Settings

Theme

UK MP's won't read your internet censorship letters

clidus.com

29 points by relequestual 12 years ago · 11 comments

Reader

h2s 12 years ago

This is standard practice. MPs receive a lot of letters from their constituents and it isn't practical to send individual responses.

As well, Amber Rudd and Damien Green are conservative MPs, so they can be considered supporters of this proposal. I would hardly expect their replies to do anything other than make positive statements about the proposal.

There's more to democracy than voting and writing to MPs. For example, in light of the leaks about GCHQ and this proposed internet censorship, I have started supporting Pirate Party UK. They are the only party with a satisfactorily strong anti-surveillance and anti-censorship stance. Put your money where your mouth is.

  • mindcrime 12 years ago

    I have started supporting Pirate Party UK. They are the only party with a satisfactorily strong anti-surveillance and anti-censorship stance

    I don't find it spelled out in their policy manifesto, but I imagine that the Libertarian Park UK would have a pretty strong anti-surveillance and anti-censorship stance as well.

    http://libertarianpartyuk.com/policy-manifesto-2012/

    In light of recent events, they should probably break that out as a separate bullet point on their platform page and make it explicit.

noir_lord 12 years ago

These cretins will be out of power in less than 2 years (to be replaced by the other cretins).

If we can stall, block and generally oppose this for 2 years the next set of cretins will throw it out (they didn't think of it therefore it has to be thrown out..good or bad) then we can start fighting their version.

Ain't democracy wonderful.

herghost 12 years ago

My MP (Jonathan Reynolds, Lab) is entirely content to play party politics over the issue.

I wrote to him some years ago when Labour were proposing something very similar, and he responded defending it.

I wrote to him again recently, now the Conservatives are in power, and funnily enough he's moderately opposed to it.

  • scotchmi_st 12 years ago

    While I agree that is a tad fishy, your stance also appears fairly cynical. Maybe he just changed his mind. I don't think we give our politicians enough slack for them to get better, which in turn means that they learn to bloody-mindedly hold onto their stupid opinions, against the facts and reality.

timrogers 12 years ago

This is a typical example of a policy that is both pointless and ineffective. The government is, for one, not clear on what the goal of the policy is.

If it's to thwart child pornography, that won't work because if you wanted to view it, you'd just toddle off to your ISP and opt out of the filters.

If it's to stop children looking at pornography in general, that will fail children/young people are smarter than people imagine at circumventing these things.

This sort of thing gets proposed because it makes people think the government is doing something to social problems, even if it is technically problematic and won't really achieve the stated aims. I'm actually all for discouraging the use of pornography because it is something of a scourge on society, but this is not the way to do it. Education is.

voyou 12 years ago

They won't read them, but they might weigh them. The point of writing to MPs about policies can't really be to engage with them in an individual debate, but to form one tiny part of a mass of opinions which might persuade the MP.

mmcnickle 12 years ago

You're rarely going to get a personal reply to a letter to your MP. The sheer volume of correspondence prevents it.

Your MP's surgery sessions are a much better place to bring up issues like these. They're usually held every week and some don't require an appointment. When I went to speak to my MP about this issue, I was seen in 20mins and had a good 15-20min discussion.

MarcScott 12 years ago

My MP still hasn't replied to my letter, and the so called opposition in this country seem quite happy for this to move forward.

  • keithpeter 12 years ago

    OK, I'll try one to mine who is part of the opposition as well and see what happens. I suspect that The Daily Mail are making the policy around the Internet.

  • gaius 12 years ago

    It was the so-called opposition who were proposing a national biometric database not so long ago. Don't look to them for civil liberties.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection