What’s the deal with screenshots on macOS Golden Gate?

1 min read Original article ↗
Jeff Johnson (My apps, PayPal.Me, Mastodon)

November 6 2026

I was trying to take a screenshot for yesterday’s blog post webloc files trigger a Gatekeeper alert in the latest macOS security updates, but the screenshot was so ugly that I had to take one from Tahoe instead. Here’s a screenshot of the empty trash window on Golden Gate:

window on Golden Gate

Compare and contrast with Tahoe:

window on Tahoe

When I take a screenshot of the entire screen on Golden Gate, the empty trash window looks fine (click for the full image):

screen on Golden Gate

Here’s a close-up of the empty trash window from the screenshot of the entire screen:

window on screen on Golden Gate

In my testing, “Tint window background with wallpaper color” in Appearance System Settings makes no difference to the window screenshot on Golden Gate. However, “Reduce transparency” in Accessibility System Settings does make a big difference:

window on Golden Gate windw on Golden Gate with Reduce transparency

Below is the same difference on Tahoe:

window on Tahoe window on Tahoe with Reduce transparency

Why are transparent window screenshots on Golden Gate so dark and ugly?

Jeff Johnson (My apps, PayPal.Me, Mastodon)