Through all the rapid AI growth that took place over the years, one key insight has solidified for me: while the raw power of AI is advancing relentlessly, how we develop and deploy it is still very much in our hands.
We can’t stop nor slow down the AI revolution, but we can definitely try to steer it towards a beneficial future. I’ve previously discussed ensuring AI’s positive global impact but lately, I have been more thinking, following discussions with peers and AI professionals, that we could actually prioritize understanding how our AI systems work before they become overwhelmingly capable.
This lack of transparency seems quite specific to AI and is unprecedented in technological history.
The challenge is that the field of AI is moving incredibly fast, perhaps outpacing our efforts to understand it. This makes it urgent for us to focus on AI interpretability — understanding how AI works. This can help us better navigate the fast-changing landscape of technology.
The Alarming Unknown Inside!
What distinguishes today’s advanced AI from traditional software is its fundamental lack of transparency. When you use a regular program, its actions are the direct result of specific code written by humans. Generative AI is different. When it summarizes information or creates content, the precise reasons behind its choices aren’t always clear, even to the developers. These systems learn and develop in ways that aren’t always directly programmed. Inside, you find vast networks of numbers that somehow perform complex tasks, but the exact process isn’t immediately obvious.
For me, many of the potential risks associated with advanced AI come down to this very lack of understanding.
- If we don’t know how an AI reasons, it’s harder to be sure it won’t do things we didn’t intend.
- The way AI learns could lead to unexpected behaviors, like trying to deceive us or gain undue influence, and these would be hard to spot.
- Without insight into how AI works, preventing its misuse for harmful purposes becomes more challenging.
- In many critical areas, like finance or healthcare, the lack of clear explanations limits the use of AI.
Press enter or click to view image in full size
A Glimmer of Hope: Progress in Interpretability
For a long time, the inner workings of AI felt like a black box. However, the field of interpretability is making progress towards changing that. It’s about systematically trying to understand the individual components and how they interact within AI systems.
Anthropic has recently made significant progress in this area. Their researchers have successfully mapped over 30 million features within their Claude 3 Sonnet model. These features represent specific, human-interpretable concepts that the model encodes. By using techniques like sparse autoencoders and AI-driven autointerpretation, they’ve been able to identify these features within the complex web of neuron activations. This allows for a more detailed tracing of how the AI makes decisions, which is a step towards better understanding.
This work enables developers to trace specific features and see how they influence the model’s behavior. It can highlight individual neurons or concepts that directly contribute to the outputs. While these methods have been scalable to medium-size models like Claude 3 Sonnet, applying them to the very largest “frontier” models is still a technical challenge.
Why Understanding AI Matters Now?
This progress in interpretability isn’t just an academic exercise. It has real implications for making AI safer and more reliable.
- Being able to trace features and circuits allows for more precise debugging of models. If a model makes an incorrect or biased prediction, we can potentially pinpoint the specific “neurons” or features involved.
- Understanding how different features contribute to the model’s performance can help in optimizing its behavior.
- It can provide insights into how the training data influences the model’s outcomes, which is crucial for identifying and mitigating biases.
- Controlled experiments have shown that these interpretability methods can even detect flaws that “red teams” deliberately insert into trained models. By inspecting features and tracing circuits, “blue teams” have been able to uncover these hidden vulnerabilities.
Looking Ahead: A Shared Responsibility
The recent advancements in understanding AI, offer a promising path forward. However, the rapid pace of AI development means we are in a race to understand these systems before they become too complex.
This endeavor requires a broad effort:
- AI Researchers: Continued focus on developing and scaling interpretability techniques is crucial. The ability to map millions of features, opens new avenues for understanding.
- Governments: Policies that encourage (or force?) transparency in AI development and the application of interpretability for safety testing can play a vital role.
As AI becomes more integrated into our lives, our ability to understand how it works will be critical for ensuring its safe and beneficial use. We should continue to push the boundaries of interpretability research, inspired by the progress being made so we can aim for a future where even the most advanced AI is more transparent and understandable.