Settings

Theme

Show HN: Student Happiness Ranking for Universities

github.com

5 points by basharov 6 years ago · 6 comments

Reader

smt88 6 years ago

Very interesting idea, but not sure Twitter sentiment analysis tells us anything. Most Twitter users don't tweet, and most college-age people are not active Twitter users. Instagram would provide more comprehensive data.

Even then, you have to make a variety of (sometimes shaky) assumptions:

1. The data set is a representative sample

2. Sentiment of social media posts is a good proxy for happiness

3. Machine analysis is sentiment is reliable (i.e. doesn't fail when it encounters sarcasm, which is common on Twitter)

  • basharovOP 6 years ago

    Twitter probably wasn't the best place to start, but it's my first data science project. I need more examples of where students actively talk about their universities, like StudentRoom forums (https://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/) or indeed Instagram.

    Gonna be tweaking the approach over time, trying out other models and frameworks.

mpochwat 6 years ago

Wondering if you RateMyProf could be a component of your happiness ranking.

ie. look at the average rate my prof rating per school. There's of course room for bias, but schools with higher professor satisfaction may correlate with overall student happiness.

  • basharovOP 6 years ago

    Thanks, I'll look at this as a data source, cause bias on social is huge, students (and people in general) tend to post on socials when they have something to say, and more often than not it's to rant rather than praise.

cmukka 6 years ago

One way to improve this is to look at the confession pages and the meme page data of the universities. Though getting all this data will be cumbersome.

  • basharovOP 6 years ago

    Oh neat idea, I haven't thought about those! Should be scrape-able. Also "Overheard at" pages

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection