Settings

Theme

Open Source Iran War Cost Tracker: 45.7B

iranwarcost.com

35 points by koverda 12 hours ago · 16 comments

Reader

SegfaultSeagull 2 hours ago

"Estimated US military spending since April 20, 2024, the day Congress passed $26.38B in emergency security assistance for Israel. "

In April 2024, Congress passed a $95.3 billion national-security supplemental package that included funding for Ukraine, Israel, and Indo-Pacific security. The Israel portion totaled about $26.38 billion.

Key points about that money:

Total Israel-related funding: about $26.38B. Humanitarian aid: roughly $9.15B (for civilians affected by conflicts, including Gaza). Missile defense: about $5.2B for systems like Iron Dome and David’s Sling. Weapons procurement: about $3.5B for new weapons. Other military supplies/services: about $4.4B.

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/whats-us-houses-foreign-aid... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Law_118-50

legitster 11 hours ago

Some problems:

- The Aid package is not immediately spent all at once. It authorizes up to $26 billion, but the CBO estimates it may take all the way into 2033 to claim the money.

- To that end, a lot of these costs are double counted. It's including the bill that authorizes these expenses, and then those expenses all in the same calculation.

More realistically, the $6.5M/day in theater operations for a Carrier Strike Group is probably pretty accurate (In reality, they already cost the US about $30M/day just operate normally). The flyaway costs for the Tomahawk missiles are going to be about $1M each (a lot of price estimates include the R&D costs divided per units).

In reality, the cost of a 60 day war with Iran using current methods at our current loss rates will get you closer to about $8-12B total cost. Which is still a lot more more incrementally accurate.

  • koverdaOP 11 hours ago

    Thank you for the feedback, I'll take it into account. Much appreciated!

diath 2 hours ago

For the record: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_...

nickff 12 hours ago

I was curious about the (AN/FPS-132) radar, which is a significant cost-driver, and have come away unsure as to whether it was a US-asset (which seems to be what this website is tracking). Qatar seems to have ordered one of these radars, and I can't see any record of the US installing one of its own at the facility in question, but it is not clear (to me) who owns this unit, though it seems most likely to be Qatar. Additionally, the widely-circulated image of the 'destroyed' radar appears to be 'fake', with satellite images showing less-than-catastrophic damage:

https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/fact-check-fake-image-de...

https://www.news18.com/world/iran-destroyed-uss-1-1-billion-...

  • koverdaOP 12 hours ago

    Pretty certain from this that it's a US asset: https://www.wpafb.af.mil/News/Article-Display/Article/111460...

    • nickff 11 hours ago

      Thanks for your link! The text seems to indicate the equipment is Qatar-owned: “The foreign military sale agreement, signed Dec. 7, 2016, requested AFLCMC provide the radar itself and associated mission support facilities at a remote location in Qatar.”

      For context, in the case of foreign military sales, the US government usually buys the equipment from its suppliers, then resells it to the foreign government.

koverdaOP 12 hours ago

I made a site a couple of days ago to track the cost of the iran war. It's open source, feel free to submit a PR or open an issue: https://github.com/koverda/iranwarcost.com

WalterGR 12 hours ago

Different tracker, but also see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47237080

Iran War Cost Tracker (iran-cost-ticker.com) 312 points | 23 hours ago | 440 comments

How does yours compare to that one?

  • koverdaOP 12 hours ago

    Mine seems to be a bit more focused and comprehensive on the financial expenditures by the US government, and open source. Also iran-cost-ticker.com seems to be "on hold" when i visit it.

    • WalterGR 12 hours ago

      > Also iran-cost-ticker.com seems to be "on hold" when i visit it.

      That is certainly a difference between the two sites. :) (In my defense, I hadn't visited since yesterday.)

JohnTHaller 11 hours ago

The modern Iran War began in April 2024 when Israel bombed Iran's consulate in Syria, marking the first direct conflict between the countries.

  • YZF 11 hours ago

    There were many many milestones that are relevant to the current war.

    - Proxy war waged by Iran in Lebanon, Syria, Iraq and Yemen.

    - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Qasem_Soleima...

    Arguably the bombing of IRGC meeting in the consulate-adjacent structure was not really "direct conflict". It was Iran firing missiles at Israel that was the first real direct conflict: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/April_2024_Iranian_strikes_on_...

    Also if we want to split hairs Iran attacked Israel's embassy in Buenos Aires in 1992: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1992_Buenos_Aires_Israeli_emba...

    "In April 2024, Argentina's second highest court ruled that the Iranian government was responsible for the bombing, and that it was carried out in retaliation for Argentina reneging on agreements to transfer nuclear material to Iran. The ruling also characterized Iran as a terrorist state"

  • SegfaultSeagull 2 hours ago

    That only works if you treat Iran’s proxies as unrelated actors.

    Hamas (Oct 7), Hezbollah on the northern border, the Houthis in the Red Sea, Iraqi militias hitting U.S. bases — that’s been Iran’s strategy for decades.

    April 2024 may have been the first direct exchange, but the war with Iran’s proxy system was already underway.

    • nixon_why69 an hour ago

      Hezbollah and Hamas are friendly with Iran but they very much have their own reasons for attacking Israel. Handwaving that as "Iran's proxies" is motivated reasoning.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection