I've been wondering why the symbol for 'record' is universally (AFAIK - has anyone seen exceptions?) a circle and usually red. Cameras, VCRs, voice recorders, smartphones, web apps... I've seen cases where even though other controls are just labelled with text, the record button still has a little red circle beside the label.

a sea of round red record buttons

I can make sense of most other playback controls: PLAY is an arrow pointing right, which tends to be 'forward' for LTR reading directions; PAUSE and STOP I'm a bit less sure of, but they feel like static, vertical roadblocks set up in contrast to the horizontal direction-ness of PLAY/FF/RW. My guess is that a circle represents writing to disk or something, but does anyone have actual sources about the design of playback controls?

P.S. My Google autocompletes 'why is the record button' with 'red' :V

Zelda's user avatar

Zelda

41k10 gold badges115 silver badges184 bronze badges

asked Jun 27, 2013 at 8:31

Jessica Yang's user avatar

4

Excellent answers so far.

I would attempt to connect the dots between recording and red button like this:

Apart from the traditional warning usage, a red light has been used in many scenarios to represent on-going work - radio show room when on air, operation theater when operation is going on, etc. The reason behind that would be the same - it is highly noticeable in the human visible color field. It acts as a signal to someone who might not be aware of what is going on, to prevent them from interrupting the process. This is highly desirable when you are recording something. And it can be easily used in social context: Rather than 'telling' someone that you are recording and they should not make a sound, you can just point to the red dot on your microphone/recorder and they would understand the situation. I have even seen some microphones with a small red indicator on when the device is on.

As far as the button's shape goes, I do not think it has that much history in it apart from a couple trend setters. But, a good explanation would be: All the other controls on a radio/cassette player were rectangular in shape. The record button demanded some extra affordance so that it was not accidentally pressed (overwriting something which you wanted to hear!). A couple options are: give it a different shape - circular button - and highlight it - red color. In many cases you would see just the red color being used (or even just the red symbol on a regular button).

Image of an old cassette player with big red record button next to other black buttons

elemjay19's user avatar

elemjay19

1,28813 silver badges25 bronze badges

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 12:38

rk.'s user avatar

10

The symbol on each button was created with references to sheet music and inventor's background.

  • For example, the || in pause may come from the Japanese character リ and/or Caesura.

  • The media control UI were first introduced by Swedish Engineer Philip Olsson while he was working in Japan. He also had a degree from Swedish design school.

The glyphs were standardized by International Electrotechnical Commission in Geneva under IEC417 Graphical symbols for use on equipment

In early 20th century - Record was denoted by 3 wave lines in a ReVox.

revox recorder control UI A 1958 revox recorder

Today's standard Media Control convention as seen on a the Panasonic RX-5150 boombox (which is 2 decades old) RX-5150

LarsH's user avatar

LarsH

2122 silver badges9 bronze badges

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 8:40

Rayraegah's user avatar

8

The record button is round because of the triangle the square and the rectangles being already chosen for the play, rewind, forward, stop and pause buttons, and the need for an eye-catcher for security reasons, that is preventing critical information erasing.

When is applied, the red color is applied for the same reason.

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 8:39

32746's user avatar

3

I suspect it follows the development of machines to play compact cassettes (which were developed by Phillips).

Wikipedia says that this was the first player that Phillips released to play the tapes

Philips also released the Norelco Carry-Corder 150 recorder/player in the U.S. in November 1964.

Here it is: and it has a round red record button.

enter image description here

http://www.shizaudio.ru/audio/data/media/32/86866a_2.jpg

The red colour is logically a warning colour - as pressing record overwrites what you've already got on the tape !

rk.'s user avatar

rk.

17.9k1 gold badge59 silver badges88 bronze badges

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 9:30

PhillipW's user avatar

1

I assume it comes from the "ON AIR" broadcasting signs, which would traditionally have a red light to indicate that the studio was recording.

I assume that other recording items then had a red light, since the "ON AIR" sign would be overkill for a small device.

Eventually, the idea of a light to indicate recording would be too expensive, especially in an era before LEDs, and so the red light was replaced with an iconographic representation - a red circle.

enter image description here

Source: Totally making this up as I go along.

rk.'s user avatar

rk.

17.9k1 gold badge59 silver badges88 bronze badges

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 12:52

Erty Seidohl's user avatar

1

I can partly answer about the colour, but not about the round shape. Colour has culture-specific meaning, and red varies from happiness (in China) to death (in Egypt).

I assume that most European, American, and Japanese manufacturers used and standardised red according to their notion of red meaning danger. Also, because their customers would probably make this association, as these were the profitable markets when recorders were first made, unlike nowadays.

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 11:18

ekapros's user avatar

1

The usage certainly pre-dates cassette tape recorders. Dieter Rams reel-to-reel tape recorder the TH 60 of 1965 had a red circle on the record button.

http://www.formguide.de/en/designers/overview/dieter-rams/

I don't know if it was established before then.

A possibility is that in the days preceding tape recorders, there were wire recorders. And as a primitive equivalent of the VU-Meter, they used a neon bulb, which would flicker when the recording level was right. Too low and the neon wouldn't come on. Too high, and it would be solidly on. And Neon bulbs were red. So a red circle could have become associated with recording that way.

answered Jun 27, 2013 at 18:31

Steve Waddicor's user avatar

1

is it not also a great example of consistent UI across physical products, a level of consistency that those manufacturing computer software, hardware and designing for the web could actually learn a lot from.

i.e. once a few products set the standard is has then been adhered too across pretty much all products so that the user knows what will happen when they press the round, red button

answered Jul 3, 2013 at 17:24

Toni Leigh's user avatar

Another reason could be that red color is easy to spot. You can distinguish red from a crowd of other colors easily. Same case with green. Our eyes are more sensitive to green than any other color and that is why greenery is soothing to our eyes. So all the important buttons come in either green or red and the button with which we should be more cautious with comes in the red color.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Eyesensitivity.svg

rk.'s user avatar

rk.

17.9k1 gold badge59 silver badges88 bronze badges

answered Jun 28, 2013 at 10:54

prince's user avatar

3

Start asking to get answers

Find the answer to your question by asking.

Ask question

Explore related questions

See similar questions with these tags.