Settings

Theme

Cl-mpi: MPI bindings for Common Lisp

code.google.com

12 points by khandekars 17 years ago · 8 comments

Reader

jganetsk 17 years ago

The kids nowadays don't even know about MPI as a framework for parallel processing. Thank you, MapReduce.

  • rjurney 17 years ago

    Is that really a bad thing?

    • mahmud 17 years ago

      Not at all. Programming has become specialized since its inception; there are systems programmers and application programmers. The former creates the tools used by the later.

      But, I expect the systems programmers to know not only the ins and outs of the current technologies, but what came before them. The past is full of beautiful architectures that didn't succeed for commercial reasons in their time, but would be perfect candidates to make a comeback in some form in the future. Even if we have to form a vigilante group of hacking do-gooders who will mail architects copies of important texts and papers (a la GvR and SICP ;-)

      Needless to say, MPI is not one such "lost beauty", more like a committee designed piece of industry infrastructure. MPI == HPC.

      • gruseom 17 years ago

        Tell us about some of the lost beauties.

        • mahmud 17 years ago

          Walk to the CS section of any big university library and scan the shelves for the purple and gray "LNCS" books (Lecture Notes in Computer Science.) then weep in sorrow.

          Not only is worse better, but industry seems to be at odds with good design.

          The examples are simply too numerous and any examples would only be a poor and narrow representative, skewed to my tastes and my ignorance.

          All I know is that we deserve better than this; a combination of MIPS, Smalltalk, Lisp, and Amoeba as mainstream platforms would have been nice.

    • jganetsk 17 years ago

      Those of us who don't know history are bound to reinvent it.

JulianMorrison 17 years ago

Anyone who has used MPI - is it any good? A cursory glance makes it look like slightly gold-plated RPC.

  • omnipath 17 years ago

    I've used it for school work, but not for a real paying job. It can be good, but I used MPI raw, which is C based. So there is tons of rope to hang yourself. I just remember that it was a little difficult to have each spun process talk to the main process.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection