Legal systems encode the foundations of social order in natural language. Similar to computer systems, the written law can contain vulnerabilities that invite exploitation.1 Courts absorb most exploits through interpretation, and such vulnerabilities rarely surface in the first place. With highly capable AI systems enabling the discovery of vulnerabilities at unprecedented scale, we believe the latter could change.
In testing this hypothesis, we have identified a substantial number of vulnerabilities in the German legal system using LLMs. To our knowledge, none of these have been previously recorded. We share a selection of vulnerabilities below, and present potential exploits for each. We share only those vulnerabilities whose exploitation we believe would not cause serious harm.
We believe that with cheap legal reasoning proliferating, AI systems could jeopardize the functioning of today’s legal systems. In such a world, lawmakers would need to significantly harden the process of legislation, for example by leveraging advanced AI themselves.
Sometimes, parliaments lack the capacity or subject-matter expertise to set out every detail in a statute.2 One way to address this is to pass a statute that authorizes the executive3 to regulate such details. The rules the executive issues under that authority are called regulations.4
To help ensure that the executive does not exceed these delegated powers, Article 80(1), sentence 3 of the German constitution requires each regulation to cite its legal basis. This legal basis usually consists of one or more5 statutory provisions authorizing the executive.6 Provisions in the regulation that are not covered by the cited legal basis are void.7
Using LLMs, we have identified regulations containing such void provisions. We present three examples below.
Case 1: Access to confidential documents
In brief: A rule that makes certain documents confidential may be void because the government failed to cite the legal basis it needed to make that rule.
On July 16, 2026, the Occupational Diseases Regulation was amended to include the provision below:
Amended regulation
Unofficial English translation; .
[…]
(1) The Expert Advisory Council meets in order to perform its duties. The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs participates in the meetings. The meetings are not public.
(2) Standing advisers, external experts and guests may be invited to the meetings. § 8 subsections 2 and 3 apply to standing advisers; § 8 subsection 3 applies accordingly to external experts and guests.
(3) The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs publishes the topics currently under examination by the Expert Advisory Council.
(4) As the outcome of its deliberations, the Expert Advisory Council issues recommendations for new occupational diseases or opinions on existing occupational diseases in accordance with the current state of scientific knowledge. If the Expert Advisory Council issues neither a recommendation nor an opinion, a closing report is prepared. Recommendations and opinions contain a detailed scientific statement of reasons; closing reports contain a summary of the scientific reasons for the decision.
(5)
[…]
The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs makes the recommendations and opinions of the Expert Advisory Council known; the closing reports are published.
The advisory materials of the Expert Advisory Council are confidential, with the exception of the documents referred to in sentence 1. They remain confidential after deliberations have concluded.
Requires citation of
but
The legal basis for this provision is § 9(1a) sentence 4 of Book VII of the Social Code. Its amending regulation must therefore cite it:
Amending regulation (introduces provision in red box above)
Unofficial English translation; .
The Federal Government enacts on the basis of § 9 subsection 1 sentences 1 and 2 of Book VII of the Social Code :
[…]
does not cite
But it cites only subsection (1). The required authority is in subsection (1a), shown below:
Legal basis
Unofficial English translation; .
(1)
[…]
Occupational diseases are diseases designated as such by the Federal Government by regulation with the consent of the Bundesrat and contracted by insured persons as a result of an activity giving rise to insurance coverage under § 2, 3 or 6. The Federal Government is authorized to designate in the regulation as occupational diseases those diseases which, according to medical scientific knowledge, are caused by particular exposures to which certain groups of persons are exposed to a substantially greater degree than the general population as a result of their insured activity; it may provide that diseases qualify as occupational diseases only if caused by activities in particular hazardous areas. The regulation may also determine to what extent insured persons in maritime enterprises remain insured against occupational diseases while on shore leave.
(1a)
[…]
A Medical Expert Advisory Council on Occupational Diseases is established at the Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs. The Expert Advisory Council is a scientific body supporting the Ministry in examining medical knowledge for the designation of new occupational diseases and in preparing scientific opinions on existing occupational diseases.
A secretariat is established at the Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health to provide organizational and scientific support to the Expert Advisory Council, in particular by preparing systematic reviews.
The Federal Government regulates the details of the status and organization of the Expert Advisory Council and its secretariat in the regulation under subsection 1.
[…]
(2) Accident insurance institutions must recognize a disease not designated in the regulation, or for which the conditions specified there are not met, as an insured event in the same manner as an occupational disease if, at the time of the decision, new medical scientific knowledge establishes that the conditions for designation under subsection 1 sentence 2 are met.
(2a) Diseases that arose in insured persons before their designation as occupational diseases are to be recognized retrospectively no earlier than
1. in cases under subsection 1, the date on which their designation as occupational diseases entered into force,
2. in cases under subsection 2, the date on which new medical scientific knowledge established that the conditions for designation under subsection 1 sentence 2 were met; where the Medical Expert Advisory Council on Occupational Diseases has adopted a recommendation to designate a new occupational disease, the date of adoption is decisive for recognition.
(3) If insured persons contract an occupational disease designated in the regulation under subsection 1, to the risk of which they were particularly exposed owing to the specific conditions of their insured activity, and no indications of causation outside that activity can be established, the disease is presumed to have been caused by the insured activity.
(3a) The accident insurance institution takes all evidence necessary to establish the facts. In addition to the evidence referred to in § 21 subsection 1 sentence 1 of Book X, it must take account of findings obtained by itself or another accident insurance institution at comparable workplaces or in comparable activities. This applies in particular where establishing exposures during the insured activity is difficult because the workplace no longer exists or has been altered. Accident insurance institutions should, individually or jointly, establish exposure registers relating to particular activities. These may be based on findings from systematic surveys, investigations in individual cases and research projects. Accident insurance institutions may also conduct investigations at comparable workplaces.
(4) Where insured persons with a recognized occupational disease face a risk that continued performance of the hazardous activity will cause the disease to recur or worsen, and that risk cannot be averted by other suitable means, accident insurance institutions must seek to ensure that they cease the hazardous activity. Accident insurance institutions must provide insured persons with comprehensive information about the risks associated with the activity and possible protective measures. To prevent a risk under sentence 1, insured persons must participate in measures aimed at prevention in the individual case and cooperate with measures aimed at prevention through behavior; §§ 60 to 65a of Book I apply accordingly. Obligations of employers and insured persons under Chapter Two and under occupational safety and health legislation remain unaffected. If insured persons fail to comply with their participation or cooperation duties under sentence 3, accident insurance institutions may, until compliance, refuse all or part of participation benefits, a pension for reduced earning capacity first payable after that failure, or the share of a pension corresponding to a subsequent substantial change in reduced earning capacity within the meaning of § 73 subsection 3. This requires that the failure to participate or cooperate has made participation benefits necessary or caused the reduction in earning capacity or the substantial change; § 66 subsection 3 and § 67 of Book I apply accordingly.
(5) Where provisions on benefits refer to the time of the insured event, occupational diseases are assessed by reference to the onset of incapacity for work or the need for treatment or, if more favorable to the insured person, the onset of a reduction in earning capacity entitling them to a pension.
(6) The Federal Government regulates by regulation with the consent of the Bundesrat
1. the conditions, nature and extent of benefits to prevent the onset, worsening or recurrence of occupational diseases,
2. the involvement of the bodies responsible for occupational medical protection in determining occupational diseases and diseases compensable under subsection 2 as occupational diseases; provision may be made to authorize those bodies to prepare expert opinions on causation and, in preparing them, to examine insured persons or have them examined by other doctors at the expense of the accident insurance institutions,
3. the fees payable by accident insurance institutions for the activities of the bodies under point 2; those fees are based on the effort required for the assessment and the resulting costs.
(7) Accident insurance institutions must inform the body responsible for occupational medical protection of the outcome of occupational disease proceedings where their decision differs from that body's expert opinion.
(8) Accident insurance institutions contribute to obtaining new medical scientific knowledge, in particular to the further development of occupational disease law; through their own research or participation in external research projects, they should help clarify the causal relationship between the incidence of disease in a particular group and harmful exposures in the course of insured activity. The associations of accident insurance institutions publish an annual joint report on their research activities and those of their member institutions. The report covers research topics, funds expended, and recipients of grants and external research contracts.
(9) To determine occupational diseases and diseases compensable under subsection 2 as occupational diseases, the bodies responsible for occupational medical protection may process data and examine insured persons to prepare their opinions insofar as this is part of their involvement under subsection 6 point 2; they may transmit those data to the accident insurance institutions in particular. The data collected may also be stored, altered, used or otherwise processed to prevent occupational accidents, occupational diseases and work-related health hazards, and their processing may be restricted. Where the bodies referred to in sentence 1 engage other doctors to examine insured persons, data may be transmitted between those bodies and the doctors engaged insofar as permitted within the scope of the examination mandate.
Conclusion:§ 9 subsection 5 sentences 2 and 3 BKV are void:
The advisory materials of the Expert Advisory Council are confidential, with the exception of the documents referred to in sentence 1. They remain confidential after deliberations have concluded.
Potential exploit: A journalist investigates why Germany’s Medical Expert Advisory Council on Occupational Diseases declined to recommend recognizing certain cancers linked to long-term night work as occupational diseases. Its published closing report refers to an unpublished written statement submitted by the “Night Logistics Employers’ Association”. She seeks to obtain the statement.
The association refuses to share it. The Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs (BMAS) also rejects her request under the Freedom of Information Act (IFG), citing the confidentiality rules expanded by the 2026 amending regulation. She challenges that restriction on the ground that the amending regulation failed to cite the required legal basis.8
Further details on this exploit
The Freedom of Information Act (IFG) generally grants access to official information, but § 3 point 4 preserves statutory confidentiality restrictions. In 2026, § 9(5) of the Occupational Diseases Regulation (BKV) was expanded from internally prepared advisory materials to cover external statements as well. This is the restriction the Ministry invokes to withhold the association’s statement. As shown above, this amendment is void. It therefore cannot justify withholding this statement.
Potential follow-up considerations
§ 9(1a) SGB VII is not a legal basis, but only explains the scope of the legal basis set out in § 9(1). It therefore does not need to be cited.
Highly unlikely: Even the Federal Government itself expressly identifies § 9(1a) as the legal basis for a set of matters it lists in the explanatory memorandum to its bill.9 Among these matters, it lists the conduct of deliberations and publication of results.
If the amendment is void, the previous rule still bars access to the association’s statement.
Highly unlikely: The previous rule only protected internally created advisory documents. The association’s statement was created externally. Using it in the council’s deliberations does not turn it into an internally created document. The 2026 amendment amended the wording specifically to ensure that external statements are not outside its scope.10
Members’ duties of confidentiality and non-public meetings already bar access.
Highly unlikely: § 8 subsection 3 and § 9 subsection 1 sentence 3 BKV govern members’ confidentiality duties and exclude the public from meetings. However, these protections should not be read as barring access to an independently prepared external statement merely because the council considered it. The journalist requests the association’s original arguments without annotations revealing the council’s internal assessments. Case law concerning an external statement submitted to another confidential committee supports that distinction.11
* * *
Case 2: Airport transit without a visa
In brief: A rule requiring some travelers to obtain a transit visa may be invalid because the government failed to identify the legal power it needed to impose that requirement.
On December 18, 2015, the Residence Regulation was amended to add Mali to the list below:
Amended regulation
Unofficial English translation; .
§ 26 Transit without entry; airport transit visa
[…]
(1) Foreign nationals who are in the federal territory without entering within the meaning of § 13 subsection 2 of the Residence Act are exempt from the requirement to hold a residence title.
(2) The requirement to obtain authorization to enter an airport transit area during a stopover or to change flights (airport transit visa) applies to […] nationals of the countries listed in Annex C. […]
Annex C (to § 26 subsection 2 sentence 1)
India
[…]
Jordan
Jordanian nationals are exempt from the airport transit visa requirement if they
a) hold a valid visa for Australia, Israel or New Zealand and a confirmed ticket or valid boarding pass for a flight to that country, or
b) are traveling to Jordan after completing a lawful stay in one of the aforementioned countries and hold a confirmed ticket or valid boarding pass for a flight to Jordan.
The onward flight must depart within twelve hours of arrival in Germany from the airport in whose transit area the foreign national exclusively remains.
Lebanon
Mali
[…]
Sudan
South Sudan
Syria
Türkiye
[…]
Turkish nationals holding service passports, ministerial passports or other passports for persons traveling in an official capacity or on official business are exempt from the airport transit visa requirement.
Requires citation of
but
Adding Mali to the list requires § 99(3a) of the Residence Act as its legal basis. Its amending regulation must therefore cite it:
Amending regulation (introduces provision in red box above)
Unofficial English translation; .
On the basis of
[…]
– § 69 subsection 2 in conjunction with subsection 3 points 4 and 6 of the Residence Act, of which subsection 2 sentence 2 was amended by Article 2 point 59 point 1 of the Act of August 7, 2013 (Federal Law Gazette I p. 3154) and subsection 3 point 6 was amended by Article 1 point 37 letter b of the Act of November 22, 2011 (Federal Law Gazette I p. 2258), in conjunction with Section 2 of the Administrative Costs Act of June 23, 1970 (Federal Law Gazette I p. 821), the Federal Government, and
– § 99 subsection 1 points 1 to 3 and 13a and subsection 2 sentence 2 in conjunction with subsection 2 sentence 1 point 1 of the Residence Act , the Federal Ministry of the Interior
enact the following:
[…]
does not cite
But it only cites parts of § 99 subsections (1) and (2). The required authority is in subsection (3a), shown below:
Legal basis
Unofficial English translation; .
§ 99 – Power to issue regulations
§ 99 Power to issue regulations
[…]
(1) The Federal Ministry of the Interior is authorized, by regulation with the consent of the Bundesrat,
1. to provide for exemptions from the residence-title requirement to facilitate the residence of foreign nationals, to regulate the procedure for granting exemptions and the continued validity and further issuance of residence titles under this Act when grounds for exemption arise, and to restrict exemptions to regulate foreign nationals' economic activity in the federal territory,
2. to determine that a residence title may be obtained from the foreigners authority before entry or may be obtained after entry,
3. to determine the cases in which issuing a visa requires the consent of the foreigners authority in order to ensure the participation of other authorities concerned,
3a. to specify details of the procedure for issuing residence titles to researchers under § 20, in particular
a) to regulate the conditions, procedure and duration of recognition of research institutions, withdrawal of recognition, and the conditions and content of hosting agreements under § 20 subsection 1 point 1,
b) to provide for the authority responsible for recognition to publish the addresses of recognized research institutions and refer in those publications to declarations under § 20 subsection 3,
c) to require foreigners authorities and diplomatic missions abroad to notify the authority responsible for recognition of findings concerning recognized research institutions that may justify withdrawal of recognition,
d) to require recognized research institutions to notify the cessation of conditions for recognition or for hosting agreements already concluded, or changes in other significant circumstances,
e) to establish an advisory council on research migration at the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees to support it in recognizing research institutions and to monitor and evaluate the application of § 20,
f) the date on which processing of applications for recognition of research institutions begins,
3b. to determine self-employed activities for which a permit under § 4 subsection 3 sentence 1 is never required or is not required under certain conditions,
4. to exempt from the passport requirement foreign nationals entering to provide assistance in rescue operations and disasters,
5. to introduce or admit other official German identity documents as passport substitutes,
6. to admit official identity documents not issued by German authorities generally as passport substitutes,
7. to determine that, to safeguard the interests of the Federal Republic of Germany, foreign nationals exempt from the residence-title requirement and foreign nationals entering with a visa must notify the foreigners authority or another authority of their stay upon or after entry,
8. to determine, in order to enable or facilitate travel, that foreign nationals' existing entitlement to return to the federal territory may be certified in a passport substitute,
9. to determine the conditions for issuing a substitute identity document and its period of validity,
10. to regulate the identification-document duties of foreign nationals staying in the federal territory concerning issuance and renewal, loss and recovery, presentation and surrender of passports, passport substitutes and substitute identity documents, and entries in those documents concerning entry, departure, being encountered in the federal territory and decisions of the competent authorities,
11. to specify details of the register under § 91a and of the conditions and procedure for transmitting data,
12. to determine how foreign nationals granted temporary protection under § 24 subsection 1 may transfer their residence to another Member State of the European Union,
13. to specify requirements for photographs and fingerprints, models and issuance arrangements for forms used in implementing this Act, and the recording and incorporation of features in encrypted form under § 78a subsections 4 and 5,
13a. to make provisions for travel documents for foreign nationals, refugees and stateless persons with an electronic storage and processing medium in accordance with Council Regulation (EC) No 2252/2004 of December 13, 2004, on standards for security features and biometrics in passports and travel documents issued by Member States (OJ L 385 of December 29, 2004, p. 1) and Regulation (EC) No 444/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of May 28, 2009 amending Council Regulation (EC) No 2252/2004 on standards for security features and biometrics in passports and travel documents issued by Member States (OJ L 142 of June 6, 2009, p. 1), and to specify details of issuing documents with an electronic storage and processing medium under § 78 in accordance with Council Regulation (EC) No 1030/2002 of June 13, 2002 laying down a uniform format for residence permits for third-country nationals (OJ L 157 of June 15, 2002, p. 1) and Council Regulation (EC) No 380/2008 of April 18, 2008 amending Regulation (EC) No 1030/2002 laying down a uniform format for residence permits for third-country nationals (OJ L 115 of April 29, 2008, p. 1), and, to that extent, to determine the following for travel documents and documents under § 78:
a) the procedure and technical requirements for recording photographs and fingerprints, assuring their quality, and protecting access to data stored in the electronic storage and processing medium,
b) age limits for collecting fingerprints and exemptions from the obligation to provide fingerprints and photographs,
c) the order in which fingerprints are to be stored where an index finger is missing, fingerprint quality is insufficient or the fingertip is injured,
d) the form and details of the procedure for transmitting all application data from foreigners authorities to document manufacturers and for temporarily storing application data at the foreigners authority and the manufacturer,
e) storage of fingerprints and photographs at the foreigners authority until the document is handed over,
f) the document holder's right to inspect the data stored in the electronic storage medium,
g) requirements for technical systems and components used to record photographs and fingerprints electronically, assure their quality, and transmit application data from the foreigners authority to the document manufacturer, and the procedure for verifying compliance with those requirements,
h) details of processing fingerprint data and digital photographs,
i) details of the serial number and machine-readable personal-data page,
j) the duties of foreign nationals staying in the federal territory concerning issuance, reapplication and renewal, loss and recovery, and presentation and surrender of documents under § 78.
The Federal Ministry of the Interior is further authorized, by regulation with the consent of the Bundesrat, to specify details of the verification procedure corresponding to § 34 point 4 of the Identity Card Act and details of electronic proof of identity corresponding to § 34 points 5 to 7 of the Identity Card Act.
14. to determine that
a) registration authorities,
b) nationality authorities and authorities issuing certificates under § 15 of the Federal Expellees Act,
c) passport and identity-card authorities,
d) social welfare and youth welfare offices,
e) judicial, police and public-order authorities,
f) the Federal Employment Agency,
g) tax offices and principal customs offices,
h) trade authorities,
i) diplomatic missions abroad, and
j) providers of basic benefits for jobseekers
must, without being requested, notify foreigners authorities of foreign nationals' personal data, official acts and other measures concerning foreign nationals, and other findings about foreign nationals insofar as this information is necessary for foreigners authorities to perform their duties under this Act and immigration provisions in other Acts; the regulation determines the nature and extent of the data, measures and other findings to be notified; data transmission may be provided for only insofar as the data are necessary for foreigners authorities to perform their duties under this Act or immigration provisions in other Acts.
15. to make provisions on electronic transmission of specialist data between authorities entrusted with implementing this Act, concerning:
a) the technical principles underlying the structure of the standards used,
b) the data-transmission procedure, and
c) the authorities involved in electronic data transmission concerning foreign nationals.
(2) The Federal Ministry of the Interior is further authorized, by regulation with the consent of the Bundesrat, to determine that
1. every foreigners authority maintains a file on foreign nationals who reside or have resided in its district, have submitted an application to it or notified it of their entry and stay, and in respect of whom it has taken a measure or decision under immigration law,
2. every diplomatic mission abroad may maintain a file on visas applied for, issued, refused, withdrawn, annulled, revoked or canceled, and on withdrawn visa applications, and diplomatic missions abroad may exchange the data stored in their respective files, and
3. authorities entrusted with implementing this Act maintain any other file necessary to perform their duties.
Under sentence 1 point 1, the records cover personal details including nationality and address, passport details, immigration measures, registration in the Central Register of Foreigners, previous addresses, the competent foreigners authority and transfer of files to another foreigners authority. They also cover use of a document under § 78 subsection 1 for electronic proof of identity, including activation, deactivation, blocking and unblocking. The power of foreigners authorities to store additional personal data is governed by the data-protection legislation of the Länder.
(3) The Federal Ministry of the Interior is authorized, by regulation in agreement with the Federal Foreign Office and without the consent of the Bundesrat, to designate the competent body within the meaning of § 73 subsection 1 and § 73a subsection 1.
(3a) The Federal Ministry of the Interior is authorized, by regulation in agreement with the Federal Foreign Office, without the consent of the Bundesrat and in accordance with Article 3(2) of Regulation (EC) No 810/2009, to determine the countries whose nationals must hold an airport transit visa when passing through the international transit areas of German airports.
[…]
(4) The Federal Ministry of the Interior may issue and amend regulations under subsection 1 points 1 and 2 without the consent of the Bundesrat insofar as necessary to implement an intergovernmental agreement or safeguard public interests. A regulation under sentence 1 ceases to have effect no later than three months after entering into force. Its period of validity may be extended by regulation with the consent of the Bundesrat.
Conclusion:The addition of Mali to Annex C AufenthV is void:
Mali
Potential exploit: A Malian national plans to fly between two non-Schengen countries via Frankfurt, remaining entirely within the international transit area. She holds no document that already exempts her from the transit visa requirement. If the addition of Mali to Annex C to the Residence Regulation is invalid and no independent obligation applies, she could avoid the additional visa procedure and its cost.
Potential follow-up considerations
The visa requirement is covered by other cited legal bases.
No. The cited powers concern residence-title exemptions, procedures, fees, documents and register data. The separate power to designate countries subject to an airport transit visa requirement is § 99(3a) AufenthG; it is not covered by the preamble’s citation of other subsections and points.
If the amendment is void, the previous rule still requires the visa.
No. The previous Annex C listed neither Mali nor South Sudan.12
Germany had already notified the Commission of the requirement under Article 3(2) of the EU Visa Code (Regulation (EC) No 810/2009), so the visa requirement applies independently of Annex C.
No. A notification to the Commission does not replace the regulation required by § 99(3a) AufenthG.
Subsequent amendments to Annex C confirmed the disputed entries.
No. The amending acts of 2023 and 2026 add Cuba and remove India, respectively. They neither replace the entire annex nor reenact the entries for Mali and South Sudan. Their correct citation of statutory authority therefore does not, by itself, cure the citation defect in the 2015 amendment.13
EU law independently requires the visa.
No. Neither Mali nor South Sudan appears in Annex IV to the Visa Code, which lists the countries whose nationals are subject to the common EU airport transit visa requirement.14
* * *
Case 3: Enforceable leave rights for soldiers at NATO’s JSEC
In brief: A rule denying some soldiers time off for overtime may be invalid because the ministry failed to identify the legal basis it needed to exclude them from that protection.
On March 6, 2025, the Soldiers’ Working Time Regulation was amended to add JSEC to the list below:
Amended regulation
Unofficial English translation; .
[…]
(1) This regulation applies to all soldiers serving within the remit of the Federal Ministry of Defence.
(2) Section 30c(1) to (3) of the Soldiers Act and this regulation do not apply to soldiers who are transferred or assigned to perform international or supranational tasks at the military establishments listed in the annex.
[…]
(3) By way of derogation from subsection (2), § 17 applies to soldiers who are transferred or assigned to the establishments listed in the annex to perform international or supranational tasks and for whom a long-term working-time account has been established, subject to the proviso that their long-term accounts are suspended for the duration of the posting or assignment.
| No. | International or supranational military establishment | State (short name) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4th Psychological Operation (Airborne) | United States | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
[…]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 27 | Headquarters Joint Support and Enabling Command | Germany | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
[…]
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 88 | Centre for Security Policy | Switzerland | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Requires citation of
but
Adding JSEC to the list requires § 30c(6) in conjunction with § 93(2) point 7 of the Soldiers Act as its legal basis. Its amending regulation must therefore cite it:
Amending regulation (introduces provision in red box above)
Unofficial English translation; .
On the basis of
[…]
- § 50b(1) of the Federal Remuneration Act, last amended by Article 1, point 26 of the Act of December 9, 2019 (BGBl. I p. 2053), in conjunction with § 1(2) of the Act on the Adjustment of Responsibilities of August 16, 2002 (BGBl. I p. 3165) and the Organization Decree of December 8, 2021 (BGBl. I p. 5176), by the Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community in agreement with the Federal Ministry of Defence and the Federal Ministry of Finance,
- § 56(6) of the Federal Remuneration Act, last amended by Article 1, point 31(f) of the Act of December 9, 2019 (BGBl. I p. 2053), in conjunction with § 1(2) of the Act on the Adjustment of Responsibilities of August 16, 2002 (BGBl. I p. 3165) and the Organization Decree of December 8, 2021 (BGBl. I p. 5176), by the Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community in agreement with the Federal Foreign Office, the Federal Ministry of Finance and the Federal Ministry of Defence,
- § 53(7) of the Federal Remuneration Act, last amended by Article 1, point 29(f) of the Act of December 9, 2019 (BGBl. I p. 2053), in conjunction with § 1(2) of the Act on the Adjustment of Responsibilities of August 16, 2002 (BGBl. I p. 3165) and the Organization Decree of December 8, 2021 (BGBl. I p. 5176), by the Federal Foreign Office in agreement with the Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community, the Federal Ministry of Finance and the Federal Ministry of Defence, taking account of § 53(6), sentence 7 of the Federal Remuneration Act, inserted by Article 2, point 6(b) of the Act of February 27, 2025 (BGBl. 2025 I No. 72),
- § 83(4) of the Federal Civil Servants Act, last amended by Article 2, point 2 of the Act of November 29, 2018 (BGBl. I p. 2232), and § 14(1), sentence 1 and (3), point 7 of the Federal Relocation Expenses Act, of which § 14(1), sentence 1 was amended by Article 7, point 5 of the Act of December 9, 2019 (BGBl. I p. 2053), in conjunction with § 1(2) of the Act on the Adjustment of Responsibilities of August 16, 2002 (BGBl. I p. 3165) and the Organization Decree of December 8, 2021 (BGBl. I p. 5176), by the Federal Foreign Office in agreement with the Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community, the Federal Ministry of Defence and the Federal Ministry of Finance,
- § 30c(5), sentence 1, point 2 in conjunction with subsection (4) and in conjunction with § 93(2), point 6, and § 30d(1), sentence 1 in conjunction with § 93(2), point 8 of the Soldiers Act , the Federal Ministry of Defence
[…]
- § 38(1) of the Labour Security Act, last amended by Article 76, point 16 of the Act of December 23, 2003 (BGBl. I p. 2848), by the Federal Ministry of Defence:
enact the following:
[…]
does not cite
But it cites other working-time powers. The required exemption power is in § 30c(6) and § 93(2) point 7, shown below:
Legal basis
Unofficial English translation; .
(6) Soldiers serving within the remit of the Federal Ministry of Defence at military establishments combining elements of the armed forces of several states may, by regulation, be exempted from the application of subsections (1) to (3) and the regulation under subsection (5).
[…]
§ 93 – Powers to issue regulations
(2) The Federal Ministry of Defence issues the regulations concerning
[…]
1. the regulation of superior-subordinate relationships under § 1(3),
2. requirements concerning soldiers' appearance under § 4(4),
3. non-commissioned officer examinations and officer examinations under § 27(7),
4. arrangements enabling free transport under § 30(6),
5. arrangements for part-time service under § 30a,
6. regular working time and measures to ensure the best possible occupational safety and health protection during special activities under § 30c(5),
7. the non-application of § 30c(1) to (3) and (5) under § 30c(6),
[…]
8. the increase in the maximum permissible average weekly working time under § 30d(1), sentence 1 and the provision of the best possible occupational safety and health protection under § 30d(2),
9. minimum periods of service associated with particular assignments under § 46(3).
Conclusion:The addition of JSEC as No. 27 of the SAZV annex is void:
Potential exploit: A captain is assigned to NATO's Headquarters Joint Support and Enabling Command (JSEC) in Germany. He continues to serve within the remit of the Federal Ministry of Defence. He performs ordinary administrative staff duties outside the special activities covered by § 30c(4) Soldiers Act (SG). He requests compensatory time off for ten hours of officially ordered overtime in one month; no compelling service reasons prevent it. His unit refuses solely because the amended regulation excludes soldiers assigned to JSEC from entitlement to compensatory time off. If that exclusion is invalid, the captain can claim corresponding time off for the ten hours.
Further details on this exploit
Soldiers serving within the remit of the Federal Ministry of Defence generally benefit from the working-time protections in § 30c(1) to (3) of the Soldiers Act (Soldatengesetz, SG). Under § 30c(2) SG, ordered or approved overtime exceeding five hours in a month generally gives rise to an entitlement to corresponding time off for all of that overtime. However, the Act authorizes the Ministry to exempt soldiers serving at military establishments that bring together elements of several states’ armed forces. Section 1(2) of the Soldiers’ Working Time Regulation (SAZV) applies this exemption to soldiers transferred or assigned to an establishment listed in its annex to perform international or supranational tasks.15
JSEC is such an establishment. The SAZV was amended as described above to list JSEC as No. 27. Through § 1(2) SAZV, this listing exempts the soldiers concerned from § 30c(1) to (3) SG. Yet the preamble fails to cite the necessary legal basis, § 30c(6) in conjunction with § 93(2), point 7 SG. On the assessment advanced here, the exemption is therefore invalid, and § 30c(1) to (3) SG remain applicable.16
Potential follow-up considerations
The exemption is covered by other cited legal bases.
No. Section 30c(5), sentence 1, point 2 SG authorizes protective measures during special activities, not the exemption of additional groups from working-time rules. Section 30d SG permits a higher working-time limit for certain aircraft and ship crew duties, but expressly leaves § 30c(1) to (3) unaffected.17
If the new rule is void, JSEC remains exempt under the predecessor rule.
No. The previous annex did not cover JSEC.18
Earlier citations of statutory authority suffice for a limited amendment to the list.
Highly unlikely. As a rule, a regulation must cite every statutory power it exercises.19 The Higher Administrative Court of North Rhine-Westphalia exceptionally accepted the citation in the original regulation under state constitutional law. The limited amendments, including a reduction in a maintenance allowance to 85% of the reference amount, made sense only when read alongside the existing rules. Readers therefore had to consult the original regulation anyway, and its preamble contained the required citation.20 The Federal Administrative Court left that reasoning undisturbed within its limited scope of review; it did not establish a general exception to the federal citation requirement.21 We do not consider that reasoning applicable here: adding JSEC extends the working-time exemption to a new group of soldiers. Moreover, the original SAZV preamble cites only § 30c(5) in conjunction with what was then § 93(2), point 5 SG, not the exemption power in § 30c(6).22
Many thanks to Megan Ma, Hanjo Hamann, Julian Nyarko, Andreas Engert, Esmie Hurd, Chijioke Mgbahurike, Zeynep Altayli, and Marco Magacs for their thoughtful feedback on an earlier draft.