USA: RSF urges Congress to impeach FCC Chairman Brendan Carr

5 min read Original article ↗

“The American people have decisively rejected the Trump administration’s trampling of the Constitution. Few individuals have been more instrumental to the White House’s campaign to weaken the First Amendment than Brendan Carr. The incoming Congress now faces a defining test of its commitment to the Constitution and the freedoms it guarantees. Press freedom cannot be defended through words alone. RSF does not take the question of impeachment lightly. In fact, our organization has never before called for the removal of a US official. But the severity and persistence of Carr’s misconduct demand an extraordinary response. Congress has a constitutional responsibility to hold him accountable. Restoring the FCC’s independence must be central to that effort.

Clayton Weimers

Executive Director, RSF North America

A record of attacking press freedom

Carr has actively eroded the FCC’s independence from the executive branch since he became chairman, despite the FCC's clear legal definition as an independent agency. In December 2025, Carr told the Senate the FCC “is not an independent agency, formally speaking.” Axios reported that the agency removed the word “independent” from its online mission statement before the hearing ended. It is still missing today.

When Trump took office, Carr reinstated complaints against and announced inquiries into broadcasters that questioned the Trump administration’s policies, from public service media NPR and PBS to major private channels ABC, CBS and NBC. Carr’s relentless investigations have also targeted local stations, such as California radio station KCBS, which has faced politically motivated scrutiny for its reporting.

Most recently, he improperly leveraged his authority during a political rally for Alaska Senate candidate Dan Sullivan. Speaking alongside Donald Trump, Carr likely violated the Hatch Act by touting his official work while campaigning. RSF and Democracy Defenders Fund filed a complaint on October 19, asking the U.S. Office of Special Counsel to investigate. 

Weaponizing the FCC: the feud with ABC

The Trump administration’s clashes with ABC in particular have highlighted Carr’s use of the FCC as a tool to silence certain news coverage. In March 2025, the FCC opened an irregular investigation into ABC’s diversity, equity, and inclusion policies. After late-night talk show host Jimmy Kimmel joked about political exploitation of conservative activist Charlie Kirk’s assassination in September 2025, the FCC pressured ABC to take him off the air, with Carr saying, “We can do this the easy way or the hard way.” These threats later extended to the entire network in April 2026 when Carr ordered an early review of ABC's broadcast licenses after President Trump and his spouse called again for Kimmel to be fired. 

The ABC stations called the review “unlawful, arbitrary, and unconstitutional.” ABC and its parent company, Disney, then sued the FCC, arguing that the Trump administration had “waged a retaliatory campaign” against ABC through the agency. In a letter to Carr, a group of Democratic senators said this was "the latest and most extreme step in your use of the FCC’s licensing authority as a cudgel ​against broadcasters whose editorial choices displease the president."

Carr has also targeted the ABC morning talk show “The View” by threatening to violate the equal time rule for political candidates. ABC says the FCC determined more than 20 years ago that the show is considered a “bona fide” news program and therefore exempt from the rule. Carr wants to reverse that precedent, which ABC says threatens to “chill critical protected speech.” The FCC’s reconsideration of these rules has also affected other broadcasters: CBS was pressured to scrap late-night host Stephen Colbert’s interview with then-Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico, setting another dangerous censorship precedent that could extend to news and journalism programs. 

The FCC’s troubling role in media consolidation

Shortly before his reelection, Trump filed a $20 billion lawsuit against the CBS newsmagazine “60 Minutes,” claiming that the editing of an interview with Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris was biased in her favor. Despite most experts dismissing the lawsuit’s legal merits, CBS parent company Paramount agreed to pay a $16 million settlement in July 2025 as it sought the Trump administration’s approval for its proposed merger with Skydance Media, the Associated Press reported. The Carr-led FCC approved the merger later that month, which put Skydance founder and Trump ally David Ellison at the helm of the merged company.

In October 2026, Paramount Skydance acquired media conglomerate Warner Bros. Discovery, which means one Trump-aligned company now owns both CBS and CNN, another news network that had frequently drawn Trump’s ire. 

In August, the FCC voted 2-1 to repeal the national broadcast ownership cap, which prevented any single broadcaster from reaching more than 39% of US households, and replaced it with an arbitrary case-by-case review. The agency’s sole Democratic Commissioner, Anna Gomez, voted against the change, calling it unlawful. This move cleared the way for another media merger between Nexstar and Tegna, two of the largest owners of American television stations, further concentrating media ownership. RSF and a coalition of civil society groups have moved to block the rule’s rescission.

When the FCC does Trump’s bidding

When Trump verbally threatens reporters and media outlets, Carr often follows up by proposing concrete measures against them. On August 30, Trump called on the FCC to punish NBC’s Kristen Welker because she said candidates that Trump endorsed had “mixed results.” Trump asserted on social media that the journalist would be “reported to the FCC for rebuke or punishment.” A week later, Carr said the FCC could issue guidance to prevent broadcasters from airing “fake polls” ahead of the midterms. 

In another notable case, when Trump decried “misleading headlines” about the war in Iran in March, Carr posted a veiled threat on social media that broadcasters had a chance “to correct course before their license renewals come up.” Later that month, the online independent outlet Status reported that, at the annual Conservative Political Action Conference, Carr announced, “President Trump is taking on the fake news media, and President Trump is winning.”