This Week: Google released a research report that describes exactly how YouTube is going after slop at scale, another company gets crushed by changing Facebook algorithms, the bright side of the buyside and more. Read to the end for how you can score Sillywood Spondoolies before they run out.
Hope you’re OK with two newsletters in a row, I’d already written about Meta’s Muse, then Friday night they killed the deep fake part. It all got me so incensed that I woke up Saturday and wrote that open letter to Meta… If you missed it, read it here. Now here’s the rest of that newsletter a day late but NOT a dollar short.
Welcome to our 38,000+ readers! I’m Jim Louderback and this is my weekly creator economy newsletter. If you’ve received it, then you are either subscribed or someone forwarded it to you.
If the latter – and you want to subscribe, get it here!
💡💡TOP STORIES
HOW YOUTUBE KILLS SLOP AT SCALE … AND WHY YOU MIGHT BE AT RISK
Google just released a research paper on fighting slop at scale, moving from analyzing individual media to analyzing production fingerprints. The paper describes a “Scalable Cluster Termination System” (S-CTS) deployed at what it calls “a major Online Video Platform.” There’s near-zero chance it’s not YouTube… the authors are Google, and the signals are YouTube-specific.
The system takes down entire clusters of YouTube channels for coordinated synthetic production. It analyzes upload timing, publishing velocity, account relationships, shared infrastructure and scripts, similar titles and descriptions and other synthetic media signals to automatically take down entire families of channels. The diagram below, borrowed from the research paper, shows how it works.
Good news for individual creators. But a HUGE red flag to larger creator studios, podcast networks, kids media companies, localization operations and anyone that runs multiple channels from a single production stack. All the things that media companies do to publish at scale, including shared templates, synced upload schedules and a common infrastructure also make them look like a coordinated slop factory.
Over six months they’ve already “terminated” 50,000 clusters of 130,000 channels. They claim a less than 1% overturn rate. That sounds small. But 1% is still roughly 500 clusters, and that number only counts creators with the resources to appeal and win. We all know how hard it is to get YouTube to reverse a channel shut-down decision… and every studio that didn’t fight back, or fought back and lost, isn’t part of that 1%. Even winning the appeal doesn’t undo the collateral damage done to subscribers, views and algorithmic juice.
The paper’s ethics section says it’s focused on coordinated behavior, “rather than isolated uploads”. That means they don’t want to shut down legit studios, but with opaque pattern matching, invisible rules and the cold dead hand of AI at the wheel, that’s cold comfort.
Every creator with more than two or three channels needs to read this paper, understand what the system does and then ask their partner manager how to avoid S-CTS’ tentacles of doom. No partner manager? Audit your entire production process now.
There’s a broader Google search / AI results angle here too. Original, hard to template content from smaller creators should get a boost. But as creators optimize for Google’s AI search results, which can improve viewership and affiliate revenue, they’ll need to strip out anything that even smells like a slop factory. That’s not going to be easy. (Google Research)
Related: I’ll bet the team at Doublespeed are actively working to circumvent S-CTS. Let the wild rumpus begin. (Doublespeed, Inc.)
META (AND GOOGLE) JUST GUTTED ANOTHER PUBLISHER
LBG Media, LadBible’s parent, saw shares fall as much as 40% in a single day after a second profit warning. Why? Because Meta’s pivot to creators crushed the referral traffic LadBible was built on… and Google’s AI search summaries did the rest.
I’ve been telling creators to stop building just on rented land for 10 years. Probably a good idea not to own stock in companies doing the same. Note, Meta does this sort of pivot regularly. What works today probably won’t work down the road. (The Guardian)
WHAT BUYERS WANT
A detailed read of Quartermast’s first-half 2026 M&A report shows that buyers are looking for rosters of talent, not individual stars. Buyers want recurring revenue and are shying away from single creator, single platform businesses. Non-endemic buyers are entering the market (that’s good), but they want distribution and audience, not star power. Deals are up, but the rate of growth is declining. And we’ll see how the second half of this year does … last year’s 2H25 dropped nearly 40%, compared to the first half of 2025. Note that Quartermast is in the business of helping buyers find creator-related companies to acquire, so they have a stake in the narrative beyond unbiased reporting. (Quartermast)
📊📊 RESEARCH
The Great State of Higgsfield: I’m tempted to ignore Higgsfield’s latest “State of AI Video” report, because it only talked to paying Higgsfield AI customers and conflates reported sample data with overall platform metrics. But there are a few interesting directional takeaways, most notably that creators who adopted AI in their workflow and raised rates won more work, while those who cut rates mostly didn’t. AI tools are better used to uplevel your content and grow your business, rather than accelerating your race to the bottom.
Other notable findings? 79% of their paid creators surveyed say the best work still needs humans in the loop, and US creators are most anxious about AI while adopting it the least. Ignore the platform-usage data (like agentic is up 1,500% month over month) because we have no idea what it’s measuring (for math wonks, where’s the denominator?). And some of the non-US/Europe country data is suspect as well. With 58% of those surveyed coming from the US and Europe, how many people made up the findings from Nigeria? What percentage of their paying customers are even in Nigeria?
Higgsfield plans on releasing this report quarterly. The trend data will likely provide more useful insights. (Higgsfield)
🩳🩳 QUIBIS
PLATFORMS
Slopportunities: I write a lot about Italian Brainrot, slop and copyright. This hilarious cartoon captures exactly what’s going on. (YouTube)
Omnimedia: YouTube adds ability for creators to organize their content into shows, seasons and episodes, another sign that YouTube really wants to be TV (along with everything else video). (Creator Insider)
Change or Pay! Meta’s apps are so addictive, they are illegal, according to the EU. (Morning Brew)
Stickers and Stars: YouTube posts five ways to grow your Shorts channel (YouTube Blog)
That’s a Lot of AI: 41% of LinkedIn posts are AI, according to a new analysis from AI-detection plug-in Pangram. I scanned my last newsletter with it, and I’m 100% human! (404 Media)
Almost Shut Out: Neal Mohan has made winning YouTubers Emmys a personal crusade. It might become his Waterloo, as even after heavily pushing seven channels, only one: the short-form Kareem Rahma’s “Subway Takes”, was nominated. Michelle Khare’s Instagram reaction video was so spot on (even down to using “Teenage Wasteland” as a background track). (Scalable, Verified, @michellekhare)
Related: YouTubers have already won Prime Time Emmy awards, dating all the way back to 2013 when @Bernie Su and team took home the prize for The Lizzie Bennet Diaries.
Six Flags: Last year YouTube marked its 20th by taking its Creator Collective to all 50 states. TikTok’s US JV liked the idea enough to run its own roadshow for America’s 250th… but the “Discover America” tour stops in just six states Sign me up for Des Moines! (TikTok, YouTube)
OTHER CREATOR ECONOMY
Mobile Still Wins: @Evan Shapiro’s latest index/analysis tries to model for attention, using proprietary math and an assumption that when consuming multiple media simultaneously, the phone always wins. It continues his narrative of discounting the TV’s ascension. I think he’s right but would love some additional validation. (EShap)
Candyland: MrBeast’s Feastables candy line has matured, with slowing growth, but probably better margins (Business Insider).
Sharkland: MrBeast and his Industries CEO Jeffrey Housenbold are going on Shark Tank this fall. I wonder who gets final edit approval? @Patrik Wilkens explores what it means. (LinkedIn)
The Answer Is Yes: @Simon Owens wonders if Netflix is diluting its brand by adding so much short-form content. (Simon Owens Media Newsletter)
Now That’s Good: Congrats to @Gurpreet Singh, One Digital’s co-founder, for launching his new creator growth agency Good Practice Media. He’s primed to help bring the world to India and India to the world. (Ad Gully)
One Word: Creators! @Darren Cross worries that creator content could simply repeat the mistakes of FAST 1.0 (No One Planned This).
Creators, Sports and the World Cup: @Reed Duchscher has a good take about why the World Cup took off this year in the US, touching on creators in the stands and how Norwegian striker Erling Haaland dominated the conversation. Haaland exemplifies my longer-term view of sports and creators. We love watching with friends and creators. But we really love when the athletes share their stories as the games, the tournaments and the season unfold. (Night Light)
Dumb Money In da House: As I predicted, Hollywood is frantically scrabbling for the next YouTube-incubated hit. Hope you score some Sillywood Spondoolies before the money runs out. (The AV Club)
Look up “spondoolies” kids… and thanks to great, great Uncle Sammy Clemens for popularizing the term.
CREATOR TECH – AI, AR, VR, MORE
Post-Website Era Arrives for Creators: Google adds TikTok, Instagram, YouTube and X insight to its Search Console. @Vipasha Joshi explores what it means. TLDR, search is becoming creator first. Hey Goog… let’s add LinkedIn too! (Creator Chronicles, Google)
Anthropic Needs Product Help: I’ve been enjoying using Claude for a number of my planning and execution tasks for event production and newsletter research. And I’m sure cowork is super powerful and can really help.
AI SEO is now a job: It’s becoming ingrained into corporate org charts, as it moves from maybe to mainstream and material. (Kaleigh Moore)
MicroDragons: A look at AI-generated microdramas, the hints of an impending backlash, and how Character.AI now wants in on the party. From @Janko Roettgers. (Lowpass)
😎 SPONSOR
POSSIBLY YOU!
❝
📍 Where’s Jim?
Open Sauce starts Friday, where I will be producing and hosting Industry Day. The Industry Summit is packed with greatness, featuring speakers from YouTube, LinkedIn, Twitch, Anthropic, Cursor, Higgsfield, Patreon, AMD, Supercast, Linus Media Group… and creators including NileRed, Jabrils, Hank Green, Jean Kang, Avni Barnam, Evan and Katelyn, Aishwarya Srinivasan, Matt Wolfe and so many more! See you there! (Open Sauce Industry Day)
100% written by me. AI was used for light editing, grammar and spelling mistakes… and challenging my assumptions. No human or AI ghostwriters were involved (except for the cover art!).
Like this free newsletter? Buy me a coffee and say thanks! Or let’s do a meetup in your town.
I've built and sold multiple creator economy startups, including Revision3 and VidCon, to top media companies including Discovery and Paramount. Before that I was editor-in-chief of PC Magazine and helped start TechTV. Subscribe for free to get this newsletter every Monday.
Let me know what you think – email me at [email protected]. Thanks for reading and see you around the internet.