GitHub - auraguardhq/aura-guard: Exactly-once + circuit breaker for agent tool calls (loops, retries, duplicate side effects)

11 min read Original article ↗

Downloads

Runtime safety for AI agents. Not a budget cap. Not max_steps. A behavior guard.

Without AuraGuard With AuraGuard
max_steps=10 kills the agent after 10 calls (productive or not) Detects which calls are loops and stops only those
Budget caps halt everything when money runs out Tracks spend AND prevents the wasteful calls that burn it
Retry libraries add backoff to failing calls Circuit-breaks the tool entirely after repeated failures
Idempotency keys protect individual API writes Guards the agent layer so the duplicate call never happens
Database → transaction guard
API     → rate limiter
Agent   → AuraGuard
from aura_guard import AgentGuard, GuardDenied

guard = AgentGuard(
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    side_effect_tools={"refund", "cancel"},
    max_calls_per_tool=3,
    max_cost_per_run=1.00,
)

# One-liner: check, execute, record — all in one call
result = guard.run("search_kb", search_kb, query="refund policy")

# Decorator: automatic guard on every call
@guard.protect
def refund(order_id, amount): ...

try:
    refund(order_id="ORD-123", amount=50)
except GuardDenied as e:
    handle_denial(e.decision)

After the run, see exactly what happened:

══════════════════════════════════════════════════
AURAGUARD RUN REPORT
══════════════════════════════════════════════════

Run efficiency: 72.0% productive (18 executed, 7 denied)
  Cached: 4, Blocked: 1, Rewritten: 2

Cost: $0.14 spent / $1.00 budget (86% remaining)

Side-effects: 1 executed, 1 blocked
  refund: 1 executed, 1 blocked

Interventions by primitive:
  [  4x] repeat_detection
  [  2x] jitter_detection
  [  1x] side_effect_gating

Quarantined tools:
  search_kb (jitter_loop)

8 enforcement primitives · Zero dependencies · Sub-millisecond · MCP compatible · Python 3.10+ · Apache-2.0

Try in 10 seconds (no install):

curl -O https://raw.githubusercontent.com/auraguardhq/aura-guard/main/standalone/aura_guard_standalone.py

Or install the full package:

Get started in 5 minutes

Demo

Without Aura Guard

Two agents (Coordinator + Analyst) told to consult each other. No termination condition. The loop runs forever.

Without Aura Guard

60 rounds. 79,525 tokens. $0.16 in 3.6 minutes. Never stops on its own.

Extrapolated: $2.68/hour → $706 over 11 days → $5,650 at GPT-4o pricing.

With Aura Guard

Same agents. Same prompts. Same task. Guard detects the loop automatically.

With Aura Guard

7 rounds. 8,540 tokens. $0.017. Caught by identical_toolcall_loop_cache.

Table of contents

Install

Option A (recommended):

pip install aura-guard

# or with uv
uv pip install aura-guard

Try the built-in demo: aura-guard demo

Option B (from source / dev): install from a cloned repo

git clone https://github.com/auraguardhq/aura-guard.git
cd aura-guard
pip install -e .

Optional: LangChain adapter

pip install langchain-core

Benchmarks (synthetic)

These simulate common agent failure modes (tool loops, retry storms, duplicate side-effects). Costs are estimated — the important signal is the relative difference. See docs/EVALUATION_PLAN.md for real-model evaluation.

Real-model evaluation

Tested with Claude Sonnet 4 (claude-sonnet-4-20250514), 5 scenarios × 5 runs per variant, real LLM tool-use calls with rigged tool implementations.

Scenario No Guard With Guard Result
A: Jitter Loop $0.2778 $0.1446 48% saved
B: Double Refund $0.1397 $0.1456 Prevented duplicate refund at +$0.006 overhead
C: Error Retry Spiral $0.1345 $0.0953 29% saved
D: Smart Reformulation $0.8607 $0.1465 83% saved
E: Flagship $0.3494 $0.1446 59% saved

All costs are p50 (median) across 5 runs. Scenario B costs slightly more because the guard adds an intervention turn but prevents the duplicate side-effect (the refund only executes once). In Scenario B guard runs, 2 of 5 completed in fewer turns ($0.10), while 3 of 5 required the extra intervention turn ($0.145).

64 guard interventions across 25 runs. No false positives observed in manual review (expected — see caveat below). Task completion maintained or improved in scored scenarios (B–E). Scenario A quality was not scored (loop-containment test only).

Full results, per-run data, and screenshots: docs/LIVE_AB_EXAMPLE.md | JSON report


The problem

Agent run without guard:

  1. search_kb("refund policy") → 3 results
  2. search_kb("refund policy EU") → 2 results
  3. search_kb("refund policy EU Germany") → 2 results
  4. search_kb("refund policy EU Germany 2024") → 1 result
  5. search_kb("refund policy EU returns") → 2 results
  6. refund(order="ORD-123", amount=50) → success
  7. refund(order="ORD-123", amount=50) → success (DUPLICATE!)
  8. search_kb("refund confirmation") → 1 result ... 14 tool calls, $0.56, customer refunded twice

With Aura Guard

Agent run with guard:

  1. search_kb("refund policy") → ALLOW → 3 results
  2. search_kb("refund policy EU") → ALLOW → 2 results
  3. search_kb("refund policy EU Germany") → ALLOW → 2 results
  4. search_kb("refund policy EU Germany 2024") → REWRITE (jitter loop detected)
  5. refund(order="ORD-123", amount=50) → ALLOW → success
  6. refund(order="ORD-123", amount=50) → CACHE (idempotent replay) ... 4 tool calls executed, $0.16, one refund

max_steps doesn't distinguish productive calls from loops. Retry libraries don't prevent duplicate side-effects. Idempotency keys protect writes but don't stop search spirals or stalled outputs. Aura Guard handles all of these with a single middleware layer.


Integration

Aura Guard does not call your LLM and does not execute tools.
You keep your agent loop. Aura Guard provides two API levels:

Convenience API (simplest)

from aura_guard import AgentGuard, GuardDenied

guard = AgentGuard(
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    side_effect_tools={"refund", "cancel"},
    max_cost_per_run=1.00,
)

# One-liner: guard checks, executes, and records the result
result = guard.run("search_kb", search_kb, query="refund policy")

# Decorator: every call is automatically guarded
@guard.protect
def refund(order_id, amount):
    return payment_api.refund(order_id=order_id, amount=amount)

try:
    refund(order_id="ORD-123", amount=50)
except GuardDenied as e:
    print(f"Blocked: {e.reason}")  # e.decision has full details

guard.run() and @guard.protect require keyword arguments only. This ensures the guard's signature tracker sees the same arguments the function receives.

3-method API (full control)

For complex agent loops (OpenAI, Anthropic, LangChain), use the 3 hook calls directly:

  1. check_tool(...) before you execute a tool
  2. record_result(...) after the tool finishes (success or error)
  3. check_output(...) after the model produces text (optional but recommended)

Full control example

from aura_guard import AgentGuard, PolicyAction

guard = AgentGuard(
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    max_calls_per_tool=3,                 # stop “search forever”
    side_effect_tools={"refund", "cancel"},
    max_cost_per_run=1.00,                # optional budget (USD)
    tool_costs={"search_kb": 0.03},        # optional; improves cost reporting
)

def run_tool(tool_name: str, args: dict):
    decision = guard.check_tool(tool_name, args=args, ticket_id="ticket-123")

    if decision.action == PolicyAction.ALLOW:
        try:
            result = execute_tool(tool_name, args)  # <-- your tool function
            guard.record_result(ok=True, payload=result)
            return result
        except Exception as e:
            # classify errors however you want ("429", "timeout", "5xx", ...)
            guard.record_result(ok=False, error_code=type(e).__name__)
            raise

    if decision.action == PolicyAction.CACHE:
        # Aura Guard tells you “reuse the previous result”
        return decision.cached_result.payload if decision.cached_result else None

    if decision.action == PolicyAction.REWRITE:
        # You should inject decision.injected_system into your next prompt
        # and re-run the model.
        raise RuntimeError(f"Rewrite requested: {decision.reason}")

    # BLOCK / ESCALATE / FINALIZE
    raise RuntimeError(f"Stopped: {decision.action.value}{decision.reason}")

Framework-specific adapters for OpenAI, LangChain, and MCP are included. See examples/ for integration patterns.

Strict mode (recommended in production)

If record_result() is accidentally skipped between check_tool() calls, the guard undercounts tool executions and may weaken protections. Enable strict mode to catch this:

guard = AgentGuard(
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    strict_mode=True,  # raises RuntimeError on integration mistakes
)

In strict mode, calling check_tool() without a preceding record_result() raises RuntimeError. Calling record_result() without a preceding check_tool() also raises. In non-strict mode (default), these cases log a warning and increment stats["missed_results"].

Framework examples (Anthropic, OpenAI, LangChain)

Anthropic (Claude)

import anthropic
from aura_guard import AgentGuard, PolicyAction

client = anthropic.Anthropic()
guard = AgentGuard(secret_key=b"your-secret-key", max_cost_per_run=1.00, side_effect_tools={"refund", "send_email"})

# In your agent loop, after the model returns tool_use blocks:
for block in response.content:
    if block.type == "tool_use":
        decision = guard.check_tool(block.name, args=block.input)

        if decision.action == PolicyAction.ALLOW:
            result = execute_tool(block.name, block.input)
            guard.record_result(ok=True, payload=result)
        elif decision.action == PolicyAction.CACHE:
            result = decision.cached_result.payload  # reuse previous result
        else:
            # BLOCK / REWRITE / ESCALATE — handle accordingly
            break

# After each assistant text response:
guard.check_output(assistant_text)

# Track real token spend:
guard.record_tokens(
    input_tokens=response.usage.input_tokens,
    output_tokens=response.usage.output_tokens,
)

OpenAI

from aura_guard import AgentGuard, PolicyAction
from aura_guard.adapters.openai_adapter import (
    extract_tool_calls_from_chat_completion,
    inject_system_message,
)

guard = AgentGuard(secret_key=b"your-secret-key", max_cost_per_run=1.00)

# After each OpenAI response:
tool_calls = extract_tool_calls_from_chat_completion(response)
for call in tool_calls:
    decision = guard.check_tool(call.name, args=call.args)

    if decision.action == PolicyAction.ALLOW:
        result = execute_tool(call.name, call.args)
        guard.record_result(ok=True, payload=result)
    elif decision.action == PolicyAction.REWRITE:
        messages = inject_system_message(messages, decision.injected_system)
        # Re-call the model with updated messages

LangChain

from aura_guard.adapters.langchain_adapter import AuraCallbackHandler

handler = AuraCallbackHandler(
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    max_cost_per_run=1.00,
    side_effect_tools={"refund", "send_email"},
)

# Pass as a callback — Aura Guard intercepts tool calls automatically:
agent = initialize_agent(tools=tools, llm=llm, callbacks=[handler])
agent.run("Process refund for order ORD-123")

# After the run:
print(handler.summary)
# {"cost_spent_usd": 0.12, "cost_saved_usd": 0.40, "blocks": 3, ...}

MCP (Model Context Protocol)

from aura_guard.adapters.mcp_adapter import GuardedMCP

mcp = GuardedMCP(
    "Customer Support",
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    side_effect_tools={"refund", "cancel"},
    max_cost_per_run=1.00,
)

@mcp.tool()
def search_kb(query: str) -> str:
    return db.search(query)

@mcp.tool(side_effect=True)
def refund(order_id: str, amount: float) -> str:
    return payments.refund(order_id, amount)

# Works with Claude Desktop, Cursor, or any MCP client
mcp.run(transport="stdio")

Install: pip install aura-guard[mcp]

For multi-client HTTP servers, use session_mode="per_session" so each client gets independent guard state:

mcp = GuardedMCP(
    "Support",
    secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
    session_mode="per_session",  # each client gets its own guard
    max_sessions=100,
)
mcp.run(transport="streamable-http")

Recommended: record real token usage (more accurate costs)

After each LLM call, report usage:

guard.record_tokens(
    input_tokens=resp.usage.input_tokens,
    output_tokens=resp.usage.output_tokens,
)

Configuration (the knobs that matter)

Most teams start here:

  • Mark side-effect tools
    e.g. {"refund", "cancel", "send_email"}

  • Cap expensive tools
    e.g. max_calls_per_tool=3 for search/retrieval

  • Set a max budget per run
    e.g. max_cost_per_run=1.00

  • Tell Aura Guard your tool costs
    so reports are meaningful

For advanced options, see AuraGuardConfig in src/aura_guard/config.py.

Enforcement primitives

  1. Identical tool-call repeat protection
  2. Argument-jitter loop detection
  3. Error retry circuit breaker
  4. Side-effect gating + idempotency ledger
  5. No-state-change stall detection
  6. Cost budget enforcement
  7. Tool policy layer
  8. Multi-tool sequence loop detection — Detects repeating tool-call patterns (A→B→A→B, A→B→C→A→B→C). Catches multi-agent ping-pong and circular delegation. Quarantines the pattern and forces resolution.

Run report

After a run, get a full diagnostic report:

══════════════════════════════════════════════════
AURAGUARD RUN REPORT
══════════════════════════════════════════════════

Run efficiency: 72.0% productive (18 executed, 7 denied)
  Cached: 4, Blocked: 1, Rewritten: 2

Cost: $0.14 spent / $1.00 budget (86% remaining)

Side-effects: 1 executed, 1 blocked
  refund: 1 executed, 1 blocked

Interventions by primitive:
  [  4x] repeat_detection
  [  2x] jitter_detection
  [  1x] side_effect_gating

Quarantined tools:
  search_kb (jitter_loop)

For programmatic use: guard.report_data() returns a JSON-serializable dict.

Shadow mode (evaluate before enforcing)

Shadow mode lets you measure what Aura Guard would block without actually blocking anything. Every decision that would be BLOCK, CACHE, REWRITE, or ESCALATE is logged and counted, but the agent receives ALLOW instead.

This lets you evaluate false positive rates before turning enforcement on in production.

from aura_guard import AgentGuard

guard = AgentGuard(
    max_cost_per_run=1.00,
    max_calls_per_tool=8,
    shadow_mode=True,
)

# Agent runs normally — nothing is blocked
decision = guard.check_tool("search_kb", args={"query": "refund policy"})
# decision.action is always ALLOW in shadow mode

# After the run, check what would have been blocked:
print(guard.stats)
# {"shadow_mode": True, "shadow_would_deny": 3, ...}

Use shadow mode to:

  • Tune thresholds on real traffic before enforcing
  • Compare guard behavior across config changes
  • Build confidence that enforcement won't break working agents

When ready, remove shadow_mode=True to start enforcing.

Example: per-tool policies (deny / human approval)

from aura_guard import AgentGuard, AuraGuardConfig, ToolPolicy, ToolAccess

guard = AgentGuard(
    config=AuraGuardConfig(
        secret_key=b"your-secret-key",
        tool_policies={
            "delete_account": ToolPolicy(access=ToolAccess.DENY, deny_reason="Too risky"),
            "large_refund": ToolPolicy(access=ToolAccess.HUMAN_APPROVAL, risk="high"),
            "search_kb": ToolPolicy(max_calls=5),
        },
    ),
)

Telemetry & persistence (optional)

Telemetry

Aura Guard can emit structured events (counts + signatures, not raw args/payloads).
See src/aura_guard/telemetry.py.

Persist state (optional)

You can serialize guard state to JSON and store it in Redis / Postgres / etc.

from aura_guard.serialization import state_to_json, state_from_json

json_str = state_to_json(state)
state = state_from_json(json_str)

⚠️ result_cache payloads are excluded from serialization (PII risk). Idempotency ledger keys (HMAC signatures) and safe metadata are persisted — replay protection survives serialization. Raw payloads are not stored. After restoring state, a cached replay will return payload=None (the guard blocks the duplicate, but the original payload is not available).


Thread safety

Aura Guard is not thread-safe. Each AgentGuard instance stores per-run state and must be used from the thread that created it. Sharing a guard across threads will raise RuntimeError. Create one guard per agent run.

Async support

Use AsyncAgentGuard for async agent loops. It calls the synchronous engine directly (no I/O, sub-millisecond), safe for the event loop.

from aura_guard.async_middleware import AsyncAgentGuard, PolicyAction

guard = AsyncAgentGuard(secret_key=b"your-secret-key", max_cost_per_run=0.50)
decision = await guard.check_tool("search_kb", args={"query": "test"})

Status & limitations

Aura Guard is v0.7 — the API is stabilizing but may change before v1.0.

Stable: The 3-method API (check_tool / record_result / check_output), the convenience API (guard.run / @guard.protect / GuardDenied), run diagnostics (guard.report / guard.report_data), the 6 PolicyAction values, AuraGuardConfig, and the MCP adapter (GuardedMCP with session isolation).

May change: Default threshold values, serialization format (versioned — old state will error, not silently corrupt), telemetry event names.

Side-effect timeouts (important)

If a side-effect tool succeeds server-side but times out locally, tell the guard:

try:
    result = refund_tool(order_id="o1", amount=50)
    guard.record_result(ok=True, payload=result, side_effect_executed=True)
except TimeoutError:
    # Server may have executed the refund — mark it to prevent duplicates
    guard.record_result(ok=False, error_code="timeout", side_effect_executed=True)

If you don't set side_effect_executed=True on timeout, the guard may allow a retry that causes a duplicate side-effect.

Limitations:

  • In-memory state only. Not thread-safe. Create one guard per agent run.
  • Side-effect enforcement is at-most-once. Idempotency ledger keys survive serialization (since v0.3.9), so replay protection works across restarts if you serialize/restore state. Raw payloads are not persisted (PII safety).
  • Argument jitter detection uses token overlap, not semantic similarity. English-biased.
  • Cost estimates are configurable approximations, not actual billing data.
  • Serialized state and telemetry contain HMAC signatures plus metadata (tool names, quarantine reasons, error classifications, cost amounts, run_id). Raw tool arguments and payloads are never persisted or emitted. In-memory caches hold tool payloads during a run only.

For architecture details, see docs/ARCHITECTURE.md.


Docs

  • docs/QUICKSTART.md — get started in 5 minutes
  • docs/ARCHITECTURE.md — how the engine is structured
  • docs/EVALUATION_PLAN.md — how to evaluate credibly
  • docs/LIVE_AB_EXAMPLE.md — live A/B walkthrough and sample output
  • docs/RESULTS.md — how to publish results (recommended format)

Contributing

See CONTRIBUTING.md.


License

Apache-2.0