Incident #210
Status
Complete, one action item outstanding.
Summary
Sentinel consumed by wolf after repeated false alarms.
Impact
Loss of sentinel. No flock impact.
Root causes
Sentinel generated noisy alerts due to premature deployment, incomplete training, and overly monotonous task. Oncalls failed to respond to true positive due to alert fatigue.
Trigger
Wolf.
Resolution
Gathered flock. Deployed replacement sentinel.
Detection
Sentinel did not report at end of shift.
Action Items
| Priority | Action Item | Type | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | Gather flock | mitigate | complete |
| P0 | Deploy replacement sentinel | mitigate | complete |
| P1 | Update playbook for wolf alerts | prevent | complete |
| P2 | Update remaining sentinels | prevent | complete |
| P2 | Revise sentinel training program | prevent | complete |
| P2 | Investigate equipping sentinels with flutes or slings | prevent | in progress |
Lessons Learned
What went well
- Flock gathering proceeded without issues.
- No flock injuries or losses.
- Replacement sentinel did not exhibit false positive alerts.
What went wrong
- Noisy alerts not addressed.
- Alerts silenced contrary to playbook.
- Loss of sentinel.
Where we got lucky
- Only one wolf.
- Wolf sated after sentinel consumption.
- Replacement sentinel available.
Timeline
All times local
March 3rd:
- 16:32 Oncalls paged "wolf".
- 16:34 First oncall arrives at sentinel location.
- 16:34 Alert diagnosed as false positive. No corrective action performed.
March 4th:
- 14:15 Oncalls paged "wolf".
- 14:19 First oncall arrives at sentinel location.
- 14:19 Alert diagnosed as false positive. No corrective action performed.
March 5th:
- 17:03 (Reconstructed) Outage begins, sentinel notices wolf.
- 17:03 Oncalls paged "wolf".
- 17:04 Oncalls paged "wolf".
- 17:04 Oncalls paged "real wolf".
- 17:05 (Reconstructed) Wolf consumes sentinel.
- 18:45 Sentinel does not report at end of shift.
- 19:05 Primary oncall dispatched to field.
- 19:10 Oncall diagnoses issue.
- 19:10 Incident begins, secondary and tertiary oncalls paged.
- 19:15 First sheep located.
- 19:52 Last sheep located.
- 20:05 Flock safe in pens.
- 20:05 Outage ends, flock protection fully restored.
- 20:45 Replacement sentinel identified.
March 6th:
- 07:38 Replacement sentinel deployed
- 18:45 Replacement sentinel reports at end of shift
- 18:45 Incident ends, 24hr without wolf alerts or activity (exit criterion).
Comment via: facebook, lesswrong, hacker news, mastodon, substack
Recent posts on blogs I like:
American effective altruists should probably donate to political candidates
My recommendation for donors who are American citizens or permanent residents is that they donate directly to high-value political candidates.
via Thing of Things December 28, 2025
Opinionated takes on parenting
This post is a collection of parenting takes that sometimes go through my head, based on my experience raising our two boys (5 and 2 years old). All of this is based on my experience and might not apply to others (see the law of equal and opposite advice)…
via Victoria Krakovna December 16, 2025
How to Make a Christmas Wreath
Yesterday, I made a Christmas wreath. Here's how to make one. First, find an evergreen tree near your house. Clip off a few branches from the tree. Try to have as many leaves or needles on the branches as possible. Next, bring them home. What I usu…
via Anna Wise's Blog Posts December 6, 2025