patio11’s classic 2012 post on salary negotiation has a few important ideas in it:
- Salary can be negotiated. A lot of things in life can’t be. If you walk into an Apple Store and try to talk down the price of a new iPhone, you'll get nowhere. But salary isn't like that. You can negotiate it, and people do.
- Salary negotiation is consequential. Spend a few hours haggling over a car and you might save $5,000. Spend the same few hours negotiating your salary and you might get tens of thousands of dollars a year in a way that may remain durable, because raises and future jobs get built on top of it.
- Salary negotiation is asymmetric. If you save $10 on a Craigslist purchase, that $10 comes out of the seller's pocket. But when you negotiate a salary, the recruiter you're talking to is pretty much unaffected by whatever increase you talk them into.
Here are a few more ideas I've found matter in the SF software engineering job market in 2026:
- Inhabit the collaborative frame. Treat it as you and the hiring manager against the problem. You want to work together, and so do they. The only thing standing in the way is this small question of what they'll pay you. This frame simplifies negotiating strongly yet civilly.
- Collect competing offers to negotiate. Nothing convinces a compensation committee like another offer at higher pay. So it's worth shopping around more broadly than you otherwise would, and getting several offers, even if the only thing you use them for is to persuade the company you end up joining.
- Salaries can be negotiated a lot. Think 50%+.
The collaborative frame
Negotiation feels antagonistic by default, and that gets in the way. There's a nice friendly fellow sitting across from you, offering you a job, and now you're supposed to fight with him?
Fortunately, there’s a collaborative frame you can inhabit:
- You really, really want to work at this company.
- The hiring manager really, really wants to hire you.
- Neither of you enjoys this negotiation. You'd both rather drop it and get to work together. But your hands are tied by your obligations to your family's finances, and theirs by their compensation committee.
Missionary stance
Negotiating your salary shouldn't make the other side pull the offer, or want you less. The one exception I know of in startups is where you can hurt yourself by seeming too mercenary.
It’s useful to communicate a missionary stance when it’s true. For example:
Company: We’re willing to offer you $X Applicant: I'd really like to join you. I'm excited about <particular mission>, and about working with Jane and the rest of the team. If everything else were equal, this is the company I'd most want to join. But Y is currently offering me $1.5X. If you could close that gap, I'd sign.
Ultimately, if you do walk away, the company shouldn't think "Oh, we got outbid." They should think "What a shame that someone so good, who really wanted to work with us, got kept away by our paltry hiring budget."
The recruiter does love you
This is one major divergence from patio11’s Salary Negotiation. He notes:
Bob couldn’t care less and, even if he did care, he has better things to do with his time than worry about a candidate he didn’t hire. Bob is working through a list of a dozen people right now, and his manager Dave is being such a hard case about that project’s schedule, and he’s not sure he can make his daughter’s piano recital, and the cafeteria’s carrot cake was a little dry. Bob is far, far less invested in this negotiation than you are.
In my experience, this often does instead look like:
John has 8 reqs to fill and is underwater, and he badly wants to hit his hiring quota this quarter. The hiring manager, Jerry, has run his interview panel hard: seven onsites so far, two offers, and both of those fell through. John is quite invested in this negotiation successfully closing.
Hiring managers often feel the same way. Some roles take months to fill, projects sit bottlenecked on those hires, and they're desperate to find someone so they can hit the timelines they promised.
Solving principal-agent problems
Hiring managers and recruiters both badly want to close you. If they think talking you into it will work, they'll try as hard as they can. If it won't, they'll try paying you whatever will. (Often they'll also try lowering the hiring bar.)
Companies have to solve this problem: how do you stop a rogue hiring manager from overpaying new employees, or overpromoting the ones already there? They generally solve this by taking compensation out of the managers’ hands - by systematic compensation bands tied to experience, and compensation committees.
So if you hold firm, you can assume the recruiter will do their best to help you convince the compensation committee to pay you more.
That changes the tenor of your conversations. You don't really need to convince the person you're talking to at all. What you mostly need to do is stay firm, and collect evidence compelling enough that they can hand it to their committee.
At smaller startups, the "compensation committee" is usually just the CEO. But the point still holds. Whoever you're talking to usually isn't the person making the decision.
Collect competing offers
The strongest evidence you can produce is a good offer from another company, or a current pay package that's competitive. And there's some strategy you can use to get the most out of this.
The effect is huge. A company will often raise an offer by a lot, sometimes by more than 50%. But it will only do that if you have a compelling alternative.
The most obvious consequence is that you should get multiple job offers. When you're looking for a new job, interview with more companies than you need to, even if you already have a strong lead, so that when the offers come in you have more to compare.
This is hard to live up to, because interviewing is exhausting. But I'd model each additional interview loop as adding 5% or more to your pay (!!)
As you’re interviewing for a new job, you should read & consider Leila Clark’s What are you getting paid in?
Your preferences and estimates are complex - and partially or completely sharing various pieces of information can help. In the past, I’ve found it useful to share offer letters, and even offer comparison spreadsheets, with recruiters.
Having more than one offer helps you in ways you'd expect, and also in some you wouldn't. Here are the common ones that aren't obvious:
Mission alignment
Suppose you get two job offers. Company A offers $X and company B offers $1.5X. But the work at A excites you a lot more. In fact it excites you so much that if you had to choose this minute, you'd still take A.
That's a very good position to negotiate from. You have a higher offer from B to point to, and you'd already be happy with A's offer anyway. You may only get $1.2X out of A. But that's still pretty good.
Overvalued stock
You've been at company A for a few years, since before the seed round and all the way through Series A. On paper your annual stock options are worth a whopping amount, which puts your annual "total comp" at $3X.
But you're pessimistic about the company. Revenue is flat, a few of the star employees have left, and you don't think they'll be able to raise another round.
Then you get an offer from company B, and you can tell them your total comp is currently $3X. You know they probably can't get anywhere near $3X. It's far above market. But you've just handed their comp team the concrete evidence they need to bump you up above their baseline offer.
Cash comp
You work at company A, which pays you extremely well in cash, and then get a new job offer at company B that’s much more equity-dominant.
If you'd rather have cash than illiquid stock options, say so. Especially if you have an existing offer that weights it more heavily. It gives the company a reason to put together a package you'll actually value more.
(An aside: I value early stage stock in a comp package at 30 cents on the dollar, and I've found it helps to tell recruiters so. I’ve briefly tweeted about this before, and may write about it at more length later.)
Understand comp flexibility
What's really happening is a negotiation between you and the compensation committee, with the recruiter standing in as their proxy. The compensation committee is bound in certain ways.
Ideally you'd have a good model of how much room this particular company has to move.
Big companies are the easy case. Levels.fyi, Blind, and sites like them have detailed records of offers people have actually received. They're not perfect, though. I once got an offer from a FAANG company that was outside the range of offers Levels.fyi listed for that level.
Some companies famously do not negotiate in most cases.
You might think early stage startups can't flex at all. In fact they can flex more than most companies for exceptional cases, often even 100+% on cash, 100%+ on equity.
Appendix: It’s probably okay to give a number first
patio11 notes:
Every handbook on negotiation and every blog post will tell you not to give a number first. This advice is almost always right. It is so right, you have to construct crazy hypotheticals to find edge cases where it would not be right.
This advice probably applies less now than it used to. What patio11 is worried about is that you'll name a number that's far too low and then be stuck negotiating from a weak position.
The biggest difference is that the information asymmetry is reduced. Historically, you had very little information on pay bands. This has changed, especially for large companies, where you should be looking at levels.fyi etc beforehand. It’s very easy then, to state an approximate salary expectation around the highest offers.
And you often have no choice but to give a lot of numbers. If you want someone to justify an unusually high offer, you usually have to show them what you make now, or what the other offers are, or both. patio11's point holds when you're not sure the other offers will actually come in higher. But often it's very easy to be quite sure of that.