What nonprofit pay filings actually show | CharitySense Data

CharitySense Data

10 min read Original article ↗

01/Start with the people

Start with the people a return is required to list

The full Form 990 names officers, directors, trustees, key employees, and certain highly compensated employees. It does not list every worker. Among the 485,109 latest full returns we studied, 485,094 contain at least one person row. Only 238,016, or 49.1%, list someone with a positive compensation total in those rows. A return with no positive row is not evidence that the organization has no paid staff.

We add three amounts for each listed person: reportable compensation from the filing organization, reportable compensation from related organizations, and other compensation. The resulting total is broader than a paycheck or base salary. For each organization with a positive row, we identify its highest total. That is the comparison throughout this article unless we explicitly say we are counting individual rows.

A wider merged people record now covers about 952,000 organizations and can include names found on websites as well as filings. That breadth helps with leadership context, but it is not a comparable pay dataset. We use filed compensation rows for the dollar figures and do not turn a website title into a tax-year salary.

Why we focus on full returns

Smaller filing types and postcards disclose compensation differently or not at all. Mixing them into one pay distribution changes the denominator and can make a missing figure look like zero. Our test of the viral CEO-pay meme uses the same full-return distinction.

02/middle and the tail

The middle and the tail are different worlds

The median highest listed total is $108,882 among paying full-return filers. At the 90th percentile it is $455,146; at the 99th, $2.67 million. These are organization-level figures, one highest row per return. They are not a distribution of every nonprofit worker’s earnings.

The highest listed person on each paying full return

Hover for the count behind each band. The bands are mutually exclusive.

Chart source values; units and population are described in the surrounding figure.
bandcountshare
Under $50K56,44223.7
$50K to $100K53,98122.7
$100K to $250K76,41732.1
$250K to $500K30,13012.7
$500K to $1M12,3075.2
$1M or more8,7393.7
Our analysis of 238,016 latest full-return filers with at least one positive listed compensation row, checked September 28, 2026. Reported totals include compensation from related organizations and other compensation.

Nearly half of these highest rows are below $100,000, while 3.7% reach $1 million. A striking number at the top can be real and still tell us little about a typical organization. The shape of nonprofit money shows why scale is essential context for any sector-wide comparison.

03/highest-paid person is often

The highest-paid person is often not labeled CEO

In 42,824 of the 238,016 paying organizations, the highest row explicitly carries a CEO or chief executive officer title. In another 49,711, it says executive director. The remaining 145,481, or 61.1%, have another or unclear title. We do not relabel those people as CEOs. In 4,346 returns, more than one row shares the highest total; the chart uses the first listed title in those ties.

Titles on the highest listed compensation row

Select a category for the count and its interpretation. Title matching is literal, not a classification of job responsibilities.

Chart source values; units and population are described in the surrounding figure.
titlecountsharedetail
CEO title42,82418The highest-paid row explicitly contains CEO or chief executive officer. This does not capture every person who performs a chief executive role.
Executive director title49,71120.9The highest-paid row explicitly contains executive director, without a CEO title. The person may lead the organization, but the title alone does not establish equivalent responsibilities across institutions.
Other or unclear title145,48161.1The highest-paid row has another title or one too ambiguous to classify this way. It may be a clinician, academic, other officer, trustee, or someone with another role.

Our analysis of the highest positive listed row on 238,016 latest full returns, checked September 28, 2026.

We can also look at individual positive rows that explicitly carry those titles. The median is $245,502 across 54,866 CEO-titled rows and $100,249 across 62,816 executive-director-titled rows. These are row medians, not the same population as the organization-level figure above. A title does not tell us the size, responsibilities, or local labor market of a role, and one person may appear on more than one organization’s return.

04/Related organizations change what

Related organizations change what a number means

The highest listed row includes positive compensation from a related organization in 41,417 paying returns, or 17.4%. A person may work within a health system, university, federation, or another group of related entities. Their reported total on one return may therefore be larger than the amount paid by the filing organization itself.

A filed compensation total may include pay from several organizations within the same system.

This is one reason we do not compare that total mechanically with a single entity’s revenue. It also matters at the upper end: 879 organizations have a highest listed total of at least $5 million, and 156 reach $10 million. Those are counts of organization returns, not distinct people. For an example of how related organizations complicate a filing, see our guide to related-organization disclosures.

05/Size changes both

Size changes both the pay range and the process

Among organizations with positive revenue, the median highest listed total rises from $26,590 for paying filers below $100,000 in revenue to $2.33 million for paying filers at $1 billion or more. The endpoints describe very different institutions. The table also shows how often organizations in each revenue band report both compensation-review processes, using all full-return filers in that band as the denominator.

Latest revenuePaying filersMedian highest rowBoth pay processes
Under $100K15,949$27K9.6%
$100K to $1M107,043$65K15.8%
$1M to $10M80,266$148K37.4%
$10M to $100M26,077$324K59.3%
$100M to $1B4,560$943K66.8%
$1B or more357$2.33M68.1%

Our analysis of latest full returns with positive revenue, checked September 28, 2026. Pay medians use paying filers; review percentages use all filers in each band. Revenue and compensation can refer to different reporting periods.

The reporting gap is especially wide: 9.6% of filers below $100,000 in revenue report both pay processes, compared with 68.1% of filers at $1 billion or more. That does not prove that large organizations make better decisions. It tells us formal review is more often reported where organizations have greater scale.

06/Governance is a question

Governance is a question to investigate, not a score

Form 990 asks whether the organization keeps board minutes, gives its return to the board, has a conflict-of-interest policy, and uses processes to determine senior pay. 91.8% of full-return filers report governing-body minutes. 34.8% report a process for CEO or top-manager pay, 24.0% one for other officers, and 22.6% both.

Reported governance and compensation-review practices

Select a bar to see what its question measures. A yes response is a reported process, not a finding about the quality of the result.

Chart source values; units and population are described in the surrounding figure.
controlcountsharemeaning
Governing-body minutes445,24591.8The organization answered yes to keeping minutes of governing-body meetings. A yes describes reported process, not the quality of the decisions.
Return given to governing body325,76767.2The organization answered yes to providing the return to its governing body before filing.
Conflict-of-interest policy278,15157.3The organization reported having a written conflict-of-interest policy.
CEO or top-manager pay process168,79334.8The organization reported using a process to determine pay for its CEO, executive director, or top manager.
Other officer pay process116,58324The organization reported a process to determine pay for other officers or key employees.
Both pay processes109,76022.6The organization answered yes to both compensation-process questions. That is evidence of a reported procedure, not proof that any particular pay level is appropriate.

Our analysis of 485,109 latest full returns, checked September 28, 2026. Missing or non-yes responses are not counted as yes.

These controls also differ by whether a return lists positive compensation: 35.5% of the 238,016 paying filers report both review processes, versus 10.2% of the 247,093 other full-return filers. This is not a like-for-like comparison. IRS instructions tell an organization with an uncompensated top manager to answer no to the top-manager pay-process question. Size, staffing, and the question’s design all affect the gap. For how ratings use governance evidence without treating it as a verdict, see how we rate nonprofits.

07/better reading

A better reading of a compensation headline

When a compensation figure stands out, we ask whose row it is, which of its components were reported by the filing organization or a related one, and what period the filing covers. Then we look for peers with similar size and work. A single unusually high number can prompt a good question; by itself it cannot tell us whether pay was well set or whether an organization was effective.

The latest available returns are not all from the same year. 277,653 of the full-return filers here have a latest 2024 return and 72,261 have a 2025 return; the rest are older. Compensation on Form 990 is generally reported for the calendar year ending within the organization’s tax year. That timing matters when comparing it with other sources or with a current job title.

What this analysis cannot decide

We cannot infer a person’s base salary, total household income, job performance, or the fairness of a compensation decision from these rows. The title categories are literal matches. The highest listed person may not be the chief executive, and a positive row does not mean every paid worker is listed.

08/Behind the Data

Behind the Data

We analyzed one latest full Form 990 per organization, 485,109 in all, on September 28, 2026. We read the individual compensation rows on each return and added three reported components: compensation from the filer, compensation from related organizations, and other compensation. We retained positive totals and selected the largest within each organization. There were 798,783 positive rows across 238,016 organizations. We did not treat a missing or zero row as an unpaid workforce.

Medians and percentiles describe the 238,016 organization-level highest totals; the percentile is the nearest ranked observation. For a tied highest total, we use the first listed row to classify its title and whether it includes related-organization pay. The explicitly titled CEO and executive-director medians instead use all positive rows matching those phrases. A person may appear on multiple returns, so row counts are not distinct-person counts. Revenue bands use positive latest-return revenue; governance questions use all 485,109 full returns, with only explicit yes responses counted as yes. The methodology explains how current records are selected.

This is a full-return cohort, not a census of the nonprofit workforce. We also inspected the broader merged people record, which spans about 952,000 organizations, but excluded it from compensation calculations because it combines different evidence and periods. Other return types differ in compensation disclosure. Filing and compensation periods can differ, titles can be ambiguous, and self-reported governance answers establish neither implementation nor effectiveness. These limitations are why we do not call the highest-row median a CEO salary.

Sources

What compensation question should we test against the filings next?

Final Thoughts

We can see a great deal in these filings, but not one clean answer to “what do nonprofit CEOs earn?” The strongest sector-wide figure we can defend is the highest listed individual total among organizations with positive rows, and we label it that way. A CEO-titled row is a narrower, different measure. Read either alongside the person’s role, the organization’s scale, related-organization pay, the return’s year, and the process reported for setting compensation. That is a better starting point for inquiry than a viral list of salaries.

More from the CharitySense Data team

About the author

The CharitySense Data team

Research team

We read public nonprofit filings and other sources to understand how the sector works. This blog shares what we find, along with the limits of the evidence. Each article explains how its figures were measured and cites the records or primary sources behind them.

The viral CEO-pay meme, testedHow we rate nonprofitsSearch the corpus