Settings

Theme

Why all Indians are rule-breakers

economist.com

33 points by crop_rotation 5 months ago · 13 comments

Reader

benoitg 5 months ago

https://archive.is/ONfHw

darth_avocado 5 months ago

Headlines: Why all Indians are rule-breakers

Actual article: There are a lot of laws that haven’t been changed either because the government wants a say in people’s life or because it doesn’t matter because people just ignore the law and no one gets prosecuted.

Comments on HN: “My experience with Indians…..”

  • rayiner 5 months ago

    People from the subcontinent will be the first to say that rule breaking is the biggest problem on the subcontinent. The phone guy demanding a bribe to install a second phone line is the straw that broke the camel’s back and caused my dad to schlep us to the U.S.

rayiner 5 months ago

The explanation seems superficial: “Because the state makes it impossible not to be.”

That suggests we could get Indians to become rule followers by having some McKinsey folks come over and write different rules. I’d put that into the same bucket of willful denial of reality as the folks who thought you could make Iraq and Afghanistan into democracies by giving them different rules and laws.

This is unfortunate, because the underlying issue is extremely important. Getting to the bottom of it would change billions of people’s lives for the better.

pfp 5 months ago

Shallow clickbait article that just lists some anecdotal gripes. The business tax sounds just like EU VAT, nothing unusual.

This is supposed to be The Economist?

  • crop_rotationOP 5 months ago

    Why do you think it is shallow click bait. It lists out several good arguments for its main point.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection