Settings

Theme

AI Is Currently Hitting the Wall of Code Structure

modgo.org

2 points by hexpeek 4 months ago · 2 comments

Reader

hexpeekOP 4 months ago

Motivation:

Beyond prompts or .cursorrules, I explored whether code structure itself can serve as context an AI can understand. Most models’ context windows are small and hinder free-form exploratory coding; if structure can act as additional context, it could be a big win.

Test:

Two codebases implement the same behavior but differ in structure.

Code A: goal-driven, structure-agnostic.

Code B: lightly refactored with some structural improvements.

Both were 100% AI-written. I fed the same model the two bases separately and issued the same modification request.

Results:

On Code A, the AI grafted features onto a structureless base; subsequent edits easily broke existing behavior.

On Code B, the AI respected the existing composition/structure/pattern; follow-up edits were far less likely to cause regressions.

Conclusion:

The AI does leverage existing code structure; on a good structure, it tends to produce sturdier, higher-quality code.

Personal note:

This is an interesting direction for AI-assisted development. The write-up is short but setup-heavy; to really grasp the test, hands-on is needed. A tighter focus on the test, results, and implications would make it stronger.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection