Settings

Theme

The NYC subway system as a string instrument

mta.me

276 points by clofresh 15 years ago · 39 comments

Reader

Jun8 15 years ago

This is really intense! I salute the mind level that conceives such a concept (and comes up with a cool visualization).

  • icco 15 years ago

    I totally agree. I was kind of hoping the authors name would be in the source (http://mta.me/js-conductor/) but no such luck. It is pretty interesting code to read through though.

    • spacemanaki 15 years ago
    • IgorPartola 15 years ago

          Registrant ID:DOT-Z21GM2Q2ZICY
          Registrant Name:A C
          Registrant Organization:
          Registrant Address:13 Charter Street
          Registrant Address2:Apt. 3Front
          Registrant Address3:
          Registrant City:Boston
          Registrant State/Province:MA
          Registrant Country/Economy:US
          Registrant Postal Code:02113
          Registrant Phone:+1.2154175999
          Registrant Phone Ext.:
          Registrant FAX:
          Registrant FAX Ext.:
          Registrant E-mail:chenalex@seas.upenn.edu
      • blhack 15 years ago

        Don't you think that posting that is a bit rude? Yeah, you could look my address up in the phone book, but I generally don't go signing my posts on reddit with it.

        • jedsmith 15 years ago

          I've honestly never understood this mindset, and this isn't the first time I've seen it. I'm willing to learn if someone is willing to explain it to me.

          The information is there, but please don't share it visibly. Make people look for it!

          It makes shockingly little sense.

          • 7402 15 years ago

            By posting someone's e-mail address in a very public web site, you are just making it that much more accessible to spammers. It is easier to spider news.ycombinator.com than to do so for many whois repositories, some of which explicitly try to block their records from spammers.

            But even more importantly, as a matter of simple politeness, it is a good rule to honor someone's choice about how much they reveal about themselves on-line, even if you possess the technical knowledge to dig deeper.

            We're talking about rudeness vs. courtesy here. The world will not be a better place if your algorithm is simply to find out as much as you can about someone and then broadcast it in as public a fashion as possible without regard to the person's wishes.

            • IgorPartola 15 years ago

              Do the Whois databases actually try to block spammers? Any idea how they do it? I also wonder if all the websites out there that allow a view into the Whois data, end up caching it (e.g.: http://whois.domaintools.com/mta.me). If then Google and Coral Cache crawl these this data is permanently accessible.

              • Travis 15 years ago

                It is very explicitly and obviously against their terms of service if you run a whois from a cli. The first lines returned: "You are not authorized to access or query our Whois database through the use of electronic processes that are high-volume and automated except as reasonably necessary to register domain names or modify existing registrations."

                Perhaps you can argue against the effectiveness of their countermeasures, but from an legal standpoint, they do not authorize that activity. I take that to mean that they probably implement some technical countermeasures, but I cannot speak to their level of sophistication.

                • Natsu 15 years ago

                  > It is very explicitly and obviously against their terms of service if you run a whois from a cli.

                  You're absolutely right, but I've yet to meet a spammer who cared about anybody's ToS and I know for a fact that they only put that up there after a bunch of spammers abused the heck out of the service.

          • Travis 15 years ago

            One practical explanation is that it simply hides the information from "nefarious" elements (e.g., spam bots, etc.) that only have the sophistication to pull low hanging fruit.

            Somewhat related: I loaded your profile and then to your linked site[1]. I notice that you don't post your email address anywhere I saw. Is there a reason? I bet it's listed somewhere publicly (and that I could find it if I looked hard enough), but it might feel better to have it somewhat less public.

            Privacy issues are tough to compare between people. Each person has a different, often inconsistent, scale. And the metric of choice seems to be how "slimy" something feels.

            [1] Also, it may be interesting to note that I actually felt a little uncomfortable even doing that, in order to look for a counterexample to reply to your post with. To me, it felt like it could appear somewhat unnecessary. If it does, I apologize. So it's obvious that my personal scale might be a bit on the touchy side.

            edit, formatting

            • jedsmith 15 years ago

              Posterous enforces http:// on related links on the left. It wasn't that I wanted to hide my e-mail, but more that I never felt like throwing it over there since it required editing the HTML.

              Since you mentioned it, though, I took the opportunity to add it and do the Google Fonts changes I've been itching to try out. Thanks for the impetus.

          • tintin 15 years ago

            Maybe it has something to do Bruce Schneier said once: Privacy is not about hiding stuff, but about controlling what others can see about you (I can't find the exact quote).

            There is a huge difference between people who are looking for explicit information and people stumbling upon information.

            I agree with you that the information is simply there. But I think context is needed for every little bit of information. And maybe posting this on a very public forum like this will loose some context.

            Edit: found the article: http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/04/privacy_and_co...

        • IgorPartola 15 years ago

          I honestly don't. The question arose as to the identity of the author. It is only a $ whois mta.me away. I saved other the trouble, just like the sister post linked to his blog. If this offends you, I apologize.

  • taylorbuley 15 years ago

    Another weekend, another amazing HTML5 app produced. If only I could put these minds towards making some money..

CognitiveLens 15 years ago

In case you haven't discovered it - you can click-and-drag your mouse across the lines to make sounds in addition to waiting for the lines to 'pluck' themselves

IgorPartola 15 years ago

This is very cool. Here's our way of visualizing buses driving around in a novel way: http://labs.transloc.com/streetview/

  • pavel_lishin 15 years ago

    Does it auto-update as the bus moves? I finally found a street-view image, but it's just sitting there.

    • jasonfeinstein 15 years ago

      It depends on the bus - it randomly chooses a bus and follows it. If the bus is not moving anywhere - the view doesn't move either. Try refreshing..

icefox 15 years ago

Loading Sound is always at 0% for me.

lsb 15 years ago

It's wonderful, if a little odd, to think of the NYC subway as a plucked guitar, versus the familiar steel-on-steel "ka-chunk, ka-chunk" as the trains rumble on the (unwelded) tracks.

britta 15 years ago

They should crash and shatter, like lightcycles.

jefe78 15 years ago

This is amazing. Would you consider offering a tutorial to implement alternate systems(other cities)?

louhong 15 years ago

This is pretty creative - does anyone have suggestions on how I can convert this into a screensaver?

goldins 15 years ago

Open up a few tabs for a more fun and chaotic track!

Though I am having some syncing issues when one of the tabs is active.

zelandpanther 15 years ago

Interesting, it's creative and artistic engineering.

Keyboard Shortcuts

j
Next item
k
Previous item
o / Enter
Open selected item
?
Show this help
Esc
Close modal / clear selection