Citizen Kane loses 100% "Fresh" rating after 80-year-old negative review added to Rotten Tomatoes

Citizen Kane, the Orson Welles classic often hailed as the greatest movie of all time, slipped from 100% to 99% on Rotten Tomatoes' "Tomatometer" sometime between February 25 and March 1 this year. The site added a negative review to the 115 positive ones already there—one published 80 years ago by the Chicago Tribune's Mae Tinée, a collective pseudonym then used by the paper's film critics. (Matinée, geddit?)

"'Citizen Kane' Fails to Impress Critic as Greatest Ever Filmed" runs the headline, followed by superficially respectful but withering criticism.

"It's interesting. It's different," writes the Tribune. "In fact, it's bizarre enough to become a museum piece. But its sacrifice of simplicity to eccentricity robs it of distinction and general entertainment value."

The unimpressed write-up was spotted by @Caulimovirus on Twitter: "Rotten Tomatoes literally dug up an 80 year old negative review of Citizen Kane and now the movie no longer has a 100% fresh rating"

The disgraced classic now languishes behind perfect-score films such as 1984's The Terminator and 1995's Godzilla Vs. Destroyah, movies about which no credible authority has ever posted a negative opinion.

UPDATE: Citizen Kane's Tomatometer day of doom was before March 1. Hat tips to Beanolini and David Whitehead for refining the possible range of dates.

• The first trailer for Buddy isn't, you know, for kids

  It can be so hard to keep kids entertained during the summer break. There's only so much swimming, trips to the trampoline park, and sleepovers that parents can afford both… READ THE REST

• Watch this classic John Ford western for absolutely free

  You may have noticed that it's a bit warm out. As good as the sun can feel after a long winter, the temperatures that the majority of the western hemisphere… READ THE REST

• Dune: Part 3 drops trailer full of fun in the sun

  Denis Villenueve's first two Dune (or DUNC depending on how badly you misread the poster) movies, with love to David Lynch, have been by far the best adaptation of Frank… READ THE REST

• Did anybody expect Microsoft to drop Visual Studio Pro 2026 lifetime licenses for $35?

  Disclosure: Boing Boing earns a commission on purchases made through links in this post.   TL;DR: Cancel your monthly license and get Visual Studio Pro 2026 for life on sale for $35 (reg.… READ THE REST

• Earn $150 credit with this $70 eSIM

  Disclosure: Boing Boing earns a commission on purchases made through links in this post.   TL;DR: Get $150 travel data credit usable in 200+ countries for just $69.99 (reg. $150) with aloSIM.… READ THE REST

• Your excuses for not reading are over — Headway Premium is just $69.99 for life

  Disclosure: Boing Boing earns a commission on purchases made through links in this post.   TL;DR: Work on your self-growth, boost your professional skills, and become a trivia night menace… READ THE REST