The BAAJA media blackout

· HEATED ·

5 min read Original article ↗
Satellite signal interference pattern on television screen. Source: Getty Images

Here’s a little secret: I watch cable news.

Well, “watch” is probably too strong a word. I sometimes turn on cable news while I’m cooking or doing the crossword or disassociating on my couch. It feels semi-productive to periodically look at the television and assess what millions of Americans watch on a daily basis; after all, 63 percent of us still get our news from TV at least sometimes. With cable news on, I feel like I’m getting a window into what corporate media thinks is worth paying attention to, and what many Americans hear about—and don’t hear about—as a result.

I’m telling you this because, late last week while I was roasting a squash, it occurred to me that I hadn’t heard anything on cable news about BAAJA since it was introduced back in September.

And though the bill was co-written by Democratic Sens. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island—two of clean energy’s loudest supporters in Congress—it has caused huge rift in the climate community. Techno-optimist climate wonks like billionaire Tom Steyer; Volts host Dave Roberts, and “abundance” advocates like Ezra Klein say the bill is important for climate progress because it will fast-track interstate power lines, therefore getting more wind and solar onto the grid. But environmentalists like Al Gore, Bill McKibben and groups like Earthjustice say the trade-off will be an explosion of fossil fuel infrastructure, data data centers, and ICE detention centers, as well as and the weakening of laws that allow communities and tribes to halt these developments. And that trade-off is unacceptable. (FWIW, Big Oil and the Trump administration both love the bill).

Anyway, it’s all a huge mess, and it’s all moving so quickly, and all it’s so consequential—and yet, it felt to me (and others) like corporate media was entirely ignoring the whole thing.


Here’s what the Media Matters analysis for HEATED1 found. From the day BAAJA was introduced in the Senate until Friday, November 13, the big three cable networks have run a combined 26 minutes of coverage about it. Fox News aired the most, with a combined 13 minutes; MS Now aired a total of 9 minutes; And CNN ran 4 minutes.

How did these networks frame BAAJA when they did cover it? Fox News ran five segments, each framing the bill as a positive way to get energy projects built faster and criticizing environmental groups for holding it up. On CNN, there were no actual segments; just passing 20-30 second mentions with little substance, according Media Matters.

Of course, cable news is not entirely to blame for the majority of people not knowing about this bill. The Senate has made it very hard for people to follow BAAJA. There have been no committee hearings, markups or legislative reports on the bill. Its sponsors put out a 494-page rewrite on a Saturday, and by Monday senators were already casting their first procedural vote. As the National Congress of American Indians pointed out, that gave Tribal Nations all of one weekend to figure out what the rewrite would mean for them.

I can’t insulate myself from this critique, either. Until yesterday, I haven’t been involved in the coverage of this bill aside from infrequent Bluesky posts. My weak excuse is that I’m one person and there was an election and this bill has literally moved so fast that I’ve not had time to both read the entire thing and talk to enough people to feel confident opining on it before it reached a cloture vote.

And yet, that’s the whole point, isn’t it? A lame-duck Congress is rushing through a bill that Defenders of Wildlife’s Chris Westfall says poses “one of the most sweeping attacks on the Endangered Species Act in the law’s more than 50-year history,” that the Center for Biological Diversity calls “a climate kill shot,” and that a coalition of “Abundance” groups says would be “the most significant modernization of the federal permitting system in a generation.”

It doesn’t matter where you fall on BAAJA: Pushing something that consequential through Congress in six weeks feels pretty undemocratic, particularly when voters just elected a new Congress that could give the bill a full public hearing in January.

At the very least, a bill this meaningful ought to be the kind of thing you hear about on the news while you’re roasting a squash. Preferably while there’s still time to call your senator.

Support independent climate media

Let’s be real: cable news isn’t really great for keeping yourself informed about big-picture policy issues anyway, especially when it comes to issues affecting the climate.

If you want to be more informed about BAAJA, here are some outlets that have been doing a great job covering it from different perspectives: