Ceb K. (@CEBKCEBKCEBK) on X

X (formerly Twitter) ·

4 min read Original article ↗

Ceb K. on X: "The coup against Jensen is comedy-of-errors. Basic timeline: -short-sellers & China-hawks raised alarms for months about ~1% of Nvidia sales being plausibly smuggled around export controls to CCP uses by Megaspeed in Singapore+ (but CCP using clouds in Singapore+ wouldn’t violate our export controls & it’s kind of unclear what actually happened in this regard) -macro jitters & interest rates cause Nvidia stock to start falling in October, then midterms make it seem like data centers will be far harder to build here, so Nvidia’s in trouble unless it can sell more abroad -post-midterms the hawks (Rubio faction etc) deal with imminent rejection by going-for-broke behind Trump’s back to seed stories about Jensen’s affairs with alleged spies in the papers (perhaps exaggerating the “spy” angle for trade policy reasons) -Anthropic et al wish to cartelize & wish to break Nvidia’s market power for obvious “commoditize-your-complement” reasons, & believe take-off’s coming, so they team up to push against Nvidia on chip exports, & claim to be on the verge of dissolving this moat anyway (eg Ant claimed last week to have made Mythos work with alternate chips in promising ways), which means Nvidia’s under further PR & regulatory & market pressure -MeToo journos “uncover” Jensen’s frankly flagrant affairs, which were anyway pretty clear & clearly personal, but now this gauche reporting on within-company affairs exposes Nvidia to liability—*including perhaps personally for board members*—*& Nvidia had anomalously minimal insurance for this*—*& Nvidia had added numerous diverse non-wealthy board members in recent years as part of its accommodationist strategy with CA’s attempts at mandating this kind of DEI*—*& Nvidia’s board was quite weak operationally relative to Jensen*—so the board members felt personal squeezes on several pretty unrelated fronts to act big here (stock fell over 30% in the last ~month; specific rumors & vague threats of looming national security interference; hysterical gossip about open secrets of Jensen’s frankly tame-for-AI lifestyle; an excuse to matter for once by taking down some show-stealer; the asset-poor new board members thus fearing risks of personal bankruptcy for inaction & facing limited upside from letting Jensen remain…) -anyway export controls on frontier chips to China mean we’re increasing our AI model edge over China for the next ~3 years to accelerate its catch-up on chip-making ~5 years from now (seems like an awful trade-off to me, given that eg we’ve already got huge leads on models & China’s best-positioned for seizing our lead on chips, but if you think software takeoff’s imminent it may be rational); thus Jensen’s trying to sell them our chips for US-patriotic reasons, & Xi’s trying to uphold our export controls to help Huawei for PRC-patriotic reasons, & US AI labs are siding with Xi on this to better cartelize, while CCP AI labs are siding with Jensen to better compete (see quoted thread for perhaps relevant papers on how Chinese industrial policy works on various kinds of industries—eg it can be very good for China at frontier stuff, very good for the world at basic stuff, & very good for the CCP at patronage stuff); think of it kind of like the movie “Burn After Reading,” where various contending sides are trying to trade away the MacGuffin like a hot potato, & various confused or myopic hangers-on are trying to frustrate them -see pics for how this moralistic busybody mass democracy has taken over corporate governance: any time any shareholders take vague moral issue with CEOs—for failing to live up to the pablum we make them spout—someone sues over “securities fraud” on behalf of all of them; our courts used to give businesses deference over how they decided to spend money invested with them, but gradually this flipped into quakerishly presuming they should make vague moral claims & if they fail to live up to any then it’s fraud against all us petty nags who indirectly hired them!"

Conversation