Impossible Chess by bcat112a

11 min read Original article ↗

Le niveau 7 est beaucoup trop dur, toutes les positions sont possible, oû que l'on mette une tour ou un pion...

There is a bug: It says that two pawns on the same column are possible. The only way for that to be done is for capture or en passant

I think that,  if it's possible for two pawns to be on the same column, then it's possible & not a bug

I pass level 9 but I don't know why the position is impossibl

It's bc first, you develop your knight to c3. the only move for black without moving pawns is to develop their knight. Then you put your knight in e4, only black move : knight anywhere. Then you check black in e6. Black is forced to take the knight, but they can't move their knight back.

Well, the two knights could have danced around for a bit before putting black in check. But crucially each knight changes the colour of its square with every move. If white's knight is on black and black's knight is on white, then they've each made the same number of moves, which means black moved last, which means black moved while in check and was still in check at the end of their turn which is impossible.

What the heck is the answer for level 7 (pawns and rooks left)? Any position allowed is legal.

Nevermind, I got it.

However... Level 11 shouldn't have any possible position at all since the black queen couldn't get out.

Nevermind episode 2: I forgot the king can move other than by casteling.

I finished the game! \o/ it was amazing

Niveau 8 je vous en supplie

Avec les 2 tours? C'est simple: C'est au tour de blanc, donc noir doit avoir joué le dernier tour, cela dit, il n'a pu bouger qu'une seule pièce. Utilise tes tours pour que cette pièce n'a pas pu bouger non plus.

Est ce que quelqu'un peut me dire ce que veut dire rot13 svp

C'est pour écrire en "code", en décalant de 13 rangs dans l'alphabet chaque lettre.

C'est pour ça que certains messages semble ne rien vouloir dire: faut les décrypter en redécalant de 13 rangs les lettres :)

Il y a des outils en ligne pour faire ça automatiquement, cherche "outil décalage alphabet" sur google et tu trouveras ça (ou directement "rot13") ! ;D

Techniquement pour le niveau 12 ça n'est pas possible car les pion peuvent etre placé n'importe ou sans que cela soit impossblie si? Je comprend paaaaaas

Level 12 is way too  hard, maybe a hint please

You need to use 3 pawns of the same color.

lvl 9??? I don't play chess 😭

This is such a cool concept and great execution with how it teaches the ideas gradually. Though I do wish there were more puzzles! I feel there are lots of things to explore with this concept!

Here is an example puzzle I came up with, but it's a bit of a twist on the concept: you need to place one piece/pawn of any color (not on the red squares) in order to make the position possible (rather than impossible). This one is a pretty difficult puzzle. (Also please ignore the terrible editing haha.)

I think I've got it : you have to place a white pawn on c6. Last move by white was bxc6 en passant (great idea to implement this weird rule in a puzzle btw).

this game is wayyy too normal

too normal, not enough bcat112a vibes

In level 10, how is B6k/6B1/8/8/8/4K3/8/Q6/B possible?  Black is in check, so white has just moved, there is a single check, so white has just moved the bishop.   Undoing any possible move leads to a check on the king, so Black has moved into that check or ignored it illegally.

It is possible if white last move was to capture a piece on g7. Let us say a black pawn.
Before the white bishop moved to g7 capturing the pawn, that pawn shielded the king from the white queen.

Help pls 😥

Bu, qvq gurl cngpu vg ntnva? V guvax urer lbh unir gb guvax ertneqvat gur ovfubc. Ubj pna n ovfubc trg bhg bs vgf fgnegvat fdhner?

bro doesn't know what rot13 is

Did you find the solution for two rooks ? (Lvl8)

Yes, I think it was a6 and c6, but i brute-forced it

Lrf vg vf n6 naq p6, orpnhfr gur bayl zbir oynpx pbhyq qb cerivbhfyl vf jvgu uvf xavtug, naq vg unq gb or ba bar bs gubfr gjb fdhnerf. Fb vs bhe ebbxf ner gurer, vg znxrf gur bayl cerivbhf yrtny zbirf vzcbffvoyr

(I hope my explanation is clear enough ^^")

What possible previous two moves could there be such that this level 10 board state could possibly be legal?


I think I see it now, if there was a black rook on d4 then the moves: Kh8, Bxd4+
Would render the position legal

Awesome game, the chess community would love this.

level ten was proved to be incorrect by icely

clever puzzles! some were too clever for me and i got some of them by accident but figuring out how a position was impossible was fun

Need help

hint How could the bishop have moved the bottom left corner? Is there a way to make it impossible for the bishop to have moved there?

Isn't level 12's solution technically possible cause 
Lbh qba'g xabj juvpu jnl gur cnjaf ner zbivat

Arent every board from white’s perspective?

There are rank/file labels on the screen in my window?   Was this just added after you left the comment?

Yes, there was an update that added those labels and changed a few levels.

Could someone explain me one thing please (a screenshot and possible spoilers ahead):

-

-

-

-

-

Why is this possible? You cannot do a mate twice, nor you can move Black King to that upper right corner if the corner is being guarded by either Queen or Rook. I beat the level nevertheless, but I still don't understand why my solution is wrong.

This position can be reached via

n qvfpbirerq nggnpx ol gur ebbx pbzvat sebz o2. vs gur ebbx vf ba u3, ur pna'g unir zbirq guebhtu gur xvat sebz p3 gb tvir gung qvfpbirerq nggnpx.

Wow. I see it now. Thanks!

Anyone know how to do level 8? 

Bayl jnl V frr lbh pna znxr vg vzcbffvoyr vf ol univat oynpx va purpx, ohg V pna'g frr ubj lbh pna qb gung jvgubhg gur xavtug.

Yes that needs to be rot13, I'm not letting anyone be spoiled.

This is the level that says "White to move", meaning black has just moved. Pbafvqre jung oynpx cvrprf pbhyq unir zbirq, naq znxr gung vzcbffvoyr.

How is that simultaneously unhelpful, but also helped me?

Also I said I'm not letting anyone get spoiled so I am slightly upset about how you described the level normally >:(

Oh, and, people, giving level numbers for the early levels is pointless.  Levels 1-5 are just five different impossibilities for the same position; you can permute those solutions arbitrarily within that set.  Similarly, 6 and 7 can be interchanged.

I too am having trouble with level 12.  I'm about ready to try brute-forcing it (screen-scraping the display for output and generating artificial mouse events for input)....

i still cant do level 11 even with the hint

Since Black is in check, it obviously was White's move last, and, because the knight is pinnned by Black's queen, White must have been in check after Black's last move.  But in a legal game, White cannot have been in check _before_ that Black move.  Lbh arrq gb svaq cynprf sbe gur ebbx naq ovfubc fhpu gung, sbe nal bs Oynpx'f cbffvoyr cerivbhf zbirf, Juvgr jnf va purpx orsber gung zbir.  If you still have trouble, wait a day or two and I'll point out another consideration which might help.

The knight has just checked the black king, so it must have just moved. This means black's queen was checking white just before. So black must have just made a move that put the queen in that corner square. Make it impossible for the queen to have moved there.

> So black must have just made a move that put the queen in that corner square.

True, but only because the position is such that none of black's other possible previous moves would have discovered check on white - well, without already having had white in check; black's bishop could have discovered check from the queen, but it would have had to itself had white in check to do so.  (I'm just trying to keep people from jumping to unwarrantedly general conclusions based on this special case.)

Man, Level 12 is making me unreasonably upset. In a vacuum, three pawns of either color can be in literally any configuration between the 2nd and 7th ranks, so something about the queen-king setup on the side matters...

But how can it matter? Both queens amd kings can get to those positions regardless of how the pawns are set, and vice versa.

Lbhe pbawrpgher nobhg gur inphhz pnfr vf jebat. Gur evtug fvqr qbrfa'g znggre, gur fbyhgvba vf nyy nobhg gur cnjaf.

Yeah.  My brute-force program found an answer (not "the" answer; there are at least two) overnight, and, once I see it, it's obvious.

I'm stuck on level 9, can somebody help me ?

The white knight can check black's king in a certain number of moves, but there are places black's knight cannot be when that check is delivered.

I need Help, am stuck in the level 7

My solutions for 6 and 7 are (rot13):

Gjb dhrraf

Gjb xavtugf obgu tvivat purpx

Then I’m stuck on level 8 nsgre orvat yvzvgrq gb cnjaf naq ebbxf. Pna'g oybpx gur ovfubc'f fgnegvat cbfvgvba orpnhfr bar bs gubfr fdhnerf vf nyernql erq. Oybpxvat gur zvffvat ovfubc'f fgnegvat cbfvgvba qbrfa'g jbex orpnhfr vg pbhyq unir orra pncgherq ol oynpx'f xavtug.

Got it, now I'm on 11.

8: Gur qvssrerapr sebz gur cerivbhf yriry vf vzcbegnag.

9: Guvf bar vf gevpxl, V unq gb guvax nobhg jul gur fbyhgvba jbexrq nsgre V nyernql tbg vg.

10: Abg gbb qvssvphyg, svaq fbzrguvat vapbzcngvoyr jvgu gur purpx.

Thanks a lot, my friend, now I’m on level 11. I brute-forced level 10; I have no idea why it worked.

Level 10: Oynpx vf va purpx sebz gjb qvssrerag cvrprf. Sebz zbfg bgure cbfvgvbaf ba gur obneq vg pbhyq unir orra n erirnyrq purpx. Ohg sebz gur jvaavat cbfvgvba, oynpx jbhyq unir unq gb raq gurve cerivbhf ghea va purpx, juvpu vf vzcbffvoyr.

11: Bapr ntnva, vg'f vzcbffvoyr sbe fbzrbar gb raq n cerivbhf ghea va purpx.

Why bother using Rot 13 to communicate vague information? May as well just speak in plain text.

I suppose so that others reading the comments don’t accidentally get answers spoiled for them

Some people prefer to solve everything without any hints at all, so I didn't want to spoil anything if they glance at the comments. You're right that I should have been more helpful with 8 and 9, logicalpencils has more details below.

What about level 7? Can you tell me where to put the 2 pieces? (In English)

can you give the actual answers? i am so lost

If you're stuck at level 7, the solution you've missed is probably double-checking the king.

Level 8 is about White to Move, ergo Black just moved — but there's only one black piece that could have just moved, make that case impossible.

Level 9, there's a certain place black's knight can't be while black is also in check.

Level 9: Abg whfg bar pregnva cynpr oynpx pna'g or, vg'f znal cynprf. Guvf bar vf nobhg gur purpxreobneq cnggrea naq ubj rnpu gvzr n xavtug zbirf, vg raqf ba n qvssrerag pbybe guna vg fgnegrq.

How many levels are there? I'm already stuck.

12: Cnjaf pna bayl zbir sbejneq naq qvntbanyyl.

thanks for explaining how pawns move, how is that supposed to help me?

Bar bs gur guerr cnjaf arrqf gb or va n cbfvgvba vg pna'g ernpu ol zbivat sbejneq naq qvntbanyyl.

Cool uncursed game? I never thought I'd see the day. Nice job.

True, this doesn't feel like something bcat would make.

That's very clever!  And, I suppose, advanced, as chess battles go.

Chess Battle Advanced. 

thank you bcat for all your cursed games btw <3

You're pretty cursed yourself.

are you going to make a video on this?