Austria has incredibly broad libel laws — so broad that they prohibit disgruntled voters from calling politicians "oafs" or "fascists." Predictably, this gave rise to a legal dispute between an Austrian politician and Facebook, when the former ordered the latter to remove a comment containing these two insults, and the whole mess ended up before the Advocate General of the Court of Justice of the EU — a person whose decisions are not binding, but are incredibly legally influential.
The Advocate General not only ruled that Facebook can be ordered to block insults to politicians globally (that is, insults to Austrian politicians will not be visible anywhere in the world), but also ruled that Facebook can be ordered to monitor a specific users' communications to ensure that they don't repeat or restate the remarks using synonymous terms, and that Facebook can also be ordered to monitor every user's account to block them from repeating the insults verbatim.
This isn't just a bonkers decision, it's emblematic of a bonkers process, as Daphne Keller writes on Twitter: "That's doubly problematic when – as in every intermediary liability case – the court hears only from (1) the person harmed by online expression and (2) the platform but NOT (3) the users whose rights to seek and impart information are at stake. That's an imbalanced set of inputs. On the massively important question of how filters work, the AG is left to triangulate between what plaintiff says, what Facebook says, and what some government briefs say. He uses those sources to make assumptions about everything from technical feasibility to costs.
Today the CJEU's Advocate General said Austria can require Facebook to (1) actively monitor/filter and (2) globally remove user posts because they call a politician an "oaf" and her party "fascist." That's defamation in Austria, but wouldn't be in US or some other EU countries.
— Daphne Keller (@daphnehk) June 4, 2019
(Image: Anthony Quintano, CC-BY)
70,000 pints of Guinness heisted
Police in England have thirsty work ahead of them after thieves took off with two trailers loaded with Guinness Stout from an industrial park in Runcorn, near Liverpool. "It is… READ THE REST
Texas judge rules again that ban on drag shows is unconstitutional
Texas banned drag shows. A judge again struck down that ban this week, telling people who are offended by drag performances that they can simply choose to not watch them.… READ THE REST
Florida Republican who wants child sex abusers put to death is one, say cops
Florida Republican Michael Caruso has strong opinions about pedophiles: they should receive the death penalty when convicted of sexually battering children under 12 years of age. He was arrested Tuesday… READ THE REST
Before buying a rental property, run the numbers with this $200 tool
Disclosure: Boing Boing earns a commission on purchases made through links in this post. TL;DR: Mashvisor's helps investors research properties nationwide, compare short- and long-term rental potential, estimate returns, and export… READ THE REST
Your sluggish Windows PC might just need a $20 cleanup
Disclosure: Boing Boing earns a commission on purchases made through links in this post. TL;DR: Ashampoo WinOptimizer Pro 29 packs 30 tools for cleaning, tuning, troubleshooting, and managing Windows PCs, with a… READ THE REST
Nobody loves Microsoft Office, but everyone still needs — $33 till Sept. 27
Disclosure: Boing Boing earns a commission on purchases made through links in this post. TL;DR: Microsoft Office Professional 2021 for Windows bundles Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and five more must-have apps into a… READ THE REST