We are grateful for helpful comments from Brendon McConnell, John Eric Humphries, Jouko Verho, as well as participants at CostasFest, the Virtual Crime Economics Seminar, and the 16th Transatlantic Workshop on the Economics of Crime. While we did not design the experiment, this paper is based on a pre-analysis plan we wrote before being granted access to the data. The pre-analysis plan is available here: https://osf.io/37ps6/overview?view_only=a28b14af1f1443a8aa9efe1d09f0bb5c. Mikko Aaltonen's work was supported by the Research Council of Finland (grant number 367676). The views expressed herein are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Bureau of Economic Research.