All change for Gmail
NurPhoto via Getty Images
Updated on Apr. 10 as Google announces a major new update which plays directly into the critical decision now facing its users.
Google has confirmed its users may face overwhelming decisions as the tech giant releases its biggest ever upgrades to Gmail and the other platforms they use daily. While changing long-standing email addresses may drive headlines, the real change is very different and 2 billion users must take it much more seriously.
We’re talking AI and Google’s relentless progam of upgrades as Gemini is stitched ever more tightly into its platforms. “There’s a lot going on in AI these days,” Gmail’s VP of product, Blake Barnes, acknowledged in a new update for Gmail users via a YouTube short. “Sometimes it might even feel overwhelming.”
Gmail has never been at the forefront of user privacy and security. It’s a platform promoted on features, convenience and scale, as well as integration with Google’s other products. Its spam and malware filters are good, albeit far from infallible. But no one turns to Gmail for its privacy and security credentials.
ForbesIf You Keep Secrets On Your iPhone, Change This Setting Now
Gemini changes the game. Putting aside the question of whether it trains its AI on user emails, “short answer, no,” Barnes says, there are clear privacy trade-offs in having cloud-based AI compose, reply, summarize or smart search through inboxes that likely contain a raft of private, sensitive and confidential data.
“Think about Gemini as a personal and proactive assistant that comes to you," Barnes says. "It’s kind of like inviting Gemini into a private room with your inbox there," and when you’re done, “Gemini leaves the room, and with it, all information about your inbox evaporates. It dissolves. Gemini doesn’t learn your secrets."
While Google was quick to deny reports suggesting it automatically opted Gmail users into AI data training, new Gemini features are likely on by default. Gmail’s 2 billion users need to decide how much AI analysis they want applied to their inbox, whether or not Gemini really does forget what it has seen as easily as claimed.
“You place a ton of trust with Gmail with your personal information. And that’s a responsibility that we take very seriously,” Barnes says. “Your inbox is your business. It’s our job just to make the tools to help you manage it effectively.”
And manage it effectively you must do. That means the normal user inertia should not apply. Because once AI crawls into your life, it’s hard to remove. You have been warned and you must act now. Don’t leave this until it’s too late.
Hours after Google’s new Gmail promo, the platform was disrupted. Per Android Authority, “some Gmail users are currently experiencing delays with sending and receiving emails. Google says it is aware of the problem and is working on a fix.”
While there was no ETA on that fix when the warnings were first issued on Apr. 8, later in the day “Google stated that it has rolled out a fix for the issue delaying the sending and receiving of emails.”
Google updated its Workspace page to confirm “the issue with Gmail has been resolved for all affected users as of Wednesday, 2026-04-08 14:49 PDT. Our engineering team identified a potential issue with a noisy neighbor and has successfully mitigated impact.”
Gmail has 2 billion users, which makes any disruption to its service a headline issue. It’s also why the AI decision now facing all those users is critical. While it was a “noisy neighbor” affecting the platform this week, Google wants you to see Gemini as a well-behaved house guest. But as ever with guests, you need to set some rules.
Meanwhile, the crux of the wider decision for Gmail users is the balance of convenience and security, to what extent are users comfortable in allowing Google’s cloud-based AI to pore over their inboxes, their unread and unsent emails. Google’s latest promo assures that Gemini comes and goes as needed. it doesn’t overstep. It doesn’t intrude. It’s a trusted guest with whom you should feel comfortable.
But clearly sharing your private emails and other data with any cloud-based service carries risk. Yes, the spectre of AI training on user data is worse, and that’s why Google has been so quick to clarify its stance. But sharing the data at all is a risk.
I’ve commented multiple times on the dilemma for Google in pushing Gmail’s security and AI credentials at the same time. They don’t easily mix. In fact, they conflict. And now again we have a clear illustration of how that manifests.
The same week Google issued its Gemini safety assurance, it also announced “we’re expanding Gmail end-to-end encryption (E2EE) to Android and iOS devices for Gmail client-side encryption (CSE) users.”
First, this isn’t really end-to-end encryption in the way you think of messaging and other apps, the client-side security sits at the enterprise level and is not specific to your device. More critically, though, encrypting Gmail in this way stops many of its AI tools working, because (rightly) they cannot see through the encryption.
All the reasons that Google and others laud full encryption as the best way to secure user data are reasons to be wary of letting AI loose on that data. Google’s new Gmail announcement is useful as it presents those two sides of the equation.
ForbesIran’s Hackers Expose Israel’s ‘Top-Secret Facilities’ In New AttackBy Zak Doffman
To put this into perspective, here’s Google’s list of restrictions; "when additional encryption is turned on, these features are not available:
- Confidential mode
- Delegated accounts
- Email layouts
- Multi-send mode
- Proposing meeting times
- Pop-out and full-screen compose
- Sending to Groups as recipients
- Email signatures
- Emojis
- Google AI products
- Smart features for Gmail
- Screen recording on mobile devices
- Screenshots on Android mobile devices."
That list is the perfect way to highlight the security versus convenience decision. Email is not an inherently secure technology. Its archaic architecture is in need of a wholesale rethink. And so for 2 billion users, perhaps the best decision is to be way of anything sent over email and use other platforms for anything sensitive.