re unusual. People exploit this desire while openly exercising vast power over their followers and the world.

It is so obviously an adolescent power fantasy, is so obviously entertainment, childish, low culture, that it absolutely must be harmless. For anyone to say that this matters the same way that Scientology or Salafi Islam do, that this child’s power fantasy has real power in the real world, seems like a prank or the manifestation of mental illness.

It is simply impossible to take them seriously. They sound like edgy middle schoolers who read too much and who think they are too special. They directly talk about plotting world domination, they call their podcast a conspiracy. Who would do that? Of course it’s a joke.

Never mind that they can pull down millions in grants and investment money without question, that they have a hotel-turned-compound in Berkeley which hosts most notable AI safety conferences, that they were involved in founding nearly every major company and non-profit in AI.

No matter how big they are, how much money they spend lobbying the government, how many kids are taught in their camps, how ubiquitous they are in the tech industry, they are always too bizarre to be taken very seriously.

To connect the core people and their ideas to the global movement sounds paranoid, even when they share money, people and ideas clearly and openly. To connect the entire sprawling complex to its crimes, scandals and other failures is always too strange to seem credible even when the connection is direct.

It is scandalous to say that ten billion dollars of fraud was done for the cause, or that those who committed that fraud willingly went to prison for the cause. It is weird to note the proliferation of cults, one of them nationally famous and with a body count, or to notice how much journalism and how many popular videos the broader movement sponsors, or to notice that the exact same core people always end up advising politicians.

It is obscene and conspiratorial to state that this group of people preferentially recruits, promotes and funds people based upon their participation in a specific Berkeley polycule and its simulated rape orgy, and that this appears to either be or be very close to being the most important center of power in policy and in the AI industry.

The broader movement “contributed” to the board coup at OpenAI and put a half billion dollars into Anthropic. They hold their conferences in the building that Yudkowsky’s long-time associates run. Their ideology appears to have directly inspired an attempt on Sam Altman’s life.

All of this is unbelievable in spite of being completely in the open. I have smothered this article in screenshots and citations, it links back to years of media reporting about these same people, and probably half of the people who read this will decide it is simply too weird to be true.

This social camouflage is the primary way they are protected from outside scrutiny, and it is the trick they pull on their members, too. “I’m just a little low status guy” is not just their strategy for predation, it is their everything strategy, and it seems to work on everyone.

Everything seems harmless, everyone is friendly, and all of this is especially appealing to the young and to the neurodivergent. One of the minor apocryphal works is based on My Little Pony. People are taught that certain secrets are infohazards and that if they do not keep these secrets the world will end. (The naive tend to love jargon.) People are encouraged to fight everything out and to never agree to disagree.42

It is supposed to be a coincidence that groups of them often collapse into authoritarian mystery cults even though this directly reflects the movement’s teachings and matches the movement’s exact structure as a whole.

They have recruited thousands of the kindest and most naive nerds on the planet to prey on, to hire, to take money from, and to use as cover. They have all read the same power fantasy, and most of them seem to think that they’re in on it but most of them aren’t. Most of them are prey. They will swear up and down that the funny stories and odd subculture are unimportant and harmless. They really ought to know better, and if they didn’t make their choices based on raw trust they would.

If you are a smart or at all connected person and your area overlaps with tech, you know at least one of these people. They will generally stop talking to you if you say anything like the truth about the sex cult that, to this day, seems to rule Berkeley AI safety. They obey out of fear of the apocalypse, and to say that they do is a horrifying insult because it is true.

I previously believed there was some meaningful difference of opinion or independence from these people within the global Effective Altruist movement. I then watched one oddball rationalist (who won’t admit that he is one) stage his exit from Anthropic and call himself a whistleblower while agreeing with Anthropic’s CEO exactly. I saw the entire movement, most of the industry, and most prominent politicians in America all line up behind it.

This absurd tail really is wagging the whole dog. Power flows from these core people out to everyone, and fear keeps them all obedient.

All of this is poison, and in a sane world we’d be rid of it all.

Discussion about this post

Ready for more?