It doesn’t take a Harvard professor to take a step back and wonder what Road & Track was thinking when they green-lit this adventure. They sent a socialist to one of the most over-the-top celebrations of celebrity, glamour, wealth, and greed on the planet. What in the hell did they think was going to happen?
To be fair, Kate’s article makes plenty of jabs at the absurdity and stupidity of the pageantry and celebration of wealth, but when it comes to covering the sport itself, her writing is vastly different from most, if not all, coverage I have read on this sport to date—and vastly better.
I have followed Formula 1 with varying levels of dedication for about twenty years, and this is one of the best things I have ever read on the subject. It is a fascinating contradiction to many of the values I hold dear: it is an environmentally devastating product of unimaginable wealth, positioned with a level of glamour I cannot see in myself. But it is, as perfectly captured by Wagner, a precise orchestra of mechanical, digital, and human control.
(Uh, why didn't I make this an actual post instead of a Quick Link?)
It doesn’t take a Harvard professor to take a step back and wonder what Road & Track was thinking when they green-lit this adventure. They sent a socialist to one of the most over-the-top celebrations of celebrity, glamour, wealth, and greed on the planet. What in the hell did they think was going to happen?
To be fair, Kate’s article makes plenty of jabs at the absurdity and stupidity of the pageantry and celebration of wealth, but when it comes to covering the sport itself, her writing is vastly different from most, if not all, coverage I have read on this sport to date—and vastly better.
I have followed Formula 1 with varying levels of dedication for about twenty years, and this is one of the best things I have ever read on the subject. It is a fascinating contradiction to many of the values I hold dear: it is an environmentally devastating product of unimaginable wealth, positioned with a level of glamour I cannot see in myself. But it is, as perfectly captured by Wagner, a precise orchestra of mechanical, digital, and human control.
(Uh, why didn't I make this an actual post instead of a Quick Link?)
smittypap
Kate on Xitter... "apropos of absolutely nothing at all if you want me to go on a 5000 word experience for your magazine you can email me kate @ mcmansionhell dot com"
Kate on Xitter... "apropos of absolutely nothing at all if you want me to go on a 5000 word experience for your magazine you can email me kate @ mcmansionhell dot com"
Wayne Bremser
Her description of Lewis Hamiliton is (was?) really good.
Her description of Lewis Hamiliton is (was?) really good.
Andrew Lilja
I am a huge F1 fan and found this to be simply some of the best writing on the sport ever. She captures the tension between values here so well — the huge, exorbitant wealth that supports what she calls the most-studied machines on earth.
It makes me wish I liked cycling, and that she'd write McMansion Hell more often. And like the best writing, it makes me want to be a better writer.
I am a huge F1 fan and found this to be simply some of the best writing on the sport ever. She captures the tension between values here so well — the huge, exorbitant wealth that supports what she calls the most-studied machines on earth.
It makes me wish I liked cycling, and that she'd write McMansion Hell more often. And like the best writing, it makes me want to be a better writer.
Chris D.
I've been a F1 fan for years, and even watching Martin Brundle walk his way through the grid before the race starts on ESPN is always a bit of a parade of horrors. The closest parallel I can draw from my own experiences is not one of sport but of dining at Sketch, a 3-star Michelin restaurant in London. It was awesome, in the truest sense, but also grotesque and off-putting. What a great piece of writing.
I've been a F1 fan for years, and even watching Martin Brundle walk his way through the grid before the race starts on ESPN is always a bit of a parade of horrors. The closest parallel I can draw from my own experiences is not one of sport but of dining at Sketch, a 3-star Michelin restaurant in London. It was awesome, in the truest sense, but also grotesque and off-putting. What a great piece of writing.
Clayton Muhleman
Would love to hear the story of how this article got pulled. Fantastic writing made better because it struck someone's nerve.
Would love to hear the story of how this article got pulled. Fantastic writing made better because it struck someone's nerve.
Michelle Lee
I'm a big fan of Kate Wagner — I first learned about her through her cycling writing, but she can make you fall in love with just about anything on the planet. I don't know why Road & Track took it down. Despite her fully fair jabs at the outrageous money consumed by this sport, I'm... now more intrigued by F1 than I've ever been?
I'm a big fan of Kate Wagner — I first learned about her through her cycling writing, but she can make you fall in love with just about anything on the planet. I don't know why Road & Track took it down. Despite her fully fair jabs at the outrageous money consumed by this sport, I'm... now more intrigued by F1 than I've ever been?
Lisa S.
REALLY enjoyed this. I didn't know her cycling or architecture writing before, but as I'm a big fan of both subjects, I've been in a bit of a rabbit hole this afternoon. I'm not an F1 fan (though I lived in Germany long enough to know that "Michael Schumacher" is the answer to every non-soccer sports question in German Trivial Pursuit and I read The Guardian so I've heard of Lewis Hamilton), but I enjoyed the F1 piece. I didn't think it was out of line, and I enjoyed the perspective on sports vs journalists. Why would they have hired her if they didn't want an honest take?
REALLY enjoyed this. I didn't know her cycling or architecture writing before, but as I'm a big fan of both subjects, I've been in a bit of a rabbit hole this afternoon. I'm not an F1 fan (though I lived in Germany long enough to know that "Michael Schumacher" is the answer to every non-soccer sports question in German Trivial Pursuit and I read The Guardian so I've heard of Lewis Hamilton), but I enjoyed the F1 piece. I didn't think it was out of line, and I enjoyed the perspective on sports vs journalists. Why would they have hired her if they didn't want an honest take?
Mary Wallace
I went to every F1 race at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway (2000-2010). The tickets for the whole weekend were less than $400/each. The teams were shocked at the level of access the management and fans expected to have—and they loved it. It makes me sad to see how out of touch it is now. This was a great piece and I’ll seek out her cycling writing.
I went to every F1 race at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway (2000-2010). The tickets for the whole weekend were less than $400/each. The teams were shocked at the level of access the management and fans expected to have—and they loved it. It makes me sad to see how out of touch it is now. This was a great piece and I’ll seek out her cycling writing.
Clayton Muhleman
Some words from the editor of road and track here on defector, but no answers.
Some words from the editor of road and track here on defector, but no answers.
Dalton
Mike F.
I assure you that if this had *stayed* in R&T, there's maybe a 4% chance I would've come across it and read it all the way through.
Given that is was pulled, though....damn right I followed that webarchive link and read it top to bottom.
(And subscribed to Kate's newsletter (albeit substack🤮) as well - that's how good it was!)
I assure you that if this had *stayed* in R&T, there's maybe a 4% chance I would've come across it and read it all the way through.
Given that is was pulled, though....damn right I followed that webarchive link and read it top to bottom.
(And subscribed to Kate's newsletter (albeit substack🤮) as well - that's how good it was!)
Peter Dash
I've been reading Kate's writing for a while now through her pro cycling journalism. It's as unique and wonderful in that world as this, but there's a lot more of it. Seek it out in places like this, and her substack if you want more. She's also been on a quite a few episodes of The Cycling Podcast, and hearing her speak about pro cycling is just as good as reading her writing.
I've been reading Kate's writing for a while now through her pro cycling journalism. It's as unique and wonderful in that world as this, but there's a lot more of it. Seek it out in places like this, and her substack if you want more. She's also been on a quite a few episodes of The Cycling Podcast, and hearing her speak about pro cycling is just as good as reading her writing.
Josh Brandt
A “Consider the Lobster” moment for the next generation :)
A “Consider the Lobster” moment for the next generation :)
Jamie Wolf
I appreciate the David Foster Wallace reference and midway through this wonderful read had the same thought.
… and so thankful that the Internet Archive exists
Now on to sharing this with writer friends
I appreciate the David Foster Wallace reference and midway through this wonderful read had the same thought.
… and so thankful that the Internet Archive exists
Now on to sharing this with writer friends
×
Hello! In order to comment or fave, you need to be a current kottke.org member. If you'd like to sign up for a
membership to support the site and join the conversation, you can explore your options
here.
Note: If you are a member and tried to log in, it didn't work, and now you're stuck in a neverending login loop of death, try disabling any ad blockers or extensions. Or try logging out and then back in. Still having trouble? Email me!
×
Change your display name
This is the name that'll be displayed next to comments you make on kottke.org; your email will not be displayed
publicly. I'd encourage you to use your real name (or at least your first name and last initial) but you can
also pick something that you go by when you participate in communities online. Choose something durable and
reasonably unique (not "Me" or "anon"). Please don't change this often. No impersonation.
Note: I'm letting folks change their display names because the membership service that
kottke.org uses collects full names and I thought some people might not want their names displayed publicly
here. If it gets abused, I might disable this feature.
Hello! In order to leave a comment, you need to be a current kottke.org member. If you'd like to sign up for a
membership to support the site and join the conversation, you can explore your options
here.
Note: If you are a member and tried to log in, it didn't work, and now you're stuck in a neverending login loop of death, try disabling any ad blockers or extensions. Or try logging out and then back in. Still having trouble? Email me!
Comments 15
Sort by: thread — thread . latest . faves
Jason KottkeMOD
Some supplemental material. A thread at MetaFilter. F1 fan Greg Storey:
Nick Heer, also an F1 fan:
(Uh, why didn't I make this an actual post instead of a Quick Link?)
Some supplemental material. A thread at MetaFilter. F1 fan Greg Storey:
Nick Heer, also an F1 fan:
(Uh, why didn't I make this an actual post instead of a Quick Link?)
smittypap
Kate on Xitter... "apropos of absolutely nothing at all if you want me to go on a 5000 word experience for your magazine you can email me kate @ mcmansionhell dot com"
Kate on Xitter... "apropos of absolutely nothing at all if you want me to go on a 5000 word experience for your magazine you can email me kate @ mcmansionhell dot com"
Wayne Bremser
Her description of Lewis Hamiliton is (was?) really good.
Her description of Lewis Hamiliton is (was?) really good.
Andrew Lilja
I am a huge F1 fan and found this to be simply some of the best writing on the sport ever. She captures the tension between values here so well — the huge, exorbitant wealth that supports what she calls the most-studied machines on earth.
It makes me wish I liked cycling, and that she'd write McMansion Hell more often. And like the best writing, it makes me want to be a better writer.
I am a huge F1 fan and found this to be simply some of the best writing on the sport ever. She captures the tension between values here so well — the huge, exorbitant wealth that supports what she calls the most-studied machines on earth. It makes me wish I liked cycling, and that she'd write McMansion Hell more often. And like the best writing, it makes me want to be a better writer.
Chris D.
I've been a F1 fan for years, and even watching Martin Brundle walk his way through the grid before the race starts on ESPN is always a bit of a parade of horrors. The closest parallel I can draw from my own experiences is not one of sport but of dining at Sketch, a 3-star Michelin restaurant in London. It was awesome, in the truest sense, but also grotesque and off-putting. What a great piece of writing.
I've been a F1 fan for years, and even watching Martin Brundle walk his way through the grid before the race starts on ESPN is always a bit of a parade of horrors. The closest parallel I can draw from my own experiences is not one of sport but of dining at Sketch, a 3-star Michelin restaurant in London. It was awesome, in the truest sense, but also grotesque and off-putting. What a great piece of writing.
Clayton Muhleman
Would love to hear the story of how this article got pulled. Fantastic writing made better because it struck someone's nerve.
Would love to hear the story of how this article got pulled. Fantastic writing made better because it struck someone's nerve.
Michelle Lee
I'm a big fan of Kate Wagner — I first learned about her through her cycling writing, but she can make you fall in love with just about anything on the planet. I don't know why Road & Track took it down. Despite her fully fair jabs at the outrageous money consumed by this sport, I'm... now more intrigued by F1 than I've ever been?
I'm a big fan of Kate Wagner — I first learned about her through her cycling writing, but she can make you fall in love with just about anything on the planet. I don't know why Road & Track took it down. Despite her fully fair jabs at the outrageous money consumed by this sport, I'm... now more intrigued by F1 than I've ever been?
Lisa S.
REALLY enjoyed this. I didn't know her cycling or architecture writing before, but as I'm a big fan of both subjects, I've been in a bit of a rabbit hole this afternoon. I'm not an F1 fan (though I lived in Germany long enough to know that "Michael Schumacher" is the answer to every non-soccer sports question in German Trivial Pursuit and I read The Guardian so I've heard of Lewis Hamilton), but I enjoyed the F1 piece. I didn't think it was out of line, and I enjoyed the perspective on sports vs journalists. Why would they have hired her if they didn't want an honest take?
REALLY enjoyed this. I didn't know her cycling or architecture writing before, but as I'm a big fan of both subjects, I've been in a bit of a rabbit hole this afternoon. I'm not an F1 fan (though I lived in Germany long enough to know that "Michael Schumacher" is the answer to every non-soccer sports question in German Trivial Pursuit and I read The Guardian so I've heard of Lewis Hamilton), but I enjoyed the F1 piece. I didn't think it was out of line, and I enjoyed the perspective on sports vs journalists. Why would they have hired her if they didn't want an honest take?
Mary Wallace
I went to every F1 race at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway (2000-2010). The tickets for the whole weekend were less than $400/each. The teams were shocked at the level of access the management and fans expected to have—and they loved it. It makes me sad to see how out of touch it is now. This was a great piece and I’ll seek out her cycling writing.
I went to every F1 race at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway (2000-2010). The tickets for the whole weekend were less than $400/each. The teams were shocked at the level of access the management and fans expected to have—and they loved it. It makes me sad to see how out of touch it is now. This was a great piece and I’ll seek out her cycling writing.
Clayton Muhleman
Some words from the editor of road and track here on defector, but no answers.
Some words from the editor of road and track here on defector, but no answers.
Dalton
Mike F.
I assure you that if this had *stayed* in R&T, there's maybe a 4% chance I would've come across it and read it all the way through.
Given that is was pulled, though....damn right I followed that webarchive link and read it top to bottom.
(And subscribed to Kate's newsletter (albeit substack🤮) as well - that's how good it was!)
I assure you that if this had *stayed* in R&T, there's maybe a 4% chance I would've come across it and read it all the way through. Given that is was pulled, though....damn right I followed that webarchive link and read it top to bottom. (And subscribed to Kate's newsletter (albeit substack🤮) as well - that's how good it was!)
Peter Dash
I've been reading Kate's writing for a while now through her pro cycling journalism. It's as unique and wonderful in that world as this, but there's a lot more of it. Seek it out in places like this, and her substack if you want more. She's also been on a quite a few episodes of The Cycling Podcast, and hearing her speak about pro cycling is just as good as reading her writing.
I've been reading Kate's writing for a while now through her pro cycling journalism. It's as unique and wonderful in that world as this, but there's a lot more of it. Seek it out in places like this, and her substack if you want more. She's also been on a quite a few episodes of The Cycling Podcast, and hearing her speak about pro cycling is just as good as reading her writing.
Josh Brandt
A “Consider the Lobster” moment for the next generation :)
A “Consider the Lobster” moment for the next generation :)
Jamie Wolf
I appreciate the David Foster Wallace reference and midway through this wonderful read had the same thought.
… and so thankful that the Internet Archive exists
Now on to sharing this with writer friends
I appreciate the David Foster Wallace reference and midway through this wonderful read had the same thought. … and so thankful that the Internet Archive exists Now on to sharing this with writer friends
×
Hello! In order to comment or fave, you need to be a current kottke.org member. If you'd like to sign up for a membership to support the site and join the conversation, you can explore your options here.
Existing members can sign in here. If you're a former member, you can renew your membership.
Note: If you are a member and tried to log in, it didn't work, and now you're stuck in a neverending login loop of death, try disabling any ad blockers or extensions. Or try logging out and then back in. Still having trouble? Email me!
×
Change your display name
This is the name that'll be displayed next to comments you make on kottke.org; your email will not be displayed publicly. I'd encourage you to use your real name (or at least your first name and last initial) but you can also pick something that you go by when you participate in communities online. Choose something durable and reasonably unique (not "Me" or "anon"). Please don't change this often. No impersonation.
Note: I'm letting folks change their display names because the membership service that kottke.org uses collects full names and I thought some people might not want their names displayed publicly here. If it gets abused, I might disable this feature.
Hello! In order to leave a comment, you need to be a current kottke.org member. If you'd like to sign up for a membership to support the site and join the conversation, you can explore your options here.
Existing members can sign in here. If you're a former member, you can renew your membership.
Note: If you are a member and tried to log in, it didn't work, and now you're stuck in a neverending login loop of death, try disabling any ad blockers or extensions. Or try logging out and then back in. Still having trouble? Email me!