DEAR AMERICA: Here's Why Everyone Thinks You Have A Problem With Guns

10 min read Original article ↗

This story is available exclusively to Business Insider subscribers. Become an Insider and start reading now. Have an account? .

child toy  gun

AP

America is truly an exceptional nation. 

It's not because of our education system, our economy or our scientific establishment. 

No, America is really only exceptional when it comes to the number of guns, the frequency of gun murders, and the shockingly high number of annual gun deaths.

Other countries don't have the problems that the United States does. Other industrialized countries don't have tens of thousands of gun deaths per year, or regular mass shootings, or a population as armed as it is violent. 

Other countries don't have America's gun problem. 

Here, we take a look at the data that shows why America is so unlike the rest of the world when it comes to the popularity and the abuse of guns. We'll look at the role that policy-makers play in the gun control debate, and we'll look at what can be done. 

It isn't pretty, but it's important. Hundreds of thousands of American lives hang in the balance. 

When Americans kill one another, they usually use a gun. In fact, Americans use guns to murder each other twice as often as they use any other murder weapons.

Murder weapons guns

The Guardian

In 2015, it is projected that for the first time in decades more people will die by guns than by motor vehicles.

gun deaths auto deaths

Bloomberg government

At the current rate, 339,000 Americans will die by guns over the next 10 years. That is roughly equivalent to the current population of Tampa, Florida.

gun deaths

CDC data, Walter Hickey/BI

As the national rate of gun ownership declines ...

gun ownership

Patrick Egan, The Monkey Cage

... so do both the violent crime and murder rate. Violence peaked when gun ownership peaked, in the 1970s and early 1980s.

violence in America

Patrick Egan, The Monkey Cage

Notice how the drop in gun ownership is driven largely by the drop in pistol and shotgun ownership.

gun ownership

Patrick Egan, The Monkey Cage

But after years on the decline, gun ownership is once again on the rise.

gun ownership

Gallup

Gun ownership in the U.S. is becoming increasingly consolidated to a minority of households. Household ownership is decreasing even faster than personal ownership.

household personal gun ownership

Violence Policy Center

The South has the most gun owners by far, followed by the Midwest and West. The Northeast has the fewest guns per capita.

gun ownership region

Gallup

The South also has the highest rate of assault deaths by far, followed by the Midwest and West. The Northeast has the lowest rate of assault deaths.

assault deaths us ts region

Kieran Healy

The states with the loosest regulation of firearms — congregated in the south and southwest — also have the highest number of annual deaths by gun.

guns in america

via The Washington Post

When Americans try to maim or kill, they prefer guns. It makes sense that states with the most guns have abnormally high assault rates.

assault deaths us ts state exdc

Kieran Healy

While this may already look bad, the U.S. looks even worse when compared to the rest of the world.

canadian canada mountie

AP

America has far more assault deaths per capita than other industrialized nations.

assault deaths oecd ts all

Kieran Healy

It doesn't help that the U.S. has more guns per capita than any other nation.

guns per country

Data from Small Arms Survey, Walter Hickey/BI

U.S. civilians control a vast plurality of the world's supply of civilian firearms. There are a shocking 270 million guns in civilian hands in the United States.

ownership of civilian guns

Small Arms Survey

Compared to the rest of the world, the U.S. is an extreme outlier. This chart shows that the more guns a country has, the more gun deaths a country has. The U.S. takes this relationship to the extreme.

Gun ownership gun deaths

Mark Reid

This chart of industrialized nations shows that the U.S. and Mexico — a nation currently engulfed in a widespread, anarchic drug cartel war — stand alone when it comes to gun ownership and gun homicide.

gun ownership gun homicide

Mark Reid

Here's a look by the Small Arms Survey at the relationship between a country's homicide rate and that country's gun homicide rate. You'll notice that for the most part, the non-firearm homicide rate remains roughly even regardless of the total homicide rate. The main driver of the high homicide rate in certain nations is due to gun homicides.

homicide rate and gun use

Small Arms Survey

The U.S. has pretty unique gun laws. U.S. federal law says almost anyone can buy a gun, provided they are of age, the gun is not an assault rifle or machine gun, and they are not a felon, fugitive, or non-citizen.

child toy  gun

AP

In the U.K., handguns are illegal and a person needs to get a certificate — and prove they have a good reason — to own a rifle or shotgun. Anyone convicted of a crime cannot touch a gun for 5 years. There are 0.07 gun homicides per every 100,000 people.

britain royal guard buckingham

AP

In Canada, a person must wait 60 days to buy a gun. A person applying for a mandatory license must take a training course, notify next-of-kin, have several references and pass a rigorous background check. There are 0.5 gun homicides per every 100,000 people.

canada

AP

In Japan, touching a gun without a license can result in 10 years in prison. To obtain a rifle or shotgun, a citizen must undergo an exhaustive application process involving several exams, health tests, police authorization, background checks, and the installation of a safe. There are 122 million people in Japan. In 2008, there were 11 gun homicides. In 2006 there were 2.

japan gun shotgun

AP

Australia is an interesting case. Following the 1996 Port Arthur Massacre, which left 35 people dead, the Conservative-led government banned all automatic and semi-automatic weapons, and mandated licensing involving background checks and waiting periods. The government also instituted a gun buyback program, where 650,000 weapons were voluntarily handed in for $360 million.

port arthur massacre

Scene from the Port Arthur Massacre in 1996 AP

The result? A major drop in gun deaths, suicides, and homicides. Australia had 30 gun homicides in 2010, 0.13 gun deaths for each 100,000 people.

australia gun laws

Small Arms Survey

In contrast, the U.S. has a gun homicide rate of 3 per 100,000 — six times as large as Canada, 23 times as large as Australia, 43 times as large as the U.K., and more than 300 times as large as Japan.

gun homicides by country

Walter Hickey / BI

How did it get to this point?

sandy hook elementary shooting

AP Photo/Jessica Hill

When it comes down to it, the gun debate is a one-sided argument in Washington. There isn't even a token opposition to the juggernaut gun lobby.

gun control political spending

Data from Center for Responsive Politics, Chart: Walter Hickey/BI

The gun lobby — led by the NRA — has spent $15 on elections for every $1 spent by the gun control lobby.

gun interest group campaign spending

Data from Center for Responsive Politics, Chart: Walter Hickey

The NRA claims more than 3 million members. Although that's roughly 1 percent of the country, the active membership claims a lot of electoral influence.

heston nra from my cold dead hands

AP

The NRA also gets a significant amount of money from the gun industry in the form of donations, contributions and fundraising assistance.

smith and wesson nra

AP

The NRA also used its influence to gut the ability of the CDC from doing any sort of research on the impact of firearms on human injury and death, deliberately making it harder to conduct scientific research.

gun cdc

Ed O'Keefe/Washington Post

The NRA's Wayne LaPierre has claimed that gun-free school zones make children sitting targets, thus teachers should be armed.

gun free school zone

AP

But children are already pretty safe in schools as is. A very small number of the 30,000 annual gun deaths take place in schools.

homicides suicides school

BJS

In fact, children are safest within gun-free school zones.

deaths schools

BJS

So are we really sure its guns that are causing America's violence epidemic? Could it be violent video games?

call of duty

First of all, it's pretty clear that there's no correlation between video game sales and the youth crime rate, despite what many will say.

VIDEO GAME AND VIOLENCE

ESA

Here's a chart showing what a hypothetical correlation between video game consumption and gun murders should look like.

video game chart guns

Max Fisher / Washington Post

By the Washington Post's Max Fisher.

Could it be violence in the media?

Russell Crowe Gladiator

Gladiator

Actually, probably not. There's just no evidence to support that. A 2008 paper by American University professors Joanne Savage and Christina Yancey found "A review of both aggregate studies and experimental evidence does not provide support for the supposition that exposure to media violence causes criminally violent behavior"

pulp fiction

Miramax, IMDB

"Most studies on which reviewers have been relying for their conclusions are decades old and they do not employ modern statistical methods to estimate effects," they wrote. "Programs such as Batman and Bonanza were used as the high-violence shows."

batman joker penguin villains riddler catwoman 1960s

IMDB

A landmark 1986 paper by Steven Messner — which originally set out to prove violent media was linked to real-world violence — found that exposure to television was actually consistently was linked to reduced real-world violence across the board.

the governor the walking dead

Gene Page/AMC

Revisiting this chart, it's abundantly clear. Countries with high murder rates have them because of a high gun murder rate. It's the guns.

homicide rate and gun use

Small Arms Survey

So what can we do to fix this gun violence epidemic?

gun show

Associated Press

Many people advocated for the reinstatement of the assault weapon ban, as assault weapons are frequently used in many of the worst mass shootings.

aurora colorado shooting theater

9 News Denver

Generally, when Americans kill they usually use a handgun.

handgun rifle use

Small Arms Survey

But a survey of mass shooting incidents found that more than twice as many people shot and significantly more people killed when an assault weapon was used. However, the proposed assault weapon ban was dropped from the reform package after it became clear it wouldn't pass the Senate.

assault weapons stats

Walter Hickey/BI, data from Mayors Against Illegal Guns

Other proposals included a ban on high capacity magazines, like the one used at the mass shooting that left former Rep. Gabby Giffords wounded. This too was dropped from the reform package.

tucson giffords shooting

AP

A 1999 study of recent ATF investigations found that rampant abuse of the "gun show loophole" — in which a person who cannot buy a gun does so at a gun show, where background checks aren't necessary.

Violations in gun investigations

ATF

You'd think it would be reasonable to ensure that everyone buying a gun is subject to the same rules, but the motion to require background checks on gun show purchases failed in the Senate, 6 votes shy of hitting the mandatory 60 votes.

Mitch Mcconnell

AP

So what's going to happen?

Sandy Hook Elementary

Police lead children away from Sandy Hook Elementary AP Photo/Newton Bee/Shannon Hicks

Probably nothing. If the most rudimentary possible reforms are shut down immediately because there are not 60 votes for gun control, then there's really no hope for federal reforms.

wayne lapierre

AP

Now here's why it all failed ...

max baucus

AP

Read next

Walt was Business Insider's Deputy Editor for Data and Analysis.Hickey is the author of You Are What You Watch, and also writes Numlock News, a daily morning newsletter. He came from FiveThirtyEight where he was chief culture writer. Walt previously worked at Business Insider from 2012 to 2013, and  graduated from The College of William and Mary with a degree in Applied Mathematics. In additon to his work on elections and data journalism, he also edits comics at Business Insider.In 2022, Hickey won the Pulitzer Prize for Illustrated Reporting for his work on Business Insider's I Escaped A Chinese Internment Camp documenting the plight of Uyghurs in China.